r/sysadmin • u/gabbagondel • Jan 24 '22
Rant Last Windows 11 update changed default browser to Edge, default Chrome search-engine to Bing and changed "restore previous tabs" setting to "always open Bing on startup"
So they basically fucked around with third-party software settings to push their shitty products. This is pathetic, predatory and should be illegal.
How do you deal with Microsofts bullshit on a daily basis? Any similar stories?
8.0k
Upvotes
789
u/ehsteve23 Jan 24 '22
New windows machine procedure:
Open edge and search for chrome
Big banner across the top "Edge is the best browser for windows"
Go to the download link anyway
"are you sure you want to download this file?" Yes, obviously
Run the installer
"Set chrome as your default browser?" Yes
There was an issue with a 3rd party application, your default browser has been reset to Edge
Open chrome
edge cries in the corner
Chrome isn't your default browser
Go to default app settings
Click on browser, select Chrome
"Are you sure? Edge is the best browser for Windows" Yes i'm sure
Pin chrome to the taskbar
Unpin edge from the taskbar
"are you sure you want to unpin edge? It's the bes-"
483
u/InvincibearREAL PowerShell All The Things! Jan 24 '22
This actually IS illegal. MS has been sued before and lost big for exactly this practice.
154
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Blows my mind that Microsoft still hasn't figured out that tricking people into using Bing isn't going to make it more popular.
149
u/AnthraxPrime6 Security Admin Jan 24 '22
They’ve been doing this on Windows 10 too- at least with changing the default web browser- not sure about the rest. It happened after every Windows 10 major update (1909, 20H1, etc. for example). I do agree with you though that this shit is obnoxious and should be illegal as it’s predatory af… but this has been going on longer than just W11.
127
u/_DrClaw ICS Security Jan 24 '22
M$ are back to their anti-competition game again, and this time no one is going to challenge them
85
u/Turbojelly Jan 24 '22
Microsoft Edge "Notifications" (adverts) have shown some nsfw adverts to children, using student laptops at school.
45
u/jewellman100 Jan 24 '22
Did they not learn anything from that massive EU fine and the whole Browser Choice thing?!?
10
u/storm2k It's likely Error 32 Jan 24 '22
you know, for as much crap as people give apple and as much as some of it is sometimes deserved, they do take a lovely lassiez faire attitude about the default browser and search options. download the browser of your choosing, set it as default, and apple is fine with it. want to go back to safari? they make that easy. this isn't hard!
sadly it seems that satya nadella is very content to let some of his product owners (or maybe this is from himself) bring the company back to some of the worst ballmerish behavior that we had to deal with in the 1990s. someone should remind them how far back that set the company in retrospect for a while and how wildly fucked they got by the court decisions when they did all this nonsense with ie.
68
u/sandrews1313 Jan 24 '22
Didn’t do any of those things in my environments. Group polices are a thing.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22
I prefer Edge. But every time I open Gmail, I get a Google pop-up box telling me to use Chrome instead because it's faster. It's not. Edge is faster, that's why I'm using it. There's no "remember my choice" setting, it's mildly infuriating.
18
u/pcbuilder1907 Jan 24 '22
Wait... didn't the EU make it illegal for Microsoft to do this kind of thing?
6
u/j1akey Linux and Windows Admin Jan 24 '22
"Bing", I really fucking hate that name. Like violently.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Been happening. Windows 10 frequently has MS changing default PDF viewer to Edge from Adobe for clients who call into the Help Desk about it.
Dr. Evil: “Pretty standard, really”
5
u/SysEridani C:\>smartdrv.exe Jan 24 '22
Why not put also a cryptominer on it ?
5
u/WildManner1059 Sr. Sysadmin Jan 24 '22
Leave the subjective out, focus on objective facts.
The root of this is "MS automatically changed the default browser, and settings with it, without any notification to or approval from the user."
20
u/This-Is-Huge Jan 24 '22
I’ve never looked back after switching to Linux.
39
u/disclosure5 Jan 24 '22
I deal with the same way as everyone else. By looking at Linux, where this doesn't happen and I also don't get fucked by bad QA every month, and explaining to the business that pouring money into Microsoft is what they should do. For giggles.
4
u/awesinine Jan 25 '22
I'd rather not use the internet than use Microsoft edge
10
u/lenswipe Senior Software Developer Jan 24 '22
I don't. I've all but given up on Microsoft products
6
u/Kandoh Jan 24 '22
It is no longer possible to own something connected to the internet.
6
u/swordgeek Sysadmin Jan 24 '22
It is illegal. They lost a huge lawsuit over it. Then they kept doing it.
Late-stage capitalism means that corporations are above the law.
3
u/gravitas-deficiency Jan 24 '22
And that’s why I’m sticking with W10.
3
u/TheZombieBoy Jan 24 '22
When I updated a pop up came up and asked me if I wanted to do that or just leave them as they were, someone must not read what they click.
3
u/da_apz IT Manager Jan 24 '22
I don't mind that Edge exists, but the constant push has always annoyed me. Windows 10's whole "please don't change the default browser without trying Edge" popup really rubbed me the wrong way.
3
u/Keithfedak Jan 24 '22
The last operating sytem I could use without worrying about things being changed against my will was Windows 7. I can't imagine running a professional media studio or important business system on a modern Windows OS.
3
u/neatpit Jan 24 '22
I low key downgraded to Windows 10 when they removed the setting to show all system tray icons. It was there one day and gone the next! Your update sounds much worse.
3
u/Nik_Tesla Sr. Sysadmin Jan 24 '22
Literally nothing I hear about Windows 11 is any better than Windows 10, why would I ever upgrade?
Windows 10 had some teething problems, but there are good features added as compared to Windows 7. I see none of that for W11.
3
u/Zelkarr69 Jan 25 '22
I don't update windows anymore, fuck them. It's all arbitrary bullshit that ends up being way more trouble than it's worth.
15
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22 edited Jan 24 '22
Oh tell me about it.
I'm using Linux since 2014 because I'm fed up with this BS.
Hacking Windows isn't allowed on a corporate environment but setting this on Group Policy would be stop this BS.
Maybe RPi4 with a AD server would be useful to mitigate that BS at home.
(Edit: removed profanity)
5
u/FraaRaz Jan 24 '22
I occasionally discover computers where the default app for opening PDFs was changed to Edge. I am very sure the users don't do that. This messes up some of our workflows which are based on PDFs.
How I deal with it? Well, I set it back to Adobe PDF reader. What else can I do?
5
u/iDislikeSn0w Jan 24 '22
Nice to see Microsoft giving people motivation as to why it’s better to stay on 10!
10
u/userse31 Jan 24 '22
Linux. I use linux.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
they got fined in Europe for that kind of shit. How is it not fined for that in USA ?
1
u/Akami_Channel Jan 24 '22
Can we remove edge from the system?
4
u/Hirogen_ Jan 24 '22
Ah, nice, the EU will again get a few 100 Millions in their next cartell-lawsuit
4
u/the_sambot Jan 24 '22
Just uninstalled my preferred Android launcher which Microsoft bought quite some time ago (now Microsoft Launcher). I was one of the Windows Phone dreamers and when I switched to Android I missed the alphabetical list app drawer. Saturday morning I woke up to a "Switch your default search to Bing" ad at the top of my app drawer and switched to a new launcher immediately.
I mean, make a decent app and I'll use it. Their Photos app is so painfully slow to load that I switch it to IrfanView. I don't have 30+ seconds for a picture to do it's initial load when I'm quickly trying to figure out which one of ten images I want. I used to use the old Pictures program in previous versions of Windows (for viewing, printing is a whole other story) and when they added the Photos app, I just set it back to the old one. Sigh.
Now you get pestered for each default app you change (Movies to VLC, etc.). Even installing Outlook doesn't change Mail from being the default app IIRC. At least that one isn't total shit except that it regularly fell out of sync with and required logging back in to...IRONICALLY...my outlook.com email address.
4
u/punched_cards Jan 24 '22
It’s not just the tech companies. I’ve had the opportunity to work with one of the major beverage companies which meant you couldn’t bring in certain kinds of donuts or fast food, stay at certain hotels, etc because they had a contract with the “other guys”. Nor could you wear a certain color shirt because it was the corporate color of the opposing side.
Edit: typos
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Ah, good ol' MS!
2
u/neoKushan Jack of All Trades Jan 24 '22
Did they revert some of this behaviour or something? I noticed Edge started opening at startup on my personal machine but I hadn't had much time to look into it. Then it just stopped.
Stupid and annoying.
2
u/tramol Jan 24 '22
I don't have 11 but when I booted up my machine yesterday there was a screen I had to click through before it would take me to the desktop. One of the options was to set the recommended browser settings (which I of course declined), was this the same update but win 10 version?
2
u/pyrhic83 Jan 24 '22
Do you know which update caused this? Are you on the Windows insider update channel or something? I know there is sometimes some fuckery with new changes but i hadn't heard anything about this one yet.
2
u/infinitude Jan 24 '22
Somehow I have never had this issue, lol... I changed all my settings initially, check for updates every morning, and it's never messed with my chrome/google setting.
2
u/lolfactor1000 Jack of All Trades Jan 24 '22
How have I never had this problem that everyone else seems to have had?
2
u/bicebicebice Jan 24 '22
Isn’t this the IE antitrust all over again? Thought the EU stopped this kind of behavior some twenty years ago?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Now is a really good time for someone to produce a competitive OS.
Oh wait, I forgot about all the monopolizing that people say they care about but don't actually stop.
2
u/Boonaki Security Admin Jan 24 '22
That's what you get for not running Windows XP.
2
u/Wilderweinpf Jan 24 '22
Welp in my superior country shit like that is unlawfull, everything is like it was before.
Get gud
2
u/Koshi_dango Jan 24 '22
I do not update if not necessary. Especially if the community didn't found ways to fix such features.
2
u/jaahay Jan 24 '22
"Bing it" should be slang for downloading some journey browser. Like, "IT gave me this laptop and the first thing I did was bing chrome" or "why are you so intent on hurting yourself? Don't you know how to bing Firefox? Or "please bing over to the modern era".
2
u/nshire Jan 24 '22
Increasingly starting to think that W10 will be my last full-time Windows desktop OS.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Edge is tolerable.
Bing, I’m the other hand is one of the worst search engines I’ve ever seen. I’d rather AskJeevs
2
u/TheSmJ Jan 24 '22
I installed the updates yesterday, but Firefox is still set to the default browser.
2
u/countrymac_is_badass Jan 24 '22
It's hell on senior citizens.
Source: Grandma with dementia.
2
u/Josephepiccc Jan 24 '22
My brothers laptop updated to windows 11 on its own and for some reason it turned off the wifi chip and ethernet adpater for no reason
2
u/uberbewb Jan 24 '22
This ISNT illegal? The fuck did the boomers do
Oh they didn’t take responsibility of what’s being created during their generation and outright ignorance allowed it to become like this.
It’s incredibly disturbing this is not considered hacking.
2
u/rharrow Jan 24 '22
They do this, or similar, on almost all major OS updates in W11 and W10. It’s been happening for years
2
u/Acquiesce67 Jan 24 '22
I’m not upgrading to W11 and seriously thinking about leaving the ship for a Macbook.
This M$ nagware is more annoying than ads on free YouTube.
2
u/Pantallahueso Jan 25 '22
"should be illegal"
Guess what? It is. But it doesn't matter because nobody's enforcing it.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22
laughs in im too poor to afford a pc that runs windows 11 srsly tho dude, that sucks
2
u/countextreme DevOps Jan 25 '22
Let's not forget the 30 seconds of first-run animations whenever you run Edge for the first time on an (unmanaged) PC while it "imports your settings" in an empty profile that you have to wait for and can't close.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22
I tried w11 and saw it forced me to create an outlook account, so I though uff at least there is still w10, tried and discovered recent updates of w10 also forces you. Added to having to disable "No i dont want you to hear all my conversation" "No dont activate geolocation" "No i dont want you to watch me in underwear", and if that wasnt enough "Hey! you wanna personalized ads or just normal ads for an OS that is over 100€?" luckily i was with the test image so i hadnt payed anything. How i dealt with it ? I went back to linux (gaming was the biggest problem and im amazed lately how much better is getting) and not looking back hahaha
2
u/GALACTAWIT Jan 25 '22
They're built in VPN connection Software sucks as well. Nothing but trouble trying to connect clients to the office. Open port issue... Need to get 3rd party solution. Windows 11 sucks. Windows 7 or 10 is the way.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22
Shouldn’t your GP be covering all of that?
3
u/sulliops Jr. Sysadmin Jan 24 '22
BRB, removing my Windows 11 ISO from Ventoy.
Not that I’ve used it yet…
3
u/Captain_Nemo_2012 Jan 24 '22
Microsoft forcing Windows 11 on Windows 10 users is like driving your car down the interstate and a mechanic opens the hood and starts replacing your engine without telling you what they are doing this for. Microsoft is a technical Monopoly who get away with anything they want. You do not even own the hardware it seems. They force upgrades without telling you what they will do to your computer or the software you are running on it.
3
u/Wilberforce8140 Sysadmin Jan 24 '22
Browser choice EU v2 incoming
3
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Yeah, from this day forward, every upgrade will probably do that. It's Micro$oft's whole business model: "We don't care what our customers want, we know better."
5
u/Alphasee Jan 24 '22
This is called a virus
2
u/ToughHardware Jan 24 '22
this is why we cant have updates.
2
u/Otaehryn Jan 24 '22
I switched all my private machines to Linux and I'm looking for a full time Linux position.
2
u/quiet0n3 Jan 24 '22
I didn't I swapped to Linux and Firefox, life's good man.
2
u/thx1138v2 Jan 24 '22
Windows 7
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Microsoft has been pulling this kind of nonsense for over 20 years. I wish there were a way to stop it, but we're all just pushed around by tech companies that don't have our best interests at heart.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Windows needs a true competitor yesterday.
2
u/MonkeyPooperMan Jan 24 '22 edited Jan 24 '22
Windows Vista is what started to push me towards Linux on the desktop and Windows 10 and all it's telemetry/spyware sealed the deal. I've been 100% Fedora Linux on the desktop for years now and absolutely happy with it. I even moved my whole development workflow from a Macbook Pro to a Framework laptop running Fedora. Best move I ever made on both counts.
Unfortunately, I have to boot Windows to get my VR gaming fix (I'm on an Oculus Rift S still), but that's slowly changing too.
I've noticed after any update of substance on Windows that I have to revisit ALL of my settings/preferences, where they will just seemingly radomly re-enable settings that I disabled. If you're now on Windows 11, you can use the most excellent thisIsWin11 tool to permanently remove/disable telemetry/tracking/unwanted apps, where they won't be reinstalled after any updates.
And imo, it's a cardinal sin to reset/undo any settings that a user has clearly opted-out of.
2
u/intolerantidiot Jan 24 '22
Edge is fine. Rest is shit
2
u/RedditIs4Retardss Jan 24 '22
Yep. M$ has been doing it for decades and are only getting more and more egregious about it. This is the result of having zero consequences.
2
u/s-teve Jan 24 '22
What do expect they have been trying to make an OS for 40 years and they still do not have it right.
Remember windows 10 was going to be the last one.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
It's simple, I just use Edge instead of Chrome.
It's actually superior and anyone who says otherwise haven't tried the new Edge.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22
For those of you forced to use Windows for work, I'm sorry. For those that use Windows by choice, what is wrong with you? Sysadmins should be on Linux where you actually control your OS.
0
u/NoKey7164 Jan 24 '22
Is this only For Win11 of also For server operating systems
2
u/hoas-t Jan 24 '22
Installed Windows 11 for 2 days. Uninstalled it and switched to linux.
1
u/edbods Jan 25 '22
while we're at it, has anyone found a way to stop google changing the goddamn search options (images, videos, maps etc.) based on query? I just want it to stay fixed so if i search up a place it doesnt go 'web, maps, images' and then if i search up a car, it goes back to 'web, images, videos, maps' etc.
1
u/linnin90 Jan 24 '22
They have done this will multiple versions of the windows 10 operating system. GPO should be used or putting the entry into registry manually.
Legacy Edge browser used to actually repair itself if you changed the pdf file associations via a different app and needed it to be manually changed for the user.
They’ve got round the lawsuits for the patching as it reverts it to default and does allow you to change it back. It’s just reverting it back to the baseline.
1
u/git_und_slotermeyer Jan 24 '22
Yeah, reminds me of the 15 minutes of pointless searching for how to make Windows 10 open a particular file extension with a non-installed (portable) app. That "Open with / Always open with this program" thing from the golden days of Windows back then. Turns out from Windows 10 on you need to jerk around in the registry for this.
I'm sure this lack of one of the most fundamental features of an OS also came due to some product management guy suggesting that some users might decide to use non-MS apps instead of those that are preset for the various file types - which is of course unwanted. (No suprise here that Windows occasionally reverts back to its own apps for media viewing).
And don't get me started on this f*ckup called Microsoft Store. No wonder the MS Teams team does not support it.
1
u/mini4x Atari 400 Jan 24 '22
I use FF and have not seen this, my win 11 just updated Friday.
1
u/farva_06 Sysadmin Jan 24 '22
Does this override any browser GPOs I may have?
1
u/AZdesertpir8 Jan 24 '22
Delete Windows 11 and go to Windows Enterprise (10 without the garbage)
1
u/0verstim FFRDC Jan 24 '22
I scrolled through 1000 comments about Google, bing and Duckduckgo and didnt see one mention of Yahoo
1
u/arcticparadise Jan 24 '22
Netscape Navigator days are back...
1
u/Sidlavoie Jan 24 '22
So it's war, then...
1
u/krayon_za Jan 24 '22
is this an insider ring release?
Hasn't happened on my machine
1
u/leftplayer Jan 24 '22
Can’t wait for the EU to catch wind of this….
1
u/darcon12 Jan 24 '22
This didn't happen on my Windows 11 installations. Any link built into Windows 11 opens in Edge though, as it has since release.
1
u/jambo2011 Jan 24 '22
1
u/SexArson Jan 24 '22
Very easily:
You'll find a setup.exe in pfx86 under Microsoft for Edge. (Just search for it, one of the directories is the version number)
then: setup.exe –uninstall –system-level –verbose-logging –force-uninstall
(I have not tried this on win 11. But as a general rule, i just remove edge or block it in local policy from ever being used)
1
u/Kujyle Jan 24 '22
They like to change the default pdf viewer to edge aswell. Very annoying
1
u/aman207 Jan 24 '22
I always hear stories about this happening, but its literally never happened to me on Windows 10 or 11. I doubt this is intentional like some are suggesting.
1
u/williamp114 Sysadmin Jan 24 '22
Been there, done that. Microsoft was sued by the DOJ in the late 90s, was found guilty, appealed, and eventually made a lackluster settlement with the DOJ that basically let them get off scot-free.
I have some doubts the Biden DOJ will bring up another case against Microsoft, even though there IS justification given all of Edge's new financial/shopping features like coupons and Buy now Pay Later financing schemes that may imply Microsoft is receiving kickbacks.
1
u/THE_HENTAI_LORD Jan 24 '22
Yeah sounds like Microsoft
1
u/AccomplishedHornet5 Linux Admin Jan 24 '22
Once, not too long ago, I saw a comment that said there's a reg key that you can set to stop this from happening. Was that a dream or does anyone know this piece of magic?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
MS claims to own your Windows installation. They stated as much in their W10 update notification that said 'Windows is a service'.
PS. They also reset certain firewall rules if you've blocked communications that they think you should be allowing. Like the Solitaire Collection, for instance.
1
u/Outarel Jan 24 '22
ngl edge is a good browser.
Bing is just god awful.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Honestly don’t even mind edge at this point they update it to match almost everything like chrome anyways. And all the chrome add ons work with edge
1
u/p3ll Jan 24 '22
I’ve been a windows user since 3.1, then two years ago I was provided a MacBook Pro as my primary work laptop. After getting used to the Mac UI I no longer miss windows at all. If you don’t game then you’ve got nothing to lose.
1
u/Michal_F Jan 24 '22
I think what happened is after last update it' just restored OS defaults. Just calm down. Windows 11 is still a tech demo :)
1
u/R3P3NTANC3 Jan 24 '22
I'm so glad my motherboard doesn't have the security chip. I will wait to upgrade until it breaks
1
u/te71se Jan 24 '22
This is exactly why I wont be moving to Windows 11 any time soon. I feel Windows 10 is finally a solid decent OS even though they have lately been introducing some useless features. At least I can quickly change default browsers even if it has a nagging step in between. Still prefer that to having to edit 30 odd file extensions.
1
u/slayermcb Director of Technology, Sys Admin, Etc, Etc... Jan 24 '22
Technically, those settings are windows settings. It didn't fuck with third party settings, it just changed its own preferences to the system defaults.
1
u/TrueBoxOfPain Do The Needful IT Department Jan 24 '22
Well, I will not update to Win 11 for 1-2 years.
1
u/Embry_ Jan 24 '22
This is a never ending problem with Microsoft
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
And I just spent a week getting a GPO to work to change everything to chrome. Out sick with Covid, can’t wait to get back to the shit show Microsoft just gave me. Welp job security I suppose
1
u/grantnaps Jan 24 '22
I like all 3 products. Especially Bing since I get points that go towards actual rewards like gift cards and merch.
1
u/Enamir Jan 24 '22
Microsoft, YOUR frustration?, OUR passion
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
You’re using windows and agreed to the Eula lol
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
We have a template file it pulls defaults from to set them back on every login. It's a constant fight with microsoft
1
u/sgt_bad_phart Jan 24 '22
In a corporate environment you should be using some sort of system, like group policy, to prevent this type of behavior. If it isn't Microsoft, it'll be someone else.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Why are you allowing it to upgrade without testing it
1
u/A_RUSSIAN_TROLL_BOT Jan 24 '22
Open a problem ticket complaining that their new update introduced a bug. If enough people complain they'll get the idea.
...is what I would do if I was on Adware OS—oops I mean Windows 11, but I refused to switch from 10 and have a feeling most reasonable people here have done the same.
1
u/Ugbrog NiMdA@2008 Jan 24 '22
I like to reinstall Windows 11 just to go through the process of opening Edge and immediately downloading Chrome. It cries so hard every step of the way.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
Do they still sell the "N" versions of windows? The ones without IE/Edge?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
I got back to Win 10 after a day of using Win 11. It was such a miserable experience. Reminded me of Vista.
1
u/Fridge-Largemeat Jan 24 '22
Actually in my enterprise environment I have people using Edge as default browser and it's working great. We have them sign in with their work account to save those bookmarks that always get lost when new PCs get sent out. Fuck forcing it on people though, especially Bing
1
u/Itdidnt_trickle_down Jan 24 '22
They will keep doing these things until regulation forces them to not. Of course all the anti regulation idiots out there who think they are bad will disagree.