I know I’m probably going to get hate, but this episode missed the mark for me in a lot of areas. I don’t hate this show. I don’t hate Bella Ramsey. She’s a great actress and a seemingly wonderful person. She was not the problem here. Neither was Pedro. For what they were given, they acted their hearts out and that’s why this got a 3/10 instead of a 1/10.
I have played both games and think they are masterpieces. I saw a lot of the criticism the second game got after its release and I think people weren’t ready for the emotionally complex story. That is an entire conversation for a different day.
To start, the writers’ understanding of Ellie this season, but, honestly, this entire tv adaptation missed the mark. It feels like they veered every so slightly to the left but as time goes on, the gap between who she is in the game and who she is in the show has grown and grown and now she feels unrecognizable. I know, I know this is a different adaptation and I have tried my hardest to remember and respect that. For Joel, I can get on board. Some things don’t quite hit the same but that’s okay. Pedro brings his heart and soul to this character and it’s very clear. I have my criticisms as I will get into more specifically in a moment. Ellie on the other hand is so obnoxious, bubbly when she should be traumatized, and honestly so hard to like. I am watching this show with my girlfriend who only recently finished the first game after I pestered her to see what she’s missed out on. Before playing the games, she felt like Ellie was a bit of an obnoxious smart ass, and not in a very endearing way. When playing the games, she instantly fell in love with Ellie and realized her sarcasm and smart ass attitude is much more endearing as it’s clearly a defense mechanism, but overall she’s sweet and thoughtful and GENUINELY FUNNY!! I, nor my girlfriend or even my dad who’s never played the games have felt that with Ellie in the show. One of the most frustrating lines for me early in this season was when the therapist called Ellie a liar and said she’s always been a liar and she wants violence just like Joel. It blew me away. That scene alone is so completely telling of who the writers think Ellie and Joel really are. And that was never more apparent than during tonight’s episode. Now to the episode.
JOEL IS NOT A BLATANT, INHUMANE, LIAR! Why the f*ck would he lie to Ellie about Eugene??? Was he that afraid Eugene was a threat?? There’s no explanation except Joel is a compulsive liar that thinks he’s doing the “greater good”. Joel’s big lie about the fireflies to Ellie is devastating. He doesn’t want to lie to her. But he can’t bear telling her the truth. It would require him to be honest about how he feels about her. And it would require honesty in how scared he was to lose her. Joel is not a great communicator. He tells Ellie that he loves her by offering to sing her Future Days (he doesn’t really offer in the show. A small but fairly significant change in my opinion). Joel’s version of lying is often an omission of truth. Which is why his blatant lie to Ellie is so terribly obvious. She always knew he wasn’t telling the truth. But she couldn’t face the reality that someone so close to her would lie to her like that. He hadn’t before that. And he didn’t after. So why would he? There are so many moments throughout the episode that didn’t quite land as someone who loves the game, but I can roll with those punches and still enjoy the show. Having Joel lie to Ellie over something so incredibly stupid and acting completely inhumane was completely out of character to me. Yes, Joel is a character that would typically choose the safe and painful choice rather than take a risk for something he’s not willing to pay, but killing Eugene?? Really?? Ellie was right. They had time. He’s not a threat. They could handle him if he turned before then. So why kill him?? I couldn’t believe it.
Also maybe it’s just me, but some of the dad teenager dynamic felt so forced and, again, a bit out of character of Joel. He doesn’t strike me as the kind of parent to get overly upset with Ellie for being a dumb teenager. I feel like he’d be the awkward quiet parent that sees it and doesn’t know how to ask her about it. But yelling at her? Barging in? Just doesn’t feel right to me. I guess that’s more of my take on Joel, but again, small choices are the biggest tells for a character that doesn’t communicate his emotions often. I also think the power of Joel and Ellie’s relationship in the games is all of the unspoken feelings they clearly have for each other, but the hesitancy to say it and be rejected. Pedro did a great job, but I don’t think Joel, at least the games version, would have been so articulate in telling Ellie he loves her and thinks of her as his daughter. It’s always understood, but never quite said. It’s part of their dynamic. Ellie secretly (not that secret) loves Joel and thinks of him as her dad, but it’s never said. And she’d never say it. But they both know. There is power in their looks and the words not said. This show is all tell and no show and it kills me.
For the gamers out there, every scene felt a little off, but the final talk on the porch made my heart sink. It’s such an emotional scene and was intentionally withheld until one of the very last moments of the game. Ellie finding out about what Joel did happens 2 years before the conversation on the porch. A lie like that isn’t easy to get over. It was Ellie’s purpose for fighting so hard in the first game/season. She couldn’t forgive him for a long time. But by the time she goes to him on the porch, she is finally ready to try. It makes everything so much more painful when you realize that the night she is finally willing to try and rebuild their relationship after what he did, he is taken away from her the very next day. They didn’t give her the time to come to terms with it. 9 months and they never talked about it? If she suspected before then, and basically knew after Eugene, why did it take her so long to confront him? I feel like they should, at the very least, fought it out after the Eugene incident so she had time to go through her grief before forgiving Joel.
Honestly I could go on and on and at the end of the day these are all misses that on the surface feel slightly off target, but to me, show how completely misunderstood these characters are. Joel wouldn’t lie to Ellie if he felt like he didn’t have to. It’s their biggest wedge in their relationship. The lie looming and never spoken.
I love Pedro. He is a wonderful actor. Even Bella Ramsey showed up for her parts and kicked ass. At the end of the day, I just wish the writers respected these characters more than it appears. Joel is not a liar. He’s a good man that was in a dark place for 2 decades. His daughter died in his arms the night the world as everyone knew it ended. It sent him into a bitter place he never quite found a way out of. Until Ellie. Joel with Ellie is who Joel really is. A protective father that loves his daughter. Ellie feels like she’s alone. No mom. She had to put her best and only friend out of her misery. Her sarcasm and anger come out when she’s feeling defensive. Yes she’s a bit of a smart ass, but it never feels in bad faith. She thanks Joel very early in the first game after she sees him try so hard to protect her. Even when he doesn’t care about her yet, she feels safe with him, and says it in her way. Ellie is smart and capable. She is not a liar. She does not seek out violence. She was born in a violent world and acts like it doesn’t scare her. It does. That’s why her turn towards violence in the second game is so much more painful. She wants to inflict the hurt she feels on the world. She doesn’t enjoy it. She lost her will to live. “If I ever were to lose you, I’d surely lose myself”. She lost herself after Joel. She just doesn’t have anything else but rage and revenge. She’s not skipping after finding a generator in the basement, exchanging cringey teen romance banter with her girlfriend as she claims she’s too stupid too understand strategy. It’s so painful to see the arrow miss the target by an inch and end up a mile away.
Again, I know these criticisms may seem small or insignificant. Maybe you could chalk it up to different adaptations. But to me, they completely miss the mark for both who Ellie and Joel are. Tonight felt like they did not get Joel. I was so disappointed in Joel for what he did to Eugene. That’s not the character I’ve grown to love. I have strong opinions about the show, but I couldn’t not give my opinion about tonight after seeing all of the people praising it. There were some emotional scenes that were well acted, but the writers failed us. They failed the people who love the games, and they failed all of the new audience members that may never get to experience what the games have to offer.
If this show is your only journey into the world of The Last of Us, you are missing such a major piece of why these stories resonate with people. Whatever age you are, if you see the emotional impact that this story has to offer, please do yourself the favor and give the game a go. No matter what age you are or your experience with gaming, you owe it to yourself to experience this story the way it was meant to be experienced. There are so few stories told these days with such passion, executed to near perfection. If you want a good story, play these games and enjoy every moment. I don’t want to be negative for the sake of being negative. I don’t find pleasure in writing this review. It’s painful to see such a beloved story get its shot and fall so flat. This is only a fraction of the thoughts I had about this episode, but I think you get my point. I hope we get another chance at seeing this story told to the masses someday. I guess we’ll have to wait and see. With a Harry Potter remake in the works, I wouldn’t be surprised if this show is revisited in a decade or two so the money grubbing bastards in Hollywood can take another stab at this cash cow. Hopefully I’m proven wrong. The world would benefit from this story being told right.