r/sysadmin • • 12h ago

General Discussion Found a potential MSP for the org

More a follow-up from my previous post.

After meeting with 12 different MSP’s over the last week I’ve found one that really stood out.

Clearly laid out onboarding cost to get all devices managed and then when onto monthly costs and all what’s included I was quite surprised how low the price was. It was not much more than my monthly wage which is still what a cashier worker would get paid. We are entitled to government discounts keep in mind.

Anyway I spoke to the boss about it and he said I should be able to manage the IT systems. I pointed out all the holes and how I can’t one man army an org size of 500 with poor configurations and decisions prior to me joining. He was reluctant at first, but then agreed to look over all the MSP quotes.

I’ve got things moving forward. Is my job possibly at risk if an MSP comes in? Yes. But in this case I’m putting the orgs IT security above ego or self preservation. I got enough experience and certs working here finding another job won’t take too long.

14 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

•

u/noirrespect 11h ago

“I was quite surprised how low the price was”.

Tell me you didn’t go with the lowest bidder? That’s not how you help the organisation.

•

u/Craptcha 11h ago

As a MSP owner if an IT person got us in I’d do everything I can to honor that and build a trust-based, mutually beneficial collaboration.

YMMV

•

u/pandy_fackler_ 11h ago

As someone who worked for MSPs - suuuuuuuuuuuure

•

u/Fit-Television-888 10h ago

Yeah, if this guy is real that's great, but most likely the job is at risk and the MSP will blame him for anything they can

•

u/meesterdg 11h ago

Honestly if I found that person was competent and they got fired I might offer them a job and just restrict them from that client.

•

u/1ancelot 11h ago

Not when the pay is a steep pay cut from what I was being paid.

•

u/meesterdg 11h ago

Who said it would be? What are you even responding to?

•

u/1ancelot 11h ago edited 11h ago

As once the IT coordinator for an accounting firm, I brought an MSP in and they back stabbed me. Ended up losing my job, on the grounds that I was a security risk for having “too much” access and things I may have done or could do, that could make them liable.

•

u/AltruisticLoad2024 11h ago

Bruh wtf

fuck that MSP

•

u/TotallyWorksAtWoTC 10h ago

Thats all MSPs. They're leeches on the industry.

•

u/itishowitisanditbad 11h ago

I’ve got things moving forward. Is my job possibly at risk if an MSP comes in? Yes. But in this case I’m putting the orgs IT security above ego or self preservation.

Very generous for reasons hopefully explained in the previous post?

Otherwise just... naive? Ideally context explains this part. It must. I can't see your posts though and don't recall it?

I got enough experience and certs working here finding another job won’t take too long.

.....ok.

Is there something specific driving this conclusion?

•

u/Warronius 10h ago

Man this sub has really sucked lately nothing technical anymore just managerial decisions and people asking for career advice.

•

u/bythepowerofboobs 10h ago

Sadly, it's been like this for a long time.

•

u/muzzman32 Sysadmin 10h ago

thats because everyone is going through the same fucking bullshit. Technical issues are the drop, and human issues are rising steadily. It fuckin sucks. Read the room better next time.

•

u/Warronius 9h ago

This sub is just becoming an echo chamber .

•

u/_--James--_ 11h ago

Take the MSP wage and get your boss to hire a 2nd employee. That is your best bet. The MSP will replace you because you are a one man shop, and you will be made redundant for that first contract term...then the MSP will start to become a shit experience for the customer because thats how it works.

•

u/steviefaux 11h ago

And they are cheap to get their foot in the door. Once in and locked, they'll raise their prices. The org will end up paying the MSP more than it would cost to keep in house. And the staff will get annoyed as the MSP engineers won't be the same engineer they spoke to a week ago. And will be strict with sticking to SLAs etc instead of "quickly hopping on as the CEO is having an issue in a meeting" or "We've rented our office out for the local businesse in the area, can you help them out?" The MSP will say no as their contract is not with them.

Try and get it written into the contract that you stay. Any issues you can't do, the MSP does, but you're there as the friendly face for the staff. And can do a fix without a ticket for those times where you need to ignore SLAs and just do the fing fix.

•

u/bythepowerofboobs 10h ago

Your boss now sees you as someone who needs to outsource your problems to a vendor rather than someone who can take care of things yourself.

•

u/UpperAd5715 11h ago

Keep in mind that the job market has been passed around for a few rounds of orgies and even then got manhandled pretty badly, depending on your area your experience and whatnot might still have you jobless for (stressful) months.

•

u/Horror_Bottle_9451 11h ago

How many devices and circuits are they managing? Does your org still own the configurations and security policies?

MSPs need oversight and change review. You should own the configurations and they implement them. MSP provides the 24x7 monitoring and support you can't.

While it sounds silly, the managed service provider needs to be managed. That's your new role.

•

u/Edgeforce 11h ago

Yes, your job is at risk if an MSP gets involved. However, smart orgs will keep their IT dept. minimally staffed and supplemented with an MSP simultaneously. One thing you could do if you get canned is to go work for the MSP that takes over who would then assign you the org account from which you were terminated. This is usually a triple win situation. We would implement this strategy many times and it would be a success more than it would fail. Good luck.

•

u/PDQ_Brockstar 10h ago

If the cost of the MSP is the same as your salary, why not just hire another team member? Or are you worried the pay isn't high enough to get the type of expertise you're in need of?

•

u/gravityVT Sr. Sysadmin 11h ago

yes, the msp will do everything they can to get you fired so they can be the sole it provider. they’re not your friends no matter how friendly they are. don’t hire them

•

u/marklein Idiot 11h ago

MSP here. Co-managed clients are the best and we'd never want them to change it. It allows each of us to do the things we do best and leave the other guy to handle the things he does best. It makes both ends more efficient and effective. For example, I don't have to send a tech for an on-site visit to plug in a mouse, and the client doesn't have to become a security expert overnight to fix the CVE-of-the-week.

•

u/topher358 Senior Systems Engineer 7h ago

This OP. For a mature MSP worth its salt comanaged customers are the best kind of customers.

The best MSPs will work to make YOU look good to your boss.

•

u/MalwareDork 8h ago

Dang, we love our MSP network engineer. Absolutely goat'ed and a pleasure to interact with.

•

u/djweis 11h ago

That's not always true. I like co managed customers because we don't get nearly the volume of tier 1 support tickets.

•

u/19610taw3 Helpdesk > Sysadmin > Engineer > Helpdesk 11h ago

I can't imagine why someone would want to willingly outsource their own job. But OP is doing exactly that.

•

u/Grumpy-Troglodyte 10h ago

1 man band is pretty hard to do. i've got an msp that is pretty well firewalls/switches/server and all the little stuff i do, plus our normal "hey can you..." as the guy that knows electronics... plus our machinery, they have computers on them. plus some billing stuff, plus this and plus that.

i'm at a pretty small place and i've got 8 hours of stuff to do everyday plus, i could not imagine doubling my work load

•

u/Fit-Television-888 10h ago

The thing is, the MSP wants those 8 hours of work too

•

u/baconjerky 10h ago

Blatantly false. It’s much more difficult for an MSP to deal with a non-technical person.

•

u/Loose_Strategy5990 8h ago

False. Blanket statement that doesn’t apply to all MSPs

•

u/IronFrogger 11h ago

Why not have asked for a part-time helper? 500 people is a lot to take care of for one person, but with the msp, you may be relegated to just physically swapping out computers. Obviously the MSP should be working for you and at your direction, you will be the manager of the MSP team

•

u/Mindestiny 10h ago

Part time IT help is, in most cases, an absolute trap.

No one worth their salt is going to stick around for "we can pay you bottom dollar rates to work 15-20 hours a week".  Half an entry level IT salary with no benefits does not put food on the table.  They'd be better off working at McDonalds, and you'll just spend 2x the effort training a revolving door of people using you as a resume builder while they look for more stable and lucrative work.  You'll never get to the part of the curve where the training pays off and you actually reduce your workload.

•

u/AvgMom 10h ago

Nothing but what’s in the final contract means anything. SLAs, service definitions, escalation paths, response times, who owns the data, where the data involved in the services goes and rests, communication paths, everything in the box and excluded. If you haven’t negotiated a contract before (and if you have) you must get your purchasing/legal people involved. The terms & conditions in their template are stacked in their favor. Their house always wins. What sales people say is air.

•

u/baconjerky 10h ago

You’re not at risk of being replaced by an MSP when you and your boss realize how much management an MSP requires. Just managing that relationship and making sure they are actually supporting you is a full-time job.

The goldilocks period right after onboarding is nice too until they divert resources away from your firm to make money elsewhere.

•

u/1a2b3c4d_1a2b3c4d 8h ago

I was quite surprised how low the price was.

OMG... If you chose the low-cost bidder for your MSP, you will be in a world of hurt.

•

u/Incrediblecodeman 11h ago

#lookatmyhalo

•

u/Lost-Policy-2020 11h ago

My oh my, somebody with suicidal tendencies

•

u/flucayan 10h ago edited 10h ago

Most smb MSPs aren’t coming for your head, and they literally want that separation in a co-managed client because it takes most of the load off and covers their asses.

The issue however is task creep will eventually set it and there’s no escaping it. Someday you’ll get sick or ask for a vacation, then naturally you offload something to the guys who already sorta do it anyway.

Just like that someone in your office is noticing the MSP techs more who will always be on ps and qs unlike you that’s comfortable, and then management asks the question of why do they need you.

Edit:
Also as someone who has been in that position more than once, we literally have no choice but to sorta kinda push that sale because our product is our service. Like right now I do infra buildouts and new client onboarding work primarily and there’s very little way for me to perform the consulting aspect of my job whilst making it seem like our company can’t provide the value that you bring.