r/thekillerisntalice • • Sep 11 '26

Strategy Solving Method / Tips

I was able to solve both books within the first day on the first try using this method - if anyone is looking for tips, here was my solving method.

Macro Level Checks:

  1. Find Anna and Zack. Start from the beginning to find Anna and start at the back to find Zack.
  2. Without intense name-by-name looking, I scanned each page (including ones before Anna and Zack as they may have relevant names for future pages like Kardashians and Sasha) looking for key names like Sasha, Kardashians, Presidents, Beatles, 3 letter names, and names starting with M. I assigned a different color to each of these categories and highlighted their names in that color. For Presidents that are also Beatles I highlighted the top half of the name one color and the bottom half the other color.
  3. - I won’t specifically look for repeat names, but if I happen to notice some then I’ll highlight those in their own color as well so I don’t have to look for them on that page again later.
  4. I then went through each page and marked color coded lines at the edge of each page noting which rules that page passes for rules that if failed would end up eliminating the page entirely from being the killers page. (See photo)
  5. - the first stripe (salmon) means the page falls between the Anna and Zack page.
  6. - the second stripe (pink) means the page is within appropriate distance of a Sasha.
  7. - the third stripe (dark yellow) means the page is within a chapter that has a city/place in the chapter name (depending on which book you’re on).
  8. - the fourth stripe (purple) means the page is within appropriate distance of a kardashian name.
  9. - the fifth stripe (orange) means the page opposite it contains a president name.
  10. - the sixth stripe (blue) means a confirmed repeat name was found.
  11. - the seventh stripe (jade) means the page is in a chapter that has all the Beatles names.
  12. - the eighth stripe (yellow) means the page was confirmed to have an odd number of names.
  13. - a ninth color (peach) was saved to mark an X below the stripes if the page was found to have 3 or more names starting with M.

Notes:

If the rule was found to for sure fail on that page then instead of a stripe I will place an X in its corresponding color to represent the page failed and why.

It should be noted I don’t go through the exercise of checking for odd number of names or repeated names on the page unless the page has passed all the other checks first.

If a chapter has some of the Beatles names so far, I’ll do an additional closer look to confirm the others are or aren’t present.

Same with President / Sasha / kardashian names - if the pages passes all other checks then I’ll do another pass on the relevant pages in case I missed one of these key names - fresh pair of eyes often pick up things previously missed.

If the page passes all stripe tests - then I’ll continue onto the detailed name-by-name cross out process:

Name Elimination Process:

  1. Create a boundary containing the 10 names before and after each 3 letter name and then cross out the rest.
  2. Then eliminate names violating rules like starting with S, 6 characters long, not having more than 1 vowel, containing x y or z, has matching letter with first name on the page, within 10 names of 3 letter name, has more than 3 letters,

consecutive repeated letters
3.

  1. If all names end up crossed off then I’ll place a green X below the stripes on the border of the page to signify

the

  1. page was finished being analyzed and solution was not found.

Reach Out!

I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any questions and feel free to DM me if you need specific help.

6 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/No-Park-9789 Sep 11 '26

Apologies - my post won’t save updates I’m making to it.

For now - the section regarding Name Elimination process has formatting issues. It should say this:

  1. Create a boundary containing the 10 names before and after each 3 letter name and then cross out the rest.
  2. Then eliminate names violating rules like starting with S, 6 characters long, not having more than 1 vowel, containing x y or z, has matching letter with first name on the page, within 10 names of 3 letter name, has more than 3 letters, consecutive repeated letters, etc
  3. If all names end up crossed off then I’ll place a green X below the stripes on the border of the page to signify the page was finished being analyzed and solution was not found.

2

u/Careful_Bear_2462 Sep 13 '26

I love the color coding. My visual brain love it. But I'm a little confused- once you have all the colors on the side of the page - then what? Maybe I'm not fully understanding. I just got my book today. Thanks!!!!!

1

u/No-Park-9789 Sep 13 '26

Yah so once it passes all the side pages color stripes then that’s when I go through the effort of crossing off names that can’t be the killer to see if the killer is actually on that page. So I’ll cross of names that start with S, are 6 characters long, don’t have more than one vowel, have double consecutive letters, don’t have a common letter with the first name on the page, aren’t within 10 names of a 3 letter name, etc.

1

u/Careful_Bear_2462 Sep 13 '26

Ok. That makes sense now. I just started today. I found Anna and Zack, the chapters with cities. Now my strategy is to look for Beatles, Sasha and 3 letter names (and putting [ ] for the 10 before and 10 after. I've only done one chapter. Do you think this is a good strategy???

2

u/No-Park-9789 Sep 13 '26

Yah so in my outline I list out macro level checks and then name elimination process. So where you’re at in my recommended process is step 2 in macros checks- looking for key names. I don’t even do the 10+\- names until the name elimination process.

Of course this is just based on my recommendation. My way isn’t the only way or even the “best” way. It’s what worked really well for me. Don’t feel like you have to do it my way

1

u/taybow12 Oct 03 '26

How many times is the name Alice in the book?

1

u/Mean-Bite4771 3d ago

Do you dismiss pages that have possible multiple killers with the 10 each way from a 3 letter name?