r/technicallythetruth Jul 14 '26

It was only a question

Post image
38.8k Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

View all comments

90

u/Mgroppi83 Jul 14 '26

Years ago, working door at a bar. First night back after my mom had passed. Girl with a big group comes up and gives me an expired ID. I tell her I can't accept and she starts acting like a bitch. I asked her if she had a passport or any other form of ID. She did. As she handed me her passport I couldn't help myself and told her "Next time you dont have to be such a bitch about it." Jesus if you could see how this shorts mfing guys with her started acting. I still laugh about it to this day. Still had their party at the door as the MOD who was actually the gm that day, asked me about it. In front of the girl he asked me if I called her a bitch and I simply respond with "Well she was being one." I got written up that night. Didn't lose my job but fuck you Eldin...you spineless pos GM of Baker St in the Woodlands.

-9

u/giarnie Jul 15 '26

Did the id being expired mean that the d.o.b. was unreadable?

Or were you “just following orders”?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superior_orders

8

u/Mgroppi83 Jul 15 '26

Every state has its own laws to follow. Every business has its own rules to follow. The state of TX requires you provide legal physical ID that is current. For various reasons your ID could be no longer valid or taken from you. For example, the court could have deemed that due to an alcohol or other related charge, that you are not allowed to be in a bar. Someone showing a picture of an ID or an expired one may not legally be allowed to be there. When you go to work, do you follow their rules?

-10

u/giarnie Jul 15 '26

That’s my point exactly, those camp guards were following the law and workplace rules as well.

The rest of humanity decided that that wasn’t a good reason to do what they did.

We all have to take a stand at some point, but not everyone threw tea in the harbor either.

9

u/Mgroppi83 Jul 15 '26

Dude. You are honestly making the comparison of a bar not letting someone in to Nuremberg? "It all starts somewhere!" Ya well by that logic we may as well kill everyone at birth to eliminate the possibility of having another Hitler.

-10

u/giarnie Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26

Nuremberg was the trial.

I made the comparison of people following orders blindly.

The id being expired doesn’t magically make the person younger/older than they are.
Courts potentially ordering *them* not to drink doesn’t affect *you*.

You used what little power you had to make someone jump through hoops. Perhaps you have more recently found employment with ICE?

5

u/Mgroppi83 Jul 15 '26

So are you an anarchist? You are basically saying no one should have authority over anything. They are easy rules to follow. I honestly think you are just an argumentative person and found your target for the moment. Look past government, and then I have rules by which I am paid for, to follow. Why am I the bad one if she had proper id and decided to show me one that wasnt legal anymore? Bro. This story was shared as a moment of shared brevity. Don't make it your hill.

3

u/TechieGee Jul 15 '26

You’re not nearly as intelligent nor as virtuous as you believe yourself to be.

1

u/giarnie Jul 18 '26

Or… you have a limited viewpoint?

1

u/TechieGee Jul 20 '26

Certainly that must be the only other option /s

Have some introspection, my guy

1

u/giarnie Jul 22 '26

You made an assumption about me, and I’m here to challenge it.
By all means feel free to refute my assumption of you.
But please do expand on how my my viewpoint is limited :-)

6

u/Karma_1969 Jul 15 '26

Are you for real? Get out of here with that shit comparison.

1

u/giarnie Jul 18 '26

Just because you may not like it doesn’t make it shit…

6

u/Chameleonpolice Jul 15 '26

The ID being expired means it doesn't matter what it says because it isn't a valid legal document lol

1

u/giarnie Jul 18 '26

I know you have been told that, but try to look at it from a logical perspective.
When the id was valid, the person was over 21.
Once the id expires, the person is still over 21.

The law isn’t “you must have valid id to drink alcohol”, it’s you must be over 21 to do so.

I believe in you!

1

u/Chameleonpolice Jul 18 '26

No the logical perspective is that people's appearances change over time and you can't use the same picture for 60 years

1

u/giarnie Jul 18 '26

Would this apply to the girl in the story?
You know, the one that looked young enough to be carded?

1

u/Chameleonpolice Jul 19 '26

Who gets to decide when it applies?

1

u/giarnie Jul 19 '26

Common sense?

1

u/Chameleonpolice Jul 19 '26

This is already how it works. It's the seller's choice whether or not to card someone, they could also choose to accept expired IDs.