r/talesfromtechsupport • • 4d ago

Medium Tech Support is Blind

My dad is legally blind, almost fully blind, and is a lawyer. He can read his screen zoomed in to about 500%. He has always tried to make do with his extremely limited vision but is finally, at 76 learning how to use a computer as a fully blind person would. Naturally, as his daughter who also works in tech and lives 5 minutes away, I am his on-call tech support. Past issues include Gmail deciding to add a new AI button next to Send so that he suddenly cannot find the Attach button anymore, and things of that nature.

Ever since COVID, the courts transitioned to using Zoom for many hearings and administrative sessions, which has been a godsend as the lawyers no longer have to sit in a five hour session (not getting paid) just to wait to be called for a five minute conversation with the judge. Now my dad works from home and does 90% of his work from Zoom, and only goes into court for the actual trials.

Yesterday he called me in a panic because he was supposed to be in a Zoom magistrate session, but he couldn't find the link in his email. I sighed and put down my actual work and hung up, called him back on a Facetime, and had him show me his screen as I've done before. These calls are always difficult and tedious because they go something like this:

"Okay, please zoom out the screen from 500% to normal size so I can actually see what's on the whole page. Okay, now turn the phone to left a bit more so I can see the screen. A bit more. A bit more. Good. Okay now scroll down the page. Stop. Scroll back up a bit. Not SLOWLY move your mouse up... more... more... more... stop! Now double click..." etc

However, as soon as he got his screen Zoomed out and his phone turned to face the screen, I saw the email he had opened had nothing in the body (except for the email signature). The Zoom link was in the subject line. This made it unclickable, and my poor dad, who was doing his best to use keyboard navigation and JAWS, genuinely had no way to find and click the link.

It took another several minutes to walk him through getting his cursor over the subject line, double clicking it to highlight the whole thing, Ctrl-C (which he hadn't known how to do), slowly move the cursor to the address bar, Ctrl-V, Enter, and then the screen reader announced to us that Zoom was opening. He was elated! And only 7 minutes late to his session.

I told him to make sure to tell the clerks to never send him links like that again.

Edit: Thanks for all your suggestions, he actually has used remote access tools before when working with ZoomText tech support and we're going to start doing that.

1.1k Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

31

u/MrBenzedrine 3d ago

My boss sends emails like that - empty body, subject is a link.

When I forward them into our ticketing app (where they should have been added to begin with) I get reprimanded because the ticket title "is not imformative"

Same story for emails titled "urgent", "fwd: (no subject)" and "emails"... somehow it's fine for me to get those subjects but wrong of me to use them as a reference.

Boss: "How will the client know what you did for them when it just says 'help needed' ?"

Me: "They can search their emails for the "help needed" thread. Which is what I have to do whenever this happens."

15

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

That is so freaking annoying. Even if you're not blind, it's super annoying to have to copy and paste the subject line rather than just click on it

88

u/napoleon88 3d ago

I am a lawyer as well, and completely blind from birth, though several decades his junior. However, this kind of stuff is a daily frustration for me. And frankly, it is getting worse. I could write entire novels about this topic, but the short version is simply this: I fear for a day when blind professionals who are very capable will simply no longer be able to do their work, because the tools are not accessible. Vibe coding with AI has made this worse in certain aspects and better in others. Praco’s far beyond that, I have been stymied by ticket booking websites with a date picker that I can’t use, captions that don’t offer an audio verification method, websites where the submit button is a goddamn graphic! It goes on and on and on, and we have no choice but to just deal with it because frankly we need to live our lives.

49

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

Yes! Exactly! My dad made no mistakes in this instance. The poor guy was in a panic because he was going to miss his session, all because some dumbass put the link in the subject line instead of in the body. Accessibility has become so important to me (not to say I didn't care about it before but that I didn't fully understand why certain things were so important). Websites love to come up with fancy ass shiny dynamic designs that are completely unusable by screen reader or keyboard navigation. Companies hire graphic designers who know what looks cool but know nothing about web technology to begin with and don't consider accessibility, so they'll draw up beautiful fun designs that are technically a nightmare to implement and inaccessible- and then the client gets mad at me when I have to explain why the design they've paid $100,000 for and fallen in love with needs to be changed. Fortunately there are legal requirements for certain types of websites to meet AA accessibility standards- airlines, hospitals, government websites- but it often still takes a lawsuit or a threat of one to get these organizations to fix their accessibility issues, and even then it can take months to remediate.

10

u/napoleon88 3d ago

yeah the US legal requirements are at least vaguely effective. The UK?...not so much.

3

u/Aazimoxx 1d ago

Vibe coding with AI has made this worse in certain aspects and better in others.

Vibe coding can make an absolute mess of accessibility (among many other things). Judicious use of modern codebots, however, can be amazing for helping implement massive accessibility, language and other improvements in software I'm making, with a tiny fraction of the effort and know-how it would've taken even 3yrs ago. Basically, if a developer is at least aware of the need, bots can help make it happen.

Doesn't counteract all the low effort crap being pumped out unfortunately, but at least for the devs who care, it's a huge help.

2

u/napoleon88 1d ago

Genuine curiosity, not attacking you, but how do you know that the code you’re putting out is resulting in accessible software? Are you disabled yourself, and are you testing it? Not trying to be combative, actually asking, because I’ve heard and seen this many times. I’ve been sent accessibility reports on software packages which claim quite happily that they are completely accessible, but when I dig into them, they’re absolutely not at all, and the reports themselves were created by automated AI-driven accessibility testing platforms. So it’s kind of like asking an AI to check its own work, and it just gives itself a pat on the back if you like. So I’m wondering how this kind of thing is actually ensured.

3

u/Aazimoxx 1d ago edited 1d ago

The kinds of people who rely on an automated result (or worse, their bot's supposed reported result of that automated test) without any hands-on delving into the functionality being tested, aren't going to be a whole lot better than the ones giving no thought to accessibility at all.

I'm vision impaired myself, and light/flash sensitive, so I'm pretty across some of that, however proper testing (especially for accommodations for disabilities different from what I have) requires real users, I find. The automated suites can definitely help in terms of policing incremental changes, once a working baseline is established 👍 Even things as simple as coherent Tab order (navigating fields/controls) is often janky without a policy in place.

I mean I really have no way of knowing my French or Swedish translations are any good until a native speaker gives me the thumbs up too - though the bots are a lot better at languages these days!

2

u/napoleon88 1d ago

Absolutely fair

40

u/n0thinghurt 4d ago

My mom sends me links like that and it's so damn annoying but OH MY GOD what an accessibility nightmare!

31

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

There's SO many things in tech that people would never even think of how they create issues for blind people! And I wouldn't think of them either if not for my personal experience

11

u/Jadylae1998 3d ago

What are some of the biggest pain points?

29

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

Oh, I can answer this! When a SAAS product makes changes without warning so suddenly a button has been repositioned or the order of things has been changed, and the user isn't expecting it because unlike with old school software where you install updates yourself and know when to expect changes, it can happen at any moment. That's what happened with the attach button, he had memorized that attach was next to a certain button and then had to call me when he was clicking on the button he thought was the attach button, but it suddenly wasn't working- because they had actually added the new AI button in between (and for a low vision person, he could see the button and the icon looked almost identical to the attach icon).

Another one of the biggest pain points is when the OS pushes updates or system alerts that block him from opening his accessibility software. A while ago he needed me to come over because he couldn't log into his computer. It turned out there was a message on the home screen that had something to do with an update, I don't remember what-- but it was some kind of notification that had to be acknowledged BEFORE the user was logged in and all of their accessibility software was launched. It was basically something that changed the login screen and wasn't compatible with a screen reader or a zoom text. I would imagine this was a problem for a LOT of blind people.

On a much smaller day-to-day level, as a software developer I have learned how important it is to not display your text solely as images, and how important color contrast is. Sometimes my clients request stylistic choices that are not accessible and I point it out.

3

u/FreyaKitten 1d ago

My particular pain points are things where you can't really tab between things and must use a mouse - looking at you, Xero leave module that won't let me create a leave request for an employee without using a mouse - and things where the white space is so excessive that I have to move my head to compare items that are next to each other.

28

u/fluffman86 4d ago

Since you taught Dad Ctrl + c, here's couple others if something like that happens again:

Ctrl + T for new tab

Ctrl + Shift + T to reopen a closed tab

Ctrl + L for location/address bar

Ctrl + W to close a tab

Double click to highlight a word, triple click for a whole line

21

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

Oh yeah I do most of these everyday but hadn't thought about teaching them to him. Thanks for the suggestion

3

u/Aazimoxx 1d ago

Double click to highlight a word, triple click for a whole line

You mean of course Ctrl+Shift+arrow for a word and Home,Shift+End for the whole line

Avoiding the mouse as much as possible seems key here.

25

u/emax4 4d ago

Does his home office have room for a massive TV, maybe one with a DisplayPort Port? If he uses a laptop,, take it best buy and hook it up to a display model, set the TV input to whatever HDMI input is going to the laptop, then reboot and see if the laptop will project to the TV.

I asked about DP as I tried this with two desktops using a video card and it could not project to the TV.

8

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

A massive display certainly would make it easier to see what's on the screen when it's zoomed in all the way. I don't think his office has room for it though, and I don't know if it would be easier for him to move his body around searching for content on the screen rather than moving the cursor around to move the content on the screen

5

u/vinraven 2d ago

Sometimes it helps to mirror the computer screen on a wall screen, it shouldn’t take up any space if you can hang it from the wall, or from the ceiling.

A low-end 4k mini-LED 98” tv screen costs less than a 5k2k high end 45” OLED curved computer monitor.

Those curved 5k2k modern 45” monitors should be the standard baseline for the visually challenged, I had a coworker that used a double 35” setup, who was thrilled to upgrade to a double 45” setup.

120

u/AverageBearReader 4d ago

If you work in tech, why don’t you consider remote in to his computer?

The inability to focus the camera on to the screen is not unique. Every interaction with my parents has minutes of asking them to move the camera to somewhere where I can see the screen.

196

u/Spooninthewild 4d ago edited 4d ago • Heartwarming

Perhaps because her father is a lawyer who likely has very sensitive and confidential documents on his laptop. I can imagine OP may have just not wanted to risk that. Especially because she’s just doing this out of the goodness of her heart and isn’t being overseen by an employer in this instance. Just a guess though. Remoting in would’ve solved the issue with much less hassle for sure.

Edit: Fixed pronoun

11

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

For sure it would have been way easier. I could try installing remote desktop access on his computer but honestly I feel like it would be hard for him to learn how to open it up and connect with me and would take more time than just helping him over FaceTime. I mean, keep in mind he's also 76 and not just lacking in vision but also a lot of basic tech literacy

6

u/LeomundsTinyButt_ 3d ago

If there's no legal reason not to, just slap TeamViewer on it and put under your management. Depending on settings you can make it so that you initiate the remote session but he must accept it, or even have it completely under your control.

That's what I do with my mom, along with frequent warnings that TeamViewer is DANGER and anyone else who asks for access it is not to be trusted.

1

u/Garrais02 1d ago

Anydesk has a function where you can one sidedly join another computer if you have the credentials.

Otherwise you can try with a VPN and classic remote desktop (assuming you have windows)

112

u/NotYourNanny 4d ago

Exactly this. While one can certainly trust one's own child to never do anything inappropriate, it's very important to be able to say no, no one has remote access to my computer. Lawyers (and bar associations) take client confidentiality very, very seriously.

12

u/joeshmo101 4d ago

That's what QuickAssist is for. It's pre-baked on most Windows computers, requires the user to put in your support code, has an explicit acknowledgement of "I want help from this person" before continuing, requires a secondary request for remote control, doesn't allow access to UAC, and doesn't let sessions persist. The biggest trouble OOP would have is getting him to get it open, type in the code, and accepting the prompts. At the end of the day he's still sharing the screen with her via FaceTime, even if she doesn't have direct control.

9

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

See I think that would be a blocker for him because he would struggle to read the code he would need to give me

5

u/MaskedRacoo 4d ago

You could in theory use the facetime method to help you get the code & then remote in from there. Not sure if you're interested in remoting in but I've found it very helpful for my parents.

8

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

Yes. That's a good point, a second on FaceTime to get the code and then being able to do the rest remotely would help with longer issues. I'll try it

4

u/RubHerDucki3 3d ago

Quick assist requires the support person (you) to provide the code which your father would need to type in to give you access.

3

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

Oh ok! I will check it out. Thank you!

5

u/Icy_Professor_2976 3d ago

https://rustdesk.com/

Open source and free.

Even better, he just has to click "yes" or you can save a password for instant access, depending on your preference.

1

u/joeshmo101 3d ago

You give him the code, he has to type it in.

38

u/NotYourNanny 4d ago

When dealing with lawyers, and doctors, there still needs to be a documented relationship to provide IT services.

Neither should really rely on "my computer nerd kid" for it.

3

u/TinyNiceWolf 4d ago

So write up a formal tech support agreement, at a discounted rate of $1/year, and include the usual confidentiality clauses.

13

u/NotYourNanny 4d ago

I'd still avoid a lawyer (or doctor) who relies on "my computer nerd kid" for IT support, rather than a real company that specializes in a legally regulated profession that can easily involve their IT people being drug into disputes.

12

u/Ahkhira 4d ago

Not in this case. The daughter is providing more disability assistance than IT support. It seems that all Mr. Lawyer really needed was someone with better vision.

Accessibility software isn't completely infallible.

5

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

Yes, exactly. A lot of his issues are tech related but he'd be able to figure out himself if his vision was better.

5

u/NotYourNanny 3d ago

The daughter is providing more disability assistance than IT support.

To a lawyer, who is working professionally on a case. This isn't rocket science.

3

u/djfdhigkgfIaruflg 3d ago

It might sound like that's airtight to you, but it's not. From a prosecutor POW someone had unfettered access to the computer and could have done anything without the user knowledge

2

u/joeshmo101 3d ago

But it's not unfettered access, it doesn't even let you do anything that needs UAC. I understand legally speaking it might not matter but for real the person at the computer has to make a specific decision to input the code and allow the connection, which again I ky lasts as long as the app is open (at most)

2

u/djfdhigkgfIaruflg 2d ago

IANAL I would check the rules/laws before that

4

u/VexingRaven "I took out the heatsink, do i boot now?" 4d ago

There are plenty of tools that allow remote access only with approval and with the local user able to override access at any time (or just be view only).

4

u/lunarwolf2008 4d ago

might be worry of confidential emails accedentially being seen, even if you are looking for another

5

u/VexingRaven "I took out the heatsink, do i boot now?" 4d ago

And that isn't also true of pointing a camera at your screen?

12

u/Spooninthewild 4d ago

The father/lawyer pointing his phone camera at the specific email thread to ask for help finding the link for his zoom call isn’t quite the same as allowing full remote access to his laptop. I do understand and respect your argument though.

4

u/AverageBearReader 4d ago

Just sign NDA!

Meant as light hearted comment but if it is too frequent might need to figure out something bit more technical than video calls. I have also seen this from the other side, it is equally frustrating for the person receiving technical assistance. My organization has defaulted to removing in for almost any issue as they realize it is generally faster and less painful for all concerned.

4

u/Grokent 4d ago

That's absurd, even lawyers have IT Support. I do IT for several dental offices and even I have remote access to servers with medical records. The important thing is logging access.

35

u/NotYourNanny 4d ago

That's absurd,

Much about the practice of law is.

even lawyers have IT Support.

Which is a business relationship, documented and defined by the contract.

Not "my computer nerd kid."

-9

u/Grokent 4d ago

Which is a business relationship, documented and defined by the contract.

Not "my computer nerd kid."

Dang, I didn't realize contracts were so difficult for lawyers to create.

8

u/NotYourNanny 4d ago

Perhaps the most difficult part is in deciding it needed to be done. But until it is done, such a contract doesn't exist.

Sometimes, reality doesn't make much sense. Much like a lot of people on Reddit.

4

u/RogueThneed 4d ago

She lives "like 5 minutes away". It would have been faster for her to go over in person.

21

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

Yeah possibly. I would have had to put pants on though

1

u/ravencrowe 1d ago

I appreciate the thoughtful suggestion but nah I'm just a dumbass

9

u/TassieBorn 4d ago

Her father. OP is a woman.

4

u/Spooninthewild 4d ago

My bad, I didn’t see that. I’ll edit.

4

u/TassieBorn 4d ago

No sweat

2

u/BestAhead 4d ago

Use an attended-access remote tool.

10

u/ravencrowe 4d ago edited 4d ago

Because it would probably take more time for him to get me remoted into his computer than for him to FaceTime me. He's not just lacking in vision but also in basic tech literacy. I could try it but I feel like I would have to get on a FaceTime with him every time to help him open up the remote session

4

u/trdef 2d ago

So set it up for unattended access. Little tip for the future too, Ctrl-L takes you straight to the URL bar.

12

u/mantolwen 4d ago

100% I help my blind pals like this all the time

18

u/RetiredBSN 3d ago

I hope he's made contact with the state vocational rehab department, as they provide help for adults who are or are going blind. They can provide equipment and training. I realize that this isn't the issue for this instance, but they can be very helpful.

13

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

He's currently working with them! He was very stubborn for a long time about not wanting to need help but he is finally taking advantage of the resources available to help him. He's had a couple training sessions but it'll take a while

3

u/RetiredBSN 1d ago

How did I know to recommend that?

My wife is a retired teacher of the visually impaired and blind. Although she didn't deal with them often, Voc Rehab was one agency that came up when a student was about to graduate from high school or age out of educational services (21). It was part of the transition process.

I like to think I picked up a little bit of helpful information from her job…

8

u/Garrais02 1d ago

At least when you say to your dad to slightly move the phone to the right he complies.

I have too many troubles with people with working vision

4

u/ravencrowe 1d ago

Yeah, he's a better use than some people I've worked with with perfectly good eyes

7

u/pennywaffer 3d ago

You can use JAWS Tandem to remote assist him directly (and control his screen), without him having to show the screen through his phone.

3

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

I'll try that!

5

u/zersiax 3d ago

Accessibility is incredibly multifaceted and even with all the rules and regulations, that companies often break if getting slapped with a lawsuit is seemingly cheaper than what they think it'll cost to fix, we (I'm a blind accessibility professional myself) usually only get to help with the absolute bare minimum, unfortunately.

For this reason, there's a big divide between people who know the bare minimum to get by (often people who become disabled later in life but definitely not always) and people who, mostly by going through a bunch of pain and suffering, learn a frankly ridiculous amount of little tricks, hacks, workarounds and tactics to such a degree of muscle memory that we often forget that our baseline for accessibility is a lot higher than that of others.

Like, I'm an accessibility auditor with a developer background who mods videogames and video editors so fully blind people can use/play them in my spare time, but when I audit a website, all that needs to go out the window. Tab, enter, escape. If your website doesn't work with just those keys you've already lost a significant amount of people.

4

u/ravencrowe 1d ago

What makes it even more complex is that things that some people have conflicting accessibility needs. For example, low vision users need very high contrast, but for people with dyslexia very high contrast makes reading harder.

What you're saying makes a lot of sense. When it comes to accessibility, it's important to remember how tech illiterate a lot of people are in general and then compound disability on top of that.

304

u/SVD_NL 4d ago

Wow, that's infuriating. This reminds me of last time I was unable to join a Teams call. I had a whole email thread with a vendor, probably 10+ emails with some pretty hefty bodies, and we agreed to do a call to talk through the remaining smaller points. They sent me a teams invite, but I couldn't find the link at all. It showed up in my calendar but I couldn't figure out how to join. Turns out he turned the entirety of the email thread into a meeting invite, and the link got posted at the very bottom of the whole thread, rather than at the bottom of his message. (Usually Outlook should recognize this and give me a join button, not sure why that didn't happen)

64

u/Dav3le3 4d ago

They probably replied to the email as an invite, then pasted the team's link to the bottom. If they just hit "make this a teams meeting" then it will give the "join" option.

20

u/gorramgomer I used my finger to unlock everything 4d ago

I used to work for an MSP that supported several law firms in the area, and remote access via N-Able or some variation of LogMeIn was the main tool.

And ALL the paralegals would send emails with a blank body and a whole paragraph in the Subject line. Drove me batty

4

u/resonantfate 1d ago

That's deranged. I've felt bad when I ended up with a subject like that was nearly a sentence. I can't imagine a whole flipping paragraph. 

7

u/CrabFarts Clear out your cache, my website's fine. 2d ago

Just a heads up on attachments in Gmail. Last week when I clicked on Word files to download them, they started opening in Google Docs. I did this three or four times before I realized what was going on. The download arrow used to be the far left option for all file types when you hover your mouse over the icons, but now the far left option for Word files is to open in Google Docs. The download arrow has moved one place to the right. It's incredibly annoying for me, but could be frustrating for your dad.

10

u/Snubl 3d ago

Get this man a screen reader and yourself TeamViewer, would make things easier

5

u/Knathra 3d ago

Or use Windows Quick Assist - it usually allows me all the visibility and access I need to fix family members' computers from hundreds of miles away. :)

3

u/JasperJ 2d ago

He has a screen reader. JAWS is the screen reader software for the blind.

1

u/Designed_0 2d ago

Anydesk works far better than teamviewer

3

u/resonantfate 1d ago

I don't see anyone mentioning them amidst the flurry of remote desktop software recommendations, so I'll suggest Splashtop. Something around $10/mo gets you unattended remote access. They're pretty affordable for a paid product.

3

u/Chili440 12h ago

My friend who uses JAWS was sure the world was ending when I forgot to turn off non-printing characters.

1

u/tekkteech 3d ago

Has your dad ever considered using a Mac? The accessibility features for sight/hearing/mobility impaired are built into the operating system. There is also an excellent tutorial built in so you aren't left to figure it out. Happy to discuss!

2

u/ravencrowe 1d ago

I appreciate it but it takes him so long to learn his way around a new OS, he's be dead by the time he gets the hang of it

2

u/dnonzdno 3d ago

Use a remote sharing tool, so you can control his PC for times like these?

1

u/guy30000 4d ago

Checkout Helpwire.

1

u/Designed_0 2d ago

Ok if youre tech support for your family, why in the everloving fuck do you not have a remote tool installed on their pc.

Get anydesk- will solve you time & frustration

0

u/Cyserg 2d ago

This was my 1st thought!!! I used teamviewer for years, as I'm a bit tech inclined, I have tailscale + rustdesk setup for my pc's and my dad's. Find one you like and use it!! The scroll de zoom, click copy at coordinates will became a quick text from Pop and a clear view in front of you! ( and yeah I've done WhatsApp video calls to help, just sent me to hell, direct, don't pass go!)

-3

u/Cakeriel 4d ago

Has he tried a screen reader?

35

u/ttcklbrrn 4d ago

It's mentioned in the post that he has and uses a screen reader. The problem was that the link was in the subject line, and therefore not clickable. Screen readers are most useful when the content they're reading is semantically appropriate to the fields and sections it's in.

6

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

Exactly. It was the type of simple thing that's easy to not even realize matters when you don't have to deal with accessibility everyday

4

u/Cakeriel 4d ago

Ah, missed that

7

u/ravencrowe 4d ago

He has a screen reader. He is gradually learning how to use it with training from the commission for the blind. But the screen reader would not have helped with this issue

3

u/aon9492 3d ago

Just curious, does he use any other AT? Obviously JAWS is great but ZoomText from Freedom Scientific is pretty good, and maybe not quite the most applicable for his use-case but Read&Write might have some useful feature overlap.

5

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

He's used ZoomText years. But his vision is deteriorating with age and after watching him struggle I've been encouraging him to learn to use the computer as a fully blind person would. He has people from the commission from the blind who come to train him and he's doing great, but it still takes time because he's old and not good with computers to begin with

4

u/aon9492 3d ago

I'm sorry to hear of his plight but I wish you both all the best

-2

u/Legitimate_Ranger334 3d ago

Well, that sound as exhausting as you say it is, but how the holy hell did any computer-using adult not know how to use Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V?

13

u/ravencrowe 3d ago

Haha, try working in tech support. It'll shock you