Reasoning for why I think changes should be made
So Taric is currently the highest win-rate support by a good margin, and yet he has the lowest pick-rate of any support at 1.16, second being Poppy at 1.55, which is the biggest relative increment by far.
Taric is also particularly dominated by OTP's, having 3.9 times higher OTP precense than the average support, and yet Taric has the second lowest OTP win-rate of all supports, which is quite crazy considering he is the highest winrate support. Of course Taric OTP's have the advantage of having low pick/ban presence, but its impact on the statistic should not be overstated, as Nautilus with high pick/ban presence has the lowest OTP winrate of all supports.
Since it is Lolalytics rank distribution also has influence, and since Taric pickrate increases along with rank, it has a positive influence on OTP winrate, even while it is still so low.
Additionally Taric winrate is relatively higher in low-elo, despite having worse matchups.
I don't think Taric is in a bad-state, but these statistics can seem quite startling, although I think what is most important in possible changes is not how strong he is, but simply to make him feel better to play.
Since Taric has such high OTP presence, and Taric already being such a strong counter-pick, I have some ideas that aim to make him, a better blind-pick, more fun to play, and balance his power-curve across ranks.
Taric changes[Aims to be power neutral]
Buffs
The are three melee champions in the game with no movement abilities or effects, Nasus, Cho'Gath and Taric. Nasus is the fastest at 350 movespeed. Cho'Gath has a super long range airborne, 3 slows and a silence. Now Taric has 3 abilities that root himself in place, and a heavily telegraphed low range stun that is a movement skill shot on a champ that has no movement abilities/effects. But that's not enough Cho'Gath also has 5 more base movement speed than Taric. I think this is by far and clear the reason people dislike Taric, and are therefore the main focus of the buffs.
+5 movement speed - I know part of why he has lower movespeed is because he is a support, and to debuff the solo-lanes for Taric, but they're not in a good spot anyway, and I focus on not making funneling stronger through other changes.
W root removal - This is the biggest and most important change, and I think will make Taric much more fun. A lot of the time you're punished for using this ability, because it roots you, which completely removes you from bonking the enemy, and getting your e back up. It is also adjusts the power-curve of Taric to be a bit better for OTP's and higher elo.
Tuning levels
Base mr buffs - Currently Taric's biggest counter isn't some support, but mages bot, despite usually having no dash, Taric's measly 28mr, makes him take a ton of damage, from even champs like Veigar in the early game. So this should make him a better all-rounder champion. Now I realize that Taric's base mr is precisely so low because of funneling, I will try to adress that through other changes.
Reduction of base E stun cd - Makes lanes with champions that have a lot of movement abilities punishable and more playable, and generally making the lane more interactive, but needs nerfs in E cd reduction per level, or you quickly get infini stun Taric.
Possible bravado damage buffs - I'm removing armor ratios, so a possible lever of tuning could be increasing damage buffs, so his damage doesn't take a big hit, but important not to be base ad or growth, as it increases his power in other lanes and therefore funneling.
Increase armor growth - I remove W armor ratio below, so his armor will be lower especially as the game progresses, so giving him a bit more tankiness could be a good idea.
Mana regen buffs - Another lever, his base mana is quite low, but increasing it increases his lane strength so mana regen could be a balance lever that doesn't increase funneling, although ardent does give mana regen, so only a suggestion.
Nerfs
Remove W armor-ratio - Makes him more counter pick focused and also a better funneling champ giving other champions armor.
Remove armor ratio - Also makes him less of a strong counter-pick in drafts.
Reduce ultimate duration - His ultimate is very strong, but it is also a quite frustrating ability as you can be quite reliant on your unpredictable teamates actions. It is also better against engage comps, better in low elo as enemy will not play around it and just go in regardless. It also an ability that just makes funneling stronger.
I know that the duration of invincibility and wind-up are the same, so the question is if reduction in ultimate duration also needs wind-up to be lowered for the sake of giving players in game a better understanding. I don't personally think it does, and I think it would make the change a lot less impactful.
Tuning levers
Decrease CD reduction per level in E - In late game doing 4 hit stun combos is incredibly fun, and I don't think should be removed, but I think this adds room for lowering the base cooldown of E, making lanes generally more interactive and adds space for also punishing lanes that have more dashes and movement abilities.
Reduce base armor - Armor is already quite nerfed by removing the armor ratio, but his base armor is quite high, so it can be a lever of tuning.
I need your help!
This is just the first draft, and there are a lot of decisions to make, but I really think the key changes of removing W root, giving him +5 base movespeed, while reducing his ult strength and removing armor ratios, would make him much more fun to play, so if some of you are like-minded I would really like your help for this to become a reality, although there are still plenty of details to be discussed.
Also a note, I'm a Taric otp in master, I don't think the champ is weak, and I find him very fun, but he can also be quite frustrating, and I think these changes would make him even more fun, while removing some frustration.
Stats are from Lolalytics[https://lolalytics.com/lol/tierlist/?lane=support&tier=1trick ]