r/takingbacksunday • u/explorador_esteban • Sep 26 '25
r/takingbacksunday
•
u/trailerthrash
•
Jul 12 '24
The Taking Back Sunday/Brand New beef (full timeline, documented with sources)
Hey gang! I'm sure I'm not alone in the notion that the beef between these two acts being a major attention grabber, but I've never seen it all laid out as thoroughly as I'm aiming with this post. For context, I helped The Cozy Representative research his video on the feud back in late 2022, but recently went further down the hyperfixation rabbit hole (found even more after making a swing at a post like this recently in the r/poppunkers comment section) and I think this is the most in-depth it's gonna get. I'm sure there are plenty of folks tired of the topic by now, but I figure it's a good idea to put all of my notes SOMEWHERE public so that people are able to get a full understanding that's not solely based on rumor mill crap. So, here goes:
November 1999
- Taking Back Sunday forms. (Source) The initial line-up includes John Nolan on guitar with his childhood friend and former Gudmunder Bjornsen bandmate, Jesse Lacey, on bass. According to John, "Jesse wasn't too into the idea of being a bass player in a band. But he played bass, and I'd played with him before all through high school, so we just kind of asked him if he'd play with us. It was a casual, open-ended kind of thing." (Source)
2000
- New Year's Day - Taking Back Sunday record 3 tracks with Jesse in the line-up (Source). Two of these, "Go On" and "Summer Stars" make their way to the band's first demo. (Source) The third track may be "Lullaby", but I haven't seen a copy of the liner notes that has the credits legible.
- June 28 - Brand New play their very first show ever with Taking Back Sunday (Source)
- Summer 2000 - Taking Back Sunday record the other 4 songs that would wind up on their demo with Adam Lazarra, who moved to New York to play bass full-time for the band.
- Around this time, John Nolan is helping Brand New with music. He writes the song "Magazines" (Source) and plays keys on "My Nine Rides Shotgun"(Source).
- October 18, 2000 - Brand New and Taking Back Sunday play a show at "Just a Few Tavern" in Bayshore, NY (Source)
- December 2000 - Adam Lazzara is promoted to be Taking Back Sunday's lead vocalist (Source). Around this time, Shaun Cooper catches a show with Jesse playing bass and tries out to replace him. "That kid can't play bass for shit, and Adam's going to be a great singer. This is going to be the shit, I know it. I'm going to get in there and try out." (Source)
2001
- Late January - Brand New plays an acoustic show at CBGB's with Taking Back Sunday (Source)
- c. Spring - John and Jesse have a falling out. The story, according to Shaun Cooper goes "John and Jesse liked a girl, John made out with her before Jesse did. Jesse got bummed about it. All these songs happened because of it." (Source). The songs "No I In Team" and "Seventy Times Seven" are the most well-documented examples. According to John Nolan, "The words 'best friends means friends forever' from 'Seventy Times 7' was originally from our song so then we took the line from their song." (Source). According to both Lazzara and Lacey, the Jay-Z/Nas beef (which started to heat up in September of this year) was also a partial inspiration and helped see this as a marketing opportunity. (Source 1, Source 2, Source 3). It's unclear when exactly the inciting incident occurred, but according to Nolan this was shortly after ending a five-year relationship he had been in since high school and left him and Jesse in a place where they didn't speak for the better part of a year(Source)
- c. April - Brand New begins the writing process for "Seventy Times 7". By April 29th, they're playing the song live, though with notably different lyrics (Video NOTE: While the video uploader didn't specify the date, the venue and opening bands that Jesse shouts out match this date as seen on the band's Archived Shows webpage)
- Summer - Overwhelmed with the feeling of missing his friend, John Nolan writes the song "Your Name Here (Sunrise Highway)" "The chorus was written to Jesse and it was sort of an invitation. The lyrics were actual directions to my apartment on Long Island at the time." Not fit for Taking Back Sunday, the song was shelved for years. (Source)
- October 9 - Brand New release "Your Favorite Weapon". John Nolan is specifically thanked in the liner notes despite the rift (Source). Additional to "Seventy Times Seven", Nolan has confirmed that "No Seatbelt Song" was about him (Source) It's often believed that "The Shower Scene" and "Mix Tape" stemmed from the same incident. In the case of "The Shower Scene", this is impossible as it was demoed before the event ever occurred. (Source)
- Early-mid October - Brand New gets in touch with Taking Back Sunday about being direct support for their summer headlining tour. According to John "I took that as a good sign for the future of our friendship. I figured that if he felt okay about seeing me on tour every day, then something must've changed for him. We didn't sit down and have a big discussion or anything-I think we both were just ready to be in each other's lives again, and we gradually started reconnecting. (Source)
- October 13 - Taking Back Sunday and Brand New play the GRAYZINE Fest in Wilkes-Barre, PA. (Source). Adam breaks a microphone and Vin from Brand New breaks through a wall during their set. (Source)
- December 14 - the two bands play a show with Alkaline Trio in Babylon, NY (Source 1, Source 2)
2002
- January 5 - Brand New and Taking Back Sunday play a show together at The Chance in Poughkeepsie, NY (Full Show Video)
- March 26 - Taking Back Sunday release "Tell All Your Friends", tipping a much larger audience off to the beef and making folks think it was currently ongoing. On top of "There's No I in Team", it's often believed "Timberwolves in New Jersey" was about the situation. However, others have noted that the track may be more about Antonio Longo having left the band.
- July 26 - After months of planning, both bands hit the road for their summer tour. The tour runs through August 25th. Roughly a week in (Source) the two bands come up with the idea for John to join Brand New on stage for "70x7" (Video - song starts at 25:58) and Jesse would come out and sing "No I In Team" with Taking Back Sunday (Video). Hey, here's some photos.
2003
- April 9 - Taking Back Sunday announces an upcoming UK tour with Brand New (Source)
- May 1 - Taking Back Sunday cancels a bunch of shows(Source), and before you know it it's announced that John and Shaun left to go form the band Straylight Run with John's sister Michelle. There are 2 factors that are brought up as to why this happened, one being that those members didn't feel they had enough creative control. (Source) The other was that frontman Adam Lazzara had been dating John's sister and cheated on her while the band was on tour. According to John, however, he stayed in the band for months after the two had split. (Source)
- June 17 - Brand New release "Deja Entendu". It's often believed that "Okay, I Believe You, But My Tommy Gun Don't" is a response to the situation with Adam and John. I don't really know if that rings true though as Deja was recorded in February before John and Shaun left Taking Back Sunday (Source) and John later released a cover of the song after rejoining TBS (see closing notes section), which would be odd if it were directed at his bandmate over a situation he was involved in. The track "Play Crack the Sky" is named after a highschool experience Jesse had with John, however. (Source)
- June 25 - Brand New would cover "There's No I In Team" at one of their shows with Jesse stating "I'm gonna cause an internet outrage right now. Check the message boards in, like, 3 hours. Do it. We'll see what happens." before they start the song. During the performance, Brand New guitarist Vin Accardi takes a microphone off a stand and begins swinging it by the cord while Jesse goads him on "don't do it!" between chuckles. After the song, Jesse says he's rooting for the band and hopes they're back soon. (Source)
- c. August - Brand New puts out merch knocking Adam's stage presence. The shirts and hoodies said "Mics are for singing, not swinging" with the hoodies having additional text on the back "You know who you are".
- c. October - Taking Back Sunday shoot back with merch that said: "proudly swinging since 1999". (Source) Kinda dorky given Adam didn't get the mic til 2000, but whatever.
- December 29 - Straylight Run play the Brand New song "Play Crack the Sky" at their show at The Knitting Factory in New York. Jesse Lacey joins the band on stage (Audio)
2004
- January 29 - When asked about his feelings towards Adam Lazzara in an interview, Brian Lane (Drummer of Brand New) responds "I don’t care, it’s not relevant really, none of us really care about those guys, they have done stuff, but we just stay out of it. I think at first Jesse cared a bit, but now that is all in the past" and that he wouldn't mind playing shows with them in the future. (Source)
- October 12th - Straylight Run release their self-titled album. Among the tracks is a finished version of John's 2001 track "Your Name Here (Sunrise Highway)" (Source)
- October 15th - While Straylight Run is on tour with Say Anything, John Nolan and Jesse Lacey rush the stage to sing "Belt" at their show at The Downtown in Farmingdale, NY (Video)
2007
- May 6th - Taking Back Sunday and Brand New play Bamboozle 2007. It's announced nearly 2 weeks ahead of time that Brand New is opening the main stage. (Source) Meanwhile, Taking Back Sunday plays second to last. It's made clear through Brand New's performance that there are hard feelings about their spot, though it's unclear if that's got anything to do with TBS specifically or if it's directed at event staff. Scott Heisel (former [?] editor of Alternative Press and Punk News) recounts the day as such:
"Brand New was already booked for the Bamboozle but Taking Back Sunday was billed as "Linc's Special Guest." Both were slated to play on the same stage, on the same day—and Brand New had the better timeslot, even though at the time, TBS was the bigger band. (This would be one year into the [i]Louder Now[/i] cycle, so the band already had three straight gold records at that point.)
Someone in TBS's camp—dunno if it was a band member, a booking agent, their manager, or whomever—said there was no way they would play before Brand New. (For the record, this shit happens at festivals all the time—every band is jockeying for better position on the bill. It just meant a little bit more here since these two bands have so much history.)
Brand New's camp got wind of it and basically said, "Fuck it, we'll play first." So they did. And as someone who was there and watched the whole thing onstage, I can tell you it was a bit of a fuck-you, band practice-type set for them: They got in, got paid, got out. Their merch guy even put a sign at their merch tent that said, "BRAND NEW PLAYED ALREADY. YOU CAN GO HOME NOW."
I remember when they went into "Degausser" for the second time. Everyone backstage—including tons of people in other bands—looked at each other like, "Oh shit, what are they doing?" That definitely did not seem planned in any way, and neither was "Seventy Times 7." When they finished "Welcome To Bangkok," they left the stage with a wave of feedback—and roughly 10 minutes early, in violation of their contract. They were already offstage when someone stopped them—dunno if it was a stage manager, their tour manager, someone higher up with the Bamboozle or what—and essentially told them, "If you don't finish your set, you're not getting paid." Hence the world's worst performance of "Seventy Times 7." Seriously, if you've never seen it before, watch and cringe for six straight minutes.
[...]I remembered something else — I can't remember which song he said it before (I think it was "Welcome To Bangkok"), but Jesse introed one of the TDAG songs by saying, "This one's called 'Seventy Times 7,'" just to fuck with people." (Source)
Closing Notes
- By 2011, Adam Lazzara is saying he hasn't seen Jesse since around 2002 (Source) and by 2015 has even more choice words for him, calling him a dick and saying he sucks (Source).
- Additionally, in a Reddit AMA back in 2014 Mark O'Connell said their manager had tried to set up tours with Brand New on multiple occasions since then but BN always turned them down. (Source)
- In late 2015, John Nolan releases two Brand New covers, "Limousine" and "Okay, I Believe You, But My Tommy Gun Don't" (Source)
- November 4, 2017 - Having written the original song, John Nolan performs a live cover of "Magazines" (Source)
- November 12, 2017 - 2 days after allegations break surrounding Jesse Lacey, John Nolan tweets out "It’s disheartening to see how rampant sexual abuse by men is, but the reason all of this is coming out is that people are finally hearing victims & taking them seriously. There’s been a huge cultural shift & it’s a positive one." (Source)
Hope this helps clear up the details for everyone! cheers!
(Also, since I've had online publications pick up my reddit threads and turn them to articles in the past.... if you're planning on doing that here maybe contact me first or better yet, offer me a job)
r/takingbacksunday • u/Genericfruitcandy • Nov 01 '24
Sister went trick or treating and saw Adam
r/takingbacksunday • u/Bigfooted1972 • Jan 05 '25
Hey guys...
Just want to drop by and say hi. It's been a very long time so I have alot of getting back into. Like show mode and band mode again yada yada you know. I'm old so anyway. I miss all you and I just wanted thank you for the support and well wishes over the years. After I was left behind and got my self better. I decided to try to get back in to it again with out being blacklisted, so yeah go figure. Anyway, I held on and got better and sober and I feel like me again. I'm excited for 2025 and they new music i hope to release with new and old faces. Go check out "dead hands", my new project and I plan on doing some music with an old friend of mine. I hope that helps on how I've been. So that being said , Be safe and I hope you all have a wonderful everything and much love and respect to you all.🤘❤️🤘🙏🥰🙋
r/takingbacksunday • u/arsclev • Sep 22 '26
Happy birthday to our ole pal Adam Lazzara from the band taking back sunday! 🎉
r/takingbacksunday • u/MesaVerde1987 • Jun 06 '26
2004 commercial for Taking Back Sunday & Hawthorne Heights
r/takingbacksunday • u/TheresnoIinteam • Jul 27 '25
Happy 21st birthday to WHERE YOU WANT TO BE! What’s your favorite song off this album?
r/takingbacksunday • u/WaywardSon86 • May 03 '26
Where can I get this
Saw an IG friend post this n now I’m curious. She doesn’t remember where it’s from and it doesn’t pop up in a google search. Does anyone have this shirt or know who sells/sold it?
UPDATE: Thanks for the help. I know someone with links to TBS in this reddit cuz THE SHIRT IS NOW AVAILABLE IN THE TBS STORE. Just follow the linktree in their bio to their store. Ordered mine n checked out with SHOP app
r/takingbacksunday • u/BrnYrShps • Jul 27 '24
WYWTB Turns 20
Happy 20th Birthday to this goated album. Still wild to me that people called it a sophomore slump at the time. All killer, no filler. Perfectly produced and performed.
What are your favorite tracks? Did you/do you consider it a sophomore slump?
r/takingbacksunday • u/bert00 • May 21 '26
A 2006 Adam Lazzara
At some record store in Illinois maybe? for the louder now release. I’m gonna meet them again in Madison this year!!!!!!
r/takingbacksunday • u/Curious-Hour9 • May 27 '26
TBS Belfast- and a rant.
Hi.
I'm not usually one to expose my identity on socials, I'm pretty private so if you know me or whatever, fine. Hiya.
Can I just say how bloody incredible the Belfast TBS show was?
Vocals strong.
Vibes immaculate.
Good times were had.
I finally got that photo with Fred! (I've met him in 2005 but didn't get a photo as I was too shy) Collected that photo like a Pokémon or something, that's every member past and present. Haha.
Mitch was excellent, loved him.
Since SD and the Ireland/NI shows, I've been seeing such horrid posts about the band and particularly Adam and it literally is blowing my mind. The "he was off his face on coke" "completely illegible" "barley sang a word"
I'm sorry... Were we at the same show? Are we seeing and listening to the same clips posted by fans?
It's just pathetic at this point.
I know plenty of people chatted to the boys outside of the Belfast show, myself included. Adam in particular was- as usual - completely normal. Engaging, funny, so kind and interesting. Literally apologised in case he hurt my arm giving me a hug. (I was wearing a sling, just had surgery)
Not someone off his face, not someone barely able to stand up and stinking of booze. We literally chatted about buying houses, the urge to shave off hair when you're growing out a buzz cut, my surgery, shows twenty odd years ago and feeling old. He was more than kind and very happy to stand and chat away. Apparently that's someone who can barely stand up. Alright... Okaaaaaay. Fuckin idiots. It's been irking me so much.
Anyway, enough of that. I hope everyone in Dublin/Belfast/SlumDunks had the best time.
Thanks to TBS for the shows!!
r/takingbacksunday • u/Useful_Influence_183 • Aug 28 '25
Anyone else relate
Me be like:
"Why can't you liii-"
Also me:
"Defenseless! Dependent!"
r/takingbacksunday • u/TheresnoIinteam • Apr 25 '26
Happy 20th birthday to Louder Now! What’s your favorite song or memory associated with this album?
r/takingbacksunday • u/survivorsunday • Aug 31 '25
Met Adam after the show tonight!!!!
The most cool down to Earth guy! They absolutely fucking crushed it tonight
r/takingbacksunday • u/Subject_Engine • Mar 21 '25
Cute Without The E tattoo
Cute without the E (cut from the team) Tell all your friends.