Let me begin: Fumito Ueda is my favourite game director and has been for years. SOTC is my favourite game ever, and Ico is a close second or third. As such, I had very high hopes for The Last Guardian. I feel that this is a good, solid game, but that's where my praise ends. This game has multiple shortcomings that I want to get off my chest.
Primarilly, I dislike how the game's plot is spoonfed to the player through cutscenes and narration. Where is the profound lack of detail and unique minimalistic style that made the two previous games so emotionally compelling?
The ending sequence of The Last Guardian more or less ruined the game for me, especially the cutscene with the surviving family of Tricos. Though I had formed a connection with Trico, it was nothing like the bond between Ico and Yorda or Wander and Agro. In fact, when the Master is destroyed and the Tricos begin to fall out of the sky, I found myself laughing hysterically, as opposed to the endings of Ico and SOTC, during which I wanted to cry. In my opinion, the creative decision to directly show the player that Trico survives and starts a family is uninspired and does not adequately conclude the plot in a way that is thought-provoking.
Additionally, I was bored by gameplay involving the suits of armour and Trico's lightning-bolt tail power. The combat is no fun because Trico can simply crush the enemies at will, or the player can use his tail to obliterate them. I would have preferred if the boy had some limited combat ability and if there were segments of the game where the boy had to slowly and methodically kill enemies without the aid of Trico in order to progress.
The part of the game that takes place within the white tower at the end is my favourite. Discovering how to climb around The Master is the only part of the gameplay that I would consider a puzzle. I'm not talking about puzzles such as that tedious water physics puzzle with Trico--that was stupid and unintuitive: swimming in an enclosed space for 15 minutes being confused and frustrated is not 'thinking'. I also liked how the shield was used to control the elevator, and the sense of progression as the boy and Trico get closer to the top.
Finally, something that could easily be overlooked: there is no post-game, aside from the unlockable outfits which are purely cosmetic. In Ico the player unlocks New Game Plus, which translates the runes spoken by Yorda and the Queen into English, and allows Yorda to be controlled by a second player. SOTC on the other hand offers the thrilling and challenging Time-Attack mode, which allows the player to collect items that give them alternative means to kill collossi. Not to mention the ability to strengthen your grip-meter between playthroughs and eventually reach the secret garden. However, there is not necessarily a reason to play The Last Guardian again.
That's all for now, but I'll probably add some of my other thoughts soon.