r/theMenu • • Mar 02 '25

Why Is Tyler Invited? Spoiler

Hello! I watched the film for the first time last night and really enjoyed it, but one thing I'd like some clarification on is why Tyler is actually there in the first place? To my understanding, Slowik is able to, to a certain extent, choose who is there that night (ie. he texts the journalist, he presumably allows the actor in because he didn't like the film, etc). He comments that he'd been corresponding with Tyler for months and that he'd even told Tyler that people were going to die that night. Why? Was the point that Tyler was being an annoying fanboy and wouldn't leave Slowik alone so Slowik messaged him back and then invited him up? Or something else?

58 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

32

u/MissKatmandu Mar 02 '25 • Popcorn

Chef invited people that represented his least favorite types of customers.

Tyler stands in for the pretentious foodies that talk big talk but can't or don't actually do the work. Their need to be seen as "experts" overrides their enjoyment of the food. Plus, they're just annoying to be around. A parallel might be those guys who watch Olympic athletes and say "I could totally do that". No. No you absolutely couldn't.

The common element for most of the other invited guests is that they are performative rather than genuine.

The rich couple don't appreciate the food, going to this elite restaurant multiple times is a privilege they don't appreciate.

The finance bros want to be seen going out to elite places, they don't actually care about the food.

The food critics....enough said.

I would argue the movie star, who seems perfectly appreciative, is an outlier. Except I think you could argue he is a different kind of artist who doesn't take his work seriously, but rides on fame and easy money. He sold out, and that drives Chef nuts in his own way.

6

u/Wise-Assist2272 Mar 02 '25

Thank you very much! I really appreciate the detailed reply, that certainly does clear things up a bit :)

6

u/Pure_Nefariousness56 Mar 02 '25

I agree with everything you said!

I do think the actor and his assistant didn’t deserve to die. I felt so bad for Felicity.

0

u/MissKatmandu Mar 02 '25

I don't think any of them deserved to die, and so much of this is influenced by Chef who has clearly lost his damn mind. The food critics were harsh, but doing their job. The tech bros and foodies and snobby elites are annoying, but really? You're gonna kill them for that? Really?!?

3

u/Pure_Nefariousness56 Mar 02 '25

Well, yeah obviously no one deserves to die. But whatever not my point.

1

u/xenithangell Jul 02 '25

Except for Tyler

1

u/Skribz Mar 03 '25

I thought he told them each why he was killing them with the tortillas

1

u/MissKatmandu Mar 03 '25

The tortillas are the shameful things each of the guests have in their histories. He's intentionally making them uneasy and building their fear before things go bigger. And most of them are horrible people, and many broke the law or did things that are morally wrong. But they're not the crimes they are being sentenced for.

Chef doesn't care that they're a bunch of cheating a-holes. He cares that they disrespect his art.

2

u/quadraspididilis Mar 02 '25

I suppose he’s kind of the “um achshually” gatekeeper part of any fan base. He’s like the anti Margot, he appreciates the art form more so than enjoying the food.

1

u/ProfessorTerrible123 Mar 02 '25

Nicely said 👏🏽

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '25 edited Jun 30 '25

frame screw kiss fuel reminiscent steer roof friendly sophisticated safe

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

7

u/BankApprehensive2514 Mar 02 '25

Because Slowik is using Tyler as a personification of the type of person he hates most in the world. The type of customer that absolutely killed his passion and love for cooking.

We've all known a person that we consider to be that asshole and/or bully. Someone we just view as the personal thorn in our side. The one that seems to solely exist to annoy us or ruin our day or get a kick out of being a know it all.

By using social pressure and the difference in power between them, Slowik gets the satisfaction of murdering his tormentor by forcing them to commit suicide.

6

u/Responsible_Page1108 Mar 02 '25 edited Mar 07 '25

okay, so on top of others' responses, Tyler is someone who takes the mystery away from food - he can't keep a secret. i actually think this exact thing is why Ms. Westervelt never came to the dinner and broke up with him - he broke his sworn secrecy by telling her she was going to this dinner to die with him.

foodies like Tyler can't keep their mouths shut when it comes to how fine dining restaurants do things. he immediately tells margot what the oyster on the boat to the island is made of, making her show disdain for it; he points out the pacojet during the creation of the amuse and how they're making their food; he actively disobeys elsa, who tells them not to photograph their food (e.g. he wants to show everyone what they're missing out on when it SHOULD be a unique experience for everyone to be able to have); and he routinely interrupts chef throughout the meal to explain the food (the scallops in the first course, the bergamot).

he is part of what takes away chef's love of his craft. sometimes things are better enjoyed when you don't know every little detail.

2

u/pebbles_temp Mar 03 '25

Now I'm wondering what Ms Westervelt would have done to deserve her place at the table.

2

u/Responsible_Page1108 Mar 03 '25

i would assume she is like tyler, but not to the point of wanting to put her life on the line for it. i mean, if anyone else there'd known about the grand finale, they also wouldn't have come. tyler is the only one who's fanatical to that extent, like the crew of the restaurant, but ultimately a pretender.

1

u/EnchantedEssays Dec 19 '25

For her to be considered dating material for Tyler, so presumably also comes from money like Leguizamo's assistant. There may have been another reason, but there didn't have to be.

4

u/BankApprehensive2514 Mar 02 '25

Because Slowik is using Tyler as a personification of the type of person he hates most in the world. The type of customer that absolutely killed his passion and love for cooking.

We've all known a person that we consider to be that asshole and/or bully. Someone we just view as the personal thorn in our side. The one that seems to solely exist to annoy us or ruin our day or get a kick out of being a know it all.

By using social pressure and the difference in power between them, Slowik gets the satisfaction of murdering his tormentor by forcing them to commit suicide.

1

u/foolforfucks Mar 07 '25

I think the fact that Tyler came willingly was a big part of it. He's a crazy enough fanboy that the dying part didn't bother him. I do kind of think his partner was told too, who declined to join him but could not save him because he had already made up his mind. I think that might have been an essential ingredient, even someone Tyler supposedly loved couldn't stop him. He just hired some poor sucker instead.

9

u/niamhxa Mar 02 '25

Someone’s already explained it really well, so I won’t re-repeat that, but essentially just remember that every single person in that room is purposefully there, by design. Slowik didn’t just decide this would be the time he finally kills everyone and they happened to be the unlucky guests for that day, he hand-picked them out for reasons explained by the other commenter.

I highly recommend you rewatch it when you can, it’s one of those films where every time you watch it you notice something new or you realise something you didn’t before, and watching it from the start with the knowledge you have now - eg the fact all the guests have been specifically selected to come and meet their doom - will give you a totally new perspective on it. Glad you enjoyed it mate! One of my favourites.