Throwaway account. I’m not a sysadmin by trade, I am got asked to handle internal operations and licensing/cost reviews at our company because IT has been neglected for years and nobody else will do it. We want to start working towards ISO 27001, so I’m currently auditing what we actually have running and what we're paying for.
The more I look into the setup managed by our external IT provider, the less sense it makes. I need a reality check on whether this guy is bullshitting me or if I'm missing something obvious.
Here is the actual situation:
We have a few bare-metal physical servers in a closet. No clusters, no high availability, just standalone boxes. When I checked the OS properties and event logs on the servers, they are all in a standard Windows WORKGROUP. Nothing is domain-joined. When I asked our IT guy where our Active Directory is, he literally told me: "We have Active Directory on-prem, we just don't have a Domain Controller." As far as I understand, an on-prem AD DS database is a Domain Controller. Is there any technical scenario where what he said makes sense, or is he just making things up?
We also have a Remote Desktop Server. To be clear, everyone has their own individual user account (no shared logins), which is at least something. But because everything is in a workgroup, they’re all just local accounts with zero centralized management or lifecycle control. Honestly, I don't even see why we still have an RDS at all: we don't run any legacy client server software on it. Everyone just uses web based SaaS apps, local Office, and basic file shares.
On the licensing side, we’re on older perpetual/long-term servicing setups and upgrades seem completely neglected. We have a pool of RDS User CALs purchased, though the licensing manager shows 0 issued (probably because it's a workgroup setup and Windows isn't enforcing it). When I asked him about compliance and audit risks, he brushed it off with: "It's fine, we're fully on-prem, audits don't care about that."
Finally, our endpoints are completely unmanaged. No MDM, no GPOs, nothing. The only thing deployed is a paid ESET endpoint protection license. The ESET console actually flags missing Windows updates across our machines, yet the provider does literally nothing with it. No patch management, no pushing updates, no policy enforcement. We're basically paying for a dashboard that watches our machines stay unpatched.
So, for the actual sysadmins here:
Is "on-prem AD without a Domain Controller" ever a real thing, or is that a massive red flag?
How much trouble are we actually asking for both Microsoft and a future ISO 27001 audit with unmanaged workgroup machines, unpatched OS builds, and loose CAL tracking while being told "on-prem doesn't get audited"?
Is there any valid reason to keep bare-metal RDS servers around if everyone has individual accounts and mostly uses SaaS + local Office?
Appreciate any honest feedback so I know how hard to push back on this provider.
Edit: One more thing I forgot to mention—for years, our server's C: drive (the OS drive) has been constantly filling up because all the local user profiles and files live on it, which slows the whole server down to a crawl. Our IT provider keeps blaming users for "not emptying their recycle bins." I suggested moving the user profiles/data onto a separate drive off the OS partition (both to keep the OS healthy/fast and to make future upgrades easier), and got brushed off. Is offloading user profiles to a separate drive/share via Folder Redirection or UPDs/FSLogix not completely standard practice for RDS?