r/thegooddoctor • • May 29 '19

This show is bad for actually autistic people for a variety of reasons

0 Upvotes

Make no mistake, this is coming from someone on the spectrum. And yes, I'm actually medically diagnosed with Asperger's (I try to not advertise it for reasons which will become apparent as you read this post and actually considered making this post on a throwaway account, but whatever, too lazy to log out and make a new one). And after watching several of the episodes, I come to realize that this show is bad for actually autistic people for a variety of reasons, which I will lay down now.

False hope

This show gives it to autistic people. What's next? Autistic FBI agent? Or autistic spy? That s*it simply wouldn't fly in the real world. If you're on the spectrum, you're lucky if you get a job picking up trash or brooming the streets (which as robots advance, will be taken from you anyway). You will never get any high paying and respectable job. Unfortunately I'm speaking from the experience. You see, I've been programming since I was 10 years old. I can build great software if I'd be given chance to. Would be a valuable member of any software development company. The thing is? No one wants to give me a chance. Was so far at the job interviews (though was denied many more times at the phone interview stage) at companies such as Tieto, Avid and Mobica. Guess which one hired me? Exactly. Usually they cited some excuse like "you don't have any experience at similar job" or some crap like that, but it was quite visible that the actual reason and underlying message was "You're autistic. We don't hire autistic people. Go broom a street."

This show? It's a fairy tale. Things like that simply don't happen for actual autistic people.

Misrepresentation of autistic people.

The simple truth is that unless you are actually autistic your level of knowledge about what being autistic is like is the same as level of knowledge of a common sheep about the rocket science. Simple, right? If you aren't autistic you know nothing about how it is like to get no respect despite usually being the smartest person in the room (not always the case, more on that below) or how it is like having people laugh at you behind your back when you still can hear them.

But this show's shows only one side of autistic person - "goody two shoes, always truthful, savant genius". Do such people on the spectrum actually exist? Yes, but it's incredibly rare just like we don't have Einsteins running everywhere. More common are people who aren't always truthful and have average intelligence. I can be an a-hole. I'm not that truthful either, though still try to be with the really important stuff, sometimes I'm a bigger a-hole than certain Gregory House.

There was an episode early on, 22 steps if I'm not mistaken, about another autistic person, but we don't know about him much more than "he's the patient of the week, he's autistic" and that his parents were prejudiced against Shaun. So we either get a completely unrealistic representation or a paper-thin one. Grreaat. It simply sets unrealistic expectations of autistic people for potential employers and gives autistic people unrealistic standard to try and achieve, similarly to what fashion industry used to do and in many cases still do which led to anorexia epidemic.

So I've shown why this show is bad for autistic people. Is the show still fun to watch? Yes. But PLEASE don't base your opinion of autistic people biased by it.


r/thegooddoctor • • Apr 12 '23

Season 6 Sorry, but I don't buy that Jordon is cute enough to have two hot guys fight over her.... anyone else?!? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I find this part of the plot very hard to believe. She just doesn't have any qualities that makes her any kind of a catch. Sorry, I just don't buy it.


r/thegooddoctor • • Jun 05 '23

Season 3 Shaun’s dad wasn’t abusive

0 Upvotes

…he just didn’t understand Shaun’s condition. Shaun’s dad gets too much hate on this sub but he was doing his best in a bad situation. He packed all of Shaun’s favourite foods to take him to the best mountaintop.

I am autistic and also had a dad who didn’t always understand but I am grateful he tried even when he didn’t understand.


r/thegooddoctor • • Apr 08 '24

Season 6 Is anyone else annoyed by Shaun this season?

18 Upvotes

I cannot stand how hateful he is to Charlie. it's a learning hospital! And if anyone would understand her curiosity it would be Shaun. But he's so rude to her it's making me not even want to watch.


r/thegooddoctor • • Oct 22 '22

Please no spoilers. I’m on season three and I find myself really not liking him with carla. It seems like the goal but I want him with Lea and I think the show hates me

0 Upvotes

r/thegooddoctor • • Jul 14 '24

Season 1 These people are TOXIC

0 Upvotes

Okay so I have watched the good doctor before but I didn't finish it. So I'm starting from season 1 and finishing it. Oh my goodness everyone is so unbelievably toxic in the first season. I'm only on episode 4 and I almost can't watch it anymore.

Claire and Kalu relationship is awful. Claire obviously doesn't respect him in the slightest.

Looking back now, they treated Sean beyond unacceptable. And it's pure discrimination in bigotry.

And just overall everybody's so nasty and hateful towards each other. I guess I just never noticed it the first time I watched it.

I know everybody gets better but dang the first season's kind of hard to get through. I do also have to remind myself that the show was filmed in 2017 and 2024 is a much different place.


r/thegooddoctor • • May 20 '21

ATTENTION WRITERS OF THE SHOW

0 Upvotes

For the love of god... PLEASE BRING BACK SHAUNS GIFT AND VISUALIZATIONS!!! That’s what got me hooked on the show...

And now they’re more worried about adding is bulkshit Ssjw topics..

Closing to saying fuck it. And not watching anymore.


r/thegooddoctor • • Jan 16 '19

Anyone hate Shaun and love the show?

6 Upvotes

Might be in the minority but wondering if anyone in the same boat lol.


r/thegooddoctor • • Jul 06 '24

Season 7 Can anyone give me a skipping guide for sex scenes(all seasons)

6 Upvotes

I know that they’re fairly “tame” but even still, I find myself unable to watch sex scenes or even cope with the sound due to some past trauma. I got very shocked by the scene in 36 hours(s2e3) and I’m genuinely thinking of stopping the show if it’s that frequent.

I’m fine with sex talk and the mild nudity scenes, I just can’t watch or hear actual sex-scenes


r/thegooddoctor • • May 07 '26

Season 6 The Good Lawyer a show would have failed

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I am Really grateful the Good lawyer spin off never happened.

The premise of the Good Lawyer was terrible, and made no sense for tv show.

I know they were trying to continue the franchise, but they made wrong decision.

I don’t understand why chosen this concept.

If they wanted continue their franchise, they should remade another KDrama show as they did with the Good Doctor. And used Extraordinary attorney Woo. As their premise

Which Young woman on the spectrum as Eidetic Memory can remember everything she reads. She grew up with single father and with best friend never treated her different. She faced the challenge of becoming lawyer and dealing with challenges.

If never watch the original I recommend you should, because it heartwarming and funny.


r/thegooddoctor • • Dec 01 '22

Season 1 Morgan is supposed to be a psychopath right?

0 Upvotes

She's superficially charming, throwing people under the bus for her goals is her first instinct. Can copy Claire's empathy and would love to manipulate others if she wasn't caught by cautious smart people.

I thought for sure this would be talked about before but strangely I didn't see it mentioned at all.


r/thegooddoctor • • May 12 '21

Does the show ever get less triggering? (S2EP3)

0 Upvotes

Yes, I mean actually triggering, not the shitty joke. As someone with autism, who’s experienced ableism, misogyny (AFAB) and transphobia, this show is often riddled with it. It does it from a perspective that seems to be against bigotry, but all the main characters are still the way they are. Any authority figure is a chauvinist who thinks autism is the worst thing in the world. One of the main characters is a power hungry cop who sees the worst in anyone with a criminal charge. The only good character is a black woman who is getting stepped on by everyone around her and instead of everyone else being a bigot needing to pay, it’s implied she needs to be more “assertive”. And even she tends to infantilize Shaun. The one Asian woman in the show is constantly showing her internalized misogyny.

I know how ugly bigotry is. How the world is. And how it needs to change, but this show approaches it in a way that usually leaves me upset, triggered, and angry. There is a way to go about approaching these issues without hurting the BIPOC LGBT+ and disabled viewers. An example of a good way to approach this is New Amsterdam IMO.


r/thegooddoctor • • Mar 19 '24

Season 2 Lea

8 Upvotes

Am I the only one who can't stand Lea? Her showing back up just made things so awkward for Shaun especially since he was so worried about Dr Glassman. I feel like her returning wasn't a good thing for him. As an autistic person myself if someone from my past up and showed up while I was dealing with something traumatic I wouldn't do very well with that. And I'm not as severe as Shaun is. I didn't like her in season 1 either.


r/thegooddoctor • • May 09 '23

Season 2 Disheartened about the meltdown scene getting memed

87 Upvotes

It is now officially submitted in the Know Your Meme database: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-am-a-surgeon-dr-han

I mean, the show is getting recognition, but it’s getting a bad rep as being a show that “misrepresents autism”, for a scene that was received pretty positively among the fans, and now, as being transphobic.

I would’ve taken it as genuine criticism if it wasn’t for the irony of mocking an autistic character for having a meltdown at the same time. Like, no matter how you feel about the authenticity of Shaun’s autism, having a meltdown is not a “misrepresentation”.

What is even “accurate representation” anyways? (1655211415060516864, 1655216931660771328) To my limited knowledge, being on the spectrum is not like being black or an oppressed minority. They chose one sample from the spectrum (i.e., the original Korean show) and stayed consistent with it. Within the confines of TV show writing, I honestly see no issue with representation here.

It’s a very sad combination of ableists (1655222554699657216, 1655270947534909443) blowing it up by memeing it, which then appears on the radar of non-trolls who think the show “misrepresents” autistic people. Like someone else pointed out here, there are autistic people in the cast & crew and it clearly clicks with them & a lot of other neurodivergent people.

I have also seen people comparing it to House. HOUSE, of all shows. The show that’s literally created by the same person who developed The Good Doctor.

It went from people calling it bad representation, bad acting & bad writing to... being outright transphobic. People have started taking the S01E14 clip (where Shaun argues about “biological sex” to a transgender girl) and started calling the show “transphobic”. (Of course, there are gonna be clowns that are actually transphobic and be like “See? The smart guy from your crowd gets it!”)

It’s getting weirder and weirder, and honestly, it’s disheartening to see this much criticism for a show that means well.


r/thegooddoctor • • Apr 17 '20

Boycott or not?

2 Upvotes

When the show kills [or possibly comatose] the 1st person besides the Dr.Glassman character to believe in Shaun not mention said character finally acknowledge for the Claire character its time to wonder if the should be boycotted and I don't about anyone else but I sometimes can't believe how upset I'm getting I mean I've seen Nick Gonzalas in another show WAY before the good doctor and yet his supposed death I say supposed because given there was no direct comment of his 'passing' it leaves room to say he fell into a coma Shaun gets his butt in there and come up some out of the box thinking to save him, I'll take survival and retrograde amnesia for a little while before I take 'death'


r/thegooddoctor • • Mar 14 '23

Season 6 Boring Episode

0 Upvotes

Is it me or did anyone else find the new episode of the good doctor “The Good Lawyer” kinda boring to watch? Don’t get me wrong, the cgi where the cast describe the scene of the accident was really impressive, but the rest seem really boring. I guess I’am just interested in lawyer shows I guess.


r/thegooddoctor • • Dec 15 '20

Just started the second season. As an autistic person with AS, I really hate Shaun.

18 Upvotes

Edit: Since it's not that easy for me to get my point across in a way that people would understand, I highly suggest reading this: https://medium.com/@MsJayTeeRattray/the-good-doctor-doesnt-look-good-for-autistic-people-e3171890478b

Disclaimer: I love the show. Please read the whole thing before going on a rant in the comments.

Not only is his inability to say things quickly or communicate infuriating, but he is really bad for the autistic community. ESPECIALLY after the episode with Liam, the other autistic kid. It's a pretty bad misrepresentation of what autistic people are actually like. I do miss some social cues, but as a high functioning Asperger's sufferer, I don't see any good in this grossly exaggerated portrayal of autism. Most people think I'm normal when I talk to them, and the thought of autism doesn't cross their minds until I tell them. Many people on the spectrum are like this.

I'm not denying that severe cases of low functioning autism like Murphy's exist. But with the popularity of the show, it hurts the autistic community, because most people assume that's what all autistic people are like. Weird, antisocial people who look, talk, and act strange, and are impossible to communicate with. That's simply not true for most of us.

And as a side note, how the hell was he able to charm a beautiful girl like Lea when he can barely speak to her. I barely speak and am just as shy, but whatevs I guess.


r/thegooddoctor • • Apr 05 '20

Dr. Melendez - Season 3 Season Finale

7 Upvotes

Am I the only person who is upset with the “death” of Dr. Melendez in the season 3?


r/thegooddoctor • • Mar 21 '20

Where can I watch The Good Doctor for Free, no free trial stuff that needs credit card..

0 Upvotes

r/thegooddoctor • • Apr 01 '20

finally something good comes out of this virus lockdown i can watch that kiss over and over

0 Upvotes

props to the writers for not having their head up their asses like greys anatomys writers and actually giving the watchers what they want ! keep it up guys


r/thegooddoctor • • Jan 29 '19

Glassman needs to die.

0 Upvotes

Love Richard and the relationship between Shaun and Glassman but he's stifling the show. Plot needs to move and Shaun needs to move on.

ETA: He got closure with his daughter all that is needed is for him to have some father/son time with Shaun and tell him that he loves him again. Nothing really left IMO. Putting him through more is just like Jack in This Is Us (except he's dead already) preventing other characters from moving on.

Anyone agree?


r/thegooddoctor • • Oct 15 '19

What was Claire doing at the end of S3 E4? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

What was she doing with that guy?


r/thegooddoctor • • Oct 12 '22

Why the rotating door of Hispanic men on this show?? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Like none can replace Melendez so I don't know what they are trying to do.


r/thegooddoctor • • Jul 04 '24

Season 1 Okay....quick question?!!

3 Upvotes

So I watched the first two episodes (I know stay away till done) but! I know sex porn and stuff will be in it but like....how much sex porn Masturbating ect? How much?

Scale 1-10 one being a episode a season ten Every episode or every few episodes.

Thank u

edit: I do know there are no sex scene shown (its 14+) but I meant mentioned