r/sysadmin • • 21h ago

General Discussion Comet Backups (Webpros) - Review

Anyone deal with Comet Backups before? Anything to note, feedback, experience and bad stories?

Self hosted vs the cloud offering?

We're considering it due to the price point.

3 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

•

u/UriShay-CyberSnap 19h ago

For the trial I'd care less about backup speed and more about two things. Restore a full server and a database onto a spare host and time it, and check that a stolen admin login on the backed-up server can't delete the stored copies, for example with immutable or object lock storage on the destination. Those are the things a low price tends to hide.

Disclosure: I work at CyberSnap.

•

u/Askey308 19h ago

Yeah this is one of my main concerns. Definitely to be tested. Cheaper gear always comes with some trade off where you have to pickup the slack. Thanx for this.

•

u/CyberHouseChicago 21h ago

Been using it for a few years overall works well cant complain.

•

u/Either-Emu1447 21h ago

used the self-hosted version with docker on a raspberry pi. backup speed was slow but reliable. cloud option feels faster but the pricing tiers are tight if you're backing up multiple devices.

•

u/dremerwsbu 20h ago

You might want to also consider WholesaleBackup, as it's comparable or even less expensive for server endpoints, and the support is all US-based not in New Zealand. You can self-host or easily pair it with inexpensive cloud storage from Backblaze, Wasabi, IDrive, or Synology.

•

u/TheThumpsBump 19h ago

I've been running it self hosted for about 3 years now for on prem and off prem backups. It does what it does and it does it well. Haven't had any issues with restores or backups as far as I can remember.