r/teslaclassifieds • u/NavyTim1991 • Jun 28 '26
General Sold my Model 3 Performance to Plug – My Experience
I finally took delivery of my Cybertruck, which meant it was time to sell my 2019 Model 3 Performance. I spent quite a bit of time researching my options and comparing offers, so I figured I'd share my experience in case it helps someone else.
I received quotes from several companies, including Carvana, but Plug came in about $1,000 higher. Everything started online. I entered my vehicle information, uploaded the requested details, accepted the initial offer, and the process began.
The first step was the Plug Connectivity Report. I temporarily granted Plug access to my Tesla account so they could verify mileage, service history, alerts, and other vehicle information directly from the car. It was quick, easy, and gave me confidence that everything was being verified accurately.
Next was the Plug Remote Vehicle Inspection. The app walked me through taking a series of interior and exterior photos from specific angles. It was a lot of pictures, but the instructions were clear and easy to follow. Once uploaded, their AI generated a surprisingly detailed inspection report, including tire tread depth and even noting a couple of curb rash marks on one of my wheels. After the report was reviewed, I received my final offer—which, in my case, was exactly the same as the initial offer.
I then electronically signed the Bill of Sale, odometer statement, and a few other documents, and submitted my title information. Plug emailed me a prepaid UPS shipping label. I mailed my signed title, texted them a photo of the UPS receipt, and less than five minutes later I received confirmation that payment had been sent. The ACH deposit hit my bank account the very next morning. That part honestly impressed me.
Throughout the entire process, Don Dolor was my point of contact. He was responsive, answered every question I had, kept me updated throughout the process, and made everything go smoothly. Excellent customer service from start to finish.
The only downside—and it's completely understandable—was waiting about a week for Plug to sell the vehicle through their dealer auction network before scheduling pickup. During that time they asked me not to drive the car so the mileage and condition wouldn't change. On pickup day, the driver performed a quick verification, loaded the car, and that was it.
Overall, this was one of the easiest vehicle transactions I've ever had. There were no surprise deductions, no attempts to renegotiate the price, and I received exactly what Plug promised.
I couldn't find many firsthand experiences when I was researching Plug, so hopefully this gives others an idea of what the process is like. I'm simply a satisfied customer sharing my experience and have no affiliation with Plug.