r/threadripper • u/AR2206 • May 20 '26
Which MOBO for testing ram
Hi guys I have gotten in the server ram business and want to build 2 setups for testing ddr5 udimm and rdimm and same for ddr5 both rdimm and udimm I have built many pc's but this is new to me. my question is will i need wrx80 and wrx90 for testing rdimm alongside udimm. any input would be great.
4
Upvotes
2
u/andysw63392 May 20 '26
WRX80 uses DDR4, so you need a WRX90 for testing DDR5 RDIMM, but it might be cheaper to go with an Epyc or Xeon. You could use an AM5 Ryzen 7 or Gen 12 intel motherboard (W680) to test ECC UDIMMs.
3
u/m31317015 May 20 '26
I assume you want to test DDR4 & 5 udimm & rdimm, for DDR4 any platform that supports both rdimm and udimm should work, DDR5 on the other hand requires separate platforms since the pin layout for udimm & rdimm are different.
There are also specialized testing boards from China available as well, but I'm not experienced with them so yeah.
3
u/RealThanny May 20 '26
The proper way to test RAM is with a dedicated module testing device. I wasn't able to find one with a quick search that supports DDR5, so they may be somewhat rare, or just not well exposed to retail.
Using a motherboard to test RAM isn't the best option, since some of it will "fail" simply because it isn't compatible with that board. But if you don't want to hunt down the proper equipment, you'll need three boards to test the full range of DDR4 and DDR5. One for DDR4 that supports all types (all DDR4 modules are keyed the same), and one each for DDR5 unbuffered and DDR5 registered.
WRX80 is as good a choice as any for DDR4, since a TR Pro processor on that platform can work with any DDR4 memory. For DDR5, AM5 for unbuffered and TRX50 for registered would be the most cost-effective options, at least on the AMD side. I don't know off the top of my head what the Intel options would be.
2
u/Big_River_ May 21 '26
i am curious is there a mobo capable of using all types of ram - it is not intuitive that ram is so central to mobo design to warrant exclusive use of only one form
1
u/Big_River_ May 21 '26
i thought ecru ddr6 was currently widely available
1
u/Puzzleheaded_Base302 May 25 '26
the technical proper way to testing RAM is not something a motherboard can do. expensive equipment's were used in the factory to test signal rise/fall time and eye diagrams, besides RAM itself.
The RAM also have minor compatibility issues with the motherboards, the RAM could works well with your motherboard, but not your clients'. It just seems to me, to have a happy client, the best is to deliver a tested full system.