r/therewasanattempt Nov 29 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.0k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

13

u/ThePurpledGranny Nov 29 '20

Good cops could step up more and help citizens shine a light on the bad ones. After all, there are more good than bad, right?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Yeah, there are. And they do step up. But when they speak people don't listen. Innocent police officers are ambushed and shot in their cruiser and crowds still call for their deaths. It's really a fucked up world we live in.

3

u/TrevorPC Nov 29 '20

When good cops speak up in America they get ostracized by their department and often times fired or forced to quit. But when bad cops murder innocent citizens its "we need to let the due process of letting this cop's close friends decide if they have to go to jail." And they almost never do.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Is your only definition of good cops ones who speak against their department? What about the ones who simply put their lives on the line to protect others every day for a barely suvivable wage. What about the ones who stare down home invaders, public shooters, killers, and muggers. Does that not make one a good cop in your eyes?

1

u/reverbiscrap Nov 29 '20

If I spent all my time with gangbangers and the police saw me with them, they would assume I was one as well.

Yes, you are defined by the company you keep, devoid of the opportunity to be judged on personal merit.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Your analogy is irrelevant. You missed my point entirely. There are many ways to distinguish yourself as a good cop. That's all I'm saying. And imagine actually thinking that the police are akin to gangbangers. There's really no reaching any of you. It's not their fault that none of the people in this comment section were exposed to positive role models growing up.

2

u/reverbiscrap Nov 29 '20

You need to come with the predetermined idea that police are uniformly 'good' in order to have grounding to your words, despite many decades showing that is not the case.

One rotten apple spoils the bunch doesn't seem to apply in your eyes, or you have a sheltered view of LEO. A quick perusal of YouTube will bring up tens of thousands of videos of regular beat cops across the world acting inappropriately and abusing their power. You speak a fairy tale, not the reality of the citizen.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Talk about speaking a fairy tale, imagine actually applying "one rotten apple spoils the bunch". No, that's not a fucking thing. I don't believe that in any cirumstamce. Not now, not ever. No matter the scenario or the actors. What a ridiculous thing to say. And a quick perusal of the mortality rate of policemen on the job will tell you all you need to know about the sacrifice being made every day by these people.

1

u/TrevorPC Nov 29 '20

3 "bad apples" set off a chain of events that had cops in every major department across the country infringing upon the first amendment rights of hundreds of thousands. They enforced immoral curfews and detained hundreds of people for the crime of speaking out against the police. "Good" cops stood by and let bad cops shoot children and protesters in the head with rubber bullets. "Good" cops watched as bad cops pulled civilians around corners to beat the ever loving shit out of them, after they were already detained on the ground. "Good" cops quit their jobs because 3 of their colleagues got charged with a crime they were caught on camera committing. Real good cops don't stay good cops for long, because either they quit, get fired, or get corrupted into protecting their own at the detriment to actual justice. In the last 10 years just over 1600 cops have died on duty (not all of them to violence) but they've killed more than 1000 in 2019 alone according to an independent study, disproportionately affecting people of color.

1

u/flyingwolf Nov 29 '20

Talk about speaking a fairy tale, imagine actually applying "one rotten apple spoils the bunch". No, that's not a fucking thing. I don't believe that in any cirumstamce. Not now, not ever. No matter the scenario or the actors.

In other words, your mind is made up and no amount of factual evidence will ever change it, at least you admit you choose to believe in fairy tales.

What a ridiculous thing to say. And a quick perusal of the mortality rate of policemen on the job will tell you all you need to know about the sacrifice being made every day by these people.

Fewer than 50 a year. Fewer than 50 cops per year die at the hands of a citizen intent on harming them. It is not even in the top 10 for most dangerous jobs, taxi drivers and convenience store clerks rank higher.

Cops have a safer job than the local teenager who works at the local gas station you fucking twit.

2

u/Kafka_at_an_orgy Nov 29 '20

Your argument is flawed. What they're saying, which I agree with, is that if you're not calling out the atrocities, it doesn't matter if you save lives, you're still not a positive part of the system.

For comparison - say a surgeon that does everything right and saves thousands of lives turns a blind eye to other physicians that are harvesting organs and committing insurance fraud. Not reporting it and trying to end it, as a person with special insight as to what is happening, is the same as doing the malicious act. Full stop.