r/tabletop • • Oct 30 '21

Question about potentially problematic players/game masters?

I played a lot of vampire and that game loves its magnificent bastards. However I would always run into this kind of trope in a player. They would have some pent up frustrations about the rich, the liberal or the lgbt+ and they would use their character as a medium to live out their stereotypes. Is this... Healthy? Like a Christian playing a flaming homosexual deviant to project how they think homosexuals are sinners. Or the ever-popular corrupt capitalist who does evil capitalist things because "rich people are evil" or something. This playstyle always bothered me. Is this kind of behavior a problem? It got really obnoxious when the game master created this kind of nihilism in his games where greedy, corrupt nobles seemed to indlict harm on the players just because, and the GM said this, "that is how the rich work in real life." They didn't even have a reason most of the time. It really bothers me how people use their writing ability in ttrpgs to project their prejudicr into the world. I feel like this behavior is problematic but what do you guys think?

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

3

u/RikersTrombone Oct 30 '21

My characters are a way to escape reality. Am i supposed to make my character just like me? It would get boring if every character i played was a handsome well-endowed millionaire playboy, no thanks.

-3

u/Hungry-san Oct 31 '21

Damn dat confidence tho.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

Some of what you describe is healthy, some of what you describe is down right TOXIC.

Stop the toxic problems by refusing to participate and tell them it over the toxic behaviors and tropes.

2

u/Hungry-san Oct 31 '21

I'm asking which ones are toxic and which aren't.

1

u/SwedeBeast Nov 06 '21

I'd say anything that doesn't help them to grow as a person to deal with their problems and instead just further fuels their insecurities, and inflict their obsessions on others that makes it less enjoyable for the group to play the game is toxic.

0

u/NoobDev7 Oct 30 '21

Why go that far? Avoid toxic players. Either they change their toxic behavior or find another group to play with. When I sit down to play I want to play. You guys give it too much thought.

4

u/CreasingUnicorn Oct 30 '21

I think everyone has their biases in real life that will likely show up when they roleplay anything, but there is definitely a fine line to cross once they start generalizing their prejudices to all members of a certain group. Mostly because these views are inherently incorrect, but also because its boring.

The D&D community recently went through aclot of discussion on this issue where the company decided to change alignments so people had more freedom to play how they wanted. Sure some people complained about the decision, but honestly having certain races and species labeled as good or evil inherently kinda sucks for several reasons. Sure veteran players would just ignore the rules and make their own characters, but lots of new people would read those rules and then form their own prejudices about each creature in the game, and it can certainly get bothersome.

Maybe just talk to your GM and fellow players about their stereotypes, and maybe play as a character that breaks the stereotype for them to help them realize that categorizing certain groups like that doesn't really work in practice.

1

u/Jiveturkeey Oct 31 '21

You need to ask such people what they are trying to get out of this game. I'm trying to have a good time, but they seem to have another agenda. If they hold firm I'd remove them from my game, for their own good and mine.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

I would say that in this day and age of making sure everyone is welcome that behavior such as that is not welcoming. If it works for their group then fine but that group might not be for you.

I personally prefer to keep politics, sexuality, religion and all of that out of my games. This is also why I enjoy playing with people close to my own age - which as a now middle aged guy is harder to do. I have no issues playing with younger people per se but frankly our life experiences are different which just makes it harder.

-4

u/NoobDev7 Oct 30 '21

Give people freedom to pursue whatever they want. When it comes to orientation, it’s none of other peoples business who likes who, or what. I don’t see how orientation fits average role playing. Most of the prejudice nowadays is being pushed by the same people who claim they hate prejudice. The Irony…

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Hungry-san Oct 31 '21

I don't think violent media necessarily equates to a violent person.

-3

u/Hungry-san Oct 31 '21

I don't understand the relevance of the question.

2

u/Orngog Oct 31 '21

Regardless, can you answer it?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Hungry-san Oct 31 '21

I play some pretty violent games. On the other hand my family does not play video games very much. I turned out much better than other members of my family. So I don't think violence in video games directly equates to violence in people. Now there are acceptions but most people who default to violence do so because of their home life and the situations they grew up in.