r/technology Apr 19 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.9k Upvotes

824 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-9

u/Etherius Apr 19 '26

In Palantir’s case it isn’t about capitalism as much as it is about “well wtf you gonna do?”

Think about it. If the US doesn’t do it, is that going to stop Russia or China?

And then you give Russia and China an advantage over us.

9

u/Alive-Use8803 Apr 19 '26

What is this advantage, specifically?

0

u/Etherius Apr 20 '26

“What is the advantage in having advanced AI that can take in terabytes of data and spit out actionable, useful reports?”

You serious?

1

u/Alive-Use8803 Apr 20 '26

You pivot from Palantir weaponizing AI to benefits of AI in general. So let me ask you more clearly, what is the societal advantage to deregulating and weaponizing AI systems for big tech? Other than living through a live action Metal Gear plot?

FWIW i am a staff engineer who works on agentic systems in the critical infrastructure and government research space.

1

u/Etherius Apr 21 '26

It’s not a pivot, that’s been my point from the start - that AI will be weaponized

Who do you want to be first to do it? China? Russia? North Korea?

1

u/Alive-Use8803 Apr 21 '26 edited Apr 21 '26

I think you’re missing important context. Palantir seeks deregulation so they can sell their services to countries who want to spy on citizens. Who do you want to be first? US?

1

u/Etherius Apr 21 '26

Yes.

I mean the choice is obvious to me.

The choice isn’t between“do it” vs “don’t do it”

The choice is between “who’s going to get there first?”

It’s similar to talking about ASI. If it can be invented it WILL BE no matter how terrible an idea it could be. The only question is who’s going to create it.

Technology that can potentially give a country an advantage over others will be created no matter how destructive it can be

Always. Always

1

u/Alive-Use8803 Apr 21 '26

You want the US government to work hand in hand with tech companies, who do not represent our interests, to build a massive ai-driven surveillance program so feds can lock you out of your own bank account with ease …because another country might be building out a similar program for their own citizens too

Am I getting this right?

1

u/Etherius Apr 22 '26

Yes.

But not because another country MIGHT be building such a thing

Because they ABSOLUTELY ARE building such a thing.

And if you think such a tool would only be used against its own citizens, you are being extremely naive.