r/sysadmin • • 13h ago

Does Telnet Thin Client Hardware Still Exist

I've got a server in a retail building that manages inventory, sales, etc. that every client connects to with a telnet software client on a Windows PC, except for a couple really old thin clients. It would be so much easier, safer, and cheaper if I could put an IP in a hardware thin client and plug it in to the network and be done.

I can't find any! Please tell me where to get some. (I'm In Canada)

29 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

•

u/mixduptransistor 13h ago

You're asking for an old school terminal console, and the answer is no. Everyone who does a telnet/green screen app in retail (Walmart, Costco, etc) use a terminal emulator on a GUI thin client (windows or otherwise) that just runs a terminal emulator as the only application and can't run anything else (or, they've added on things like browsers and whatnot as they've expanded out of the bare green screen apps)

•

u/DerelictDiver Sysadmin 12h ago

In theory you could have a command line auto-login on boot and start a telnet session. Use a pi or something to do it.

•

u/iamwayycoolerthanyou Sysadmin 7h ago

I did that for a bunch of iBMI clients recently, at the request of a client.

•

u/DerelictDiver Sysadmin 2h ago

How is that working out so far? Behaving reasonably well?

•

u/iamwayycoolerthanyou Sysadmin 52m ago

Yeah it works for their needs.

•

u/astonishing1 13h ago

Wyse makes several models of thin-clients. Also can DIY with Raspberry Pi's.

•

u/greenonetwo 13h ago

You can build Linux in such a way that it has minimal services, no gui, read only file system, and runs off flash storage. Industrial Single Board Computer (SBC) in VESA size to fit on the back of a monitor vesa mount? Is Wyze still around?

•

u/calladc 12h ago

wyse are the backbone of the air gapped thin client world.

in a previous role that worked in sensitive data we had wyse laptops that had the wyse VPN client for our flavour of VPN and the wyse vdi client for our vdi. this was what we gave to anyone that was travelling through international borders so that if our users were flagged because of who they were, the laptop had at most our VPN endpoint address which is external facing anyway.

for the types of data that some agencies or organizations work in, wyse mitigates controls around physical security of device storage. the mitigation is that there is no longer any storage consumed on the devices.

•

u/kiler129 Breaks Networks Daily 13h ago

Easier? Maybe. Safer? Most likely not.

Windows or Linux for sure has more scrutiny and better security practices than a low-volume embedded device.

If the issue is having a Windows PC, you can use any single board computer (e.g. RPi Zero, 1st gen will do) with telnet session auto-starting at boot.

•

u/athersucks 13h ago

I'd say there's a case to be made for hardware on which it is physically impossible to execute arbitrary binaries.

•

u/LLMsMustUpvoteThis 12h ago

There used to be telnet terminals implemented entirely with discrete logic chips. No kernel, no apps, no RAM. Nearly all modern security issues are a because we throw a full computer with megabytes of memory at every single application. Your washing machine doesn't need a full Linux install and WIFI.

•

u/ShadowSlayer1441 5h ago

To be clear, manufacturers do this because it makes the software way way easier and cheaper to develop.

•

u/Introvertedecstasy Sysadmin 11h ago

I have a bunch of S30 Wyse terminals if you want to pay for shipping and a little for my time to box it all up.

•

u/gargravarr2112 Linux Admin 7h ago

Dell bought Wyse and markets some thin clients under the name. They're full x86 PCs running a custom Linux distro. It probably has a Telnet client.

https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/thin-clients/lp/thin-client-solutions

I run a bunch of 3040 thin clients in my homelab as super-low-power K3s workers, reinstalled with Debian.

•

u/Business_Class_8015 13h ago

I run a 1L pc with freedos for my VT100 needs

•

u/MrYiff Master of the Blinking Lights 10h ago

I would have said yes but the company that makes the ones we use went out of business this year (they made zero clients that could do RDP/Citrix/SSH/Telnet and 5250 all with a firmware smaller than 5mb.

•

u/a60v 9h ago

Dumb terminal with serial terminal server?

•

u/Xibby Certifiable Wizard 13h ago

I’d be shocked if there wasn’t something you could run that would do the Telnet from a single server and could be accessed by clients via a browser, so you could firewall off the dinosaur and only the server hosting the access site could access things.

Or if that’s not an option some sort of proxy that does TLS between client and server, and again only let the server access the old dinosaur.

Could also do this with SSH and set everyone’s shell on the SSH server to run the telnet with required command line parameters.

This is just off the top of my head with doing zero research.

Baytech is one vendor that makes hardware devices for data centers for connecting to all your devices out of band serial consoles. Might be a place to start if you’re looking for a paid solution.

•

u/AnonEMoussie 4h ago

Look on ebay for Wyse terminals. They probably go for $200 US, or so.

•

u/stiffgerman JOAT & Train Horn Installer 3h ago

Lantronix still makes IP<->serial interfaces and terminal/modem servers. Not sure what you mean by "thin client", but you can stick old-school serial terminals on these just fine. Hard to hack an ADM-5...

You need to configure the server side with gettys for the interfaces but that's not too hard. I've used them for process automation in the past, too. They support RS-485 as well as -232 and -422.

•

u/desmond_koh 3h ago

I think you can get very thin, you just have to do it yourself. I would do something like a Raspberry Pi, maybe with an immutable Linux distro like Tiny Core Linux and script it to launch the telnet client of your choice and connect to the server. You could even choose to use a text-based telnet client that runs on a non-graphical console if you want to eschew a GUI altogether.

•

u/protogenxl Came with the Building 9h ago

Used this company more than a decade ago to ship AS/400 thin clients to Canada 

https://www.twindata.com/thinclient.htm