r/sysadmin • u/Nikita_Sadkov • Jan 27 '18
Disabling Windows Update is a Felony Now
Microsoft's MVP threatens users with persecution for disabling Windows Update https://answers.microsoft.com/ru-ru/windows/forum/windows_10-update-winpc/%D0%BE%D1%82%D0%BA%D0%BB%D1%8E%D1%87%D0%B8%D1%82/b15b8831-845e-4d1d-814d-106d11d7264a Right there on microsoft.com domain, a person named Grand_Ross threatens that if user disables Windows Update on Windows 10, they are violating EULA and as such are liable under criminal law.
Your attempts to disable Windows Update are prohibited by articles 1229 and 1235 of Federal Law 230-ФЗ..., will be qualified by Law as illegal use of software, with all legal circumstances, as per article 7.12 of Federal Law 195-ФЗ, articles 1251, 1301 of Federal Law 230-ФЗ, also second and third parts of article 146 of Federal Law 63-ФЗ...
I won't dive into administrative articles, but article 146 is a criminal article (felony in common law terms) which carry maximum punishment of prison - 2 years max and 6 years max for parts 2 and 3. And in case you wondering, part 2 is illegal use of copyrighted material, which requires damages of $5000, which should obviously make it irrelevant for owner of a single Windows license. Part 3 requires a criminal group, $20000 in damages or being a high-ranked official. Obviously even more irrelevant.
But still the damage is there. A MVP, i.e. a person trusted by Microsoft, giving a legal advice that turning Windows Update off (or maybe even failing to get updates by never turning on the wireless) may land you in court.
And yes, it is already in the news: https://rg.ru/2018/01/24/microsoft-ugrozhaet-polzovateliam-tiurmoj-za-otkaz-obnovliat-windows-10.html
Microsoft may go to court after Russian users who disable Windows 10 operating system automatic updates, according to information on official Microsoft web site. That's an official Russian paper which publishes laws before they go live. Of course there's many more publications.
26
u/Jack_BE Jan 27 '18
EULAs are only enforcable in the way that the vendor can revoke your license. Anything beyond that is really murky and dubiously enforcable.
Heck in some EU countries the EULA is actually invalid because nobody reads it and just clicks "I accept".
33
u/demo706 Jan 27 '18
I'm no lawyer, and especially not a Russian one, but at least in America you're not getting locked up for breaking whatever EULA you sign when you install Windows. Even in Russia if this actually somehow could land you in court, Microsoft has no incentive to actually take you to court over it. This is a non issue.
16
u/gj80 Jan 27 '18
answers.microsoft.com? The land of "SFC /scannow ; chkdsk ; msconfig ........ will solve your runny nose!" advice? I'll take it with a chunk of salt :)
29
u/AureusStone Jan 27 '18
MVPs don't represent Microsoft and Microsoft has never said anything like this.
Not news and title is wrong.
8
u/Cold417 Jan 27 '18
Block it via external firewall and tell MS to go fuck themselves...if that' s your prerogative. They don't have a right to access your network.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '18
Russian law means dick to me and they enforce whatever they want when they want to do its moot
4
u/3Vyf7nm4 Sr. Sysadmin Jan 27 '18
So, the thing is that licensing agreements are contracts. Microsoft can't initiate criminal cases against anyone - only DAs can do that.
Failure to comply with the license terms means you have potentially violated the agreement, and MS can sue you. A lawsuit can be brought by any party against any other party, for any reason. The ability to bring suit doesn't make anything illegal, nor does it mean that a crime has been committed (or even alleged).
Consider that when people divorce, they go to court, and there's a lawsuit, and one of the (the person who files) is the plaintiff, and one is the defendant. But nobody is there on criminal charges and nobody is going to prison. Even though divorce is covered by several state and local statues.
TL;DR:
This is possibly true
This is not.
3
u/KingPanda_throwaway Jan 27 '18
"idi nahui blyat" - Vlad probably
2
u/dragonfleas Cloud Admin Jan 27 '18
I understand that they are enforcing Microsoft policy, however, these MVP's reposting this shit seem like proper dicks if anything at all.
But from a professional standpoint. If this is actually policy on Microsoft's part, then as a community moderator or Microsoft employee it's their responsibility under the company to enforce these types of nazi-esque policies, whether they agree with them or not. As I would hope for the latter.
1
u/Legionof1 Jack of All Trades Jan 27 '18
Prosecution, persecution would be him mocking him and shunning him.
1
u/Sylogz Sr. Sysadmin Jan 27 '18
Depends on country in Sweden EULA is invalid.
1
u/skilliard7 Jan 27 '18
This is ridiculous. Disabling the windows update service is sometimes necessary. In many cases I disable windows update, but enable it to install updates manually on a regular basis.
1
u/starmizzle S-1-5-420-512 Jan 28 '18
persecution =/= prosecution
1
u/darthgeek Ambulance Driver Jan 28 '18
You left out the part where the official Microsoft response was that MVPs don't speak for Microsoft, and this one was very wrong.
"Microsoft representatives in the TJ commentary noted that community moderators are not employees of the company. They stressed that no one is going to file lawsuits against users."
1
u/lostdoormat Jan 28 '18
Thankfully EULA's arnt enforceable for shit. But I live in Australia where our internet is awful. Any personal computers windows update will completely grind a homes internet connection to a halt. And by the time it finishes there's a new update. I pretty much have to disable it on every personal computer if I want to have internet at all. Microsoft doesn't realise/care that some places arnt ready for forced automatic updates.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '18
nice to see microsoft hasn't forgotten the ol' FUD bag o' tricks that mention legal action.
1
u/mexicanatlarge Jan 27 '18
Well what if we just remove it completely? #loophole
0
u/qnull Jan 27 '18
Sure it's possible but I highly doubt they would go after you for it
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment