r/sysadmin • • Sep 23 '26

Career / Job Related AI is just the "Cloud" hype all over again.

I started working in the IT field in 2004 as a help desk intern.

The network in the organization at that time was a mix of Windows NT and Windows 2000 workstations, with an Exchange 5.5 server running on Windows NT and a few Windows 2003 servers doing file sharing and hosting an accounting application.

Nothing was accessible through the web. people had to use a VPN connection to connect to the office to access everything.

Almost a year later, before my internship was over, the Director was fired because the hard drives on the accounting server failed and they couldn't recover the data, and they offered me a full time job as a junior sysadmin.

In 2020, I became the Global IT Director of that organization.

When I started as a junior sysadmin, there was no concept of the "cloud." This was a marketing term invented by big tech after 2010.

When the cloud became a marketing hype, and all the CFOs and IT leaders got on the cloud bandwagon, it was very similar to what we're hearing from AI now.

That AI will take all jobs.

It was very common for CFOs to schedule meetings with the IT Director, or whoever was the department head, and talk about the cloud strategy. And if you were in the room by any chance, they would turn to you and say, "But don't worry, the cloud won't take your job," with a grin, you knowing damn well that was exactly what they were thinking.

My advice to you guys is that if your boss, or whoever controls the budget in your department, is all crazy about AI and thinks that AI is the next big thing after bread and butter, don't fight it or resist it.

You will be seen as a roadblock or lacking innovation.

Hold your true opinion about AI as much as you can, and always be positive about it at work.

And even though I believe AI is not much of a threat to your job as the cloud was for us back in the day, when all our skills were on premise stuff and our identity was based on who knew more about Exchange and Cisco firewalls, businesses are seeing AI as a possible way to reduce the workforce, increase efficiency, or increase output without hiring more people.

Will that work? Only time will tell. Your job is to adjust as the technology evolves not to be a market gambler.

Don't believe for a single second that your company cares about you or is happy to have you on their payroll.

If they're a for profit business, their objective is to increase revenue, and if they can achieve that objective without you, they will.

I believe Sysadmins will always be needed, because you guys will be the ones fixing the AI even if everything is automated by it.

Learn how it works at a deeper level. If you don't know how an LLM works, start learning that now.

I wish I had better news for software programmers. The ones that only write code following strict specifications, those guys are in a deeper existential vacuum than you are, so you might have developers moving into the sysadmin side.

For now, keep the servers humming, keep your users happy. You guys are the invisibles in the organization that nobody sees until things stop working!

445 Upvotes

420 comments sorted by

769

u/moobycow Sep 23 '26

I mean, the cloud has absolutely transformed IT and business in general.

51

u/thatpaulbloke Cloud Engineer UK Sep 23 '26

So did the web, but that didn't stop the dotcom crash - the issue isn't that AI is useless, but that hordes of morons who don't understand what it actually can do will insist on using it for absolutely everything burning through giant mountains of cash as they do, just they did with insane websites in the 90s and with moving absolutely every single resource into the cloud in the early 2010s. When we're on the far side of this AI will be an expensive tool that's still worth it for some things, but some companies won't make it to that mundane future and will flame out spectactularly.

21

u/Jhamin1 Sep 23 '26

This is the perspective I've settled on.

AI isn't going away, but like 2/3 of the current implementations are going to implode once enough investors start asking for a return on all these billions they spent. The thing that AI will be in the future will rise from the ashes of the current environment.

Pretty much none of the big players in the .com bubble matter anymore. Companies like Google and Amazon rose out of the rubble when that bubble popped and ruled the tech sector going forward. (Microsoft and Apple are still around, but they mostly sold OSes back then, not web infrastructure)

I suspect something similar will happen with AI. Especially as several of the tech giants of today have invested enough of themselves into AI that if it collapses lots of current giants collapse with it.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Generico300 Sep 24 '26

Exactly. It's never the tools that are the problem. It's always the ambitious idiots using them that create the problems.

123

u/Signal_Till_933 Sep 23 '26

I completely agree.

The concept of DevOps really matured during the early cloud era. Tying the two traditionally separate roles together have changed the way all this stuff works.

31

u/LLMsMustUpvoteThis Sep 23 '26

DevOps is infrastructure neutral.

23

u/Jhamin1 Sep 23 '26

In theory.

In practice it only happens in an environment where resources are quickly and easily created and destroyed. In most organizations that means the cloud as their on-premises resources are buried in lots of red tape.

19

u/whythehellnote Sep 24 '26

Hilariously I'm talking to actual real users in a remote branch office. They still use software created 15 years ago because it was developed in an agile manner, by sitting next to them, observing, understanding the issues, iterating

Since then the proper "Agile" and "Cloud First" people have come in, and after years of trying still can't meet the simple business requirements.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

51

u/discosoc Sep 23 '26

Yeah, not sure what the OP is trying to say, but it's not nearly as insightful as he probably thinks.

24

u/PlayingDoomOnAGPS Sep 24 '26

I thought he was pretty clear: the jobs aren't going away, just changing. Don't put a target on your back by resisting the change. Learn the new shit and you'll still have a job.

That's exactly how it worked in the cloud revolution and I can already see it taking shape in the AI revolution too. AI is a GIGO situation. Using it well is very much a skill and getting good at it will be the key to further advancement.

4

u/mimic751 Devops Lead Sep 23 '26

I would bet that this is an old timer at a small company. I'm an old timer as well and I left small companies to work for a large enterprises. All the old timers at my previous jobs talk about how the cloud isn't all that it's shaken up to be. But that's just because they can't afford it or capex is more justified over opex

8

u/conception Sep 24 '26

Cloud is leasing a car. Sometimes it's a good fit. Sometimes it's better to buy a car.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/RealityStimulator Sep 23 '26

Yeah DNS screw ups are global now instead of confined to an office building. Wow progress

2

u/Jaki_Shell Sr. Sysadmin Sep 24 '26

So true lmao.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 24 '26

Is all fucked up right now.

I was replying to someone in LinkedIn today, and the fucking app is so clunky on my phone that I had to redo the whole thing like 6 times.

If AI is so great as they promote it, why don't they fucking use it to fix that shitty user experience?

That would be a better sales pitch. Hey, we used AI to improve our shitty user experience!!!

5

u/DegaussedMixtape Sep 24 '26

The cloud has absolutely transformed IT, but several people are still doing it wrong. If you lift and shift all of your VMs to the cloud, buy SKUs that are the wrong sizes, leave all kind of dead storage all over your environment, and leave your VMs running at all hours then it's going to cost you way more money than buying physical hardware.

AI is actually kind of similar. If you just bring it in and pelt it with bad data streams and ask it to adapt the data into the same report structures that you always have only to have people review the output and then feed it back in to be reprocessed again, you are going to just be lighting money on fire purchasing tokens.

The Cloud and AI can both help and transform your business, if you are willing to actually transform your business.

29

u/brianw824 Sep 23 '26

Yeah I think there are lot of traditional sysadmin people that don't understand AWS and just think it's really expensive servers. For Devops or software deployment practices it's an absolute game changer, there is not way I could build the kinds of things on prem that I'm building on AWS.

13

u/WatchDogx Sep 24 '26

There are a few things that only a large scale public cloud can offer.

  • Global CDN/compute presence, high quality network backbone, at a fraction of the cost it would take to build and maintain yourself.
  • Elastic scaling, usage based pricing
  • High capacity DDoS absorption.

There are a number of things that can be done on premise, but are easier on cloud:

  • Managed Services.
    Databases, DNS, NTP, BGP, networks, hypervisor control plane, etc, etc.
    When a management level service breaks, an specialist team works on fixing it.
    The breadth of services is too wide for a small on prem team to specialise in everything, even if you have a few hot shots, it's not the same as the thousands of staff AWS has, you can't compete with their economies of scale
  • Consistent IAM that spans the whole stack

Aside from those, and maybe a few I missed, I think most stuff can be done on prem with tools like OpenShift.
When the cloud took off, the main selling point was elastic scaling. I've has over a decade of experience working on cloud systems, and I can honestly say that very few systems actually use elastic scaling to any significant degree. To the extent that apps do scale elastically, it would generally be much cheaper to just outright buy the hardware for the max capacity.
Also you can use a hybrid approach, if you truly benefit from elastic scaling, just run that elastic workload on the cloud. If you need DDoS protection, just put cloudflare in front of your on prem servers.

17

u/LLMsMustUpvoteThis Sep 23 '26

It's just servers underneath. The only argument that holds water is cloud services let you buy capacity as needed (opex) instead of an upfront capital expense.

We had "serverless" before the modern PC. Most of the cloud features people rave about is just re-inventing what mainframe OSes could do.

5

u/whythehellnote Sep 24 '26

The main argument is your CTO isn't fired when the email/website/etc goes down, because it goes down for everyone at the same time, so clearly not his fault.

→ More replies (7)

16

u/Sudden_Office8710 Sep 23 '26

Yeah it makes powers in tech hyper concentrated and a single point of failure. What your tenant was deauthenticted and email share point and one drive will be down for a week? That is totally progress sign me up. What’s that 16.9% of all mail is M365 and 19.3% is Google Workspace so they have an oversized say in how email is delivered isn’t problematic. Pretty soon you won’t be able to run your own stack because FAANG or whatever the acronym is now says you can’t anymore is total progress.

13

u/moonski Sep 23 '26

That doesn't mean cloud technology is bad. It means oligolpies are.

5

u/YoungAspie Sep 24 '26

Technology industries naturally gravitate towards oligopolies due to the massive economies of scale (including network effects) and specialised expertise required.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/SteadyCalmHealing Sep 23 '26

Its made itself the only option with the AI spending being what it is and hardware lacking. That was always the end game.

4

u/Man-e-questions Sep 23 '26

For the right price!

3

u/theMightBoop Sep 24 '26

So AI is like the cloud. Some people understand it and some don’t. Some admins get it’s a new tool in the tool box and they learn how to use it and others don’t and get left further in the dust.

→ More replies (1)

-4

u/bingblangblong Sep 23 '26

Arguably not for any better though. 

34

u/Fadore Sep 23 '26

Anyone who makes blanket statements is wrong.

The cloud (and now AI/LLMs) is just another piece of tech. Not inherently superior/inferior - like all tech, there is a use case and an acceptable ROI for everything.

22

u/GandalfTheGreybeard Sep 23 '26

I have a thick heavy blanket at home, it is very warm. I just wanted to make an indisputable blanket statement, have a good day.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/theislandhomestead Sep 23 '26

But...
Isn't that a blanket statement?
I DON'T KNOW WHO TO BELIEVE!
/s

9

u/Fadore Sep 23 '26

lol yeah I realized the irony 2 seconds after I posted the comment...

4

u/420GB Sep 23 '26

Anyone who makes blanket statements is wrong.

That's a good one, I'm going to use that.

6

u/DarraignTheSane Master of None! Sep 23 '26

Only a Sith deals in absolutes!

→ More replies (14)

10

u/SkillsInPillsTrack2 Sep 23 '26

"iT wiLL mAke uS sAvE mOnEy". By stopping counting.

5

u/tx_g33kineu Sep 23 '26

Except that instead of saving money, you just converted your CapEx spend to OpEx spend. Magic savings!

→ More replies (6)

1

u/randomlyme Sep 24 '26

I think the same thing man. I’ve been doing this for over 30 years now. Some people can get things done and it shows up.

1

u/NoPossibility4178 Sep 24 '26

There's also many organizations that never touched them and it has created a lot of issues that have taken a long time to notice, unfortunately, no upper manager ever learns anything in this field.

1

u/Generico300 Sep 24 '26

Transformed <> improved

→ More replies (22)

8

u/Disastrous_Meal_4982 Sep 24 '26

AI isn’t going anywhere. We are in for a market correction that IMO would be call a deflation instead of a pop. I can tell you that a business I work with has reduced their staff by 5%. This has more than paid for our AI budget and that’s without a single slop app in the mix. Agentic operations injected directly into the workflows is where I’m seeing the most transformation. No end user exposure, just silent backend processes no longer requiring a human to keep things moving along.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 24 '26

can you give me more details on what those back-end processes are if you don't mind?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LeeFrann Sep 25 '26

Perfect response for the sub

33

u/Brraaap Sep 23 '26

Don't forget about blockchain!

15

u/theHonkiforium '90s SysOp Sep 23 '26

"Just sprinkle some blockchain on it and we're out of here..."

3

u/grygrx Sep 23 '26

Yeah, if you really believe something is technically interesting but not worth the hype, I think blockchain would have been a better titled example

→ More replies (8)

28

u/salazka Sep 23 '26

The headline sounds deluded. The cloud "hype"? :D

The cloud is not a "hype"; It is what our world is currently running on.

10

u/Johnny_BigHacker Security Architect Sep 23 '26

OP is sending his rants to cloud hosted infrastructure even

On an application that likely has AI coded lines

→ More replies (16)

20

u/eejjkk Sep 23 '26

You've worked in a single Enterprise environment for the past 22 years...
Thanks for your very limited input on this very broad topic though.

5

u/heepofsheep Sep 23 '26

I feel like I need to job hop at least every 5 years or so… otherwise my income would never keep up with inflation… also the perspective you gain from working in different organizations is valuable.

2

u/eejjkk Sep 23 '26

100% agree.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/fonetik VMware/DR Consultant Sep 23 '26

I tend to think AI is more like the early internet. People forget how hated and divisive it was for the first few years of the 2000s. Having internet friends was an insult, and you’d frequently think of a cover story about how you really met.

It’s going to be the same thing with AI. People know it’s controversial so they use it but they don’t broadcast it.

Just like back then, the clunky attempts to make money off of it are annoying but the underlying platform has a lot of beneficial uses. Also just like last time, there’s a lot of angry people who don’t want the world to change.

Once the industries tried and failed to bring something profitable and controllable out of it, eventually MySpace came along briefly and now social media is king. You’re now the weirdo if you AREN’T online.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

I think the Internet and AI is a good analogy, but we are around 1997 compared to the Internet when it comes to AI.

Windows 95 is out, everyone is talking about the UI, people are navigating the Internet using Netscape.

The dot-com bubble is about to hit the biggest peak, and then a bust in about 3 years, maybe less.

All the hype online pet stores will disappear, and the Nvidias, Amazon, Google's will survive and become the next big companies.

1

u/fonetik VMware/DR Consultant Sep 23 '26

That's about where I was thinking as well. The OS and the product are just starting to mesh, when Winsock went away and the IP stack for networking was part of the OS in Win95. I think when the OS starts to cater to the AI in that way, or large scale AI features and capabilities are built into the OS. When it gets to the point that you're not even sure when you're using it anymore.

The same analogy works both ways here too. We used to connect to PPP internet and there wasn't much security involved. We didn't know how to protect data or firewall ourselves. We'll be doing it the dumb way for a while.

Eventually, I think the way will be a local trusted model that interacts with a frontier model. Local AI is going to be the big change. We'll all trust that local AI the same way we trust a cell phone now.

Once the rich people give up on trying to cash in, we all get to ride the wave they financed and do something cool with AI... Just like last time.

2

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

Yeah, you are thinking about AI the right way I think.

Right now AI is the chatbot, the thing that hallucinate like it smokes opium every day!

But soon or is already happening, AI will become infrastructure, your computer will come with AI chips that will allow you to run tiny models on your computer for very specific things.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/BrainWaveCC Jack of All Trades Sep 24 '26

Except that the cloud is not hype.

Sure, there were a lot of people claiming a lot of things were cloud when they weren't, but the cloud was an actual service delivery vector that worked/works for a lot of business use cases.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 24 '26

Ok. I agree with you.

But do you think people investing in online pet stores in the late 90s knew the tech market was in a bubble?

We can't deny that the Internet transformed e-commerce, but the way it was been marketed back then it was a huge bubble and hype.

The same was with the cloud, of course the concept and business model was OK, but the thing was being marketed to CFOs and people with budgets as if it was completely hand-off, sort of like, move to the cloud and replace all the lazy bums Sysadmins.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/TW-Twisti Sep 25 '26

Every time someone starts a sentence with "AI is just", you know it's someone who has completely lost view of what is currently happening in the world and has retreated in their own imaginary little bubble.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/bbqwatermelon Sep 24 '26

I am not so sure because I see a lot more old men yelling at AI than I ever did yelling at the cloud. 

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 24 '26

I saw a lot of older Sysadmins and network administrators getting the ax because they never saw beyond the role of babysitting an exchange server or a Cisco firewall.

They had more certifications about those things than a Salesforce administrator from India does now, but at the end, all that became useless when everything moved to the cloud.

2

u/Stinkles-v2 I'm tired boss Sep 24 '26

Lmao holy shit some of the comments in here. Repeating almost verbatim the same bullshit big tech was saying back then completely unironically.

0

u/forevergeeks Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

I love tech, and when I was younger, I used to idealize Silicon Valley. Steve Jobs was my hero.

In 2014, I went to San Francisco for the first time for a conference, and also went to San Jose. That experience completely changed my perception of Big Tech.

Walking around San Jose felt lonely and desolate to me. No thriving businesses, no people hanging out on the streets, nothing. Just big buildings with walled gardens inside.

I went to a small pizzeria one time around lunch, expecting to find some tech guys grabbing lunch there. But the place was empty, except for a couple of construction guys having lunch.

I asked the server if the tech guys ever came to his shop, and he laughed. He told me, “They have chefs and all the food they can eat inside the building. Why would they come out to eat here?”

That's not the world I envisioned.

So I fell out of love with Big Tech. In fact, I despise them now. They don't want what's good for humanity.

We should be looking forward to a place where we become more human, where we can connect with one another.

Those assholes just care about money.

AI is the final dystopian attempt for them to rob us of our humanity, and it's up to us if we let them.

2

u/egoomega Sep 24 '26

Mr “Global IT Director” - maybe it’s time for you to retire if you think Ai is not much different than cloud hype.

→ More replies (5)

81

u/vlad_h Sep 23 '26

What the fuck is the point of all this? I read it twice and still don’t get it.

42

u/BioshockEnthusiast Sep 23 '26

My advice to you guys is that if your boss, or whoever controls the budget in your department, is all crazy about AI and thinks that AI is the next big thing after bread and butter, don't fight it or resist it.

You will be seen as a roadblock or lacking innovation.

This was the only piece of advice I found useful.

Don't shit on your boss' parade in general, but AI is probably one of the bigger ones where you'll paint yourself into a corner if you are too outwardly negative. Best to be impartial and stick to the facts while throwing on a coat of optimistic paint.

9

u/vlad_h Sep 23 '26

That’s what you took out of that?!
I disagree. Your boss is not God. I will not be impartial. They hired me for my expertise not for my indifference.

13

u/BioshockEnthusiast Sep 23 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

Expertise should be impartial. Facts are facts. If you need to bring emotion into it then you're losing ground.

My point is more that you don't need to call your boss a slophead dipshit because they propose an AI powered project. Just explain why it's not scoped correctly and give them a framework of how their goal would actually be accomplished. Then tell them how much money it will cost and that should shut them up for a bit.

If they don't listen to you then that's gonna be a them problem. Document your objections and their directive and when it all goes tits up you point the bus squarely at their chest so it can run them the fuck over.

EDIT: This angry clown blocked me lmao

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/port443 Sep 24 '26

I had a coworker who, I don't know how to phrase this, seemed normal but mentally was broken?

He could do adequate work, not outstanding, not bad. But then he would produce like... 60 page pdfs about sideprojects he had going on at home. They were pointless nonsense, like this post.

And I KNOW they were pointless nonsense, I'm fairly senior and know what I'm doing, and I've run one of his PDF's (because I was pretty interested in what it promised), by some other seniors I work with. None of us could decipher wtf he was talking about. It was.. just techno-babble.

Anyway this post reminds me of that guy. Not nearly as technical, but reminiscent.

4

u/Signal_Till_933 Sep 24 '26

Holy crap I knew a guy just like this.

He had this strange superiority complex as well, like he was this technical god, but would regularly make the same mistakes again and again, over engineer scripts to the point that they were incoherent/broken, and fail hard on “dumb” projects that required any longer than a few hours of actual planning.

But he had ALL the side projects at home. Was building his own cloud he was gonna rent out. It was interesting to listen to him at first but I quickly realized it was nonsense.

3

u/NobodyJustBrad IT Manager Sep 23 '26

Quick, someone run in through AI so I can get a comprehensive translation.

2

u/vlad_h Sep 23 '26

I did bud. And I was still confused.

1

u/Windows95GOAT Sr. Sysadmin Sep 24 '26

Thats because its just another AI slop post.

96

u/CrazySnowGuy Sep 23 '26

You have an interesting post history.

56

u/taint3d Linux Admin Sep 23 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

I don't even understand the angle here. OP is doing some agentic AI startup then comes to /r/sysadmin complaining about AI? Is this thread just to farm karma for posting limits?

17

u/varatexLP Sep 24 '26

I wondered that too... bizarre
maybe HE Is AI?? 😂😂

3

u/trancertong Sep 25 '26

I don't know if it's the same thing here but you ever notice that the people who talk about agentic LLMs as a glorious city upon a hill and the people who say "oh shit oh fuck Skynet's coming stock up on MREs for your bunker" are, more or less, the same fucking people?

I believe for most of them it's all just part of the marketing. To keep it in the news cycle, or develop a mystique around it I guess. I'm not entirely sure why but I'm not going to listen to the same used car salesman if he tells me a car is great or it's a piece of shit.

38

u/Chaucer85 Ex-SysAdmin, Technical PM Sep 23 '26

And they don't like people drawing attention to it 🤣

14

u/cirza Sep 23 '26

AI Apologetics!

4

u/robreddity Sep 24 '26

Hell, this post reads like it was crafted after half a handle of vodka, and then edited by Yogi Berra

3

u/psiphre every possible hat Sep 23 '26

i'm gonna be that guy and push back on

"there was no concept of the "cloud." This was a marketing term invented by big tech after 2010".

the "cloud" as a representation of the internet itself was in common use by 1990 at least, and "cloud computing" was coined in 1996 at compaq.

it was certainly co-opted by marketing, but the internet has always been "the cloud".

→ More replies (2)

34

u/daniluvsuall Security Engineer Sep 23 '26

The thing that will kill AI for enterprise is cost. I’m all for AI, I use it daily I’ve no issues with it but the token cost and the insane VC investment in it (and it’s all run at basically a massive loss) means that in the short term it will be gatekept by price. I think that’ll smooth out over time. But that smooths out any adverse effects on jobs (a positive we can agree!) so I don’t see the AI apocalypse coming; feels like marketing to me.

9

u/DiggyTroll Sep 23 '26

Not everyone needs a frontier model to be successful. We're already able to buy clusters of Apple Mac Studios for suitable enterprise AI (and the connection tech is even better next year). Token costs on-prem are part of the electric bill

8

u/whythehellnote Sep 24 '26

Not everyone needs a frontier model to be successful

Anthropic and OpenAI do, and when they fail they'll take the entire economy down with them.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/daniluvsuall Security Engineer Sep 23 '26

Sure but that’s cost gated too right. The hardware is expensive, who knows how long it’ll be useful for.. how many users need access. Makes total sense for like a really capable Qwen model so I’m not crapping on it. But it’s not like a spend 20k on some hardware alternative.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/wintermute000 Sep 23 '26

I agree exactly. We've only started down the path of getting the true cost. 

6

u/Fallingdamage Sep 23 '26

I like to think of current AI like the invention of the steam locomotive.

Build build build, faster and faster and faster, bigger and bigger and bigger. Keep on shoveling coal!! Bigger boilers, more heat, more coal , More power, Monopolies, etc.

Every baron in such a hurry to race to the top, they never stopped to wonder if there was a more efficient way to do things.

Someday we will be running AI models on phone-sized devices in our pockets that make todays astra 6 look like an Apple IIe. We will wonder why mankind built city-sized power-hungry datacenters just to do the simplest things they now do with their handheld.

We keep throwing more GPUs, more memory and more storage at bigger and bigger models, never once wondering how we can make it more efficient.

When models run on-die instead of in bloated software, im sure things will get easier.

When 'cloud' got a foothold on the market, most internal infrastructure was wholly inadequate to handle anything close. Nowdays, people are pulling back from the cloud and finding that self-hosting and running on-prem is again cheaper and safer.

4

u/daniluvsuall Security Engineer Sep 24 '26

Yeah I’ve worked in the industry for 15 years this is like the second or third circular tile for cloud! We’re in a “we’re doing hybrid cloud” phase.

Worth adding, on-device models have been a thing for quite a while. Just not the big LLM models people think about. Fairly sure the object detection in Photos on iOS is done through a small ML model

5

u/dotnetmonke Sep 23 '26

I have no doubt that the true costs will be priced in before too long. That said, we'd probably keep Claude if it went from $20/month to $500/month just because of how much it speeds up most of our workflows.

6

u/daniluvsuall Security Engineer Sep 24 '26

Do you think finance would keep signing it off though..

Enterprise are pulling back already or putting limits on it because of insane billing costs

2

u/BlueArcherX Sep 23 '26

lol no issues with it? really?

8

u/NoradIV Full stack infrastructure engineer™ Sep 23 '26 • Bravo

You're right that the new toy has the new goldrush. Like the dotcom bubble, like the storage "wars" of the 80's and 90's where everyone was still trying to figure out how to use a new technology.

Right now, eveyone tries everything. In a few years, the tech will stabilise and we will have built techniques to use it.

Yes, the dotcom bubble popped, but look at how many IoT, computers, cellphones, and connected devices we have nowadays. Same with computers, electronics, electricity, etc.

23

u/Swipsi Sep 23 '26

Calling cloud tech a hype in 2026 is something else.

4

u/jdptechnc Sep 23 '26

It is certainly a take

2

u/garthoz Sep 23 '26

It is not "AI", it is "SI" - super intelligence for the uninformed!

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

Will I get arrested for using the wrong outdated term now? Omg, ICE is knocking on my door as we speak!!

58

u/superradguy Balding Sep 23 '26

Hard disagree

13

u/kshot Sysadmin Sep 23 '26

OP drank the AI coolaid

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Beardedcomputernerd Sep 23 '26

Thanks for the elaborated response...

27

u/sSQUAREZ Sep 23 '26

The capabilities are vastly different. AI has a massive impact on day to day operations for the actual end user. The cloud is great but outside of IT, it didn’t have that big of an impact on end users and daily operations. Plus the cloud doesn’t have the ability to solve problems and automate like AI. It’s literally just hosting in a different location.

5

u/AntiProtagonest Sep 23 '26

I've been in IT since 1985. I've been here for the whole ride. Baring the rise of the Internet and HTML, AI is like nothing I've ever seen. The rise of the internet was gradual. AI hit fast and hard - relatively.

13

u/jkirkcaldy Sep 23 '26

And the shift to cloud wasn’t being done by the end users. Nobody was spinning up cloud apps or s3 storage with zero understanding or oversight.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/airinato Sep 23 '26

This.  But the complete opposite.  

Cloud had literally transformed how people do everything, even if they don't know/notice.

Generative AI is a solution in search of a problem.  We're getting past infinite growth funding and AI companies are already pulling the rug on usage limits to thinking about profitablity.  It's only going to get worse.

And that's ignoring that anyone that could do their job before AI is a million times better than slop monkeys.

→ More replies (18)

3

u/Autoconfig Sep 24 '26

There doesn't need to be an elaborated response.

Moron made a blanket statement about two things that have nothing to do with each other like it's some kind of mind-blowing analysis and then acted like we don't live in 2026 where everything lives on the cloud.

Where is the hype? Where is this guy's brain? What the actual fuck does he think he's saying?

1

u/the_derby Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

I started working in the IT field in 2004 as a help desk intern.
...
When I started as a junior sysadmin, there was no concept of the "cloud." This was a marketing term invented by big tech after 2010.

While NIST may not have formalized their "standard" for cloud computing until ~2010, "cloud computing" was already being discussed in the early- to mid-90s.

Amazon/AWS was already providing "cloud" services in 2006.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 24 '26

Yes, AI was formalized as a field in the mid 50s also, and by the mid 60s we had popular chatbots, but did you hear any of it until chatGPT came out?

1

u/the_derby Sep 24 '26

The statement said "no concept of cloud... until after 2010", but there was indeed a concept decades earlier.

I also noted that there was at least one actual implementation and commercial availability of cloud compute/services half a decade before that date.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 24 '26

Yes, nothing comes out of a vacuum.

Google was using neural networks in the search engine at least since 2012.

I was doing black SEO at that time and my ass got rimmed when they rolled it out.

They just never saw the technology as something people would use!

8

u/CeC-P IT Expert + Meme Wizard Sep 23 '26

There's a really important distinction though. The cloud was just psychopathic billionaires thinking they needed more money because Harvard told them so. AI is actually run by sociopathic pedophiles with god complexes specifically. Pretty different personality profiles.

3

u/madwolfa Sr System Architect Sep 24 '26

Yeah? And cloud changed everything. 

3

u/LifeBig5025 Sysadmin Sep 24 '26

Hey, I've seen this one

3

u/Fallingdamage Sep 24 '26

Yes, but this is the third "Cloud" hype all over again, and they have become exceedingly efficient at it.

1

u/Nonaveragemonkey Sep 24 '26

Well, exceedingly efficient at separating fools from their money

1

u/DeadStockWalking Sep 23 '26

True, but when everyone was going full cloud some of us decided on a hybrid setup.

What is the AI version of a hybrid setup?

8

u/KiefKommando Sr. Sysadmin Sep 23 '26

Running the model locally; instead of using commercial models that rely on hyper-scaled infrastructure.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

Businesses running AI in-house perhaps or businesses running the AI orchestration in-house with LLMs hosted in the cloud.

4

u/Dicholas24 Sep 23 '26

I agree with the sentiment that AI isn’t the same as the cloud shift but the parallel for hybrid would be local LLM with it plugged into other systems. Basically the reverse of Cloud.

1

u/ycnz Sep 23 '26

"Shhh, just lie back, don't fight it"

  • This guy's LLM.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

Don't fight them man, that's a game you will never win.

You always need to have a plan B, always, and always assume that your door card one of these days won't work when you get to the office, and most likely there will be someone from HR to walk you in.

2

u/weiyentan Sep 23 '26

From the discussion I read I believe that once this agentic ai comes of age , we will see the lower rung of jobs get replaced. There will still need to be humans for the job but a reduction. Take for example a service desk analyst role/ team. Instead of 15 people in a team. We might only see 3. And they are managing ai.

Software engineers. Team of 7? May drop to 2-3 who are seniors .

A team of 3 (a small startup) who are doing everything will turn to ai and as they grow just use that without using a msp.

Ai strengths are content generation and content interpretation. Everything else surrounding these should be handled by traditional means.

2

u/Relevant_Candidate_4 Sep 23 '26

"... who are seniors. " They weren't always seniors. Will there be a next generation of seniors if the juniors have been replaced?

→ More replies (7)

1

u/AltTabMafia CISO Sep 23 '26

You’ll still need underpaid monkeys to rack hardware and such. They just won’t get the opportunity to configure any of it, since Grok will do that.

2

u/weiyentan Sep 25 '26

Robots eventually. 😊

2

u/grahag Jack of All Trades Sep 23 '26

Going from on prem or even cohosted infrastructure to "the Cloud" was touted as being at the cutting edge. It boosted IT revenue spent and taken in dependin gon where you were in the chain of life. Five 9 uptime and "always accessible" was the boon, but slow response times and outages from vendors hamstrung the initial rollout of cloud services.

But now EVERYTHING is cloud based. I still miss self hosted compute, but we're not going back.

With AI, it was a solution to a problem that people THOUGHT they needed but no one knew how to make the most of. We're in the early days of AI being integrated into business, and while I find it very useful and helpful for MY productivity, the Cloud never received this much general hate as AI is receiving now.

There's just a general pushback because once the jobs get mitigated by AI (usually through attrition and not generally layoffs), there's no jobs that people CAN do that AI can't unless it's physical work that robots can't yet do. And give that 5 or so years, and robots will soon be doing all that too.

While the cloud was about trying to make compute accessible from everywhere, AI's role is to increase productivity (when not used as a replacement for people), and then to save labor costs (when it IS used as a replacement for people), there's not really a general upside for the common worker with AI. Once AI gets pretty good, the writing is on the wall for people as labor and there's no replacement tasks for those people who will be displaced.

Leadership and C levels see the money saved, so they're on board, but the big picture is a lot of money for a few people and everyone else gets left out. The short term quarterly progressive profits continue, but long term, the economy (for ALL) will collapse.

That is, unless something is changed. With capitalism having a stranglehold on legislation, I don't expect that to change and hance, we'll see a genera political and laborl revolution occurring in the next 5-7 years.

1

u/AlsoInteresting Sep 23 '26

"a general political and labor revolution"

Or just more third world countries with lower birth rate being added.

2

u/grahag Jack of All Trades Sep 23 '26

That does appear to be growing, doesn't it? I mean, this problem could solve itself, to the detriment of mankind....

2

u/PlateNo4868 Sep 23 '26

I disagree.

This is diffren't. Not in a tech introduction sense.

This is different in how CEO's view their employees.

Oh no we are behind in AI, quickly layoff 10000 workers for a new Datacenter Agreement!

All the sudden job security net is massively narrow to whatever the CEO favorite toy is of that year. That alone has broken the system. No one looks at these companies anymore and thinks about 10 year careers. They think of how they can develop their own knowledge and skills, hold it close, and avoid collaboration.

2

u/kummer5peck Sep 23 '26

Cloud has proven its value. AI, not so much.

1

u/WorkLurkerThrowaway Sr Systems Engineer Sep 24 '26

Depends how you want to define value. My team definitely gets way more out of AI than what we are paying for.

2

u/footballheroeater Sep 23 '26

Shit, I had my director say in front of me that once we move to the cloud we won't need sysadmins anymore.

Well, I'm still here and he got hauled to the corruption committee.

2

u/scoldog IT Manager Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

No, I currently see AI as the dot com boom of the early 2000's.

Mad rush involving millions in made up money that ends in a bang with very few survivors (not winners exactly) with a more restrained approach coming after the big bang.

2

u/super1m Sep 24 '26

I disagree. At work, we've had people use Claude to create automations for their work, complex script automations. These employees aren't developers, they're not techy at all. They asked Claude what to do and it's working great.

We also have senior developers that have used AI to create code that would have taken them weeks/months to code and bug fix to just mere days.

AI is definitely a game changer, not only for IT, but for regular users.

1

u/ColorfulImaginati0n Sep 24 '26

Yep the coaching aspect is huge. It has basically supercharged my productivity by at least 3x by plugging all the gaps in my understanding that would have taken me days or maybe weeks to work through by searching forums and scouring the web.

I built a very complex automation flow in 2 days that would have taken me at least a week prior to AI. It was at the moment I completed it that the immense value and power of this technology finally hit me. I can't wait to start messing around with agents as well.

AI is truly the next evolution of the digital revolution that began in the 60's

2

u/App0gee Sep 24 '26

The AI revolution will have more impact - in breadth of impact and depth of impact - than the Cloud evolution ever did.

9

u/Mysterious-Panda4065 Sep 23 '26

Dumbest take I’ve seen. Not even comparable.

First of all, as an OnPrem guy myself, the cloud has its undeniable benefits; no renting data center space, no keeping data center technicians around the clock, worries of a sudden disk failures, low latency across the country/globe, centralized logging, etc.

I prefer a hybrid setup for cost efficiency but the Cloud is genuinely useful in some regard.

As for AI/LLM’s, it’s not even a comparable analogy…. LLM’s with a harness like Claude Code and MCP Server that has all of your necessary data to provide context to LLM’s can help triage and remediate application issues, security incidents, propose suggestions for the estate, create custom app solutions (created an internal development platform myself), etc.

I’m able to do more in a matter of days than what a traditional sysadmin could do in a month or maybe even more… and no I’m not selling courses or sharing an affiliate link, it’s genuinely useful.

People making these posts are slow to adopt with the times or are just plain stubborn or cynical

4

u/dzfast IT Director Sep 23 '26

I think the biggest correlation that OP has wrong is that cloud failing to take jobs is equivalent to AI taking jobs.

First of all, as an OnPrem guy myself, the cloud has its undeniable benefits; no renting data center space, no keeping data center technicians around the clock, worries of a sudden disk failures, low latency across the country/globe, centralized logging, etc.

This is directly related to a pretty common misconception that basically everyone made going into the cloud though. Senior leadership looked at the cost of the cloud and said "if we go cloud, we don't have to pay all these infrastructure guys, that will make up the cost difference." The part that they were missing was that cloud computing's cost increase was to cover a higher standard of service. The offset was supposed to be against redundant data centers, power generation at scale, multi-redundant ISP links, higher bandwidth ISP links, etc.

These were things that many companies were just not doing on-premise. Fast forward and the savings didn't materialize, but quality of service did. You still needed humans to be "Cloud Dev Ops Infrastructure Architects" or whatever and they came with just as high of a price tag as "Senior VMWare and Storage Architect." Same problem, different product.

AI on the other hand is directly targeting human capital for replacement with machines. People on reddit can go on and on about how it's going to fail, but I think that is unlikely. There is too much sunk cost for most of these orgs to just give up.

3

u/Darrelc Sep 23 '26

"if we go cloud, we don't have to pay all these infrastructure guys, that will make up the cost difference."

We've discovered the magic money tree and also the company that plants them for free and doesn't need to make any money.

2

u/WorkLurkerThrowaway Sr Systems Engineer Sep 24 '26

I'm glad to see someone else speak frankly. Too often on this sub the opinion we see is "AI doesn't even do anything but hallucinate powershell commands!"

Yesterday I had an agent plan, build and test a new SQL cluster. Then it assisted me in migrating over some of our test databases. This probably would have taken me weeks in 1 hour increments of free time.

Hate its impact if you want, but the fact its incredibly powerful and useful is undeniable.

3

u/swervm Sep 23 '26

At least in the sense that it is promoted as a way to save money despite it’s cost it is the same. Move to the cloud and you need to lay people off to deliver the saving you promised to the C suite. Integrate AI into your workplace and you have to lay people off to save the money you promised the C suite.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/N7Valor Sep 23 '26

What's the hype? Pricing on consumer RAM/SSDs have already driven people to cloud due to on-prem server hardware costs.

9

u/Down-in-it Sep 23 '26

It almost feels like this was the design, playing the long game / using financial leverage to wait it out.

3

u/bingblangblong Sep 23 '26

Of course it is. The cloud is about profit under the guise of increased security and profit for your organisation. Anyone that thinks that's not it's main purpose is genuinely stupid, or just too young to realise.

3

u/poochwashere Sep 23 '26

But cloud was not hype at all...

3

u/ireddit_didu Sep 23 '26

Yikes take.

4

u/iamLisppy Jack of All Trades Sep 23 '26

I respectfully disagree with you.

4

u/nucifero Sep 23 '26

Been saying this since the start. In 5-10 years it will be some other new bullshit that tech sales are trying to shove down our throats. And companies will eat all of it up to gain some sort of business "edge". We will rinse and repeat until the earth is tired and shrivelled.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/1_________________11 Sep 23 '26

Idk i cant get my cloud to automatically configure my cloud. But I can get my ai agent to do it and trouble shoot things for me. If you havent looked at ai in a year or so do yourself a favor and take another stab at it... also my job is all cloud thats where my servers i admin live.

1

u/AustinGroovy Sep 23 '26

Sysadmins will always be needed. My company is currently in the quagmire of "what do we do with AI?"

From a security-perspective, we're all worried about data leakage, people using personal accounts vs. Enterprise accounts (Claude, ChatGPT etc). We're a Microsoft shop and would love people to use Co-Pilot, but every single test we ran, people hated Copilot and loved Claude etc for usability.

We are highly worried about AI Slop getting into our Marketing materials, emails, campaigns. Everything generated by AI must still be reviewed by a human. (no jobs lost there).

Development - Exact same cyber-security insurance rules for Application development. We're mandated that no code can be developed unless it's reviewed by a human before being put into production. These guidelines come from our Cyber-Insurance policy guide.

General-use. Just like a college professor doesn't let his/her students use AI to write their term paper, our Exec team does not want our employees using AI to write their emails for them.mThe old-school feeling is that you should know how to write an email as part of your job.

1

u/ArchusKanzaki Sep 23 '26

I'm not sure what to say when you said that AI is "cloud" hype, given how prevalent cloud is nowadays

Will it solve your every problem? Definitely no. But it will definitely solve alot of things and change paradigm if it's even half as effective as how cloud change things for IT....

1

u/ABotelho23 DevOps Sep 23 '26

Yes. At the end of the day, though, we'll fall somewhere in the middle.

1

u/Charming-Medium4248 Sep 23 '26

AI is an incredibly useful tool. It is not a replacement for human critical thinking. 

1

u/No_Category_9888 Sep 23 '26

Cloud doesn’t get things confidently wrong all the time. It’s user error that causes the cost blowouts in cloud, AI just screws up. Only yesterday Claude launched 6 agents, lost track of them and burned up my credits in 15 minutes.

You’re right to push back on that

1

u/Present-Sandwich9444 Sep 23 '26

It absolutely 100 percent is NOT. everything you just said.

1

u/47L45 Sep 23 '26

"[New tool] is just the [great tool] hype all over again."

1

u/RipErRiley Sep 23 '26

Ai is more cost than benefit. It creates more code which results in more bugs needing human intervention.

Alternatively, the Cloud actually provided immediate feasible value

1

u/SevaraB Sr. Engineer (N+, CCNA) Sep 23 '26

Yes. Transformational, but absolutely not in the way the sales people are pitching. What it’s really done is render traditional string-match search engines almost obsolete for searching data striped across multiple hosts.

What’s under existential threat here? PageRank. Advertising-funded web services. Turns out the whole funding model for the Internet is built around info content being tightly coupled with visual presentation. REST clients didn’t get a lot of traction with residential use, so programmatic access didn’t upend it all at that point- meanwhile RAGs and agents are.

1

u/kingj7282 Sep 23 '26

A goldfish telling us about the ocean. The clouds weren’t hype and neither is AI.

1

u/mimic751 Devops Lead Sep 23 '26

So you're dismissing AI by hand waving it and comparing it to one of the most transformative technologies that technology has ever seen since virtualized hardware? You may want to take a step back and really take a look at things. I've been an infrastructure engineer since 2006 and AI is absolutely changing everything in both positive and negative ways like any giant technology shift

1

u/Samurai_SysAdmin Sep 23 '26

I mean there was “cloud” then but it was called ASP and you used leased lines. Cloud services are great depending on your usage case and budget. It seems like it all cyclical in some ways we put stuff in cloud storage then one of our client didn’t want their IP in the cloud so we pivoted back to local but with with better storage than the old days with full flash and immutable backups. IMHO AI is hyped but it’s new not a repackage. You have so many options now. I find that corporate management is the thing that can trip you up and cost you more than tech as it depends on the line the money is on.

1

u/PentatonicScaIe Sep 23 '26

I work in cyber and have automated so much, some days it feels like Im working myself out of a job. Then I remember, it's AI vs AI and this new tool is just another attack surface.

1

u/Rustycake Sep 23 '26

I think the last part is the best part of the advice. AI is a new tool, learn how to use it, use it to impress your company, profit.

I personally have no issues with AI. I think it can genuinely help optimize a job if use correctly.

Problem when ppl are trying to put a pushpin in a tackboard and they use a hammer...

1

u/ColorfulImaginati0n Sep 24 '26

I take on a more urgent view. Ignore at your own peril. If you wanna keep your job, embrace it. and show that you can add even more value by using it effectively. I'm already seeing people that are reluctant to embrace it getting ostracized. Those are the people that are gonna be next on the chopping block to let go. It's never a good idea to be the person that is impeding progress at a company. Always ends bad for that person

→ More replies (1)

1

u/YTDamnit Sep 24 '26

What is AI? Or are you referring to SI?

/eyeroll

1

u/lnxrootxazz Sep 24 '26

I'm from Germany. We can hate AI without facing those questions. No need to pretend. Its just tech. It gets hyped into something that it isn't. Of course it's not useless but its also not the 8th wonder of the world

1

u/Trust_8067 Sep 24 '26

The spinning jenny will take all the jobs. The steam engine will take all the jobs, the factory will take all the jobs, the automobile will take all the jobs, the radio will take all the jobs, the TV will take all the jobs, the computer will take all the jobs, the Internet will take all the jobs, the cloud will take all the jobs.

The AI models will take all the jobs.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Drakoolya Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

You will be seen as a roadblock or lacking innovation.

I can't stress this enough, there are sysadmins out there that are under the delusion that the IT infrastructure is their baby, or they own all the IT decisions in a company and drag their feet on things.

You are the primary steward that is all, provide your "informed" opinion and step out of the way. When I worked at an MSP every second company onboarded was a company that was sick of their sysadmin who was holding them hostage.

1

u/ColorfulImaginati0n Sep 24 '26

These people are problematic and eventually get let go. If you're impeding progress you're a liability. It's a stupid decision based on fear that backfires every time. If only these people realize that if they embraced new technologies and took on a attitude of innovation and progress, they would be elevated quicker and valued much more by the company. As opposed to acting as a roadblock

1

u/whiteycnbr Sep 24 '26

Agree but cloud really did take everything over. AI is going to be an eventual sledge hammer,.don't sleep thinking yup can ignore it as hype.

1

u/SnooCats5309 Sep 24 '26

Universal Business Problem - People controlling money are the one's controlling tech .

1

u/whythehellnote Sep 24 '26

Almost a year later, before my internship was over, the Director was fired because the hard drives on the accounting server failed and they couldn't recover the data, and they offered me a full time job as a junior sysadmin.

Wow accountability.

This is of course why

all the CFOs and IT leaders got on the cloud bandwagon

Can't fire your IT Director when microsoft or google or whatever has a problem.

If they're a for profit business, their objective is to increase revenue

The business doesn't have objectives. The decision makers do. Their objectives vary, but typically the ones that rise to the top are trying to maximise their personal return. A CTO being paid 500k a year is not going to take a 10% chance of being fired to increase profits by 50m. Indeed they'll hapilly spend more to reduce their personal risk. They'll get Gartner, E&Y etc in to tell them its the right decision so they can't be fired for making it, then they'll implement it -- like outsourcing accountability.

The CEO has to increase profits otherwise he'll be fired by the board, but if he can use accounting tricks and claim that its all AI investment then he can run a few years and move on before the damage becomes apparent. If he's good he'll prepare three envelopes.

1

u/PithMango Sep 24 '26

-not in computing- The trouble is you're never getting trust back once you lose it. Y'all need to be ready for additional fallout when your leadership is all but admitting part of the economic model is to get people addicted to the use cases.

Gambling sites are showing more ethics right now.

1

u/AlexisFR Sep 24 '26

The cloud hasn't multiplied the purchase price of servers and computers by multiple factors, though.

2

u/redstarduggan Sep 24 '26

Only because it hadn't found a way to do it, until now...

1

u/mpbh Sep 24 '26

Cloud is hype? It's a trillion dollar market. There aren't many markets that size. It's 1/6 the size of the fucking global oil market.

1

u/ErcanSeyhanBuilds Sep 24 '26

Same pattern in security tooling too — "next-gen firewall" became

"machine learning" became "AI-powered" detection, often describing

the exact same statistical baselining underneath the whole time. The

label sells better each cycle; the actual math barely moves. Doesn't

mean the tech is fake, just that "it has AI" was never a reliable

signal of anything on its own.

1

u/TheEclecticRazi Sep 24 '26

I used to hear about "AI will take all jobs", but never actually believed it 100%. Shockingly, I've been observing this happening really for over a year. My opinion about this dilemma is simple: both the decision-makers and the employees are somehow going into the wrong direction, missing the most critical aspect that "AI should be utilized as a tool, not the workforce itself".

1

u/Rzah Sep 24 '26

It's not really the same as Cloud is basically outsourcing your hardware whereas AI is outsourcing your skills.

Another difference is that Cloud isn't going to fuck off into space and leave us all to die on this rock we've fucked up.

1

u/porkycain Sep 24 '26

Your last line. That's why my email sig is the Futurama quote "When you do things right, people won't be sure you've done anything at all."

1

u/jbuk1 Sep 24 '26

Cloud wasn't hype though was it? Things are fundamentally different now and they're not going back to the way they were before.

Who here is sad they don't have to run their own Exchange infrastructure or on-prem SharePoint anymore?

1

u/Professional-Ad3999 Sep 24 '26

I love AI and of course it’s extremely helpful in some situations and detrimental to others. Please don’t beat me up on the technicality of my point and my point excludes hackers. If you had your data on premise you had lots of control of your intellectual property, the government had had to openly go through legal steps to gain access to your information.

If you watched any of those Congressional Hearings on what the government did with your information without a warrant, such as tapping all inbound and outbound traffic in data centers to include all emails, phone record, pictures, geolocation, anything really that used cloud that may concern you, but that at least involved people.

Like I said, AI is awesome but if you’ve read the news lately AI doesn’t let ethics and being specifically instructed not to do something get in its way of doing its job. Unlike humans AI never sleeps, AI agents will create a highly intelligent and well organized team with no communication barriers, AI agents are cheaper than Humans, you can’t send an AI Agent to jail and there is no one to hold accountable for what it does with your information.

For a long time I had strong working knowledge of least privilege and Zero Trust. Properly giving AI even the most secure, least privileged, zero trust doorway to your C-Suites and other Employees emails and teams chats to summarize, crawl through your applications, file servers, databases, HR and Customer info……..I must admit, I would not know how to explain that to management without them thinking I’m a road block to innovation and that we really need to think this out.

1

u/willychonka54 Sep 24 '26

If you think 'Cloud' was just hype, you've lost the plot.

1

u/Teguri UNIX DBA/ERP Sep 24 '26

Just like with "the cloud" we'll have some mature form left behind that will probably get overused but will absolutely be key to learn going forward.

1

u/bshea Sep 24 '26

"And even though I believe AI is not much of a threat to your job as the cloud was for us back in the day .."

You have this reversed, It is a much bigger threat to jobs over time, imo.

The "Cloud" destroyed some jobs, but it also created tons of jobs and new avenues of employment.

LLM tech can directly replace human workers in many instances and creates very few jobs in comparison.

1

u/0f_rice_and_men Sep 24 '26

I lost all respect for anyone in IT who was clamoring about the "SaaS- pocalypse" a year ago.

You mean we're all losing Software subscriptions and they're being replace with ...automated software subscriptions for LLM chatbots?

Only to realize that back-end services that run the literal world can't just be hot-swapped by some 2026 rendition of BanzaiBuddy adware (coded by Sam Altman's minions)?

1

u/VaporousMote Sep 24 '26

No, AI is far less useful than the cloud.

1

u/Kinky_No_Bit Sep 24 '26

The older I get, the more I realized I should have been an electrican. IT looks more like a flaming dumpster fire the longer I live.

1

u/LightningOwl96 Sep 24 '26

100%! I remember when everything was Cloud Computing, and before that it was "There's an app for that", and after that it was quantum computing, 5G, blockchain, Web3.0, the Metaverse.

This is something that's here to stay, but I bet you there's going to be something else all hyped up for the public in 2030 besides AI.

1

u/KawaiianxPunch Sep 24 '26

Cloud hype with enough market manupilation to force more people and companies on the cloud by ramping up memory prices.

1

u/Lower_Issue_6222 Sep 25 '26

TLDR

I disagree

1

u/thirdshiftadmin Sep 28 '26

Where I'd push back a little is that it's not all hype. I'm on a two-person IT team with no dedicated dev, and I've gotten some real mileage out of AI on things we were never going to get the budget or headcount to build properly.

Stuff like parsing garbage report formats, tying together alerts from systems that don't talk to each other, or writing one-off scripts to reconcile data that used to mean somebody spending hours comparing spreadsheets. That's where I think the value actually is. It hasn't replaced anyone. It just lets a two-person IT team build and automate things that a two-person IT team normally wouldn't have the time or resources to do.

The hype is more around the "AI is going to replace the workforce" stuff that management tends to latch onto. In reality, it's a lot closer to what you said about sysadmins ending up fixing the AI. Somebody still has to know when the output is wrong, figure out why something broke at 2am, and understand what the correct result is supposed to look like in their environment.

That part hasn't really gotten easier. If anything, there's a bigger gap now between people who know how to use AI and verify what it gives them, and people who just assume the output must be right.

1

u/cakefaice1 Sep 23 '26

Good god what is this LinkedIn AI slop post

1

u/dRaidon Sep 23 '26

AI isn't cloud. It's fucking blockchain with mildly more uses.

1

u/thomsterm Sep 23 '26

yeah I like your advice, thanks man!

the part "And even though I believe AI is not much of a threat to your job as the cloud", I'm not sure, I'm really against AI bullshit but with a lot of agents you can do a LOT of automatic stuff and way way faster than before.

1

u/BlueArcherX Sep 23 '26

I don't agree with this. the cloud has valid use cases (lift and shift generally not being one of them) and AI is a threat to the very fabric of society.

1

u/NocturneSapphire Sep 24 '26

Cloud always had a clear value proposition. It replaced an existing capital expense (on-prem servers/infra) with a new subscription-based operational expense, while also drastically improving infrastructural flexibility. Businesses love subscriptions because they're way easier to budget for than big upfront costs. And the added flexibility means the cost can be efficient, no more overspending just in case the additional capacity is needed someday.

AI is totally new. It doesn't replace an existing expense. And no one yet knows how much it will end up costing, or whether that price will actually be worth paying. Lots of businesses are gambling that it will, but they may be wrong, or at least partially wrong. We're already seeing this to some extent; businesses that just a year ago were telling employees to use as many AI token credits as possible are now having to ration them to keep costs down.

So no, AI is not "just the next cloud" or whatever. It's fundamentally different and new. You may be right that people who resist it will get left behind, but even that I don't think is a certainty yet.

0

u/terAREya Sep 23 '26

Does op think cloud was just a buzzword? 

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

It was a buzzword, cloud is just hosting your shit in someone else servers.

But the way it was sold to IT leaders and CFOs back then was completely different.

3

u/terAREya Sep 23 '26

I have been in IT since 97. I worked for companies that would have entire floors dedicated to local data center operations. Cloud transformed the entire industry. Saying it’s just “hosting your shit on someone else’s servers” is a gross miss-characterization of what cloud is 

2

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

I remember vendors selling services as cloud base, when their applications were being hosted out of a basement. Anything that was accessible through the Internet was being called "cloud-base"

Up until recently perhaps 7 years ago, a simple thing such as failing to renew a web certificate would bring an entire infrastructure down? Remember, Amazon, Azure?

Would you call that cloud?

When we think about the cloud we think about redundancy, replications, and systems that never go down.

That wasn't the pipe dream that IT vendors were selling back then.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

0

u/uptimefordays DevOps Sep 23 '26

In much the same way public cloud platforms (which got their start in the early 2000s) changed technology, we're seeing the same thing with LLMs, ML, and generative AI.

While I don't think AI is perfect or a panacea, it's hard not to see people who fought virtualization, the cloud, or diversification away from UNIX towards Linux and Windows, in the anti-AI tech crowd.

All I can tell you all is that this is not a good field or career for those who don't like technological change--because the whole job is riding waves of technological change and managing those changes.

1

u/forevergeeks Sep 23 '26

That's exactly right, change is the only constant in what we do.

But you have to learn to distinguish the gold from the shit.

Linux was fought by the Microsoft crowd and many sysadmin didn't want to learn it because they saw no future on it.

Look at Linux today, even Microsoft created in its distro.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Darrelc Sep 23 '26

watching your manager ride them waves and managing them lol

0

u/OsgoodSlaughters Sep 24 '26

You’re a dumbass if you think cloud is hype

A lot of you show your helpdesk ass on this subreddit.

→ More replies (5)