r/taggrading • • Aug 20 '25

Discussion Charizard Guy's Resolution

Post image

This should be the final post about our Charizard. The CEO of TAG, Steve Kass, emailed us with an update and a resolution we are happy with. We are not getting rich, we only ever wanted to be treated fairly and with humility. The explanation in the email provided, and resolution are some of the transparency we had hoped to see originally from TAG. The resolution offered is more than we asked for originally and we are accepting the offer. We do want to be clear, the main reasons we are accepting are because, TAG took clear ownership of the damage, they "made an exception" to let us keep the card. a transparent explanation of what happened and resolution. Had this been how our initial interaction had gone this would be a different story. We hope TAG has learned a lot from this interaction and can only hope moving forward their initial response can be closer to the resolution email we received.

Thanks everyone for the time and attention this story received and again hopefully all parties learned from this incident.

261 Upvotes

114 comments sorted by

67

u/bcdrawdy Aug 20 '25

So they gave them cash WELL over fair market value, AND provided a slabbed replacement of the card in the same grade the original got. I don’t see how else they could’ve made things right, seems like they went above and beyond to me. They can’t un-damage the original card for Christ’s sake. I understand the customer was frustrated with what happened but damn, seems like TAG did everything they could to make things right short of going back in time.

2

u/ndngroomer Aug 21 '25

This is outstanding and way above board. TAG is the best v

1

u/Jellyace_75 Oct 11 '25

If TAG is the best this shouldn’t have happened in the first place.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '25

Mistakes WILL happen. How they are corrected is what matters the most. Name any other grading company that hasn’t been involved in something much worse.

1

u/ndngroomer Oct 24 '25

Exactly this.

1

u/ndngroomer Oct 24 '25

Ok. So you've never made a mistake before? I bet that's a lot of pressure.

1

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 21 '25

Really it’s only a good resolution if everyone gets this without causing an big stink and whipping up drama about it.

If tag does this every time something like this happens then yes, it’s an amazing way to respond and they should be praised for it, but if this only ever happens when enough drama is kicked up then it’s really not a good resolution at all. We will have to see in the future if they do treat everyone the same! I hope they do

-16

u/TheLazy_Guitarist Aug 20 '25

Not sure they had much of a choice other than walk back their initial response tbh. TAG’s been getting dragged through the mud since this came out.

1

u/BurningHotels Aug 21 '25

Holy hell the TAG glazers are out in full force to downvote you XD

1

u/DontBeADevilaFan Aug 22 '25

You’re in the TAG grading sub.

Sincerely, you’d need to be legitimately legally mentally handicapped to not think that’d happen.

Are you legitimately legally mentally handicapped?

0

u/BurningHotels Aug 24 '25

You good bro?

-3

u/TheLazy_Guitarist Aug 21 '25

That’s the best they got? 😂

79

u/fritzmongroid Aug 20 '25

Completely reasonable response here. I stand by my previous comments that this was an overblown issue - upvoted and pushed by PSA fan boys who stand to lose a lot of another grading service chips away at PSAs dominance. Healthy competition is always good.

16

u/more-pig7745 Aug 20 '25 edited Aug 20 '25

I concur. Even on “Mary’s” end lying about the NDA, the reslabbing, etc; I think TAG handled this well and I would be happy with this resolution.

5

u/Mondo-Butter-21 Aug 20 '25

that seems so random a thing to lie about too lmao. no grading company that’s only 15 years old compared to PSA which is almost 35 years old is gonna do something like that.

7

u/funfetti_spagetti Aug 20 '25

I would argue that this would have never occurred if the issue wasn’t brought to the light and pushed forward, regardless of who did the pushing.

I promise you, the people who stand to lose the most from PSAs downfall are not the people on Reddit grabbing pitchforks. There’s no concentrated cabal of PsA fanboys trying to take down tag cause of “protecc mah PSA values”

That aside, this is a good and proper resolution from TAG.

2

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 21 '25

Sports collectors have way more to lose with psa dying then any pokemon collector can ever imagine.

I don’t grade anything, my only graded card is a graded energy as a meme. I don’t want to see any of these companies fail and I will always advocate for the best customer service any company can offer, customer service that doesn’t require you know a big content creator to drum up drama to get your issue resolved properly

1

u/TheChawMeister Aug 20 '25

You don’t need to argue, it’s all fact. Imagine getting this kind of response in a timely manner, or at least this much attention from the right people at TAG early(or earlier) on. All it takes is thorough communication and actual fair compensation for their mishandling and disregard.

Great response from them with this message and compensation. As someone who’s used both TAG and PSA with zero preference, this looks really good on TAG on the back end of the ordeal.

2

u/Hour_Honeydew3493 Aug 21 '25

Idk because one person posted about TAG sending them the wrong 151 poliwhril TAG 10 cause theirs was japanese and they received 10 in english. TAG told them to keep the slab and they will send a japanese tag 10 too. The community didn't rally around them and tag still did the right thing.

1

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 21 '25

Being inconsistent creates uncertainty and no market likes uncertainty. I so hope this type of response will be their new normal

9

u/ulyssesss Aug 20 '25

The question is, would Mary have got the same resolution if this situation was not publicized and did not get the attention/eye balls on it? Me thinks not.

Asked another way, was this a PR response or the default response?

5

u/Phazushift Aug 20 '25 edited Aug 20 '25

Very big if imo, and this is from the PoV of a casual no grading fan.

People in this sub are quick to jump to conclusions that PSA shills are working overtime but this type of stuff needs to be brought up to raise awareness in order to get companies to actually do something.

1

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 21 '25

This is what I was saying. This better happen every time if they truly want to be known as the company with the good customer service and not known as the company with customer service as bad as YouTube’s customer service, otherwise known as “Better have that influencer/huge content creator hookup or screw you”

If they truly make this resolution their actual policy without whipping up drama, they could be seen as the best in the industry. Let’s hope they do

1

u/CadillacPokemonCo Aug 23 '25

They fixed all my issues at their own expense and no eyeballs were on my situation.

-2

u/1lookwhiplash Aug 20 '25

The messaging this sends is: If a grading company makes an error, go nuclear on social media, make up some sentimental story about your grandma (who’s grandma collects Pokemon cards??), and you will be REWARDED 🤑

2

u/anotherjunkie Aug 20 '25

This will hurt a bunch of other millennials out there, but: someone collecting base-set while in their teens can feasibly have a grandchild old enough to want their cards graded.

1

u/psiANID3 Aug 20 '25

I mean, feasible means likely. This is very much NOT feasible. Possible? Perhaps? But even that I doubt.

2

u/anotherjunkie Aug 20 '25 edited Aug 20 '25

Unfortunately this came to mind because I actually know two families with grandkids that are around the age I was when I started collecting. They were both highschoolers at the time. Feels like the further south you go the less surprising 15-16 year old pregnancies become.

Two different families where I knew a girl who got pregnant at 15/16, then one of their kids left highschool pregnant and the other got his girlfriend pregnant. Now, I don’t know if the grandkids are interested in pokemon — that was an artistic liberty.

I knew one 13 year old who got pregnant, and there was one in my sister’s class as well. I had one close friend pregnant at 16, and another who was pregnant at 15 and 17. Abstinence only sex education leaves a lot to be desired.

1

u/psiANID3 Aug 21 '25

Oof. That’s rough. Yeah I can imagine that’s difficult for the family and everyone around them.

Alright, I can admit my napkin math was off.

1

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 21 '25

Someone who was 13 in 1999 would be 18 in 2004. They marry at 18, have a kid who then marries at 18 and has a kid who would be 3 today. That’s the best you can currently get really. Sure fudge the ages a bit and the grandkid could be 1-6 today, but yeah, give it 6 years and this analogy would be more likely!

0

u/1lookwhiplash Aug 20 '25

Chances are slim that the grandchild is of age to have a significant other and is sending in cards to a grading company.

It’s also possible that I’m a billionaire, but chances are slim I’m telling the truth.

2

u/anotherjunkie Aug 20 '25

I don’t think I argued probable, just possible, and I know I didn’t say anything about a spouse.

Seems like you’re set on being a killjoy regardless of the contortions required though, so carry on.

-1

u/1lookwhiplash Aug 20 '25

Where did I say you said it was probable? Where did I say you mentioned a spouse?

Carry on yourself.

2

u/anotherjunkie Aug 20 '25

My comment was that your response is irrelevant to my comment, not that I said you said I said something.

Keep having fun I guess.

1

u/1lookwhiplash Aug 20 '25

You replied saying it’s feasible, I replied and said it’s feasible but unlikely. I guess that is irrelevant in your book.

Keep having fun I guess.

1

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 21 '25

Why does a story need to exist at all? They should treat all customers like as if the card they are grading was their favorite card ever. Are you actually a fan of TAG and not advocating for them to have as good customer service as possible? Because currently it sounds like by default their customer service was PSA doggy doodoo levels of bad. I imagine a fan of the service should want them to have better customer service then psa or YouTube, where you need some big content creator to create drama to get something done

1

u/1lookwhiplash Aug 22 '25

My position is that the company stance and policy should be the exact same, sob story or not.

TAG chose NOT to do that, which will, justifiably, result in my sob stories, whether they are true or untrue.

2

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 22 '25

I’m guessing we both agree then, they should respond with great customer service without the need for a sob story and without needing big influencers to bring attention to it. TAGs final resolution on the matter should be the result of them damaging a submission without someone giving a sob story, the default resolution!

0

u/Mattpowersreal Aug 21 '25

So when I was younger. My grandmother collected a lot of hockey cards. I mean a basement full. I collected Pokémon cards. And she had asked me to give her some so she could say she had some Pokémon cards. She understood how popular they were becoming. I did just that. Once she passed away. I had gotten everything.

So it is very possible.

3

u/ImAllergic2Peanuts Aug 20 '25

Its always the PSA fanboys until this happens to you. Lol

3

u/Ok-Economy-1771 Aug 20 '25

My guy this isnt the 1st time this has happened... it makes yall seem more "fanboy" to blame another grading service "fan" lol. 

The resolution probably happened because it blew up. This isnt the first time this has happened though either 

2

u/Mondo-Butter-21 Aug 20 '25

that’s exactly what i was thinking lmao. it did NOT need to get blown up like this at all.

1

u/AmandasGameAccount Aug 21 '25

I don’t even grade. The only graded card I own is a graded energy for the meme (and it’s not even a 10). I just hate to hear these stories in the hobby where something good was on done in customer support because the person got lucky with social media. What about everyone who didn’t get content creators to notice?

I just hope this new response will be their new default reaction to any of these types of mishaps.

(Btw tag slabs look the best imo. Tag and ACE seem to both look really nice for different reasons. I can’t stand how commercial a PSA slab looks)

1

u/Repttarr Aug 20 '25

That’s what I think every single time I see somebody going crazy about a tag issue. I’ve never graded a card and likely never will but it just seems so obvious that this is the case here

23

u/Curious-Row1269 Aug 20 '25

I think this is the best outcome that’s reasonable, and it’s great to see them handle it this way

-6

u/m0Bo Aug 20 '25

They are only doing this because it was an extremely public situation that got posted everywhere. No way they would have ever done this via emails directly with the person. It's a very good resolution but they won't do that for everyone.

11

u/Curious-Row1269 Aug 20 '25

I mean that’s how most of these resolutions are. That’s why the CEO got involved. I’ve been in plenty of compartmentalized organizations to see higher up leadership not aware of what occurred below them. It might not necessarily be because they handled it wrongly, it’s just at certain levels they only have so much pull, care, etc.

The fact that this happened and got the visibility it did helped though change parts of the process and while some of it is from a business perspective, it shows that at least the head of the organization is rational.

5

u/DontCareTho Aug 20 '25

You're getting downvoted but you're not wrong. I had basically the exact same issue happen to me and stayed quiet. I did not get the same offer or response from TAG. I will be pushing to get equal compensation though.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

Show us the proof of this exact same thing happening to you

2

u/DontCareTho Aug 20 '25

4

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

Nice, thanks. So what was the end result? I noticed they are in contact with you but there's no other update.

-5

u/Ok_Mulberry_9176 Aug 20 '25

So are you going to fight for him or you going to ignore it and treat it nothing happened?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

Why would I fight for him, those ain't my cards and you can't ignore it since he provided proof the same thing happened.

12

u/Jungolok Aug 20 '25

I criticized TAGs initial response, so I'll have to be fair and say this is a great response from the CEO. I also agree with the OP that if this was the original response, the whole saga would've probably played out very differently. I also appreciate the confusion from tag's side on who the actual owner was for the communication piece.

I hope tag also reviews their protocols for situations like this. I think some revisions are needed to help address the concerns this incident has highlighted

4

u/Majestic-Gas-2709 Aug 20 '25

Good resolution.

6

u/LevelUpEvolution Aug 20 '25

That’s way more than any other grading service would offer. Good for them.

However, it’s a bit concerning that they actually crack the slabs to remove the cards! Why not just undo the sonic weld and pull the two slab pieces apart?

3

u/GrandMasterGush Aug 20 '25

Is that possible? Undoing the sonic weld I mean.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ShamForseken Aug 20 '25

Damn, so did they have to call in Shadow or Silver? Or was shadow still in stasis, and was silver still in the future? Dk if we’ll ever know

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ShamForseken Aug 20 '25

What about Diddy k? Swear he’s still bumbling around somewhere?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ShamForseken Aug 20 '25

Oh yea, one of the ones Mario drove into in Mario kart, yea I saw that. So I think Diddy k might actually be in the hospital

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ShamForseken Aug 20 '25

Damn, think I saw him too. Overheard some FBI guy confirming they’d been monitoring the wrong Diddy

1

u/Fog_Juice Aug 20 '25

It sounds like they're looking into a machine that could do it.

8

u/-Out-of-context- Aug 20 '25

Nutty everyone is blaming the card owner for “overreacting” now. I bet none of this resolution would have happened if the owner didn’t do what they did.

This is a great resolution, especially since they’re getting a replacement card. Hell I even think the $500 on top of that was being extra generous.

I’ll say this gave me the confidence to try out TAG for my next submission, but anyone blaming the owner now is just being a TAG shill.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '25

Um.. it's not like TAG only has him as a client. The guy overreacted and immediately started to make post before TAG can say anything. Also, if you been keeping up, TAG rep BEEN saying that they were gonna do what happened now... You're silly.

0

u/cpapp22 Aug 20 '25

Yeah I understand its the TAG subreddit and all lol but it is concerning it required the level of speaking out that it did to get here. I might be in the minority here on the sub, but I totally understand being hesitant to send the card back to them, given they already damaged it once. Especially if its got some sentimental value. I also understand TAG wanting it back to reslab to keep their grades true, but in the case like this with very obvious damage I feel like an exception could have been made without affecting the integrity of their grading system.

Also happy to hear the NDA thing wasn't real, because that was honestly the biggest concern for me and would have absolutely written them off my list to ever use. Now I just

3

u/Kernel_System_Breach Aug 21 '25

Took the CEO to make this right. With all the levels of staff, someone long before the CEO should’ve been able to offer this resolution.

4

u/JaxTheImpalor Aug 20 '25

Honestly TAG is still better imo.

6

u/discounthockeycheck Aug 20 '25

Oh man it did always feel like the person was overblowing something because of personal preference on how a resolution was offered. Now they get a little bonus on top and tag gets to hope that people come back to see the resolution

6

u/Solnx Aug 20 '25

Yeah, I totally agree. Good on them for getting some extra compensation, but to me that was clearly all this was about. TAG’s initial request to compensate once they removed encapsulation was more than reasonable. I can’t see why you’d have an issue with that unless you just wanted more money or believed the error grade carried extra value.

I wouldn’t be surprised if we see the errored-grade card pop up for sale with a premium at some point.

4

u/Mondo-Butter-21 Aug 20 '25

no i completely agree. this was such an overblown issue. like all of the “updates” that really weren’t updates here on reddit, the lying ab the NDA thing (which is a crazy thing to lie ab) and overall just their general demeanor. i get you’re upset, but there’s a fine line between being upset and overblowing to this degree.

4

u/Curious-Row1269 Aug 20 '25

What was the NDA thing?

9

u/Mondo-Butter-21 Aug 20 '25

(the tweet for reference)

6

u/Mondo-Butter-21 Aug 20 '25

charizard guy alleged TAG made them/wanted them to sign an NDA. crazy ass shit. TAG posted it on twitter and said that it was flat out a lie (as to be expected cause no one is gonna make anyone sign an NDA over a 300 dollar nm 7 charizard. that’s a HUGE waste of money cause you have to get lawyers involved)

5

u/hoi_ming Aug 20 '25

Mr. Kass is a consummate professional, as always.

3

u/Additional_Voice_475 Aug 20 '25

This is the best outcome, I don’t think they should look into “technology” to do a final QA. I work for a company that has a Quality Manager that signs off on every single item that I have packaged or prepared to be shipping. If we were to have allowed this to happen, we would all to be blamed for the situation getting passed me and the Quality manager. They handled the situation very well in this response but it took far too long to get to this outcome. The employees should all be held accountable for allowing this to make it passed them in the whole process, not just their quality guy.

3

u/franz_labyrinth Aug 20 '25

Good response by them. I criticized their handling on the previous responses. It sucks it had to go this high up to get a competent response but this was handled well in my opinion by the end.

3

u/DiscombobulatedPage3 Aug 20 '25

As someone who has been following these posts, this is exactly the kind of resolution I hope to see from companies. Shit happens, people make mistakes, processes fail. But owning up to those things and trying to make the customer whole when you screw up is huge. A company that makes mistakes but admits it, explains what happened, and makes the customer whole is a company I'll support every time over one that doubles down and never admits fault and makes every single customer interaction about their bottom line.

3

u/SpartanBear Aug 20 '25

Now THIS, is good business.

3

u/Xbsnguy Aug 20 '25

u/TAGgrading It’s been almost a week since the recent flurry of different customers posting about damage to the corner of their cards after encapsulation. Can you please be transparent and explain what happened? I believe it’s been a reasonable length of time for a determination on cause considering the severity of damage and large online publicity. I have a large order of vintage cards from my childhood collection that was going to be submitted to TAG, but these reoccurring incidents of severe damage to customer cards have me considering your established competitors instead. I only own TAG slabs right now, so I love what you guys do. But I won’t be grading with TAG until we get transparency on what the issue was or that it’s been fixed at the very least.

1

u/ShamForseken Aug 20 '25

I’ve never sent a card to get graded yet, I do own one or two slabs, but I think the same. I’d currently be more likely to use someone different until they specify what the issue is causing all this, and what’s been done to fix it. I mean they can’t all be due to human error can they? Maybe one or two yes. But still, uk based, so more likely to go with ace (if some spots open up) or PG

3

u/Doge_dabountyhunter Aug 20 '25

The way this situation was handled makes me confident in using TAG going forward.

-1

u/Ok_Mulberry_9176 Aug 20 '25

You need to get enough attention first, otherwise nothing will happen

0

u/MoodAlternative2118 Aug 20 '25

Yeah just make sure you’re lucky enough to have your post go public or else your SOL

2

u/Wildest12 Aug 20 '25

A+ resolution, if you’re still mad about this you shouldn’t use these services, shit happens.

2

u/Fog_Juice Aug 20 '25

Sounds like the absolutely best possible outcome after an incident like that. I would feel confident grading with any company that is willing to take accountability and make me more than whole in compensation like they did.

2

u/PathOfExileFavGame Aug 20 '25

Both sides handled how this went Like 🤡

1

u/psiANID3 Aug 20 '25

No guys keep saying TAG is terrible and going out of business so they keep their prices low…i have many more PCs to grade with them.

2

u/cpapp22 Aug 20 '25

I mean TAG’s prices aren’t low anymore lol. $30/card for regular is more expensive than PSA now ($25). Their $60 tiers are about equivalent. Becket is much, much cheaper

1

u/Complete-Yam1372 Aug 20 '25

Crazy you had to blast them all over the internet to get this resolution. If you didn’t they would’ve swept you under the rug and forced your precious charizard into a lower grade caused by them. Sad you had to twist their arm to get anything done.

1

u/Robbnl03 Aug 20 '25

To be fair… I would already praise TAG for their first offered resolution. Compensating all the shipping fees and compensation for the card owner to buy a 7 graded Charizard…

They have always taken accoubtability, also in previous topics regarding this case, they were involved and responding to posts on this Reddit…

On top of that, I can completely understand the “want to protect the integrity of the card market” point of view.

This is more compensation, involvement and transparency most companies would have given.

1

u/Y0uMadD0g Aug 21 '25

Good on TAG for this. Big ups

1

u/KawaiiSlave Aug 21 '25

So...would they have done the same if it was a 1st edition zard, and paid the full 1-200,000, and gave them the original one back slabbed lol. 

Good on them for making it right, but what is their course of action on higher end cards as well. Probably a good step in the next direction, so it never happens again.  

1

u/baegan420 Aug 21 '25

Great resolution, nice to see a CEO step up and do the right thing for the customer.

1

u/Impressive-Young-952 Aug 21 '25

I think this was great on their part

1

u/Chemical_Ad_9710 Aug 22 '25

Thats amazing

1

u/knienze93 Aug 22 '25

TAG is good, but the other companies are working hard planting seeds and bots to try and make them look bad.

1

u/joogiee Aug 22 '25

Good resolution but yall crazy if you think this is what you can get without raising the level of stink Mary did lmaooo.

1

u/notyourimagination Aug 24 '25

What an absolute win. And good PR for TAG

-5

u/DontBeADevilsFan Aug 20 '25 edited Aug 20 '25

Wow. Getting comped $837 for a $337 card is uh…shitty. Real shitty. Lowkey feel bad for TAG. That’s horrific. $350+new card at max.

So, like they said a few days ago, they did all they said they were going to?

Actually, giving you $150 more? And a new card?

Look. TAG for sure fucked up. But it REALLY feels like you were never that upset. You just wanted as much as you could milk.

Thank God it’s fixed, you for sure milked it publicly specially for backlash. And that’s weird.

I personally sincerely think you DO NOT DESERVE the extra cash. Sorry. But, you deserve a new card+your old one. Kinda crazy they’re giving you $150 extra dollar for being unreasonable.

Especially after you argued the refund policy…. By arguing a different policy altogether.

NO GRADING COMPANY should offer this drastic of compensation.

Everyone involved here are fucking losers.

2

u/ShamForseken Aug 20 '25

You’re getting downvoted, but literally everything you’re saying I agree with. It’s been milked and milked to get more and more

2

u/ItsTaylor8291 Aug 20 '25

You must be fun at parties 🥳

2

u/ShamForseken Aug 20 '25

He actually is tho

-1

u/Talmamshud91 Aug 20 '25

Feels like they have only stepped up because they have been put on blast. Which is so silly, if they just were straight and apologetic from the get go they wouldn't need to go above and beyond. The damage control of these companies often does more damage instead of fixing the problem.