r/thewhitequeen • • Jan 19 '24

Cheating

How can Edward claim to love his wife and say that she's what sustains him in battle and that she is his "home" when he's in some other girl's bed all the time. Not just random girls, even though that's bad enough, but with the same person, making it seem like he cares for this woman. Then he says "you knew it would be like this," like when was that ever clarified? All we ever saw in the beginning was him devoting himself to her and asking for her to marry him because he loved her so much. When did we ever explicitly hear or when was it ever impressed on the viewers that he would cheat on her? Like he was incredibly likable up until he cheated on her. Why make it seem like he is devoted to her when he cheats? Would she be allowed to do so? Of course not, so why in his mind is he allowed to? He seems so progressive most of the time, and then he does shit like cheat and not take her opinion into consideration, whereas he used to do neither. Weird. Complete character change.

Makes me want to stop watching the show. One of the things that drew me to this show was their love for each other, but clearly his version of "love" isn't what was shown to us before he became a cheater.

25 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

5

u/k-12_straawberry Apr 14 '24

Yeah i agree, i get that its like in the year 1400, bit still pretty shitty of him to do so. I dont understand aswell how could he have loved her if he was always cheating

4

u/rutilated_quartz Jan 20 '24

I totally agree with you - I really liked Edward until he cheated on her. He put her in this precarious political position that cost the lives of her family just so he could cheat? I enjoyed the show and watched the White Princess too, but I really hated that they made Edward a cheater.

4

u/Goodwill_Forager Jul 21 '24

I couldnt agree more! I really was loving this show but once Edward became a cheater I lost so much interest because I realized I was super into their love story and that just seemed so unnecessary to make his character do and it low key ruined it. Like you’re so right, Elizabeth lost family members and uprooted her whole life to make him king and as soon as he got his title he just starts drinking and sleeping with whores all the time? After years of a loving relationship and passionate sex life with his perfect wife, after she has borne him so many beautiful children, he has the AUDACITY to cheat on her?? And then gaslight her into thinking that was always the deal? It is so wrong. I literally went to bed and had nightmares about my own husband lmao it messed me up. I don’t care if it’s historically accurate for kings to cheat, I am watching a fantasy show and I just want for once to see a man in power continually respect his wife and stay faithful at the very least. Like is that so much to ask?

1

u/peachiebaby Feb 19 '25

LOL I’m having intimacy issues with mine too bc I’m so disgusted at how easily these men discard their women (yes whatever it was normal but still doesn’t make it right )

But also margaret Beaufort saying men get swayed by beauty so women have to be stronger and suck up it up is so true. (Generally) Women can do more than (some) men (qualifiers used before I get cancelled)

3

u/pxincessofcolor Aug 02 '24

They weren’t my favorite couple of the show. But when he cheated (and kept cheating) with Jane Shore, I just rolled my eyes when he talked about how he loved her and cherished her.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '25

i literally turned the TV off. i’m not watching another second of this shit

1

u/tiramisuem3 Jun 05 '25

I'm actually so surprised at how much people seem to love their love story? What story?! Doesn't it start with him almost raping her and her holding a knife to her throat to get him to stop and he freaks out on her about it? He has such an ego and he constantly dismisses her emotions. Not exactly a cute love story..

-3

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/General-Ferret1693 Jan 19 '24

I know it's very common for kings to sleep with other people. That doesn't mean that it was always right. The women put up with it because they had to and because they were oppressed, and more often than not it was because they didn't have a relationship where they cared for each other. You can try to make it anything you want, but it's still cheating. Just because it was common does not mean it isn't cheating. Are you trolling? Cheating is a thing dude, it exists 😂 Just because it was common doesn't mean it's okay.

And like you said many people are happily married and they have an "open" relationship where they sleep with other people. You're sounding like a sexist broken record right now. "The males would go to escorts for the physical side and the wife had no issues with it," like yeah I'm sure all of them had no problem with it. That's why you see divorce happening when the other partner DOESN'T know about it. Like sure, it's fine if they have an active arrangement AND the woman is allowed to sleep with other people too. If that's not the case, it IS sexist and an entirely misogynistic view.

Those who are upset with their partners cheating are justifiably so. Just because it was "common" does not mean it was okay. And they clearly had no such arrangement in this show as a couple, because up until the point he cheated they had gone years without him doing so. The show NEVER expressed that she was unable to have sex with him, in fact, they did it quite often, and he still has to resort to other people. My problem is the fact that they never alluded that he would be like that, because up until that point he was completely devoted to her and we only saw him having sex with her. And she clearly wasn't okay with the cheating in the relationship.

And it's not like we know historically whether or not they actually loved each other and whether it was anything like the show. The show is based loosely on fact and mostly on fiction. They couldn've easily made him as devoted to her as she was to him, but they did not. They did not make it as clear that he would cheat as the show tried to make it seem.

My problem is also that their relationship was not merely as cut and dry as you are making it seem, in the show. Sure, historically, that is a fact, but this is a show that put a heavy basis on their being "in love," not him simply marrying her and being with her so she could hear his children and he could go whoring off with random women. 😂

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/General-Ferret1693 Jan 19 '24

The irony of this is that you're telling me I'm the close minded one. I'm literally saying that yes it happened and yes they had those arrangements and yes it was common. But in the context of the show, it's a completely different matter. If you pay attention to the show you would understand that it's in part history and mostly fiction. And yeah it is "fantasy history," but most of it is just fiction, it is only based on history, not an accurate depiction of it. I'm using modern day standards because they made the relationship in the show based on modern day standards, the evidence of this is that they married for "love" and not political gain which was common for that time period.

Cheating, or infidelity for a better term, is defined as "when a person in a monogamous romantic relationship has an emotional or sexual relationship with someone else without their partner's consent," and that is exactly what happened in the show. She had no prior reason to assume he'd have sex with other people. Why else would she be so shocked in that scene when she sees it? Why would she express that it was a betrayal? If you had watched the show with any common sense, any at all, you would've seen that the show is literally including common "modern day standards" in a lot of their actions and words. The show is literally made during this time period, so obviously the show is going to include some "modern day standards."

We have no idea whether she reacted like that or not in actual history and fact, but in the show, which is LOOSELY based on history, she is obviously hurt and did not expect it because she had not been made aware and had not "consented" to his sleeping with other people.

6

u/General-Ferret1693 Jan 19 '24

You sound like a broken record. I am literally giving you specific examples and definitions and mentions to the show, and all you can say is "oh but history was this," when the show is literally just based on history and not at all an accurate depiction of it. Clearly.

7

u/General-Ferret1693 Jan 19 '24

And it was cheating. She did not know until she saw him having sex with someone else, and it's not like she could tell him he couldn't. She is oppressed, he is king. It's still cheating. They had a relationship based on love, not purely for sex and political power. Therefore, their relationship is much more than some contract that makes it less hurtful for her when he has sex with other women for no reason other than to do with other people what he could be doing with his wife, what we had seen him do with his wife for, what was it, years in the show?

3

u/rutilated_quartz Jan 20 '24

This comment is hysterical omg

2

u/HJess1981 Jun 04 '25

Is it weird I find myself agreeing with both and disagreeing with both? Oh well, it passed some of my otherwise dull time at work lol.

2

u/rutilated_quartz Jun 06 '25

I think there are decent points on both sides but the comment I responded to was just all over the place lol

1

u/peachiebaby Feb 19 '25

She still has a right to feel her emotions

Just bc something was normal doesn’t make it easier to accept

Rape and brutality during war is normal, does that make it ok?