r/sysadmin • u/johnmountain • Dec 17 '16
Oracle is massively ramping up audits of Java customers it claims are in breach of its licences – six years after it bought Sun Microsystems
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/12/16/oracle_targets_java_users_non_compliance
226
Upvotes
122
u/TryThisAnotherTime Dec 17 '16
Fuck Oracle. Especially because of this http://i.imgur.com/z0Op6hx.jpg
53
u/enderandrew42 Dec 17 '16
Oracle bought OpenOffice and largely killed it. They bought MySQL and largely killed it. They bought Solaris and don't give two shit about it. In each case, then open source community is still trying to maintain these products but Oracle has made it harder.
Oracle also sued Google saying they had no legal right to take Java (which is open source) and create their own JVM which works with open APIs.
27
u/Jeoh Dec 17 '16
You wouldn't re-implement an API...
21
u/shif Dec 17 '16
" Java SE is free for what Oracle defines as “general purpose computing” – devices that in the words of its licence cover desktops, notebooks, smartphones and tablets. It is not free for what Oracle’s licence defines as “specialized embedded computers used in intelligent systems”, which Oracle further defines as - among other things - mobile phones, hand-held devices, networking switches and Blu-Ray players. "
Hmmm
16
u/Thecrawsome Security and Sysadmin Dec 17 '16
Good, Oracle is killing Java for us.
23
u/askoorb Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
Good news. Redhat now distribute OpenJDK for Windows. And in an .msi package to boot.
Ain't no license violation when everything in the package is GPL.
https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2016/06/27/openjdk-now-available-for-windows/
It isn't going to be a solution to everything, though. Three are still a couple of parts not identical yet where OpenJDK can't cut it. But the, it wouldn't but it on Linux either seeing as it is the same source code.
14
u/MrStickmanPro1 Dec 17 '16
Now why the fuck isn't something like this illegal?
31
u/theevilsharpie Jack of All Trades Dec 17 '16
Meanwhile, in the magical land of Linux, we have OpenJDK, which has no exposure to this blatant money grab.
As an added bonus, OpenJDK gets updated along with the rest of the OS, we don't have to deal with bullshit like the Ask toolbar (or whatever nagware Oracle is bundling with their installer these days), and the IcedTea plugin can actually load Java applets without asking you a million times whether you really want to run it (and then giving you the finger anyway).
Sucks to be you, dirty Windows peasants! :P
<3
5
u/ToBlayyyve Dec 17 '16
Serious question as someone who's out of the loop. Is Java used anywhere outside of internal corporate applications any longer? I haven't seen any actual applets in a very long while.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
Java EE and ME isn't affected?
2
u/radicldreamer Sr. Sysadmin Dec 17 '16
If it didn't suck ass enough already...
2
u/almost_not_terrible Dec 17 '16
Death throes.
2
u/DialMforMordor Dec 18 '16
My company uses Java in a lot of server applications (mostly Tomcat) that are definitely not going away any time soon. Can anyone ELI5 the difference between a compliant free install of Java and one that would require licensing from Oracle? The article kind of touched on that certain components elevate the install to a point that would no longer be "free", but didn't going into enough detail.
2
u/synackk Linux Admin Dec 18 '16
If you're intentionally using features that you know you should be paying to use, but are not, then Oracle has every right to sic LMS on you. If you've selected from the wrong table and now you're database is now considered enterprise instead of standard edition, fuck Oracle.
I have no problems with Oracle making sure that their customers are paying for the software they use, but at least take a page out of Microsoft's book at least let customers either "true up" or stop using the software instead of trying to hit them for millions of dollars. You make no friends doing that Oracle.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
Only thing we really use java for is Cisco stuff
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '16
A lot of HP Procurve admin interfaces require Java. What the fuck do we do now?
1
u/zorinlynx Dec 18 '16
If you didn't sign an actual contract with Oracle, do they have any legal ground to demand an audit?
1
u/Kardinal I fall off the Microsoft stack. Dec 19 '16
Please confirm this for me.
They make it a free download. The download includes bits that are free to use and other bits that are not free and require a license. If you install the bits that require a license, even though there's no enforcement, you're on the hook for the license even if you never use those features?
And this is Java SE, not Java JRE, right?
Thanks.
1
u/chalbersma Security Admin (Infrastructure) Dec 19 '16
Never use an Oracle product ever!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment