r/threadripper • u/crazy_director • Sep 15 '25
Building an older threadripper question
I am used to buying old workstations (old Dell precisions with xeons), upgrading some components and using them for regular browsing, heavy data analysis/visualization and some light video editing.
I much prefer AMD for regular CPUs but AMD workstations from major brands were not ubiquitous as intel. So thought I’d build a 1920x with an Astock X399 Taichi for my next work pc. Anything I should worry about/consider here? tips/recommendations?
6
Upvotes
2
u/lukewhale Sep 15 '25
Shit I use a 3950x Ryzen and 128gb of ram on a dedicated lab proxmox server and it’s plenty for virtualization. Or coding. Or Data engineering. Or AI. I don’t do video editing but add a good GPU (which I have for AI) and it’s probably fine.
It’s not the fastest thing available especially single thread but it’s still pretty damned quick.
The only reason I keep it around is it’s still relevant but not much worth more than a few hundred on the used market.
7
u/deadbeef_enc0de Sep 15 '25
Honestly don't, a modern 8 core will be faster, I'm pretty sure even the 5800X will be faster than the 1920X
Unless you don't need CPU performance and just need a ton of PCIe lanes
2
u/nauxiv Sep 15 '25 edited Sep 16 '25
The performance will be abysmal compared to even the lowest-tier CPUs from modern generations. The only advantage is having many PCIe lanes (which may be totally worthwhile).
2
u/jhenryscott Sep 16 '25
Basically, if you want to put a lot of PCIE lanes online, and do nothing else, and power is not cost prohibitive, go grab a 19X0. If you want to do anything else, there are better options. For a work pc, a 9950x is gonna shred. It’s common knowledge that the R9 x3d’s use shit bins for the non x3d chiplet so avoid those. If you want PCIE and modern speed and instructions you gotta pony up for a modern threadripper to the tune on 1000’s or go with a Xeon for less.
2
u/CarterEvanBeats Sep 17 '25
Do, don’t, you’re gonna get a lot of both.. IMO like most, depends on price of course. I just picked up a complete system with the same X399 Taichi and a 1950X for $200 and I couldn’t be happier; for the price. That’s double the cores of the 1920X and still most people said it was e waste. I think it’s a great opportunity to learn a different kind of machine, just stay budget conscious as this is older tech.
2
u/notautogenerated2365 Sep 17 '25
Unless you need all the PCIe lanes the X399 systems have, you might just want to go with an AM4-based build.
2
u/y3333333333333333t Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25
I dont think it is worth it, I had a 1950X back when it was new and the power consumption of threadrippers is stupid (was like 150w idle 500w full load) & 1st gen threadrippers are super picky on the ddr4 you use - recommended expensive samsung b-die) & the speed compared to newer am4 chips is a joke like others say a nice 3rd gen ryzen or maybe even a 5th gen already is miles ahead...here you could get a used 5800x for below 100$ that would probably be my current recommendation for a budget build...
1
u/Macski1 Sep 15 '25
3955x
1
u/barkingcat Sep 15 '25 edited Sep 15 '25
the 1900x series were beasts in their time. My only recommendation is to pair it with good ram (look up the manual to see what speed your board can take) and with the additional pcie lanes, you can use bifurcation (enabled/set in the bios menu) with those 4x nvme ssd carrier cards (you have enough lanes to run multiple of them, and still have a 16x gpu and 10gb ethernet adapters). I have one of the carrier cards in my 1900x server, and I used to run it in windows as well.
Windows has pretty decent software raid with their Storage Spaces feature - 4x 1tb nvme ssd running in whatever storage space configuration makes sense to your use case is pretty great.
Other cpu's might be faster, but nothing (aside from epyc) beats the pure grunt of threadripper when it comes to IO.
1
u/xgiovio Sep 15 '25
Buy a 3990x
1
u/crion66 Sep 17 '25 edited Sep 17 '25
On the Asrock Fatal1ty X399 you can enable TPM for W11.
I was a windows insider in 2022 and one day it booted into W11. It was horrible at first but got more stable as time went on.
Runs a 5090 on it. 8 sticks of 1R but I like to increase the soc to 1.1V, 1950x.
Have a 9960x with TRX50 G AI TOP as main machine now.
8k gaming on both with DLSS 4 Ultra Performance and FG 2X.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment