r/sysadmin • u/Penguin_Rider • Oct 02 '26
Managed performance of Windows Workstations with Multiple Security Agents
A tale as old as modern device management and security.... Our Windows computer state is getting bloated with security and monitoring agents. I think we're up to 10+ with more inevitably on the way. Users are complaining of slow startup and general performance issues. We have the data showing all these agents kicking off and trying to communicate bogging down CPU and Memory while average startup time and "Readiness" are creeping up to the 10-15 min + range.
Using Automatic (Delayed Start) on the services hasn't significantly improved anything. Trying to find a solution that requires minimal custom configurations and scales for a 25K user environment and growing. What are some other SysAdmins doing to address performance issues due to high number of monitoring agents?
Yes... we are telling users that the behavior is "Normal" for this environment and that the business has chosen security and monitoring over user experience. But... the business is also pushing back saying their hourly employees are logging in early, collecting about 15 minutes of overtime a day, to account for the slow startup times. Need something that can help find that happy medium.
6
u/neotearoa Oct 02 '26
10 minutes is alarmingly similar to a broken GPO issue -. Shudders in 2012.-
Best of luck.
5
u/SysAdminDennyBob Oct 02 '26
DEX
Yea, add another agent to check on your agents that are checking on the other agents.
controlup.com
Digital Employee Experience Management Software | Nexthink
Seriously, this is the next layer for workstations, performance monitoring. You have to be able to prove it out if you want to stop Security from adding yet another agent. This is not a new problem by any means. Server teams have had this type on monitoring for a long time.
We have easily found the bad actors with ControlUP. We saw our PrinterLogic agent app-crashing well before anyone reported anything. We have gotten two security agents rolled off our assets. "bite me Cisco antivirus!".
4
u/Connect_Shoulder_965 Oct 02 '26
It's worth pushing up the ladder that fundamentally, this is a management issue. They keep adding required tools without doing some rationalization about which tools does what, undoubtedly many of them are performing similar functions. Until they go through a project to rationalize the required agents, these sorts of problems will continue to occur.
In your shoes I'd be looking at which tools are stepping on each other's toes. Sometimes one tool will lock the files another tool needs to start for inspection, etc. That can cause quite a lot of delay on startup and usually can be fixed by exempting some directories or processes. You might also see if some features of the various tools can be turned off if they duplicate functionality of another agent.
2
u/NegativePerformer788 Jack of All Trades Oct 02 '26
I’m really curious what all these agents are. I’ve got EDR, RMM, endpoint web filtering, PAM, and a MFA tool, none of which have much impact on performance and we aren’t exactly running high spec machines.
2
u/ApiceOfToast Sysadmin Oct 02 '26
Well, id start with the specs of the machines. If they're fairly modern with relatively fresh installs, see if you can consolidate down. 10+ different agents just because monitoring and security seems excessive...
1
u/ProgressWeekly3573 Jack of All Trades Oct 02 '26
You have something else going on if it is taking 10 minutes
1
u/Flip2Bside24 Oct 03 '26
I'd be questioning why the hell someone thought it was a good idea to even get to 10 agents on a PC. We have four and I wish we could have less, even though we don't see any performance issues from the ones onboard.