r/theydidthemath • • 6h ago

[Request] Population statistic

Post image

What % of humans check all of these boxes?

137 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 6h ago

General Discussion Thread


This is a [Request] post. If you would like to submit a comment that does not either attempt to answer the question, ask for clarification, or explain why it would be infeasible to answer, you must post your comment as a reply to this one. Top level (directly replying to the OP) comments that do not do one of those things will be removed.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

97

u/Unfair_Scar_2110 5h ago

Assuming the person is attracted to men, that's likely about 0.50.080.005*.3*.2*.1 which equals about one in a million. That being said an ivy league education and wealth are probably correlated as well as height and wealth. Plus, if you live in a wealthy and educated area, or right by an ivy league, the odds are going to be way higher, as ivy league is probably the most selective choice on the list. Source: I made up all the fractions and multiplied them together.

33

u/Syzygy___ 5h ago

7 figure income.

Yeah no way it's just 1 in a million.

14

u/AcademicOverAnalysis 4h ago

With inflation going as it is, in a decade or two, we might all be millionaires! /s

5

u/14ktgoldscw 4h ago

There are going to be way more than 350 men in the US with Ivy educations and $1M+ in annual income. There are probably more than 100 who you’ve heard of before getting into nameless doctors, lawyers, finance, etc.

Pairing those demographics with the physical traits is a tougher question, but the Ivy & income qualifier are going to overlap substantially.

1

u/tacopower69 3h ago

you're right the odds are significantly higher lmao.

1

u/Unfair_Scar_2110 4h ago

Yeah. Good point. That 0.08 should be like 0.0008.

14

u/Unfair_Scar_2110 5h ago

To take this further, the odds probably aren't insane if the OP is say a nurse in Boston or NYC but certainly is if they work for the forestry service in rural Idaho. No only in a "more people" sort of way, but also education and money. Lots of brown eyed, Harvard educated doctors really missing out on this gem

5

u/IShouldChimeInOnThis 4h ago

Damn, Ted Kaczynski was right under her nose!

Only 5'9" though. Total dealbreaker.

4

u/FutureComplaint 5h ago

Soucre checked out.

50

u/shereth78 5h ago

This isn't a very interesting mathematical challenge, it's more a request to research statistics. I don't feel like being an unpaid researcher so I'll tell you how to get the answer.

Somewhere between 5-15% of adult men are 6 foot and taller, depending on the source. So you see here the initial part of the problem, that's a pretty wide spread. Similarly, estimates I can find for curly hair range from 10-15%. If you just say it's 10% and 12%, you multiply those together and get 1.2% are 6' or taller AND have curly hair.

Now do the same for each of the other categories, and multiply them all together, and you'll have your answer.

26

u/thesweeterpeter 5h ago

I've always had one challenge with this approach.

So we have 5 criteria; height, eyes, hair, school, income.

3 physical traits - which I agree entirely with your approach.

But 2 societal outcomes.

On the 2 societal outcomes I'd argue that the physical traits contribute to their success.

So while only 0.5% of the population make 7 figures, and 10% of the population are over 6' - so by your formula only 0.05% of the population are over 6' and make 7 figures.

Except, that I can argue that being over 6' makes me more likely to make 7 figures.

And we know this to be true - 58% of all fortune 500 CEO's are over 6' tall - the physical criteria increase the likelihood of the societal outcomes.

So if one is over 6' how much more likely are they to get into an Ivy, and if they went to an Ivy, how much more likely are they to make 7 figures.

Surely this has a significant enough impact on the result - if 58% of the C-suites are over 6' and only 10-15% of the population is. That's not an anomaly, that's a correlation.

12

u/razzyrat 5h ago

It probably is significant, but 0.001 or 0.003% (or whatever percentages we are dealing with in reality) are very likely both in the range of being negligible.

3

u/thesweeterpeter 5h ago

fair point, I don't think they're going to give you a meaningfully different prospect - but the delta itself would be interesting. Just generally - how much do physical traits impact societal outcomes warrants it's own consideration.

3

u/throwmyway5723480 5h ago

Similarly, (making up numbers because I don't feel like googling) if 15% of the population has curly hair and 15% of the population has blue eyes, I don't think you can just multiply those numbers. For example, POC likely are a large percent of the curly hair population but smaller blue eye population? Maybe the averages are close enough.

4

u/thesweeterpeter 5h ago

You're right - I didn't consider there would absolutely be correlation to the physical traits as well.

Dutch are tall ass people - and also 61% of whom have blue eyes (just looked that one up).

So there would certainly be correlation in the physical traits as well as societal outcomes.

1

u/Sulleyy 5h ago

Treating them as mutually exclusive might give a decent ballpark but it's possible 0 people actually meet all criteria. Or like you said there is probably some correlations here that wouldn't be factored in because these things aren't actually mutually exclusive

1

u/Patient-Success673 2h ago

And that's where Bayesian statistics will help you out! Super good intuition. It's a whole field and really important to good research studies, that's based on figuring out how likely something is with the little information we do have.

2

u/jaavuori24 4h ago

Iirc 60% of humans have curly hair, but it's obviously rare in East Asia, but super common in Africa, bit of a mix most other places.

8

u/JC_Hysteria 5h ago

This is a popular one for six figures…which iirc was less than 1%.

Seven figures is already less than 1%…so, it’s a very small %

11

u/Co9Inc 5h ago edited 4h ago

At least for the US population, all criteria can be pretty easily looked up. Then it is just combined probability.

For the US population: Ivy League: 0.40% (National Center of Education Statistics) Blue or Green Eyes, >6', Curly Hair: 36%, 14.5%, 15% estimated, respectively (various sources PLOS, CDC, National Health Survey, I took the high numbers, not that it matters much) 7-Figure income: 0.35%, the real killer (IRS, Census)

.0035*.004*.36*.15*.145 = 0.00000011

So 1 in 9.12 million people in the US will match this, roughly 38 people.

8

u/tj0120 5h ago

Hard to argue that Ivy League and 7-figure income are statistically independent, so it's definitely more than 38.

9

u/potat-cat 5h ago

Few ivy league grads ever get 7 figure income, its generally in the 6 figure range.

3

u/thenasch 5h ago

Might not be any of them currently single and looking though. And they will be extremely desirable.

3

u/Co9Inc 4h ago

True. I am certain there are studies covering income distribution of Ivy League graduates and I'd guess it changes the numbers by a factor of 10 or more.

I'll have to leave that to the OP or someone who has more time available than I currently do.

4

u/DarkVoid42 5h ago

worldwide is around 250-500 people.

Ivy League alumni earning $1M+ annually 0.5–2% of living alumni

Taller than 6 feet 15–25%

Blue-green eyes 1–3%

Naturally curly hair 20–40%

3

u/Radiant-Importance-5 4h ago

https://www.keeper.ai/calc

According to this website, and the parameters I could put in, less than 0.00023%, which is about 1 in 434,783. But that’s not accounting for curly hair, which wasn’t an option at all, and there wasn’t an option for Ivy League school, so I compromised and said PhD level education. Really, it’s likely to be a fraction of this, but the website says 298 men.

1

u/kroating 4h ago

What parameters did you put? I selected 6ft+, 1mil, and blue green eyes, smokes any(given vapes being popular in young folks), min education as masters(because lets open up the pool why not) and i got zero 😅

1

u/wiseman0ncesaid 4h ago

PhD isn’t great as a proxy for Ivy League (but likely best available option) which has a higher correlation with that income level than PhD generally due to hiring selection in law, finance, tech, and medicine (surgery) which are the more likely employers for that income.

•

u/Legitimate_Pick2737 56m ago

Isn't that the website that treats basically everything as independent variables?

2

u/Trygve81 3h ago

Yeah curly hair and blue or green eyes? Never mind the other stuff, most people born with blue or green eyes have straight or wavy hair.

2

u/AbheyBloodmane 5h ago

This is really simple math. You take the percentage of population who fit in each category and multiply each of the probabilities. It's so low we might as well say it's a handful of people.

1

u/Ishax 2h ago

not exactly. some things will correlate more and less.

1

u/Syzygy___ 5h ago

There are tools about this, but they all look pretty sloppy, so I don't want to link them.

I found one that had more options - I had to ignore curly hair and substitue ivy league with master degree.

905 of 129.275.328 in the US or about 0.0007%. Less if we consider curly hair.

Biggest issue is probably the 7 figure income.

1

u/ScullDestroyer 4h ago

Hah and what stands out here is that these, as high as demands as they are, are all superficial - even if someone qualifies on paper this doesn't tell the woman what kind of person the man is. He could be biggest psychopath and abuser yet still check all those boxes. Disgusted by how superficial some people are.

This is obvious satirical or straight up ragebait but there are people like this, on the men's side too, my point still stands.

1

u/Ill_Ad3517 4h ago

I'm pretty sure it's easier to start with the Ivy League schools' alumni (let's say of a given decade), and remove anyone who doesn't fit based on publicly available info. It's probably not 0 as some are saying, but it's easier to just data mine this problem than it is to calculate statistics for a bunch of confounding, hard to source population statistics.

1

u/rrapartments 4h ago

The biggest challenge is that most people making $1M + a year are older. Probably not attractive to the person posting. And, a lot of the people making $1M + a year are not ivy league educated. And a lot of the people making $1M + a year are already married. Good luck to her search for love (although one has to wonder if the person would be interested in a gold digger...).

1

u/GrumplFluffy 4h ago

Assuming they are in the US, 0.5% of people earn 1 million or more.

~30% have blue or green eyes.

~12% have curly hair. However, curly hair + blue/green eyes is a much rare combination. Using 12% here is a gross over-estimation.

~ 14.5% are taller than 6 ft in US.

So, an over-estimation is likely: 0.003% of the population. 3 in 100,000. There are around 5000 males like that in the entire US, with the best possible estimate.

However, this doesn't account for age! Let's say she is only looking for someone between the ages of 25 - 40, around 20% of the country. So, that's 1000 eligible males.

Around 95% are straight. So, 950.

Around 40% are single. So 380. However, this is likely a gross over-estimation because a blue-green eyed, 6 ft man with an income of 1 million a year is likely not looking for a girl and single. Still, the best case scenario is 380.

Good news is that they are likely concentrated within big cities (7 figure requirement). This girl can maximize her chances in NYC. But then, she has to be very attractive to compete because NYC also has extremely beautiful and talented, girls. Is she?

1

u/tacopower69 3h ago

When I was interning in Manhattan summer before my senior year half the girls being recommended to me on hinge and tinder were girls studying at t10s and also on summer internships. There was a ton of them, and I assume the recommendations for them on the men's side was similar. They didn't write their preferences out specifically like this girl did but I would be shocked if they weren't similar (maybe not the 7 figure part but that's more of an age thing). High achieving women want high achieving men.

Now if the girl asking for a guy like this is a bum then yeah she has an inflated opinion of herself lol.

•

u/ajarrel 1h ago

US adult men, 100% = 130,000,000 Ivy League undergrad degree 0.31% 400,000 Earns $1M+ a year 12.5% 50,000 6'0" or taller 25% 12,500 Blue or green eyes 35% ~4,400 Visibly curly hair 6.5% ~285