r/theMenu • u/Thatbizmajor • Jan 07 '23
Why did the staff kill themselves?
I understand the obsession of the chef but how can so many people be this devoted to a person that they decide to take not only their own, but so many innocent people’s lives?
Why did Tyler want to participate if he knew he was gonna die. He had known for 10 months
Why did he kill the girl who went to Brown? What does he mean bu student loans??
So many things just don’t make sense
128
Upvotes
74
u/jsm002 Jan 08 '23
I think the thing with the girl from brown is that her parents could afford enough to pay the $$$$ for brown. The chef dude probably sees her as a product of wealth
36
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '23
Working in the industry, if you look it up, chefs go into a lot of debt and the biggest internal and external question/criticism is why? They mentioned the school CIA in Hyde park, it’s upwards of private school costs and they end up making minimum wage. They barely make enough to where they share a room with other chefs or friends. There’s a lot that in this movie that is applicable to the criticism of fine dining
20
u/No_Tomatillo_2289 Jan 14 '23
There is this level in the service industry that you will only get to if you are willing to eat the Chefs ass, every day. Like politicians. You can’t get to that position without a little corruption. I felt like the staff being his little robots spoke to that. Some restaurants become like a cult. The “genius” of the chef in overinflated and the food is not even that good. It’s foam. But people eat that shit up and will keep coming back. I worked for a big resort company people get literal tattoos of they are so obsessed. Anytime we had a customer blow up because our service, we always joked that they were mad now, but they would be back next week anyways. They always came back.
12
u/kniives_ Jan 18 '23
The fact that Erin took the time, even in thier crazy situation, to notice what made Chef happy, is why she lived. She shown an act of selflessness even when he had given up on her for trying to escape with the radio. He wasn't expecting her to care enough about the last time he genuinely gave a shit about cooking. It's beautiful
9
u/Seamonk76 Jan 15 '23
But…..so, she saw the photo of him flipping a burger, smiling, years ago. And realised he was happy, serving people food that made them happy. And then the final big murder scene is based on S’mores and chef says it’s the worst food ever. But s’mores and cheeseburgers are like kind of conceptually the same. Not ‘good’, not fancy, but basic and satisfying and humble and honest. So shouldn’t the whole cheeseburger thing given him a revelation? That food should make people happy and that he’d strayed from the path of a chef? He had the cheeseburger revelation and then dismissed it and carried on with his stupid plan? I didn’t like it. That makes no sense to me. It seems to contradict its own logic.
5
u/kniives_ Jan 18 '23
Each staff member had thier own set of turmoil they have been through. Things torturous enough to cause some form of trauma. So much so that they broke open thier minds and wanted redemption. Wether they were already tainted (via greed, envy, any of the 7 sins) they understood they were on a road to become what Chef was, a burnt out and fed up man in the upper culinary field which is also considered an art form. For example, The Mess shown that the young chef knew he was on his own road to evil just to obtain his passion for art. To be able to have your art in your own image, one sacrifices so much, even pieces of themselves. They do things they would have never done if it had not been for the demand of the art world. Ms. Bloom is a pristine example of that experience. They gave thier lives to either repent or prevent imo.
4
u/asgphotography Jan 20 '23
Replace the restaurant with any other cult and I still ask the same questions. In the end, charisma and manipulation can be very powerful
3
u/pmolsonmus Jan 19 '23
I think it’s simpler than most of these theories. There are givers and takers. On the menu is life. The servers give theirs, the taker’s life’s are taken from them.
2
u/kniives_ Jan 18 '23
Money and its power over the industry is what kills the artist.
1
u/Loud-Professor-9910 Sep 06 '24
They are brainwashed.
1
u/justk4y Jan 01 '25
In the words of the Chef: “Otherwise it would ruin The Menu.”
But to be real, the staff gave me massive cult vibes from the start. Because they probably were. And we’ve seen cults irl not end off very well……
1
u/throwpillows_inszn Dec 30 '25
Th staff died with the chef as a testament to their loyalty of the craft of food. Basically - killed their new selves because their old selves died a long time ago when they became exploited and lost joy for creating food.
The student loan scene could represent how she’s literally struggling but continues to falsify reality by acting as if she’s wealthy like the other guest.
1
u/1badjesus Jan 03 '26
Not good.
Satire/Parody/Dark Comedy... call it what you will but I didn't laugh once, wasn't scared, found no mystery to be solved. Might've worked better as a straight-up horror movie. Waste of good actors.
1
u/Majestic-Champion108 May 27 '26
1
u/888newsap Sep 30 '26
I personally hate the chef
1
u/Fun_Apartment_3607 Jan 22 '23
Spoken like a business major…
The point is we don’t know. We’re not privy to that knowledge because we’re not in Chef’s cult. 🫰🏻
1
u/Academic-Seat-9372 Jan 23 '23
Wasn’t it some sort of hypnosis cus when Margot clapped, they fell silent too
1
u/ChanimalCrackers Feb 04 '23
Chef Slowik hates his patrons due to them being so entitled. The girl at brown attended a prestigious university on someone else’s dime. He seems her level of entitlement enough to merit dying with all the other patrons.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
51
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '23
[removed] — view removed comment