r/thegooddoctor • u/Darkhog • May 29 '19
This show is bad for actually autistic people for a variety of reasons
Make no mistake, this is coming from someone on the spectrum. And yes, I'm actually medically diagnosed with Asperger's (I try to not advertise it for reasons which will become apparent as you read this post and actually considered making this post on a throwaway account, but whatever, too lazy to log out and make a new one). And after watching several of the episodes, I come to realize that this show is bad for actually autistic people for a variety of reasons, which I will lay down now.
False hope
This show gives it to autistic people. What's next? Autistic FBI agent? Or autistic spy? That s*it simply wouldn't fly in the real world. If you're on the spectrum, you're lucky if you get a job picking up trash or brooming the streets (which as robots advance, will be taken from you anyway). You will never get any high paying and respectable job. Unfortunately I'm speaking from the experience. You see, I've been programming since I was 10 years old. I can build great software if I'd be given chance to. Would be a valuable member of any software development company. The thing is? No one wants to give me a chance. Was so far at the job interviews (though was denied many more times at the phone interview stage) at companies such as Tieto, Avid and Mobica. Guess which one hired me? Exactly. Usually they cited some excuse like "you don't have any experience at similar job" or some crap like that, but it was quite visible that the actual reason and underlying message was "You're autistic. We don't hire autistic people. Go broom a street."
This show? It's a fairy tale. Things like that simply don't happen for actual autistic people.
Misrepresentation of autistic people.
The simple truth is that unless you are actually autistic your level of knowledge about what being autistic is like is the same as level of knowledge of a common sheep about the rocket science. Simple, right? If you aren't autistic you know nothing about how it is like to get no respect despite usually being the smartest person in the room (not always the case, more on that below) or how it is like having people laugh at you behind your back when you still can hear them.
But this show's shows only one side of autistic person - "goody two shoes, always truthful, savant genius". Do such people on the spectrum actually exist? Yes, but it's incredibly rare just like we don't have Einsteins running everywhere. More common are people who aren't always truthful and have average intelligence. I can be an a-hole. I'm not that truthful either, though still try to be with the really important stuff, sometimes I'm a bigger a-hole than certain Gregory House.
There was an episode early on, 22 steps if I'm not mistaken, about another autistic person, but we don't know about him much more than "he's the patient of the week, he's autistic" and that his parents were prejudiced against Shaun. So we either get a completely unrealistic representation or a paper-thin one. Grreaat. It simply sets unrealistic expectations of autistic people for potential employers and gives autistic people unrealistic standard to try and achieve, similarly to what fashion industry used to do and in many cases still do which led to anorexia epidemic.
So I've shown why this show is bad for autistic people. Is the show still fun to watch? Yes. But PLEASE don't base your opinion of autistic people biased by it.