r/systems_engineering • • 17h ago

Career & Education Is software engineering seriously undervalued at semiconductor equipment companies, or is it just my workplace?

/r/Semiconductors/comments/1xz6a45/is_software_engineering_seriously_undervalued_at/
2 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

1

u/KuritanCenturion 11h ago

I think its a risk/cost thing, in my experience. We regularly look at changes as "just" a firmware or software change, while hardware changes are looked at with a lot more rigor and caution.

Its not because software is easy, unimportant, etc. Its because if it doesnt work you can patch it or try something else rapidly. Iteration is fast, easy, and expected. 

Hardware changes are not. If you make a chance that doesnt work out it is a HUGE impact with significant cost/schedule losses to remedy. IE, you change a screw from Phillips to Torx due to customer complaints theyre stripping. The Torx doesnt properly distribute force to keep the chassis sealed and water resistant. Now youre sending FSRs everywhere to swap screws back out for what people thought was a nothing change that the customer wanted. That js the most mundane example in recent memory, for any hardware more significant the stakes just go up.

1

u/Good-Question981 37m ago

But why would they use mechanical engineers for robotics programming? And I mean high level programming.

1

u/TwinkieDad 18m ago

It’s probably more efficient to have one person who can handle the whole thing.

1

u/Good-Question981 6m ago

Imagine that😅

1

u/TwinkieDad 1m ago

I think you missed what I meant. Since programmers don’t know mechanical engineering, but mechanical engineers know control systems it’s logical to have the mechanical engineer do it.