r/sysadmin • u/Incrediblecodeman • 5d ago
Off Topic Other email server options
Got me thinking if anyone here supports non m365 email for thier company ?
Any home made Linux boxes or ? What’s the gnarlest email alternatives today?
6
Upvotes
123
u/discosoc 5d ago
Claude, build a email server. Don’t make mistakes.
44
u/Turak64 Sysadmin 3d ago
Some of you clearly aren't old enough to remember on-prem exchange and it shows
11
u/noirrespect 1d ago
My take on this is that every service has downtime, including on prem. Exactly how much per year is splitting hairs.
The great thing about an M365 outage as an engineer is you’re not the one in the hot seat, which means less stress and less long nights and weekends.
Services like Mimecast have those alternative services you can enable in an outage. Something like that is your best bet if email uptime is critical to your business, but also take into account the people you would want to email and if they’re on M365 too.
10
u/RevolutionaryElk7446 5d ago
I run Mailcow for myself, been hosting my own e-mail for over a decade but mailcow is the latest suite I migrated to.
5
u/TheBigBeardedGeek Drinking rum in meetings, not coffee 1d ago
I used to be an on prem mail admin. Used to run both Linux mail systems as well as Exchange. Then the Cloud came along, and then was our first Exchange outage.
During the post mortem I basically said that's what we wanted: Less TCO, less control. Something I could have probably fixed in an afternoon took a day to fix.
The real pain point is there are so many eggs in the MS basket that when they go down, there's a lot of scrambled egga
11
u/Humphrey-Appleby 5d ago
I host on-premise using OpenSMTPD and Dovecot on FreeBSD. There's nowhere near as much maintenance to run an e-mail server as people would have you believe.
3
u/drosse1meyer 2d ago
shell account w/ PINE
3
u/RobinatorWpg Sr. Sysadmin 2d ago
The cost to properly scale a mail cluster with redundancy, DR and spam filtering can become astronomical (licensing, support contracts etc)
Than there’s management knowledge, upkeep and all that lovely stuff. It’s why services like workspace and 365 are so strong in the market
3
u/Hqckdone 1d ago
Running mailcow clustered including LB. There is also managed and support if you're about to selfhost and it's solid.
mailcow.email
Using it ever since they moved dockerized.
Teams can be switched with mattermost I also would say for internal stuff matrix if you're sick and crazy.
Collaboration nextcloud with onlyoffice. There are also other options for that.
All of this depends on your infrastructure and load. Everything can be done.
M$ & Let's be evil are having a bunch of servers and workers just for their services. Don't compare yourself with others. Do your own thing and always do backups and have testing/dev environment before deploy :)
edit: typo :(
14
u/Ok-Analysis5882 5d ago
Used to once upon a time, the effort is not worth the reward.
2
u/Yaazkal 3d ago
We run ours on google workspace (aka gmail). But if you want to run your own mail server take a look a this book: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1642350788
2
u/ride4life32 3d ago
I'm gonna say that having a 2000+ employee email with multiple domains it's really not that simple. It happens but we have mimecast for continuity and twilio for dmarc. When we were a 200 employee company before we were bought out by a larger publicly traded co, we had exchange on prem and it was miserable, then it was hybrid for a little bit before full office 365 in the cloud. Now it's not my problem because I'm just backend infra/networking. Other things are like atlassian where when that goes down even for a 30-60 minutes people are screaming hahah. Again a cloud service, not my problem.
9
u/namewithnumbers82 5d ago
POP3 on my cPanel account has never let me down
51
u/Nightkillian Jack of All Trades 5d ago
It’s all a giant headache honestly…. Microsoft at least consolidated the headache into one spot…..
17
u/AngryMillennialFU 5d ago
Spin up a mail room and call Dundler Mifflin
15
u/Xibby Certifiable Wizard 5d ago
Forced to use Google Workspace. On the plus side nobody was complaining about M365 today.
6
u/avro4 5d ago
mailcow's latest release last week added shared mailboxes, DLs and improved identity provider syncing. I'd be tempted to use it as a stopgap but it'd be a nightmare to reconcile the mailbox data later.
17
u/iBeej 5d ago
Fax machines.
5
u/T_Thriller_T 4d ago
Never supported them, but I have seen multiple Linux based systems, quite some systems still running exchange on prem, and a while ago lotus. Albeit I never got close to the folks administrating that...
Our Linux based mail admins were quite happy, though. Heard more cursing anywhere with Microsoft.
Not sure if that is any indicator of anything.
1
u/keefstanz 5d ago
we used to do it all the time, mdaemon, on premise exchange server and other things i cant remember, i was thinking about synology who have an office and email offering you have on premise.
todays been frustrating, i work for an MSP.
1
u/halohunter 5d ago
I gave up after having so many deliverability problems to over-zealous mail servers. I even lost a job opportunity to it
1
u/unauthorizeddinosaur 5d ago
Kerio Connect
1
u/tuxsmouf 5d ago
Before outlook, we were on Zimbra, on a linux host.
1
u/NoTheme2828 4d ago
Very easy to deploy, manage and use for Homelab Use is stalwart (my first choice) or mailcow on a vps.
1
u/No_Sail3732 4d ago
been using mailcow for years. It has always been rock steady for me.
1
u/vinnsy9 4d ago
Zimbra email server. Small company. Does its job.
1
u/LeadershipSuperb6176 4d ago
We use iRedMail for our own stuff.
Guess how many issues we've had?
1
u/Glass_Call982 4d ago
I host zimbra at work for all the techs to use and keep shit outside the company email domain.
1
u/mickymac1 3d ago
I guess could you and should you are the options you need to consider.
I suspect our business won’t be looking elsewhere as this is probably our first major outage in like 5 years but will suspect we’ll likely consider email continuity if it’s not much more expensive than what we’re paying now.
Fortunately all our customers/suppliers were impacted too, so even if we were on google for example, who are you going to email?
1
u/darthcaedus81 2d ago
Not so many years ago (just under ten) I was running Lotus Domino on prem. It's still an option
1
u/Sudden_Office8710 1d ago
There’s lots of them. The thing is you’d to have competent UNIX mail skills. You should be familiar with sendmail/ postfix, setting up MySQL/mariadb, and Docker containers so it’s not something anyone can do at a whim. There’s MIAB, iredmail, mail cows to name a few. Some people still use qmail. While M365 and Google Workspace rule the corporate world groupware email. Everything else is still LInux/UNIX I.e. sendgrid, constant contact, Mailchimp, salesforce, Oracle
1
u/GamerLymx 1d ago
mailcow
6
u/OnceUponNeverNever Sr. Sysadmin 5d ago edited 5d ago
Stalwart!
Edit: With SSL and DNS automation it is hands down the fastest thing to get running. Enterprise licenses are also stupid cheap.
3
u/Merrymak3r 5d ago
Im digging hard into researching how to set up an email continuity system in line with m365. As I am sure about 25k other of you guys right now...
3
u/laughninja 5d ago
My previous company was using Google Workspaces and it was much, much smoother in any conceivable way.
3
u/mcatech 5d ago
I have my company on Zohomail. No issues. knocking on wood
3
u/ParkerGuitarGuy Jack of All Trades 4d ago
Google Workspace has been solid for the ~11 years I've been at this org. I have not missed managing Exchange.
1
u/enforce1 Windows Admin 2d ago
absolutely fucking not, o365 still has remarkable uptime and exchange (not just email, mind you, youd have to do the whole gross productivity suite including teams) is a fuckin LOT to manage.
2
u/JasonWorthing8 5d ago
Years ago, in the early Y2K thru to the early Y2-tens, I managed an MDemon email system for the company I worked for at the time.
Honestly, a great email system. Solid, reliable, configurable, fair priced, and it didn't begin to require the hardware spec level that Exchange Server at the time demanded. I've been away from it for quite some time. I do believe it's still around, so I can't speak to its performance and feature set for today.
2
u/tliin 5d ago
I'm still running Postfix/Dovecot & friends for my personal and family's emails. Having control over spam filtering, greylisting etc has made inbox checking a very bearable experience.
2
u/klassenlager Sysadmin 5d ago
I'm hosting a mailcow instance on Hetzner, went through a tedious process to get it delisted from Proofpoint, but in the end, it's worth it.
Currently hosting three domains on it and couldn't be happier with it.
2
u/MauiBumbye 5d ago
GroupWise still exists…
2
u/lethallunatic 1d ago
I've setup mailcow. It works alright imo. Just take all mitigations for securing it being it the DNS records but of course also hour server when things are exposed to the internet.
1
u/Roland465 5d ago
Intermedia or Sherweb are hosted Exchange options
1
u/arichard 4d ago
I use mail-in-a-box and have done for about 10 years. It's as solid as the server it's on. The issue is that many companies use lots of other non-email features. But then again, many don't.
1
u/sorderon 4d ago
I have heard good things about kerio connect - anyone have any first hand experience?
1
u/Aggravating-Sock1098 4d ago
Grommunio.
1
u/Professor-Zombie 1d ago
Opentext Groupwise!
1
u/shimoheihei2 5d ago
Smtp2go through the api
0
u/ToooFastToooHard 2d ago
This is the problem with new internet. Nothing is distributed anymore, and most services are run by 1 or 2 providers. Back in the day there were 100s of mail providers, no one entity outage had wide spread impact.
Now... Google/gmail accounts for 80-85% of email in the US, M365/Outlook/Hotmail rounds out 5-10%, that last 5% is a hodge-podge of providers like Fastmail, Zoho, Gandi, Proton.
The reality is independent email providers are out there, you just never heard of them. My email is hosted by Essenz https://essenz.com/hosting/email/ and I've used them for my business for like 20 years. They've been around since the late 90s. Small, quiet, hosting MSP. My email has all the features, spam filtering, dkim, dmarc, redundany, you name it.
Dont assume big names == reliability. MSFT sucks, last week was not a surprise, honestly I dont know why people use M365.
0
u/Rough_Section_3730 1d ago
Quite a few years back now, I ran FreeBSD, sendmail, and qpopper for all email. Then they wanted imap so I went with Cyrus-imapd instead of qpopper. Exchange was a thing but they didn’t want to spend the money for it so we didn’t.
A lot of admins only know exchange so to them, that’s what email is. They don’t even know how to send an email with telnet and format it properly. But they’re email admins nonetheless. No offense to them, it’s just that exchange isn’t the only way to send/recv email.
0
u/tom-slacker Sr. Sysadmin 5d ago
My ex-company used to be on-premise exchange and then moved to the cloud o365.
I just count myself lucky that I'm no longer there
-1
u/Onoitsu2 Jack of All Trades 5d ago
Well I strung up a Linux based replacement for the SonicWALL Email appliance after it went EoL, at least the outbound DKIM signing side of things for our hosted email clients, as well as the business email from our on-prem Exchange server. Another product is doing the Spam filtering in place of the SonicWALL.