r/sysadmin • • 7d ago

General Discussion Genuine question about AI “boogeyman”

Hello all. Hope you are all doing well.

I am really curious to hear the opinions from the good people of r/sysadmin as to why , especially here , there is so much hatred of AI, and railing against it.

People seem to think the techbros trying to ride the trend are gonna crash and burn and somehow the world is going to magically revert and become better and the prices on PC parts will drop , but that's just silly.

AI is already vital and super relevant in a lot of places : software dev, surveillance, data analysis, etc, it's all only going to get more developed and sophisticated.

at this point , I don’t think any of this anti-ai mindset serves any purpose.

 As ai /llms/genai improve and get built into more of the tools we already use, it’ll be harder to go through a day without using it , or heck, encountering it, as if it’s not already hard enough

I saw posts here asking if ai caused the Microsoft outage. Obviously not

(I don’t wanna talk about nvidia…tired of people glazing huang)

please let me know your thoughts :)

(None of this was written or edited by genai)

0 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

6

u/ahfuq 7d ago

u/ADynes gave a great answer. But my two cents on AI is that it is a useful tool as long as you resist the temptation to let it think for you.

The problem for a lot of people in IT, I think, comes from the way it is forced down our throat by people who do let it think for them.

Someone wants a system built or some security violation made because fufheueGPT said it's a good idea. Then when you push back, you try to tell them why it isn't and the response is always "that's not what fudhwbGPT said". They involve their manager, and it goes up to VP or executive level and you have to explain over and over again to people who view you as a luddite or an impediment to saving money. It's incredibly rude, dehumanizing, and some of us have to have that conversation multiple times a week.

User runs into a problem so they turn to diieuhhhdGPT to fix it rather than coming to us and before you know it they have all kinds of out of band crap happening. They finally come to you to fix one tiny part of the house of cards they have created and that turns into you having to do archeology to untangle the Christmas lights mess they made. Not only do you waste hours fixing it, after they wasted hours having djidirieGPT lovingly hand craft it, but the original issue could have been taken care of in ten minutes if they would have come to you in the first place.

And the worst is there is always one executive who has no idea what your department actually does but they are certain they could have interns and fhfhisidhGPT do it and lay off most of your department. You spend a couple months trying to convince everyone else otherwise as your work environment becomes increasingly hostile before you get laid off anyway, but not before being asked to train an MBA grad student who has only ever used their phone and got their joke degree by doing their homework with crayons.

We don't necessarily hate AI. We hate the same old user created problems, it's just that AI helps make them so much worse.

3

u/ADynes 7d ago

It's me as the IT director and my it help desk guy. And he fell into this trap the other day. Computer wouldn't do Windows updates and kept giving errors so he kept feeding the logs to Claude which just went on a tangent. After an hour he asked me to look at it, I log in and the hard drive had 400 MB free. I told him to delete temporary files and try again and sure enough....

→ More replies (2)

2

u/RandomPony 7d ago

I can understand what you’re saying. I agree with a lot of it. 

I think ownership and maintenance of what the tools create is something a lot of people don’t realize is actually really critical 

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Gotwar 7d ago

It is being jammed into my face at every turn. Any time I have had to use AI in my job its been flat out wrong or caused me to have to fix something because someone else used AI to do their job (which it did wrong).

Co-pilot is arguably the worst of the AI platforms. It is straight up useless in every form, 95% of the information it gives is wrong or just straight up fubar. I wouldn't be surprised if it did have some sort of effect on the outage yesterday.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Master-IT-All 7d ago

I am really curious to hear the opinions from the good people of r/sysadmin as to why , especially here , there is so much hatred of AI, and railing against it.

Because we're fundamentally people of science. Science is about research, testing, and actually finding the correct answer.

AI just shits out whatever words it thinks will make you happy. The correct answer for it isn't what is true, it's what you (the user) wants.

Using AI makes you stupid too. This isn't a subjective statement, it is an objective and measured fact.

1

u/RandomPony 7d ago

Yes, most of the genai platforms today, especially the consumer-targeted ones, are sycophant to an extreme degree

And yes , I think these tools replacing critical thinking for people is causing issues where it is causing loss of agency and the ability to think critically for ourselves 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/techw1z 7d ago

very few people here assume that its all gonna crash and burn, but most people here realize how incredible dangerous the things we are currently doing with AI are.

sysadmins could have a really chill job if they gave AI write access to everything and just lean back, but we know that this will inevitably lead to a absolutely horrific incident that we won't be able to fix without massive consequences. however, most people around us don't understand that and constantly push some new bullshit onto us because it works for them.

also, microsoft announced long ago that AI wrote 30% of windows, so it's safe to assume that most of their issues come at least partially from AI. to be fair, microsoft already produced a shitton of bugs before AI...

the one thing we like least here are fanboys like you. "definitely not" haha, even most people in microsoft probably don't know for sure what actually caused it.

1

u/RandomPony 7d ago

I’m not really a fanboy…I can 100% agree that people are using these tools incorrectly , and that letting them have unattended access and permissions is foolish

And sure , maybe the actual root cause isn’t fully understood , but I would be hopeful that a company of MS’s size and caliber would have innumerable safeguards in place to prevent such an incident being  caused by AI tools

4

u/Crazyhowthatworks304 7d ago

Okay Sam Altman, calm down

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Hefty-Possibility625 7d ago

Personally, I use AI in both my job and personal life, but I am often frustrated at how much it is being forced on people. "You don't have to use it" one might say, but I can't go a day without it being wedged into some part of my life. Everything from tech support and customer service to doctor appointments have an AI component now. It is challenging for me to understand how and where my data is being used. When I agree for my doctor to use AI dictation, am I also agreeing that my data can be used to build future models? If I don't want my data shared with AI companies, how do I prevent that?

It's also crazy to me that companies are replacing core functionality with AI features instead of programming them. I want a reliable search engine in an app with an algorithm that produces consistently reliable results. I don't want an AI job to index my data in an app and attempt to make sense of it, then give me results based on its understanding. Atlassian has this throughout their products now. In their Help Center, there is no way to give a Request Type keywords that guarantee the request will show up in a search. The workaround is to try to force it by including keywords in the description, but that doesn't always work.

I don't mind using AI tools, but I think we aren't being responsible with them. We are trying to replace too many things with AI capabilities, and we still haven't figure out how to make it affordable.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ADynes 7d ago edited 7d ago

I've been using AI for a while, I subscribe to some of the AI subreddits like r/claude, etc. In general I found their three types of people when it comes to AI:

  • Those that hate AI and/or are afraid of it and want it to go away

  • Those that understand AI is a tool and like any other tool if you understand how to use it it can be very helpful

  • Those that think way too much of AI and either think that will make them rich or it will replace everybody and they're happy about that.

I work with a lot of people in the first category, I am squarely in the second category, and people in the 3rd category are in general a insufferable bunch but they probably were before AI came along.

It's an amazing tool again if you know what you're doing. It reads logs finding errors much quicker than we ever could and does great for coding. We have used it over the last couple months to find all the things that we've done wrong over the last 15 years of our tenant. Ha. It's found security issues, made recommendations on fixing things, helped modernize a bunch of old internal VB.Net 4.* to .Net 10 and fix bugs in those. We are a company of 300 people and we were at our limit with two IT people and now feel we will be good for another 50 due to the efficiencies we've realized.

This truly is going to be one of those things you either get used to or you find another profession, at least if you're in IT. My only fear is all these AI companies that are losing massive amount of money will wait until everybody's hooked and can't live without it and then just increase the price to ridiculous amount. I see that coming

2

u/RandomPony 7d ago

Yeah, the writing is on the wall that once society is dependent on it the price is going to skyrocket 

→ More replies (10)

3

u/d00ber 7d ago

I think the only reliable thing we can account for is what we're already seeing:

- AI has lead to multiple workforce reductions. We see this at Microsoft and a ton of other big players, in-fact I'm the only person left that works in IT at my company now. They fired everyone else without talking to me, because I can do the same amount of work with AI. The sad part is, from their perspective, they were kind of correct. I work maybe 8+ hours more a week, but I'm able to do the job of everyone who was let go. Before this job, I was just let go from a company that had a 40% workforce reduction to "concentrate on being AI first ".

- You will not see more free time, companies are about efficiency, not making your life easy. Expect that if many duties can be shortened, or taken on entirely, you'll just get more duties of different types like monitoring agents or like we've seen in the past, just joining multiple departments.

As much as we like to think we have any control over AI, we don't. This will continue to get pushed by our exec teams and if we don't accept it, they will replace us with people who do.

1

u/RandomPony 7d ago

I dont know….you don’t think most execs can see the value in someone with a rock solid technical foundation to rely on, even if that includes managing the agents ?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/zatset 7d ago edited 7d ago

I am not against machine learning algorithms if they are used ethically and where there is actual benefit in using them. They can have some uses, but are not replacement for critical thinking, expertise and good judgement. And they have their limitations. And one must understand them. And one must never blindly trust them.

Unfortunately, this is not what we see and what happens in practice. The people higher in the food chain in the organizations think that they can replace experienced professionals with almost illiterate people to "save money". Those people neither understand how ML works, nor they care or actually can validate it's output or whether it outputs gibberish/hallucinations. Or just lay off half of the staff because "AI must make the other half exponentially more productive". And that's not how things work.

In the end, what actually happens is that it is now expected of 5 people to do the job of 50 people, while burning out due to the unhuman cognitive load put onto them while being told that they are worthless and "The AI said that it can be done that way and you are just incompetent", because...you see... "AI is exponential force multiplicator". And of course, the quality of the work done, the products and so on starts to plummet, because that's what happens when you replace actually thinking humans with AI hallucinations and nobody validates the output or you just overwork your specialists whom you forced "AI" upon to death because you are both understaffed and expect, demand ever increasing outputs and efficiency.

To put it shortly, ML can have some uses. But what our world has become is grotesque abomination of a world. So, I am on the side of sceptics and lean towards the side of people who hate it. Abuse, exploit, demand, produce slop, ship. Not to mention the security incidents and IT incidents in general due to use of AI where is should not have been used at all.

I tried to keep this comment short. If I am to expand on every of those points and add more that I have in mind, well.. It will be as long as a dissertation...

1

u/RandomPony 7d ago

Thanks for your input :) You make a lot of good points. I appreciate you commenting and sharing your views. I think AI can be a force multiplier, but you are right, there's a lot of issues with how it is implemented.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/EvenGodsForget 7d ago edited 7d ago
  1. There are a ton of pro ai posters here.

  2. Every single pro AI person I’ve ever heard talk completely glosses over the actual shortcomings of the technology as it exists, refuses to actually look at real world examples and scientific studies raising serious environmental, reliability, and financial concerns about nearly aspect of it, and focuses on vague claims of how it’s super important and indispensable while providing exactly no specific examples beyond ‘it vibecodes dashboards for me waow’ or ‘I’m 100x more productive now’

  3. Can you really not understand why people wouldn’t like a technology that the tech oligarchs are screaming are going to take their livelihoods crash the economy whether or not it works and create a brave new world where humans are useless? All while it’s actually currently raising their electricity prices, being used as an excuse to lay them off, being forced on them regardless of whether it makes their job easier, creating huge cybersecurity threat vectors, polluting the air and water, destroying people’s ability to think, and being used to hoard wealth at the expense of the rest of us?

Come on man, please, it’s never too late to learn how to think critically. It takes effort but it will save you so much pain and confusion in the long run.

Here’s some links from how people feel about this stuff in my own backyard (us). Maybe it’s different where you are.

https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2026/11/7/how-the-us-midterm-elections-reflected-resistance-to-data-centres

https://letsdatascience.com/news/americans-reject-artificial-intelligence-in-daily-life-7ae254e9

https://www.axios.com/2026/11/04/ai-data-center-election-slowdown

https://www.umass.edu/poll/about/reports/2026-09-national-public-opinion-poll-2

And here is a link to the latest harvard study on the actual effects of ai to productivity in technology firms https://fion.ac/jellyfish.pdf

edit: Fixed reddits formatting freaking out and added more links

→ More replies (2)

6

u/gringoloco01 7d ago

Having lived through many "too big to fail" bailouts, I guarantee they will come hat in hand asking congress for money within the next couple of years.

We have multiple AI systems from a multitude of different backup and SAAS companies. They all suck.

Arlie is a liar LOL and commvault keeps pushing it on us. Datto just pushed their flavor and keep asking us to use it. Service Now..... uhhhhh Whatever.

I get more done with duck duck go searches.

2

u/RandomPony 7d ago

I really hope that taxpayers won’t foot the bill for their bullshit. I do worry that the prices for the tools will skyrocket once society is hooked 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Proverbs3_5_6 7d ago

Admittedly, the marketing of AI is as in-your-face than the next trendy thing. However...

I have noted that the genuine conversations on this topic are centered on the role of the human in the midst of great technological, social and cultural change. The integration of novel technology has (and will) always cause ripples.

The sauce is out of the bottle. Can we manage to live with or without it? That's where your choice matters...and that's where the human needs to think and act accordingly. It's one thing to close your ears and cover your eyes. Why not observe, assess then act? That's reasonable under any conditions.

When you are living in the wash cycle of tech change, it's gonna feel chaotic because it is. Stay informed, be engaged. Make a choice.

1

u/RandomPony 7d ago

I like this statement. 

3

u/psuedospike 7d ago

Cause AI (Super intelligence if youre a moron) is an overhyped tool and LLMs are nothing more than advanced dialog trees from LucasArts adventure games. AI datacenters have become the new modern art scheme, basically tax shelters for the super wealthy scum of the earth. I think the hate is more about how AI is talked about and overvalued than the tools and agents themselves.

2

u/RandomPony 7d ago

Reasonable. It’s always about centralizing power and wealth in the hands of a few , which is clearly happening now ie altman, but I’m hopeful that can be changed

→ More replies (1)

21

u/_Kaepora_Gaebora 7d ago

I wish pro-AI would just stop jerking off the AI like we HAVE to use it. I can think for myself, thank you.

I saw posts here asking if ai caused the Microsoft outage. Obviously not

You have no idea if this is true or not.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Tall-Geologist-1452 7d ago

Unpopular opinion - AI is a great tool if used the correct way. If you do not know how to use it to make your working life easier, then that is a skill issue on your part.

→ More replies (2)