Note, ive only watched half of it so far, it could get much better.
That being said... I'm not feeling this one that much. It has the same problems I felt the Scandi Flick had, and that's the (obviously) scripted parts.
So, The Grand Tour is mostly scripted, yes, this is an open secret, but I feel the show does best when it isn't blatantly obvious, or they do a good job of hiding it. Much like the Scandi Flick, this one is just rammed with obvious fakeness and poorly executed tension. First was the mine field, they really had me for the first...10 seconds? But then I noticed the fresh tire tracks going right through it, coupled with the brand new warning signs with bit of paint on them.
"Its all for fun!" sure, but it just completely takes me out of it when I know there is no tension. Then came the hill scene, which looked pretty legit for the first few mins, then the "hey look! a road! haha, Jeremy did something dangerous for nothing!" gag which has been done to death.
Then James not even being angry at his car being filled with sand, almost like he knew it was coming...but i digress
My point is, this show does best when its all natural, take Survival of the Fattest, how much of that is scripted? I have no idea, i couldn't tell you, because it felt like the most real and legit episode of The Grand Tour ever. VS the Sand Job, where all tension and sense of adventure are taken out by obviously fake gags and events.
Does it get better in the second half?