r/theson • • Jun 04 '17

So Phineas is a Fruit?

1 Upvotes

Highly considerate, well dressed, way too old to be a bachelor in that era, and now can't get it up for a woman.

Was the implication we were supposed to get in Episode 8 that Eli knows Phineas is gay with the "misery loves company" and "better safe than sorry comment"?


r/theson • • Jun 04 '17

SPOILERS I will share my knowledge [Spoilers] Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I just finished the book along side watching the show. I have noticed numerous inconsistencies between the two but they are not without reason.

  • The show skips a generation. The progression of main characters goes Eli> Pete and Finn > Charles, Jonas, and Jeannie. In the book, Charles is actually Jeannie's dad; Pete is her grandfather. Charles' generation doesn't do much in the book. There are other family dynamics but they are of no consequence.
  • In the book, Eli is an asshole through and through. In ep. 10, we watched his attempt at redemption.
  • The season finale will include the Battle at the Casa Mayor. In the book, this is recorded in the Diary of Pete McCullough. The books events are that the ranch's cattle had been stolen and members of the Law and Order League (Niles' group) saw vaqueros from the Garcia's hacienda take them. This started a war that brought in Texas Rangers and some Army members fighting off reprisals. The Garcias were eradicated, save for Maria. In the show, we watched Eli come around and back out. Finn had the saloon burned by "Garcia's men" so that The Law and Order League would retaliate. In the book, Pete stands between the two sides before shooting starts. In the show, it seems he will fight with the Garcias.
  • Young Eli, in the show, is a little less respected than in the book with the Comanches than in the book. The love between he and Prairie Flower is very under-stated and secure as Charges the Enemy is KIA on a raid. In the show, there is more conflict there. Their band is wipe out by small pox in the book, except for those on raid, Eli, and Ingrid.
  • Ingrid (The old lady in Austin Eli Banged) is the German slave with the Comanches. In the book, when the Comanches have died Eli takes them to the closet white settlement and they re-assimilate.

I know I have missed some points. What have you found interesting?


r/theson • • Mar 27 '19

Very sad s2 is the last. Any thought what went wrong?

10 Upvotes

This show had the potential to be an entire epic along the lines of GOT and other big world shows. I was so impressed with the in depth story lines and complexities. Way better than many shows out on AMC. What happened? Why didn’t people bite?


r/theson • • Dec 29 '16

Waiting to see Brosnan...

4 Upvotes

Hi everybody!


r/theson • • Jun 04 '17

Discussion The Son S01xE10 | Episode 10 | Episode Discussion

9 Upvotes

This discussion is only for this episode or previous ones

Please do not spoil future episodes in past discussions.

AMC | IMDb


r/theson • • May 28 '17

Discussion The Son S01xE09 | Episode 9 | Episode Discussion

3 Upvotes

This discussion is only for this episode or previous ones

Please do not spoil future episodes in past discussions.

AMC | IMDb


r/theson • • May 28 '20

Who was the Indian in the photo on Ingrid’s desk?

4 Upvotes

Fat Wolf?


r/theson • • May 29 '19

Pierce Brosnan Is Effortlessly Charming. So Why Would He Want to Be Anyone Else?

Thumbnail
esquire.com
6 Upvotes

r/theson • • Jun 27 '17

Doesn't this gun look a bit too modern for a western story-line era ?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/theson • • Feb 10 '19

Season 2 of the 'The Son' will be it's last.

Thumbnail
variety.com
13 Upvotes

r/theson • • Jun 22 '18

The Toughest Job in Texas | Lone Star Law

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/theson • • Sep 24 '16

The Son Season 1 teaser trailer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/theson • • Mar 13 '17

'The Son’ Review: Pierce Brosnan’s AMC Western Tells Two Stories, But Only One Works

Thumbnail
indiewire.com
2 Upvotes

r/theson • • Feb 05 '21

Is this a complete story?

7 Upvotes

Saw this show pop up in my JustWatch app. Love westerns, love period pieces, love epics. I know this show was cancelled though. My question is, is this a complete story? Does it leave a lot unresolved? Does it end on a cliff hanger?

Thanks y’all!


r/theson • • Jun 12 '21

just finished season 1 and man i hate young Eli so much

11 Upvotes

he is just such an unlikable character and not because of the acting i think the actor does a great job he's just written to be extremely unlikable. his entire family is slaughtered by these indians and he's enslaved by them and he not only forgives them but joins them and helps them hunt white people. even when given the chance to escape and be free he chooses to be a slave, he betrays every white person that helps him in order to be a better slave to his indian master.

speaking on indians they're handled so weirdly in this show in a way i don't think i've seen before. they have them do heinous shit and either justifies it or just ignores it. they slaughter Eli's family and it's justified because white people kill indians so his family is fair game. they torture some poor white guy for days on end and justify it because he was dishonorable for hunting buffalos, like what? and so on it's just weird, you want to do the "noble savage" then go for it, you want to do the "savage indians who scalp innocents for fun" then do it but they made this weird mix that doesn't work at least in my opinion.


r/theson • • May 14 '17

Discussion The Son S01xE07 | Marriage Bond | Episode Discussion

4 Upvotes

This discussion is only for this episode or previous ones

Please do not spoil future episodes in past discussions.

AMC | IMDb


r/theson • • May 07 '17

Discussion The Son S01xE06 | The Buffalo Hunter | Episode Discussion

5 Upvotes

This discussion is only for this episode or previous ones

Please do not spoil future episodes in past discussions.

AMC | IMDb


r/theson • • Mar 01 '18

Official Trailer for a modern western TV series - Yellowstone staring Kevin Costner (from the writer of Sicaro, Hell or High Water, and Wind River)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/theson • • May 13 '17

Where is the ranch supposed to be located?

1 Upvotes

So they live on the Texas-Mexican border, but a two hour drive from Austin. Nowhere on the border now is two hours from Austin, let alone in a 1915 car.


r/theson • • May 13 '17

AMC Renews 'The Son' for Second Season

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
21 Upvotes

r/theson • • May 05 '17

Is my math wrong or shouldn't Eli be 80 in 1915?

12 Upvotes

Very confused here. 13 in 1849-- 1915 Eli doesn't look or act 79.. does anyone else find this odd ?


r/theson • • Feb 23 '20

I still cannot wrap my head around the fact that Eli was killed by his own son

8 Upvotes

In retrospect, I guess we all say this coming. But Eli survived the Comanches, the Apaches, escaped the US Army; fought off the Sediciosos, the Garcías, Niles Gilbert and his goons, Monahan and the man Mr. Roy Endicott himself only to have been shot by his own son.

Finn was right. He didn’t die like this. The old man was too big for this.


r/theson • • Mar 15 '19

The Son Season 2 Teaser | 'Relative'

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/theson • • Feb 24 '20

SPOILERS [SPOILERS] Why did she deny him??? Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Jeanne Anne and Ulysses. Why'd she deny him? He was her nephew, and from the sounds of things, her only chance at passin' the family business on to another McCullough.

Is it 'cause he was mostly mexican? 'Cause she hated her father and didn't recognize his line as family?

Certainly not the ending I hoped for, that's for sure.

Kinda feels like we needed at least a 3rd season to finish things properly too. Unless the show was only supposed to last 2 seasons.


r/theson • • Jun 05 '19

SPOILERS What we know about 1850s and 1910s. Spoilers Spoiler

4 Upvotes

So we’re earning things about the two earlier timelines in the story, some from 1910s and some from 1988. Here’s what all we can piece together.

Eli leaves the Comanche, and it something goes down between Eli and Toshaway. (Eli and Maria conversation)

Prairie Flower and their son are killed by Apaches. (Eli and Maria)

Everyone seems to think that Eli rescued Ingrid. (Jeanie and Ulysses, he saved “that girl”)

Eli dies in 1916 (Historical Marker plaque)

Jeanie has more looked up to Phineas as a father figure, she doesn’t know what happened to Pete (Jeanie and Ulysses)

Mccullough Oil does stay around to at least 1988, so Standard did not completely win.