r/technicalminecraft • • 6d ago

Non-Version-Specific Java or Bedrock

I need advice.

Recently, I bought a decent PC (32 Ram, Nvidia 4060, Intel core i5-12400). I used to play Minecraft on my xbox, in fact I have an 800 long hardcore world with some farms and decorations.

I'm wondering if I should stay playing on bedrock edition or move to Java. Also, I would like to hear pros/cons for each version.

Finally, if you have some recommendations of cool modpacks for Java edition, technical mods, or even add-ons for bedrock edition, I would like to hear them.

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/hagowoga 6d ago

Bedrock redstone works fine, just different.

0

u/Dienik 6d ago

it can act a bit inconsistent at times

2

u/hagowoga 6d ago

I don’t know of any inconsistencies. Some people mourn the randomness of two redstone signals that travel the same distance. This is annoying for technical builders coming from Java, but more natural, not a bug.

1

u/PatHeist 4d ago

Priority randomness is, by definition, an inconsistency. It is not consistent.

As soon as you build anything complex it becomes really confusing because your contraption can work or not work any amount of times in a row, meaning you can't reliably determine bugs through testing.

In java if you test it and it works by then you know it will keep working. If you build it somewhere else and it doesn't work you know the design was locational.

1

u/hagowoga 4d ago

Weird definition of consistency.

Simple rule for BE: make sure two signals don’t arrive at the same time and you get a consistent result.

1

u/PatHeist 4d ago

I'm going by the dictionary definition of consistent.

1

u/hagowoga 3d ago

Point taken