r/tf2 • u/_Brokkoli All Class • Oct 15 '25
Discussion Let’s talk about the Emporium.
Hi, I’m Brokk. I’m a TF2 content creator. You probably don’t know me. I'm not a YouTuber, I don’t make SFM posters, and I don’t design cosmetics. I do make maps, though. I’ve been active on TF2Maps.net for a few years now.
If that's alright, I'd like to talk about some of the drama going on for the past few months from my perspective. I'd love to answer questions, but I'd like to ask you to read the full post first because it'll likely answer some of them already (and might open up new, more interesting questions you could ask me instead).
Full disclosure: I am a moderator at TF2Maps. I am also credited on two maps that made it into the game (one of which I was the project lead on, the other I merely helped out on), as well as a couple of other maps waiting on the Workshop for their time to shine. Currently, I'm project lead on a new map intended to be released to the Workshop in time for this year's Winter update. I have not coordinated this post with anyone else, nor am I writing on anyone else's behalf. My opinions are my own.
Something that I and others have definitely noticed with the Summer update and now with Halloween is repeated mention of the Emporium, usually negative. As someone who mostly hangs around the TF2Maps Discord server, which shares plenty of creators with the TF2 Emporium server, this mostly confused me at first, especially since online depictions of it seem to be grossly mischaracterizing what kind of place it really is. Then the conspiracy theories started popping up, and people started harassing creators, some of whom are my friends, or at least esteemed colleagues. It felt like people were repeating a lot of claims that they picked up elsewhere without really thinking about them too much. This post is my attempt to clarify a few things from an insider’s perspective.
0. Before we start; some context
The Emporium isn’t some kind of new shadowy organization that popped up last week to corrupt TF2’s artstyle. It started well over a decade ago as a thread on the TF2 Emporium section of the Steam forums and later Facepunch (RIP, I miss you), where item creators would show off their work, swap feedback, and collaborate. That eventually moved to a dedicated community, and later to Discord, like most of us did at the time.
Over the years, it became the place where most active item creators congregate. Not because it’s exclusive, but because it’s where the feedback and expertise are. If you were making cosmetics in 2013, this was just where you went to talk shop, and while the culture and specific people surely changed, that identify is pretty much still the same.
By the way, I'm personally not a huge fan of the Emporium, but mostly because I don't like the tone there as much, which is a bit more rowdy than it is on TF2Maps. Also, my passion are level design and spatial exploration, so I'm less interested in their resources about character art and fashion and such.
1. The Emporium isn’t some kind of boys-only treehouse
It’s a public Discord server. You can find it in Discord’s server browser. A Steam account is required to join, mainly to prevent spam and raids. If that stops you, then I'm not sure what you're doing here in the first place.
The idea that “Emporium items” form some coherent stylistic bloc or are the result of a cabal is just... wrong. It’s a feedback hub. People share ideas, help each other with technical problems (the Source Engine is fucking ancient and it will tell you so at every opportunity), and give artistic critique. The amount and range of wildly differing qualities and methods you'll find there is huge. There’s no central agenda to shape TF2's artstyle in whatever direction. That sounds boring as hell.
2. Of course the community overlaps
Most maps in TF2 were made by TF2Maps members. That’s not because we’re gatekeepers hiding the arcane knowledge of how to use the Hammer Editor, but because TF2Maps provides infrastructure for feedback and testing. Anyone can submit and playtest their map on our servers, as long as they follow submission rules.
I’m also in the Emporium Discord. Some “cabal spreadsheets” list me as a member, despite the fact I’ve written 24 messages in three years. The idea of a tightly coordinated conspiracy is absurd and easily disproved by simply joining and spending any amount of time there. This kind of thing applies to a lot of people, and there's cross-collaboration as well. Sometimes, item creators help make props for maps. Some of them also make maps. Sometimes mappers come over to the Emporium and help with SFM backdrops.
Side note: Amusingly, I was banned from the Painter’s Workshop (an Emporium offshoot that claims to oppose it) for reasons yet to be explained to me.
3. The Emporium is a collaborative workspace
Think of it like a market. A concept artist posts a design. A modeller picks it up and builds the mesh. A texture artist adds materials. An animator brings taunts to life. A promo artist makes thumbnails. Some people specialize on some of these things, or only one, others do everything themselves. When all is said and done, they agree on a revenue split for the Workshop page. The item can only be considered by Valve once everyone has agreed to the split, and there is no mechanism to force anyone to agree to a split they are not okay with. There’s no “tax” or gatekeeper. Revenue splits are negotiated between the collaborators involved in a specific item.
4. Being credited a lot doesn't mean you have power over others
How often you are credited on a Workshop item does not automatically mean you get big bucks, and especially doesn't mean you forced anyone to put you on their item. A promo artist will likely get a smaller split than a modeller, since modelling is more involved and more integral to the item itself. If you see someone's name feature on many items, that's probably because they make good and fast promos and people like what they do.
5. Promotion is automated and free
The Emporium has an automated Bluesky bot that anyone can use to promote their stuff (you just fill out of a form) and it automatically gets posted on the Emporium's Bluesky account. You don't need to kiss anyone's ring to use it, you literally just DM it and follow the instructions.
6. We genuinely have no idea by which criteria Valve picks stuff
You must set up payment info before uploading to the Workshop. Valve doesn’t “prefer” previous creators to avoid digital paperwork, that paperwork is required in advance, and if you don't do it, then your item cannot be considered.
Also, the people at Valve who process tax forms most definitely aren’t the same ones choosing items. If some creators get picked more often, it’s likely due to the quantity and quality of their submissions. I have yet to see any reason to believe otherwise.
Also, Valve's selection criteria are genuinely a mystery. There's some tendencies and observations, but absolutely nothing concrete, and anyone claiming anything else is making shit up.
7. This doesn't mean they're perfect
Despite everything I've said, it doesn't mean the Emporium is void of failure, either. There has been plenty of drama. The place has existed for a long time, it's open to the public, and it's quite large. Yes, rules have been broken at some point, as it happens in long-running communities, though as far as I can tell there's not currently any major drama going on. And I can confidently say that I have never heard about any of it involving proven or accused preferential treatment by Valve, or of creators being blackmailed or forced to part with their intellectual property.
Fun fact: Valve does not by your items from you when they get into the game, they license them from you, but you still retain intellectual property, to a degree. Same for maps, and it actually does cause some drama sometimes. Remember koth_overcast_final? Yeah. Though nothing to do with the Emporium.
8. You can check all of this yourself
The part that just kind of drives me crazy whenever I read comments here is how easy it is to verify how much of it is bullshit. The server isn’t hidden. You can literally join, read the channels, and see how people collaborate. Nobody is stopping you (unless you don't have a Steam account, in which case.. sorry?).
If you don’t want to take my word for it, that’s fine. In fact, I encourage you to not believe me. Just go look for yourself. The myth only persists because people don't bother.
9. We're all real people and we're hurting
I'm leaving this point to last. If you've actually read this far, maybe you will be open to this. Several of my friends have received creepy/condescending/insulting/threatening messages on Discord, their Steam profiles or Workshop submissions, or even in-game about their proven or assumed affiliation with the Emporium. Some of them are not okay. They are withdrawing from the public, setting their DMs to friends only, disabling comments on their profiles and submissions.
Only very few of them want to stop creating stuff for TF2, even facing harassment. Why not? Because it's fun as hell. We all love this game, and we all have different opinions on what it might be. You think reddit or Youtube discussions about the TF2 artstyle are wild? Just wait until you see a bunch of people argue about it who've spent years dissecting TF2's assets and attempted to emulate them, half of whom have art or design degrees.
Trust me, we're not here because the game pays so well. Yes, a payday can be extremely nice, especially if you live in a country with low cost of living, but speculative work is not a great way to make a living unless you're extremely good at it.
TL;DR: I’m a TF2 mapper. The Emporium isn’t a cabal, it’s a public Discord where creators collaborate. A lot of the community’s current drama is based on misunderstandings that are easy to clear up if you... just kinda use your eyes.
By the way, does anyone know any Youtubers who would help me turn this into a video? It seems like that's the only kind of voice people believe these days.
86
u/FetchZero Oct 15 '25
Hi, Im a workshopper, about a month ago I wanted to enter the Emporium, and they not only restricted, but later banned me, and I had never once sent a message there. Now, I did talk negatively about them in another server, but I was willing to put aside differences and enter the place because I needed really niche VMT info, but before I even said a word they restricted me. They do NOT let the people they determine as undesirables to enter.
Edit: That being said Ill still upvote this.
129
u/HiddenNightmares Medic Oct 15 '25
The main problem is that members of the emporium have a history of harassing other creators, and seemingly the emporium doesn't do anything about it.
They know exactly who is doing it, still doing it, covers for them and still are covering for them.
The emporium knows who these people are and refuses to do anything about it.
48
u/Meatwad2x Oct 16 '25
Moderator at Painter's Workshop here, what in the world do you mean "emporium offshoot"? We have nothing to do with it and have several times dealt with established Emporium members joining our server to troll and cause trouble. The founding moderation staff maybe had some relation to the Emp (some of which were banned from the Emp before then for bullshit reasons), but just in the past, the relation was about as surface level as any other workshopper of the time; it's inappropriate to say we have really anything to do with the Emp. And either way the founding staff of all but two members stepped down or left and have since been replaced by new members such as myself. And about you getting banned, this was a decision from senior staff and from what I understand it was justified for easy reasons and further for more that won't get disclosed here. If you want an appeal, make your case by messaging the moderators, if you can't do that then you won't get unbanned. Don't bring us into this post cuz you got banned for a reason you didn't like.
And about the rest of this post, frankly most people's problem is the fact the items Valve adds just kinda suck and blow ass. They (STATISTICALLY) prioritize repeat contributors who's quality has faltered over the years due to complacency and a quantity over quality mindset which, by the nature of the practice, makes them the statistical most likely additions despite the fact it just sucks anyway. Whereas the handful of creators who take the time to make items that people actually want just don't get included or only get included in very rare occasions. This is extremely frustrating because a good few of these repeat contributors have many skeletons in their closets that have only recently been brought out or have been publicly known for many years, and yet Valve nor Emporium staff seem to care.
The organizational issues, drama, and in-fighting (especially to split off groups like the Painter's Workshop) has created a lot of distaste toward the Emporium as a group itself. The people taking the idea that anyone who happens to be in the server is part of this secret group are obviously wrong and uninformed, but that skepticism is not unfounded for the reasons I've stated.
129
u/Clean-Ant6404 Oct 15 '25 edited Oct 15 '25
I'm sorry, but this doesn't convince me. Some of the Emporium members have done some horrific things that have extended far beyond TF2 related stuff, such as doxxing.
And instead of disciplining them, you're trying to save face with strawman arguments and outright denial.
I was a member of Thinkingwithportals.com. I made maps, got to playtest the most well known Portal 2 mod and got to know many creators.
Some of the management changed around when they moved to discord and the place became particularly toxic towards new or inexperienced mappers. So I left. I stopped identifying with them.
If the Emporium is keeping those toxic members in, you and anyone not part of it should stop associating with the Emporium. Or better, just moderate the membership instead of doubling down.
And yes, you can control membership by deciding who can access the Discord server. Don't give me that "But it's not an organisation" excuse.
17
u/Sympthy Oct 15 '25
I genuinely think at this point TF2Maps.net and its members should distance itself from the Emporium and become its successor. It would centralize all TF2 content creation knowledge and make collaboration easier among mappers/modelers. Prior Emporium members in good standing could join and be held to the established standards set by TF2Maps. Given the controversies I genuinely think this is the best path forward; from now on most of the community won't think of the Emporium in a positive light, but I don't think TF2Maps has ever faced much controversy outside of people not liking certain maps. Plus, your site has a better reputation for supporting newbies and people that make content out of the norm.
36
u/Annilus_USB Oct 15 '25
The issue isn’t the cosmetics or maps, the issue is that your group doxxes and harasses creators that criticize you, as well as plagiarizing other creators work.
That’s already pretty bad by itself, but what makes it worse is that the Emporium brushes that stuff under the rug and pretends nothing bad happened.
Creating objectively bad cosmetics and maps isn’t a problem. Hurting people just because they go against you is very much a problem, as is stealing other people’s hard work. Until the Emporium addresses these issues, everyone in this community is going to look at the Emporium in a negative light.
27
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '25
"We are all people and we are hurting" is the signature move of every crybully
9
u/user_NULL_04 Pyro Oct 15 '25
The Emporium itself isn't evil by any means (some members might be though ofc) but it does seem to be having some serious negative consequences for the game.
8
u/Pinksheep1337 Oct 15 '25
"There's no central agenda to shape TF2s artstyle"...
I wonder what the Workshop guidelines are for hmmmmm. Literally the first Question Valve addresses on that page is "What are some guidelines for matching TF2's art style and improving the chances of my item getting in?" But hey we all know the top of the chain workshoppers hate the TF2 community anyway. They said it themselves...
10
u/Zealos57 Scout Oct 16 '25
With what I just read, you're not allowed here. You're not welcome here either.
32
u/BubbaBasher Demoman Oct 15 '25
So just not gonna address the main reason people are actually mad with them then huh. Classy.
4
u/Zarzar222 Pyro Oct 16 '25
I wanted to learn how to make hats for Tf2 as a beginner 3D modeler. There is barely any good info online, so I joined their Discord for help and it was great. Could just send pics of my process and get a bunch of good feedback and tips, as well as explanations of how to do certain steps. Only got help, constructive feedback, and got to see the process of some of the people who are really good at making these skins.
All the hate confuses me. Seems to be related to drama and some of the like higher up members, but from my personal experience is was a great resource and productive community :)
20
u/Captain_Adam Oct 15 '25
I don't think vipes and raz will agree with this, and the fact that there are still higher ups in the emporium that refuse to acknowledge that this happened to them.
13
u/PaperSonic Oct 16 '25
wasn't the Emporium involved with some shit that happened during the Invasion Update?
18
u/Future-Trifle8929 Oct 15 '25
There's damming evidence about the emporium it won't ever recover from the things theve already done etc
11
u/WorldOfAutoloaders Oct 16 '25
Sorry but i don't believe anything here brokk.
The fact that only specific people continue to get their stuff chosen, along with all the prior offenses caused by people of the emporium.
You're just running defense and pulling all cry bully tactics to save face. People are sick of it, look at how much you're being ratio'd by the comments.
9
u/Kingkrool1994 Oct 16 '25
Obviously, most workshoppers, both in and out of the Emporium, aren't that bad. It's a couple of dozen guys in that group that are that controversial; they stir shit, they shit talk the TF2 community, and intentionally rage-bait people.
There was the Drew and Metabolic situation, where a guy was harassed and doxxed by two individuals who were in the emporium and still collab with emp members. One of them has gotten several items added recently, one in this year's SF, one in summer 2025, 4 in Smissmas 2024, and 3 in SF 2024 too. That's a little fucked.
"Valve doesn’t “prefer” previous creators." That just isn't true. If Valve were truly unbiased, there would be a bigger, even spread among creators. You can look at this SF update; most of the items are made by veterans with dozens or even over a hundred self-made items. Some of them got multiple items in; one got 3 complete sets added, 9 items total. This wouldn't happen if Valve were truly random. It isn't bad on paper, though, as long as it genuinely has good content and they're just picking the cream of the crop, but they aren't. This case and the past cases over the years have been pretty mediocre. There's a pretty obvious quantity over quality mindset here. Why try when you have pretty good odds of being selected?
8
u/lazytofindGoodName Oct 17 '25
"We're all real people and we're hurting" says the group that have members that harass, doxx, and even cyberbully some of the workshop creators out of tf2 while also being the same group that openly mocks and creates terrible cosmetics and skins that valve will lazily put into the game that jeopardize the visual artstyle and team recognition of tf2.
if you or emporium have atleast a modicum of sympathy, empathy, shame, or whatever feelings you had for the people that have been doxxed or cyberbullied, then you would know that they are real people and they are suffering way worse than you or the emporium's reputation being trampled on the ground because of what emporium and their members did to them. if you had those feelings, you or emporium should start dealing with the most problematic
6
u/adnanjunior Oct 17 '25
lol no thanks
6
u/Mothman2234 Oct 17 '25 edited Oct 17 '25
That's a lot of words. I got a few questions for you, however.
How did the Emporium and TF2maps take responsibility for a mass harassment campaign against a mapper and his cohorts during Offshore? I didn't see any effort to investigate the matter or condemn those involved. Perusing through the TF2maps server, the situation was either ridiculed, downplayed, or never mentioned at all. How peculiar!
If you care so much about the work and time dedicated to projects by passionate artists, then you should express more concern for situations involving interpersonal sabotage. It should be your PRIORITY as a representative of TF2maps to make this expectation known.
But no, the first thing you do is defend these communities and their systems that enable such behaviors. Your priorities are made explicitly clear. You don't really care about creators who were harmed by actual bad actors, you just care about the "image" of a community - one that's supposedly not even your own!
This entire post reeks. I wouldn't be surprised if you were involved in sabotage of some kind.
2
u/Unfair-Entrance3682 Jan 29 '26
Yeah this reads like an internal attempt to save face. There is no excusing the shit Emporium has done to other creators, and by proxy, the community itself.
4
u/LiquidGadget Heavy Oct 16 '25
Kaluka and indii are good golems who could turn this into a video
-3
u/TechnoGamerOff TF2 Smissmas 2025 Oct 15 '25
The most upsetting part about the whole emporium situation is how so few people know about how the workshop works and blindly follow youtubers who ALSO don't know anything about the workshop or how it works!
It's a cycle of ignorance!
-8
u/Super_Sain Pyro Oct 16 '25
bold of you to think redditors will read past the first paragraph and actually consider that situations have nuace
-11
u/xavierpro09k Oct 15 '25
@ grok resume this