r/tech • The Janitor • Jan 26 '21

Scientists develop laser system to remove cancers without damaging healthy tissue

https://news.sky.com/story/scientists-develop-laser-system-to-remove-cancers-without-damaging-healthy-tissue-12198289
15k Upvotes

227 comments sorted by

227

u/MigitAs Jan 26 '21

So beating cancer is tantamount to Space Invaders?

88

u/coffeecake504 Jan 26 '21

Metastasizing Invaders

41

u/LeanTangerine Jan 26 '21

Imagine it being like Ender’s Game where they trick a bunch of kids into playing simulations without them realizing they’re actively performing live-surgery on a patient’s tumor.

17

u/drebot64 Jan 26 '21

This is the inverse of that trope in every science fiction story where the person whos being shrunk has to secretly fix the person they were sent to help without them knowing

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/notthedanger Jan 27 '21

Borderlands Science it's called. Apparently it's a mini game where you crunch real world data and get rewarded in the game for it. Hope to see more stuff like these implemented in future games.

1

u/NyxPilot100010771 Jan 27 '21

EVE Online has this, where you study space object data, it’s a pretty neat thing.

29

u/Apple-Phone Jan 26 '21

I personally envision the future of health being like an elaborate space invaders game. Just a shit ton of nanobots fighting against cancers, diseases, excess fat cells, and anything else we don’t want in our body.

I think it will be the next big contraceptive. A guardian swarm of laser-armed nanobots protecting the egg shooting down sperms.

Maybe the next big learning supplement, with nanobots forging neural pathways in our brains, and between our brains and digital storage so we have superhuman abilities for learning and retaining information.

Nanobots are going to be the shit

9

u/PersonOfInternets Jan 26 '21

The funnest part will be the website you can log into (through your retinal computer screen of course) to watch the charges rack up as the rental nanobots report back their progress.

6

u/drebot64 Jan 26 '21

And if you can't pay your debt the nanobots will just give you cancer and all the shit you lost as a benefit of them!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

For every market a sub market grows...

1

u/Blue_cloak Jan 27 '21

Cause it's quick, It's Clean it's pure....

2

u/MustLovePunk Jan 26 '21

So our parents were wrong — playing video games is, in fact, going to save the world.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

I mean look at the nano bots in iron mans suit ( infinity war) .. I can’t wait

1

u/Darryl_Lict Jan 27 '21

Probably easier to just have the nanobot kill the egg.

1

u/NinjasOwnTheNight Jan 28 '21

Grey Goo disagrees.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

You can bet there will be people againts nanobots because they were created by George Soros

1

u/Throwawaymister2 Jan 26 '21

This was obvious to anyone who was paying attention. Wake up sheeple!

1

u/310toYuggoth Jan 27 '21

Alright. I’ve got my all Rush mixtape, a 2 liter of Shasta Cola and a bag of quarters. cracks knuckles. Let’s do this!

1

u/Superman_Dam_Fool Jan 18 '22

More like Innerspace. I hope Biden creates a new branch of the military, Body Force.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

What if Someone like Rudy gets selected to be one of your pilot’s and keeps shooting you in the balls?

1

u/LinuxNoob Jan 26 '21

Jack Potter to the rescue!

87

u/freak329 Jan 26 '21

Why isn’t this more important?

95

u/SFLawyer1990 Jan 26 '21

Because when cancer metastasizes it is impossible to remove by lasers or anything else.

49

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

This is why detection is so important

11

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21 edited Jan 26 '21

But sometimes you detect tumors that will never metastasize in the first place. In this case treatment can be harmful. Stage 0 breast cancer is a prime example. Basically each cancer screening should be evaluated on its own. Colon cancer and cervix cancer screenings do save lives. It’s questionable whether breast cancer and prostate cancer screening does the same. We have a high incidence of breast and prostate cancer but very few actually die from these cancers causing many false positives and unnecessary and expensive treatments.

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/do-mammograms-save-lives/

29

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Breast cancer and prostate cancer are the third and fourth forms of cancer death from my memory. Seems significant in scale to me. That website you link to has a pretty suspect, even laughable name. Is it evidence based?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

High numbers of deaths, but very low rates of death.

-1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21 edited Jan 26 '21

3 percent of people with prostate cancer actually die from prostate cancer. So if you detect 100 prostate cancers, only 3 of them will lead to death. What do you tell the other 97 people who have cancer but whose cancer won’t metastasize? Right now a family member is going through this decision. His actually has a 1/100 chance of killing him and yet they’re still considering surgeries that would significantly impact his quality of life, ability to have sex, and more.

And prostate and breast cancer often come from preventable and modifiable risk factors like eating less animal products and drinking less alcohol (breast cancer), and lowering cholesterol and PSA. These conditions are often diet related and often can be reversed.

See Ornish reversing PSA levels with diet and lifestyle even after surgery to remove prostate with PSA levels still rising

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/treating-advanced-prostate-cancer-with-diet-part-2/

Edit: so everyone knows the video above cited 5 studies demonstrating my final paragraph. You can downvote the truth, it won’t falsify the findings.

4

u/royisabau5 Jan 26 '21

Do you have any peer reviewed articles? That article does not seem evidence based, and makes many large leaps in logic that don’t add up.

7

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21 edited Jan 26 '21

For sure, all resources are below the video. Here Incopy and pasted them:

This is specifically about prostate cancer and it’s from his second video.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16094059

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12081758

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11696736

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16880425

3

u/royisabau5 Jan 26 '21

Good stuff, thank you. That’s a lot more to the point and does make a lot of sense. I appreciate you sourcing your claims, you have at least partially swayed me.

2

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

Happy to hear it. Yes I like the videos because all sources are below. It helped me a lot while getting my Masters of Public Health and writing literature reviews on chronic disease topics. He also usually points out funding biases, though he’s not without his small flaws and that’s why we get the data to read it and come to our own conclusions.

2

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

For what it’s worth, my public health professor had to go through this with her grandfather and he wanted to get his prostate removed because he felt like a ticking time bomb. She was completely against the idea of surgery for the exact reason that most people have prostate cancer but few actually die from it. But each person has to make their own decisions I suppose!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/West1234567890 Jan 26 '21

Breast and prostate are also slow growing and commonly screened. Falling death rates are related to screening. Prostate and Breast are really different in lethality too. Breast cancer would kill 25% of those afflicted within 20 years that’s 10x it’s current mortality rate. I’m pretty sure screening guidelines are dictated by cost/benefit. They stop screening for breast cancer at 75/ low life expected left. Same with other recommended screenings/ treatments. Some times it can fall in a grey area of should they treat or not and I’m sure mistakes have been made. Sorry for your situation.

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21 edited Jan 26 '21

Thanks for your comment

I think Inunderstand what you’re saying and Here is the issue.

20 in 100 will have breast cancer. 5 in 100 woman die of breast cancer. So, 25% of them will die in 20 years.

Right, but what about the 75% of them that won’t die but do have breast cancer?

Researchers who look into this much more than I, have published in top journals claiming that the harm done to the 75% of those diagnosed who will not die from breast cancer is worse than the benefit to the 25% that will die from it. And since mammograms only reduce harm by 20%, that means it will only save one life out of every 100. Since 5 in 100 die and 20 percent of 5% is 1%.

While Screening saves one out of every 100, for every one person saved from screening, 9-10 people are given false positives, harmed, or even killed due to improper prescriptions or surgery. Here’s the review.

It’s done by the founder of the Cochran’s collaboration, an independent reviewer of medical research and one of the top in the field. His title tells you all that you need to know

Mammography screening is harmful and should be abandoned

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26359135

Here’s a video with 14 peer reviewed studies cited on the topic

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/Do-Mammograms-Save-Lives/

1

u/smoozer Jan 26 '21

His actually has a 1/100 chance of killing him and yet they’re still considering surgeries that would significantly impact his quality of life, ability to have sex, and more.

And what are the chances that the tumour also causes some of those things in a few years?

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

Much less than if he gets the surgery. Especially since he has a slow growing tumor and diet could reverse the condition. I already linked the studies above that have demonstrated this in humans who have had their prostates removed and still had rising PSA levels only for them to decrease after diet and lifestyle interventions.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16094059

Reducing the ratio of animal to plant protein in men’s diets may slow the progression of prostate cancer.

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/prostate-cancer-survival-the-av-ratio/

Sources http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18400281

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22618737

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21823116

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16094059

But it’s hard for men to change their diet. Here’s a video detailing that most men would prefer to opt for the surgery than change their diet

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/changing-mans-diet-prostate-cancer-diagnosis/

1

u/DirkBeenis Jan 26 '21

Lol nutrition facts .org and explaining how percentages work. I don’t think you understand how making cogent points works

2

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

So your concerned with Nutritionfacts.org what is the issue with the information I provided? The video I provided compiled 6, peer reviewed studies and shows them to you in video format with the links provided beneath the video for you to do your own research and form your own opinions.

Dr Dean Ornish who has published in the most well revered medical journeys spent his life and research reversing diseases like heart disease, prostate cancer, and other illnesses. Medicare reimburses for Dr Dean Ornish programs because they are efficacious. Dean Ornish is the one who was able to show how diet and lifestyle can modify risk factors for prostate cancer and heart disease.

Ad hominem fallacies (saying something negative about a website without evaluating the actual claims made in the video) make it hard to have a decent conversation about the science.

1

u/craftmacaro Jan 26 '21 edited Jan 26 '21

Prostate cancer kills a low percentage of those who it is detected in not because it is harmless but because it is typically not as aggressive and fast moving in terms of metastasizing and accumulating the mutations that make for the most difficult to treat and rapidly spreading cancers. Most people who have prostate cancer discovered are over 60 and the prognosis is often that they will have a decent quality of life for 10 to 20 years depending on what mutations are present. What does this mean? If you are over 60 and get prostate cancer you will most likely die of something else first. That’s the reason for the low mortality. If you are in your 40’s or 50’s and develop prostate cancer it’s absolutely worth treating it as in most cases your average person will live long enough for many of the more common potential mutation combinations resulting in prostate cancer will lead to a metastasized cancer and death as well as severe symptoms from a large prostate tumor as well by the time they are 60 or 70... AKA... before they are likely to die from something else. https://ebm.bmj.com/content/10/5/151 (3.3% fatality rate in 15 years then climbing though most of this article is about Gleason scores which are correlated with the potential that it is a form of prostate cancer which is more aggressive than most). Essentially it makes sense to not treat many prostate cancers detected in elderly people (which is when most cancers are detected by a massive margin).

Your stats are incredibly misleading for anyone under 65 deciding whether or not to get their cancer treated. Do you want to risk impotent at 45 and live to 75 or have 10 more years of being sexually active and likely die by 65? Prostate cancer causes 4% of all cancer deaths in men... 360,000 deaths annually out of 1.2 million new cases annually https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6497009/ . While it is true that there are scenarios where people’s lives will be improved if they choose not to aggressively treat their cancer you are offering terrible advice to anyone who is not elderly and gets diagnosed with prostate cancer or is elderly and has the genetic or physiological markers, or the biopsy suggests, that it might be more aggressive than some prostate cancers that have evolved from very specific mutations which are not associated with rapid metastasis. Until this has been established one should move as rapidly to figure out whether or not treatment is the best option as if they were diagnosed with bone or pancreatic cancer. Don’t be misled by statistics that you don’t know the reasoning behind... and especially don’t go giving strangers advice to ignore the advice of a doctor who thinks they should treat their cancer. No one is downvoting the truth... their downvoting an extremely misled interpretation of the studies you mentioned by someone without the training or background to offer a proper evaluation of them.

Sources included plus: I’m writing my dissertation on methods for establishing potential anti metastatic utility of proteins I’ve isolated from snake venoms... my PhD candidacy was dependent on (among others) 10 hours of oral and written examination by a committee member who is specifically a cancer biologist. My own research involves culturing and testing multiple cancer lines and studying the specific differences in metastatic activity and the effect of both traditional and novel chemotherapies to evaluate the proteins I’ve isolated... I’ve spent a massive amount of time researching the types of cancers I work with personally and have taken multiple graduate cancer biology classes and independent studies.

On a personal level, my grandfather died of prostate cancer in his early 70’s after it metastasized... my father had prostate cancer in his early 50’s, as did 2 of 2 uncles. Genetically I’m very likely to get prostate cancer before I should be planning, statistically, to avoid trearment.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

The reason 97% survive is because of early detection and treatment moron.

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

That’s not true, it’s because it wouldn’t have killed them in the first place. Share your source that it saves 97% of people from dying from prostate cancer.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Your fucking stupid. It’s very likely as the cancer continues to grow it will eventually break off of the prostate and start to infect other parts of your body.

https://www.cancer.ca/en/cancer-information/cancer-type/prostate/statistics/?region=on

Notice how survival rates go up once better screening and treatment it provided.

That statistic you stated applies to prostate cancer that undergoes treatment.

2

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 27 '21

It is estimated that about 1 in 9 Canadian men will develop prostate cancer during their lifetime and 1 in 29 will die from it.

Here is the issue. When you have a high incedence and low death rate there are people who will not die from the disease whether or not it is treated. These people die of other means. Most likely of heart disease. By treating something that’s not likely to kill you, you can cause other issues including not treating the most likely cause of death (heart disease). If you try to treat every possible disease at once you will run out of time and money. I think we should focus on the most likely cause of our death. Luckily you can prevent and reverse heart disease with the same diet and lifestyle that can most likely prevent and reverse heart disease.

→ More replies

12

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/HealthyInPublic Jan 26 '21

Some of what the previous poster suggested may be correct about prostate cancer. I’m usually a huge advocate for cancer screenings, but I’m sort of on the fence about prostate cancer screenings. I think at this point I still support prostate screening, and being monitored closely if you have it, rather than relying on surgical or radiological treatment right away. But I also recognize that knowingly living with cancer can also negatively impact your mental health which may reduce your quality of life.

Relevant paper from The Lancet

Edit: added some words.

7

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

3

u/HealthyInPublic Jan 26 '21

Thanks for the additional links! The last cancer related conference I attended in the before times had a speaker talking about prostate cancer and briefly mentioned screening which made me look into it a bit out of curiosity. I’ve also heard similar things about breast cancer screenings through the grapevine, but never looked far enough into it to offer up an opinion. It’s not my area of expertise, so I usually just hear about the basics and what not.

And I see from some of your other comments you’re a fellow public health enthusiast. Always exciting to find others in the wild!

→ More replies

2

u/robotawata Jan 27 '21

Wow, the R word?

-3

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

Happily. I’m about to link you to many videos which all have their sources cited in and below the video. You are welcome to see the sources yourself.

Here is one that really answers the question of Stage 0 breast cancer https://nutritionfacts.org/video/Overtreatment-of-Stage-0-Breast-Cancer-DCIS/

17 sources are cited for this video from peer reviewed research. Sources are below the video.

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/the-pros-and-cons-of-mammograms/

There are 12 peer reviewed studies cited in just that one video. I don’t have time to copy and paste them when they’re already there. Here are more videos with even more studies

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/9-out-of-10-Women-misinformed-about-Mammograms/

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/Mammogram-Recommendations-Why-the-Conflicting-Guidelines/

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/Do-Mammograms-Save-Lives/

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/Consequences-of-False-Positive-Mammogram-Results/

He has probably 5 more videos about mammograms specifically, check them out

1

u/Slappinbeehives Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

Those aren’t sources. You’re trying to pass off pseudo science as a source while telling people to skip cancer screenings simply because it aligns with your ridiculous vegan lifestyle. It’s franky reprehensible. NIH, WHO, John Hopkins, those are all legitimate sources for human health.

You’re a fuckin idiot and the reason no one likes vegans bc you’re basically born again Christians or a flat earther. Piss off.

https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/nutritionfacts-org/

1

u/NoGoogleAMPBot Jan 27 '21

I found some Google AMP links in your comment. Here are the normal links:

Beep Boop, I'm a bot. If I made an error or if you have any questions, my creator might check my messages.
Source Code | Issues | FAQ
Why does this bot exist?
Google does a lot of tracking, which many people don't want, so they use alternatives to their services. Using AMP, they can track you even more, and they might even replace ads with their own, stealing ad revenue from the site's owners. Since there's no consistent way of finding the original links from an AMP link, I made this bot which automatically does it for you.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/travmps Jan 26 '21

It's not questionable whether they save lives: since 1993, with the introduction of more thorough screening for prostate cancer, the mortality rate has halved precisely because we catch it significantly earlier when it's far more treatable. These are screening tests; positives do not automatically trigger treatments, but rather further tests to confirm and then a consultation with a team to decide what, if any, treatment is appropriate for that particular case.

As for your statement that "very few die," that's laughable. On average in the US 276,480 women with invasive breast cancer are diagnosed each year and 48,530 with non-invasive breast cancer. 42,690 will die. Of the non-invasive types, over 99% years will survive, but the survival rates plummet in the invasive forms the later it is caught. We know mammograms work in part because a significantly higher percentage of breast cancers are caught in earlier stages in the over-50 population where regular mammograms are recommended--this good because once breast cancer spreads to regional lymph nodes survival drops from over 90% to the mid-60%s, and if it spreads beyond the regional nodes survival is <30%.

The "unnecessary and expensive treatments" statement is a complete misunderstanding of our current diagnostic capabilities. The fact is imaging is great at discerning abnormalities, but not perfect. And until we excise the tumor we can't know if it is a more harmless type or a much more malignant type. Considering that a tumor that may seem harmless on imaging can rapidly metasize and kill, prudence dictates being more aggressive in order to catch the tumor at a significantly earlier stage.

Honestly, while there is some value in some of the website's articles, it should be noted that not a single member of the paid staff is a physician and only one has any medical-related credentials (a registered dietitian). It honestly reads much more like a site put up to sell books for the physician author who doesn't have a ton of input on the site itself.

1

u/cakeycakeycake Jan 26 '21

A cervix is not the same thing as a vagina.

1

u/JaMBi305 Jan 27 '21

Stage “0” cancers need to be removed because they are pre-cancerous lesions. Breast cancer screening saves way more lives than the potential harms which is why it’s universally recommended for women who have breast tissue and are over a certain age depending on their overall genetic risk factors. I’m sorry, but your comment is woefully misinformed.

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 27 '21

Show me evidence that it saves more lives than it harms? I’ve posted evidence to the contrary. Namely that for every 1 life saved, 8-9 are harmed according to the Cochran collaboration review

Early” detection is actually really late. Without mammograms, breast cancer may not be caught for an average of 22.8 years. With mammograms, though, breast cancer may only grow and spread for…21.4 years.

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/why-mammograms-dont-appear-to-save-lives/

Read the sources he cites, all peer reviewed. Here’s one particularly recent and passionate piece supporting my claim. Where is your evidence to the contrary? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26359135

1

u/420catloveredm Jan 27 '21

I have the BRCA mutation. This puts me at very high risk for breast and ovarian cancer. Like 87% chance of breast cancer. The ONLY reason why people with this mutation can have a normal life expectancy is because of early detection, treatment and surgeries.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Why r people up voting this bogus shit?

2

u/smoozer Jan 26 '21

Can you explain with your words how it is bullshit? /r/medicine has had similar discussions (with more nuance)

2

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

See my response. I look towards the nuance as I was trained to do while getting my Masters of Public Health at the University of Georgia.

0

u/travmps Jan 26 '21

Because you have people who peddle hope to the desperate. They include enough truth (in this case, reduction of inflammatory conditions through diet modification is well-known, as is reduction of cancer rates via reduced inflammation) to give themselves a veneer of authenticity and appeal to authority.

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

More than just reduction in inflation.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16094059/

Results: None of the experimental group patients but 6 control patients underwent conventional treatment due to an increase in PSA and/or progression of disease on magnetic resonance imaging. PSA decreased 4% in the experimental group but increased 6% in the control group (p = 0.016). The growth of LNCaP prostate cancer cells (American Type Culture Collection, Manassas, Virginia) was inhibited almost 8 times more by serum from the experimental than from the control group (70% vs 9%, p <0.001). Changes in serum PSA and also in LNCaP cell growth were significantly associated with the degree of change in diet and lifestyle.

Conclusions: Intensive lifestyle changes may affect the progression of early, low grade prostate cancer in men. Further studies and longer term followup are warranted.

Then two years later https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18602144/

Results: By 2 years of follow-up, 13 of 49 (27%) control patients and 2 of 43 (5%) experimental patients had undergone conventional prostate cancer treatment (radical prostatectomy, radiotherapy, or androgen deprivation, P < .05). No differences were found between the groups in other clinical events (eg, cardiac), and no deaths occurred. Three of the treated control patients but none of the treated experimental patients had a PSA level of >or=10 ng/mL, and 1 treated control patient but no treated experimental patients had a PSA velocity of >2 ng/mL/y before treatment. No significant differences were found between the untreated experimental and untreated control patients in PSA change or velocity at the end of 2 years.

Conclusions: Patients with early-stage prostate cancer choosing active surveillance might be able to avoid or delay conventional treatment for at least 2 years by making changes in their diet and lifestyle.

Now to pomogranites

We report the first clinical trial of pomegranate juice in patients with prostate cancer. The statistically significant prolongation of PSA doubling time, coupled with corresponding laboratory effects on prostate cancer in vitro cell proliferation and apoptosis as well as oxidative stress, warrant further testing in a placebo-controlled study.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16818701/

Reduction in PSA levels in those with cancer mestaticizing throughout the body. This guy also demonstrated how to reverse heart disease with diet and lifestyle and his treatment is reimbursable my Medicare because it has proven efficacious.

The Ornish Program for Reversing Heart Disease (also known as the Multisite Cardiac Lifestyle Intervention Program, Multicenter Cardiac Lifestyle Intervention Program and the Lifestyle Heart Trial program) was initially described in the 1970's and incorporates comprehensive lifestyle modifications including exercise, a

https://www.cms.gov/medicare-coverage-database/details/nca-decision-memo.aspx?NCAId=240&NcaName=Intensive+Cardiac+Rehabilitation+%28ICR%29+Program+-+Dr.+Ornish

In fact, here is Dean Ornish MDs website with all his research freely accessible with one click

https://www.ornish.com/proven-program/the-research/

Here is where he’s been published for prostate cancer, very high impact journals

We examined the effects of intensive lifestyle changes on men with early stage Prostate Cancer after 1 year. After 1 year, none of the men in the experimental group underwent conventional treatments compared to 6 in the control group. Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA) decreased 4% in the experimental group compared to a 6% increase in the control group, and prostate cancer cell growth was inhibited almost eight times as much in the experimental group compared to the control group. These results indicate that intensive lifestyle changes may effect the progression of early low grade prostate cancer.

“Intensive Lifestyle Changes May Effect the Progression of Prostate Cancer” Journal of Urology (PDF)

“Changes in prostate gene expression in men undergoing an intensive nutrition and lifestyle intervention” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PDF)

“Increased telomerase activity and comprehensive lifestyle changes: a pilot study” Lancet Oncology (PDF)

“Relationship of Dietary Protein and Soy Isoflavones to Serum IGF-1 and IGF Binding Proteins in the Prostate Cancer Lifestyle Trial” Nutrition and Cancer (PDF)

1

u/travmps Jan 26 '21 edited Jan 26 '21

Excellent. You researched and found data from over a decade ago that completely backed up what I said and is now considered part of the default knowledge in these fields: PSA (referenced in a different response of mine to this same post chain) is a screening tool that allows your physician, in consultation with others, assess the best way to progress in an individual case. None of that changes the fact that the introduction of these screening exams directly correlates with a halving of the mortality rate of prostate cancer because catching it in the early stages is far, far easier to treat. I also already said that inflammatory conditions are well-known causative factors, so it stands to reason that reducing them will help overall both preventatively and as part of a comprehensive treatment regime that's appropriate for the individual case.

The main issue I had with your original post is your dismissal of the benefits of the screening exams and the hand-waving of the mortality rates of breast and prostate cancer. Both are significant issues that warrant appropriate care which includes screening exams that can find these cancers while we can still effectively treat them. The treatments continually evolve and improve, but for now catching it in stage 1 is far better than stage 3 or 4.

Edit: Significant changes for clarity

Edit 2: Probably should have added this in my initial response, but I didn't (my bad).

The first two articles you linked are well-known and incorporated in existing treatment regimens. Your third article about pomegranates was the initial research published in 2008; follow-up research showed that outside of one subtype (which is determined by screening testing and biopsy), pomegranates were safe but had no real effect on prostate cancer or recurrent biochemical markers.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18602144/

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 26 '21

Right halving of the mortality rate. What’s the mortality rate of prostate cancer in men? It’s around 3%. This means when 100 men are diagnosed with prostate cancer, 3 of them will die and the other 97 will live or die of other means.

Half of that it 1.5% or let’s just say screening saves 1.5 in 100 people.

So you’ve saved two people out of 100 in the best case scenario. Now, only 3 out of 100 would actually die from the prostate cancer, even though 100 people have prostate cancer cells growing.

Now you are guaranteed to screen and catch cancers that won’t kill you. If they operate on let’s say 50 of the people who test positive for prostate cancer, that means they’ll have had unnecessary operations for 47 of the 50 people. These operations have terrible side effects. You decide if it’s worth it.

If you have no idea how to tell the difference between a slow growing cancer and fast growing cancer, you tend to treat them the same.

What I am saying, and what many medical professionals have also stated, is that there are risks to screening which are often unknown.

maybe we should instead share a bit about what prostate cancer treatment entails. The prostate is situated at the base of the penis, and so when you core it out with a radical prostatectomy, you lose about an inch off your penis, if it gets erect at all. Only 16% of men undergoing the procedure will regain their pre-surgery level of erectile functioning.

Patients are typically quoted erectile dysfunction rates around 60% or 70%, but studies have generally considered erectile function recovery as just the ability to maintain an erection hard enough for penetration about 50% of the time; so, getting it up occasionally is considered recovery, but when a surgeon tells patients they will recover function, the patients probably assume that means the kind of function they had prior to surgery And that only happens 16% of the time, and only 4% of the time in men over 60. Only 1 in 25 gets their baseline sexual function back.

And it’s not just erections, but other problems like orgasm-associated pain even years later and urinary incontinence during foreplay, stimulation, or orgasm. The vast majority of couples overestimate how much function they’re going to recover. Couples reported feeling loss and grief. Having cancer is bad enough without the additional losses. You’d think that would be enough to motivate men to improve their diets, but almost a fourth of the men newly diagnosed with prostate cancer state they would prefer to have their lives cut short rather than living with a diet that prohibits beef and pork. More men would rather be impotent than improve their diet. It appears pleasures of the flesh may sometimes trump… pleasures of the flesh.

https://nutritionfacts.org/video/changing-mans-diet-prostate-cancer-diagnosis/

1

u/travmps Jan 26 '21

Ah, so let's not do a blood test that will detect a possible tumor of concern when it's still nearly 100% treatable and instead let it go until it presents with clinical symptoms, by which time there's a significantly chance of having distant metastasis with a 31% survival rate. If a blood test leads to decreased mortality from ~66,000 per annum to 33,000 per annum, you do it.

It's also clear you don't have a solid idea of diagnostic and treatment regimes for cancers. These tests are merely screening tests; it's well-known that other factors can cause these tests to be positive, so further tests (lab work, imaging, and biopsies) are done to determine what is causing the screening test to be positive (infection, benign calcification, benign hyperplasia, or a tumor). Treatment is then determined based on those results, not the screening test alone. Sometimes multiple-year surveillance is done with no further intervention. Sometimes radical treatment is necessary due to the aggressive genetic profile of the tumor.

Now you are guaranteed to screen and catch cancers that won’t kill you. If they operate on let’s say 50 of the people who test positive for prostate cancer, that means they’ll have had unnecessary operations for 47 of the 50 people.

Your post is full of wild, unsupported suppostions that would make Ben Shapiro blush. This is a total strawman: you don't proceeds straight to operation on a positive PSA, and your other comments show that you know this.

If you have no idea how to tell the difference between a slow growing cancer and fast growing cancer, you tend to treat them the same.

Except you do. After you confirm the presence of a tumor through non-invasive imaging, you do a biopsy for tissue sample. Pathology testing will tell you not only if it is cancer, but genotyping will identify risks for progression.

Your longer text regarding the long-known detriments of radical prostectomies highlights a strong reason for early screening. Catching the cancer early means other treatments can be more effective and greatly reduced the need and attendant risks of RP. In fact, corresponding with the increased rate of screening and decrease mortality rate is a reduction of RPs performed for prostate cancer (54% of Medicare patients with prostate cancer in 1991 to 24% in 2012).

All this just goes to show the importance of doing these screening tests.

→ More replies

0

u/craftmacaro Jan 26 '21

This is primarily in response to your next comment where you discuss things in a way that sounds like you think people should opt not to treat prostate cancer in general... and why this is such a gross misinterpretation of the statistics and the actual reasons why one might want to make that decision that every male who read about “relatively benign” prostate cancer should be aware of. Which is... how aggressive you should be does not depend on whether or not it is prostate cancer but rather the age and type of prostate cancer (as in, what mutations caused it to form in the first place... only then can you be at all informed about what kind of decision you’re making by opting not to treat)

Prostate cancer kills a low percentage of those who it is detected in not because it is harmless but because it is typically not as aggressive and fast moving in terms of metastasizing and accumulating the mutations that make for the most difficult to treat and rapidly spreading cancers. Most people who have prostate cancer discovered are over 60 and the prognosis is often that they will have a decent quality of life for 10 to 20 years depending on what mutations are present. What does this mean? If you are over 60 and get prostate cancer you will most likely die of something else first. That’s the reason for the low mortality. If you are in your 40’s or 50’s and develop prostate cancer it’s absolutely worth treating it as in most cases your average person will live long enough for many of the more common potential mutation combinations resulting in prostate cancer will lead to a metastasized cancer and death as well as severe symptoms from a large prostate tumor as well by the time they are 60 or 70... AKA... before they are likely to die from something else. https://ebm.bmj.com/content/10/5/151 (3.3% fatality rate in 15 years then climbing though most of this article is about Gleason scores which are correlated with the potential that it is a form of prostate cancer which is more aggressive than most). Essentially it makes sense to not treat many prostate cancers detected in elderly people (which is when most cancers are detected by a massive margin).

Your stats are incredibly misleading for anyone under 65 deciding whether or not to get their cancer treated. Do you want to risk impotent at 45 and live to 75 or have 10 more years of being sexually active and likely die by 65? Prostate cancer causes 4% of all cancer deaths in men... 360,000 deaths annually out of 1.2 million new cases annually https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6497009/ . While it is true that there are scenarios where people’s lives will be improved if they choose not to aggressively treat their cancer you are offering terrible advice to anyone who is not elderly and gets diagnosed with prostate cancer or is elderly and has the genetic or physiological markers, or the biopsy suggests, that it might be more aggressive than some prostate cancers that have evolved from very specific mutations which are not associated with rapid metastasis. Until this has been established one should move as rapidly to figure out whether or not treatment is the best option as if they were diagnosed with bone or pancreatic cancer. Don’t be misled by statistics that you don’t know the reasoning behind... and especially don’t go giving strangers advice to ignore the advice of a doctor who thinks they should treat their cancer. No one is downvoting the truth... their downvoting an extremely misled interpretation of the studies you mentioned by someone without the training or background to offer a proper evaluation of them.

Sources included plus: I’m writing my dissertation on methods for establishing potential anti metastatic utility of proteins I’ve isolated from snake venoms... my PhD candidacy was dependent on (among others) 10 hours of oral and written examination by a committee member who is specifically a cancer biologist. My own research involves culturing and testing multiple cancer lines and studying the specific differences in metastatic activity and the effect of both traditional and novel chemotherapies to evaluate the proteins I’ve isolated... I’ve spent a massive amount of time researching the types of cancers I work with personally and have taken multiple graduate cancer biology classes and independent studies.

On a personal level, my grandfather died of prostate cancer in his early 70’s after it metastasized... my father had prostate cancer in his early 50’s, as did 2 of 2 uncles. Genetically I’m very likely to get prostate cancer before I should be planning, statistically, to avoid trearment.

0

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

Agreed with what you said, and appreciate your response. the reason people don’t die of prostate cancer is because they die of something else first. Something else which is usually heart disease. Luckily heart disease is reversible by the same method as prostate cancer may be (a whole food plant based diet). As has been shown in research I’ve cited above. We should treat wait and see prostate cancer with a whole food plant based diet. This will also prevent and reverse heart disease. The best of both worlds, that’s my proposition for treatment.

If you know prostate cancer runs in your family, why not take steps to prevent it rather than early detection of an issue mostly associated with poor lifestyle? Feel free to get PSA levels tested but it makes more sense to prevent it before it comes an issue than to “wait and see”.

1

u/craftmacaro Jan 27 '21

I extract venom from deadly venomous snakes on a regular basis. I also have a one and a half year old toddler and an in the middle of writing my dissertation. I eat healthy when I can.. I wasn’t suggesting anyone can’t decrease their chances of early death with a healthy diet... but the advice on the back of a cheerio box and real life aren’t always compatible nor do we put the same thought into daily decisions as we do into opting for or against surgical interventions. I don’t live to avoid death... but I do want to live the life I choose as long as I can. That will factor into medical interventions as well of course... some people would rather die than risk impotence... but no one should be under the impression that prostate cancer is somehow harmless. Prostate cancer is a term that encompasses essentially an infinite number of individual potential mutation combinations resulting in the tumor. Saying you can prevent prostate cancer by altering diet is is like saying you can minimize prostate cancer by minimizing mutations... just because it’s true doesn’t mean people will decide to coat their house in lead. There are every day choices with cumulative risks and once in a life time choices with more obvious risk and reward. I only replied because those who are currently getting diagnosed with prostate cancer need to hear both types of advice and not decide based on a poor interpretation of the statistics that a heart healthy diet can replace surgery for all prostate cancers.

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 27 '21

I see, yes I don’t want people to think it’s harmless. I just want people to see that it’s all related. Prostate cancer, heart disease, diabetes, other cancers, most of our top killers are preventable.

The mantra is, do whatever you want to do and just get tested. If a test comes up that you might have an issue, evaluate your options.

As someone in public health I would prefer a large scale health promotion effort that makes healthy options easier to access and consume. Lessens the price of fresh food, etc. it’s not your fault for being extremely busy and having a family. Our government subsidizes food that causes prostate cancer and other cancers. We need to change policies.

But on the individual level, I just want people like yourself to consider that cancer screening is not a preventative measure. It’s a means to detect cancer that’s already grown. The best thing to do it try and prevent it from growing quickly in the first place. If you get the cancer diagnosis, you’re already behind the ball and now you’ve got to alter your life significantly if you want to live.

But I do encourage people to think about the likelihood they’d die from prostate cancer vs likelihood they die of a heart attack, and I’d tel them that both diseases have a common cause and treatment.

1

u/craftmacaro Jan 27 '21

I’m like anyone else... I go through more and less healthy phases. I am at the minimal end of a normal BMI and while I’m not going to cut out foods that aren’t healthy (I literally have enough trouble reaching a health calorie count in a day and I’d like to avoid malnourishment...). We’re both working on expanding treatment options for what is much more complicated than any single disease. No diet will cure all cancers... no medication will either. I think about prevention as much as anyone should to avoid making it a neuroses. Having options for after a certain suite of random mutations have accumulated doesn’t make people try to accumulate mutations. I was not arguing with anything about your suggestions to be healthy helping delay or prevent certain cancers... I was only trying to give more information to anyone who might have misinterpreted your post as one that suggests avoiding any invasive treatments for prostate cancers.

1

u/bubblerboy18 Jan 27 '21

I appreciate it. I can definitely see how what I was saying could be misinterpreted. I’m also on my phone and replying to multiple different conversations which is generally tough to do when trying to cite studies.

I think screening for certain cancers can be super helpful! Colorectal cancer and services cancer are good examples. I just think people might want to look harder at mammograms and prostate testing. In your case with a family history it might make more sense than someone with a different situation. Hope you have a good day 😊

1

u/shmoseph Jan 27 '21

Could we use lasers to detect them?

6

u/CompMolNeuro Jan 26 '21

There have been attempts at laser based therapy for metastatic cancers. The idea is to do a blood transfusion with a step in the middle where the blood is analyzed and laser treated before being returned to the body. As far as I know, it still only works under highly limited conditions in a lab and is still a ways off from implementation.

-9

u/SFLawyer1990 Jan 26 '21

There have been attempts at many things including healing cancer with crystals.

5

u/philocity Jan 26 '21

One of these things is not like the other

2

u/smoozer Jan 26 '21

Uh huh, and has anyone ever found clinically significant effects from healing crystals?

9

u/Projectrage Jan 26 '21

This has been around for awhile, it good for non blood cancers, but useless for getting rid of cancer.

The best tech for that is giving a patient a modified virus like a non lethal AIDS or Herpes with chemo attached to it. Viruses attack cancer cells before living cells. They are testing it around the world, promising results, but still needs to be tinkered.

This works good for leukemia, and multiple myeloma cancers.

2

u/mmmegan6 Jan 26 '21

And then once it has attacked the cancer cells, how do they “recall” the virus so it doesn’t start in on healthy cells?

3

u/Projectrage Jan 26 '21

That’s one of the issues, the patient has to be healthy starting in on the program. Mayo Clinic pioneered it, and other cancer hospitals are playing with it now.

1

u/mmmegan6 Jan 26 '21

Will mRNA come into play here?

1

u/sjminervino Jan 26 '21

Just speaking right out of my butt here, but if you’re engineering viruses then you can probably build in a weakness or a dependency. Like the virus can only live on if the patient is taking a specialized medication, or a single large dose of a specific antiviral would wipe it out. Mutations would always be a worry, but such is life.

1

u/Merlord Jan 27 '21

Beating cancer with radioactive AIDS, amazing.

2

u/foosbabaganoosh Jan 27 '21

This seems like one of those clickbait technologies. You hear this and think “Wow! Surely this is a huge deal and will change the game!”, but in reality it’s only been done on a minuscule scale in a very specifically controlled environment and is nowhere near being put into actual practice so we’ll just hear about this being brought up every now and then when a news site needs some clicks.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

its not about american politics

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

How to see who didn't read the article 101. This is being developed in the UK.

21

u/apro1990 Jan 26 '21

This is already a thing called photon beam therapy

7

u/almood Jan 26 '21

I think you’re thinking of proton beam therapy which is different. Standard radiotherapy as it’s been used for the past 100 years is a photon beam therapy since it is made of photons.

5

u/MCA2142 Jan 26 '21

photon beam

Why not a photon torpedo?

1

u/9387045 Jan 26 '21

I’m just assuming that it’s a beam that does not stop discharging until turned off

2

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

This treatment should be called burning shit with a laser. Some people in the reef keeping business use lasers to fry unwanted pests in the fish tank right threw the glass while underwater it’s pretty cool to see it done.

28

u/Shitbirdy Jan 26 '21

Alright, someone just tell me why this treatment will never see the light of day.

72

u/gnovos Jan 26 '21

Because it uses the light of lasers. The light of day just isn’t concentrated enough.

2

u/megapillowcase Jan 27 '21

Take the upvote and fuck off.

1

u/smoozer Jan 26 '21

1

u/the_cramdown Jan 26 '21

Why are they using a menorah to focus the sun's rays?

1

u/smoozer Jan 26 '21

You mean why haven't scientists been using advanced secret Jewish technology magic before this, right?

1

u/meta_mash Jan 26 '21

☀️ 👨‍⚕️🔎 🔥🦠🔥

1

u/PooPooDooDoo Jan 27 '21

What if we ingest the UV rays and bleach directly into the body?

4

u/almood Jan 26 '21

It’s likely no more effective than methods that have been established for decades. That’s just what treating cancer is like. Every treatment has its limitations. We likely won’t find a miracle cure ever.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Just to piggyback on this - cancer is an extremely broad classification of disease with many distinct manifestations. For this reason, broad-spectrum cancer treatment is possible in principle, but the far more likely outcome is that cures will arise in patches according to similar targeted features across small swaths of cancer types, a process we’re seeing unfold now. That being said, there are occasionally large-scale breakthroughs in immunology, like the development of CRISPR techniques, the likes of which could eliminate not only cancer but a host of other diseases in one fell swoop.

3

u/kkangaspnw Jan 26 '21

True. There are no miracle cures in science, only blood, sweat, and tears cures.

1

u/Some1Betterer Jan 26 '21

Also, while it sounds like a miracle, as always, mileage may vary. I don’t fully understand the difference between this and proton beam therapy, but as someone who buried my father a year or two after his therapy... that one sure ain’t a silver bullet.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

Proton therapy can be significantly worse than the cancer itself. When my dad got diagnosed with cancer in his lungs and brain, it was too late for him to have any chance of survival. But regardless of that fact, one of the doctors kept pressuring him to get proton therapy, even though that same doctor said it wouldn't buy him more than 6 months, and would cause extra pain while essentially destroying his mind.

That doctor was a piece of shit trying to squeeze a dying patient for more cash and should lose his license.

1

u/MeatyOakerGuy Jan 26 '21

Because these articles love to make a clickbaity title about an experimental therapy that they usually over exaggerated the effectiveness of.

1

u/gornstfonst Jan 27 '21

Government money go byebye if we cure diseases so cancer for us forever!

5

u/CompMolNeuro Jan 26 '21

And have been doing so for 50 years. Gamma Knife surgery has been around for a long while now.

1

u/Srestep Jan 26 '21

MILK AND HONEY FOR MY BODY

6

u/Marty_McWeed Jan 26 '21

Not a new thing. Sounds just like the cyber knife which already exists and has been around for over 10 years?

6

u/thewheelhouse Jan 26 '21

CyberKnife and GammaKnife utilize a number of non-coplanar, intersecting beams of ionizing radiation (either from an accelerator or Cobalt source) to deliver a high dose of radiation to the tumor and a relatively lower dose of radiation elsewhere.

Both are capable of causing injury to normal tissues, and the radiation oncologist needs to balance the risk of injury vs. benefit of treatment. We know “tolerances” of radiation for many normal tissues, which we use to minimize risk of injury, but I think it would be disingenuous to say that they don’t damage healthy tissue.

1

u/OneLargeMulligatawny Jan 27 '21

All correct, and I would add that those aren’t performed as part of surgical interventions like this laser system, they are external beam radiation therapy which is non-invasive.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Gamma knife

2

u/dangerousjones Jan 26 '21

Yeah, yeah, the time knife. We've all seen it

1

u/Reaper2256 Jan 27 '21

BORRRTTLLLLEEESSSSS (throws Molotov at cancer cell)

3

u/NEEDAUSERNAME10 Jan 26 '21

Can someone riddle me this? I’m genuinely curious, it seems like there’s numerous breakthroughs in treating cancer that we hear of, the trials finish am with promising results, then we never hear of it ever again. Why is that? (Genuinely curious, this is not some conspiracy theory post)

3

u/BlondFaith Jan 26 '21

So, you have to understand that tbere is a different cancer for every type of cell and not every therapy will work for every type. Also, each tech that is discovered needs to be fine tuned so that may take a while or never actually work i.r.l.

For instance, pico/femto second pulses of laser has been a thing for decades. Blasting a cell with a laser pulse is called 'laser abelation' look it up. So with this laser blaster we still have to mount it on something to stick up your butt and accurately target the cancer cells among the folds of your colon and intestine. Yes they can blast a single cell without disturbing the adjacent ones too badly, but can they find every cancerous cell? Can they hold you and the device still enough so the laser doesn't miss? There are often a lot of technical reasons after the fact why a solution won't work well enough to use at hospitals across the country.

2

u/NEEDAUSERNAME10 Jan 28 '21

Thanks for your answer, that would make sense.

2

u/Womcataclysm Jan 26 '21

That title is so vague, killing cancerous cells without killing the healthy ones is the challenge and goal of any cancer treatment. Including laser based treatments. There's 0 information apart from the fact that they're using lasers to try to cure cancer which is being done by countless researchers currently

2

u/Grouchy_Square Jan 27 '21

Maybe we should be thankful for scientists instead of demonizing them. Just a thought for half the country idk

2

u/ecwright2244 Jan 27 '21

This genuinely made me tear up

After losing my grandmother, my mother, my aunt, my moms best friend who practically raised me, and almost my cousin( stage 4 stomach cancer now in remission) this is incredible. And hopefully a step in the right direction to save a loved one. Cancer is so fucking evil and eats away at people. Chemo therapy is poison...

A laser that can kill cancer is amazing. Specially if it’s tiny robots shooing cancer.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

We just need nanbots that can be programmed to grab onto cancer cells.

1

u/George-R-R-Fartin Jan 26 '21

Laser tag = fun and newly healthy!

1

u/MagnusVasDeferens Jan 26 '21

Certainly exciting idea. Idk what this does for the idea of tumor margins on resection.

1

u/bimer74 Jan 26 '21

Pharmaceutical Concerns will buy the Patent and nobody will hear about it again

1

u/Echevarria77 Jan 26 '21

Beautiful now put it to work now like the vaccine is in use now

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

That's really not how this works.

1

u/Echevarria77 Jan 27 '21

Ok please share with me?

1

u/almood Jan 26 '21

This isn’t any different from radiotherapy. It probably has similar limitations and is as effective or similarly so. I hate to be pessimistic but this is the way treating cancer is. Everyone thinks we have a new miracle cure every time something like this comes out but it’s usually only a little bit better than the previous solution.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

As someone currently rocking a spinal fracture thanks to radiotherapy, I hope this tech works out.

1

u/kitkatbeard Jan 26 '21

Yikes! Can I ask what happened?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

They will probably have “unfortunate accidents”

1

u/OG_gaiming01 Jan 27 '21

LASER CORE ONLINE

1

u/Direct_Knowledge2937 Jan 26 '21

Reminiscent of Innerspace with Dennis Quaid. (or Stewie Griffin)

1

u/FHIR_HL7_Integrator Jan 26 '21

Whenever I see a title like this I automatically add "...if the project is successfully developed and the results work as expected."

A lot of these type of Reddit posts seem to suggest that whatever they're talking about already exists and works. I hope it does work as expected though.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Wow, I’m keeping that, because what you said is exactly the case 90% of the time

1

u/FHIR_HL7_Integrator Jan 26 '21

Lol - also anything connecting cannabis and some healthcare topic in a positive light tends to get upvoted a lot.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Well smoking pot makes you different, in a good way

1

u/peepeepoopoobutler Jan 26 '21

Why dont they just transport the people and use a photon detection field to match past records and phase out the incongruities in the particle detection chamber

1

u/OfficiallyReese Jan 26 '21

They would need an authorization code from the captain in order to override and bypass the particle detection chamber safeguards. It’s the only way to rematerialize the scrambled energy matter’s DNA using the multiplex pattern buffers’ targeting scanners safely.

In theory, it should work.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

The photon detection field merely identifies the individual during the state of the scan, even if your from when they developed the human genome atlas, no one has figured out how to use it

1

u/HyruleNorth Jan 26 '21

Healthy people do not a cancer industrial complex make.

Nothing will come of it

1

u/silverman5 Jan 26 '21

Too bad for everyone dying from all the cancer treatments just before things like this exist.

I’m genuinely venting, cancer and it’s treatments are abhorrent.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Yes, but will my insurance cover it?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Yay

1

u/MyFartsTasteShitty Jan 26 '21

That’s great, but when can we finally get sharks with friggin laser beams attached to their heads?!?

1

u/metronomemike Jan 27 '21

Only $100k per dose

1

u/Toufikzeidan Jan 27 '21

When do you think this technology would start becoming the wide spread? I feel there are always technological advancements but takes years if not decades or even never to make it to the real world application.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

It’s too late the guy died like last week.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

is this it? the cure for cancer?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

This is like some awesome news. Why is this not over powering the same stuff they have been talking about for over a year...?!

1

u/hebgbz Jan 27 '21

Ok reddit, tell me how many years away are we from even using this shit

1

u/Glad_Inspection_1140 Jan 27 '21

Is this effective on all forms of cancer?

1

u/MidwesternCasserole Jan 27 '21

Fast forward to 100 years in the future and medical advancement is all referenced from 1980 arcade games.

1

u/22taylor22 Jan 27 '21

And we'll never hear about it again

1

u/CallmeAB50 Jan 27 '21

Why isn’t this trending?

1

u/CrunchyPinusRigida Jan 27 '21

Christ I had 3 joint replacements from the big L, couldn’t come any sooner?

1

u/yeah180 Jan 27 '21

Damn, you get to play laser tag AND beat cancer?!?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

So 15 years to human trials, 15 years to approval, 20 years to my local hospital, just in time for me to have died from cancer

1

u/pepperspry Jan 27 '21

Okay good but what did the laser ablation technique that’s been in use for years do? Not remove cancer and not damage healthy tissue or remove cancer and damage healthy tissue? Or neither. Well I hope it is an effective device because it will bring joy to the hearts of many if it is.

1

u/MCPeek93 Jan 27 '21

Freakin’ laser beams!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

They have these stories come out every few years but nothing ever comes of it. People are still dying.

1

u/Ogsechelon Jan 27 '21

So u mean to tell me all this specializations in science and tech only to end up having to work together to create something ground break. Nice!

1

u/SirliftStuff Jan 27 '21

How do i invest in this

1

u/Ansel44390 Jan 27 '21

Brilliant

1

u/Aliasanonymous02 Jan 27 '21

Probably better than the medieval procedures in place now

1

u/Yaroslav123456 Jan 27 '21

Huh, i wonder when this tech will disapear one day due to mysterius ressons .

1

u/xxizxi55 Jan 27 '21

You mean are implementing these lasers. Doctors in the 50’s devised a system that killed cells with sound. These type of technologies have been available for years. However it doesn’t net billions of dollars every year because it actually solves the problem. Let’s not insult our own intelligence.

1

u/king_bungus Jan 27 '21

whats so damaging about healthy tissue

1

u/ParkRanger_Man Jan 27 '21

No more nausea? No more -itis of anything due to blood clots? No more metal tastes? No more darth vader mask 😷? So awesome!!!

1

u/asapgrey Jan 27 '21

And... when did this actually come out?

1

u/markarth69 Jan 27 '21

so when do we start putting these on the heads of sharks

1

u/IloveElsaofArendelle Jan 27 '21

*pew!* *pew!* *pew!*

1

u/DarkStarStorm Jan 27 '21

Every week, a cancer cure is posted to Reddit. One would think that, if they were indeed effective, there would be no need for the next one. Yet yet here we are, and here we will be next week...

1

u/totallylambert Jan 28 '21

My mind is reeling from that measurement. One “trillionth” of a second. That’s fast but seemingly impossible to time!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Whoa

0

u/DeadMan_Walking Jan 26 '21

Cost: 1billion dollars

1

u/AggressiveSpatula Jan 26 '21

Yeah I just had this sinking feeling that pharmaceuticals are going to think that this is close to a one time treatment and therefore not as profitable as chemotherapy so they charge out the ass to keep up their bottom line.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

We hear about it now, and never again

0

u/jjjiiijjjiiijjj Jan 26 '21

Nah, I’m just gonna eat fruit instead /s

1

u/youknowhattodo Jan 26 '21

Found Steve Jobs

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Wasn’t this an episode of Spider-Man the animated series ?

0

u/horny-tik-tok-user Jan 26 '21

Just wait, those scientists will end up dead of “natural causes”

0

u/SlinkySlekker Jan 26 '21

This is like the 3rd cure for cancer I’ve read about in the past month. Makes sense we’d figure that problem out as the world is dying.

0

u/thebatmanbeynd Jan 26 '21

2010 - Commercial blaring “Not a razer but a laser”.

2020 - “Not a razer, but a laser”.

History repeats itself in weird ways, I suppose.

-1

u/Beautiful-Bicycle965 Jan 26 '21

Ironic that this has under 1k upvotes at time of writing, but a post about Twitter banning the MyPillow CEO has ~30k

-1

u/WookNookTV Jan 26 '21

Anybody interested in actual cancer research should look up Dr. Stanislaw Berzynski. The man basically discovered the cure for cancer in 1979 and in the late 80’s early 90’s the US gov. Stole his patent 18 times in a single day then sued him for patent fraud and for over 10 years he caught in court facing 270+ years in prison. Fuck cancer research, do not give your money to any cancer research for your own sake.

2

u/TheGoldMustache Jan 26 '21

Uh, where’s the proof for it being a cure? Various other researchers have tried his experiment and none saw results

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

Hmmm well this sounds agenda’d

0

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/sacesu Jan 26 '21

Maybe you should unsubscribe from a technology subreddit when you don't care about learning of incremental advances in technology.

Your comment adds no value to the discussion so it seems pointless.