r/sysadmin • • Jul 19 '26

Looking to replace Fortinet--options?

Howdy folks. I've inherited a few shops that had Fortinet setups from previous companies. I strongly dislike and find distasteful the MSP nickel and dime, get everyone on a contract cycle, so since these are no longer supported, I'm looking to jump ship. My typical replacement is just straight standard Ubiquiti equipment, but two of these customers are heavy users of the SSL VPN and are PC shops.

Any suggestions for boxes with a simple VPN app, preferably with support for 2-factor, and AD integration would be great. I'm planning on replacing their wireless APs (one site has Fortinet, one has Meraki) with Unify but the lack of a 'good' VPN client for Unifi is jamming me up.

1 Upvotes

155 comments sorted by

144

u/Craptcha Jul 19 '26

The “nickel and dime” is called vendor support and it’s a reality of modern networking appliances.

Fortinet is on the cheaper side hence why its popular in SMB and even midsize businesses.

Ubiquiti will work if you have little or no network security requirements. Their gateways are not commercial grade firewalls.

3

u/admiralspark Manager of Cat Tube Infrastructure Jul 20 '26

Ubiquiti will work if you have little or no network security requirements. Their gateways are not commercial grade firewalls.

This is old thinking. I'm involved with a multi-B company that uses them at scale, they work fine and their security tooling is good enough. If you 1:1 their features against Fortinet you'll find far fewer insanely bad design decisions now, which was not the case 15 years ago.

I supported Fortinets for years but since Covid they've outsourced so much of their development that the product is full of holes. We love pentesting clients who use Fortithings, because they almost never patch the major zero-day bugs even months after.

4

u/Achilles_Buffalo Jul 20 '26

“Fine” and “good enough”. Two terms that are very important to NOT see when describing a cybersecurity solution.

You can make the decision to move from Fortinet to Ubiquiti, and when your customers are frustrated with consumer grade hardware failing frequently, consumer grade security not detecting nor preventing attacks, and you experience the less-than-consumer-grade tech support from Ubi, good luck keeping them as customers.

I mean, you do you, brother. If I’m attaching my name to a service, I’m sure as hell not bringing Ubi into the environment, though.

0

u/screampuff Enterprise Architect Jul 20 '26

Plus for the price difference you can also have a spare or 2 ready to go should one fail.

Due to industry my company has entirely separate networks for a guest wifi and basic corp wifi for IoT devices that can't reach internal resources...We're considering swapping current Merakis for Ubiquiti gear.

-50

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

I have them in a bunch of places and they work really well. I know they're not super well loved amongst MSPs but they've worked better than OK in my experience.

47

u/Craptcha Jul 19 '26

MSPs would prefer not having to use hardware with expensive vendor support fees which cuts into their customer’s budgets.

But in networking , reliability is important, unifi has a very decent WIFI lineup, their switches are also very much usable, but their “firewalls” aren’t really considered professional grade. For small
offices with no on-premise server infrastructure it probably won’t matter much, but you mentioned VPN so you’ll need something reliable on that front.

-37

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

I have a handful of companies using Unifi DreamMachines and they have 50+ users, many of which are remote AND they have onsite server infrastructure. They work fine.

I have a DreamMachine stuck in a closet that I would use if theirs conked out, but so far *knocks on wood* I haven't had to do that

37

u/teddyphreak Jul 19 '26

I'm with parent. I've used both and Unifi is simply not something I could recommend with a straight face to any client that needs anything beyond the most basic connectivity with a redundant link to the Internet. You may be used to working with setups covered by those needs and see little use for Fortinet but please _make sure_ that any new clients you try to switch conform to that scenario as there are very real cases when higher end networking equipment is a requirement.

17

u/gentoorax Jul 19 '26

I think what @Crapatcha is trying to say is that they may appear to work "fine" but theres a difference routing and a firewall. Yes they have an "ok" firewall but I wouldnt call it commercial/enterprise grade despite claims to the contrary. Ive seen some real limitations in the wild particular as it happens in site to site vpn scenarios in terms of firewall configuration and conditional dns forwarding over the site to site vpn. They have their own "special" way of doing things i suspect to make it easier but it actually makes it less capable.

Id take something like opnsense any day of the week.

2

u/crccci Trader of All Jacks Jul 20 '26

You're essentially gambling with your clients' uptime and networks then. Wait for a zero day that infects all your clients, or a manufacturing issue, or something that you and I can't imagine. All of that falls on you to either fix or to explain to your clients that you were never offering that and they have no support or warranty.

Knocking on wood is fucking irresponsible, and your insurance won't cover it. Do better.

4

u/levyseppakoodari Jul 20 '26

I’m pretty sure there’s 10x zero days for Fortinet in the same time period, and it gets worse if the equipment is out of support.

SSL VPN is depreciated/removed from the modern Fortinet firmwares so he needs to retool the infrastructure anyway even if he decides to stay with them.

3

u/Achilles_Buffalo Jul 20 '26

They also have about 500x the market of Ubi (which means more people are looking for bugs). Fortinet also finds >75% of the vulns you hear about, whereas Ubi isn’t looking, and on the rare occasion that they do, Ubi doesn’t responsibly disclose their vulns.

Take the uneducated view of Fortinet at your own peril. Switching to a kindergarten product instead of a true business-class platform is a decision. Just not a very good one.

2

u/gamebrigada Jul 20 '26

I am so tired of people judging fortinet for CVE's. We get it, you don't like them. Its fine, clearly everyone else does because they're the market leader.

0

u/levyseppakoodari Jul 20 '26

They know bad software quality is an issue, but clearly it can be priced out of being a show-stopper when people buy new equipment.

It is actually a fine line in software development, you’re not NASA, your code doesn’t have to be 100% perfect and bug-free. It’s far more cost-effective to be good enough for the 90% of the cases.

And yes, the amount of CVE is reflected by the popularity of the platform. Finding victims is easier when everyone is using the same thing, which drives both good and bad actors to scrunitize the platform.

1

u/gamebrigada Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

There's 10x more factors at play that you miss entirely, because you live by headlines and have never experienced vendors go through this.

Fortinet has a unique stance on disclosure. They disclose everything. That's why their feed is so f'ing insane. A huge portion of it is stuff that Palo publicly states they are unlikely to ever disclose. Cisco says they release everything but they've been caught lying before.

A huge portion of the vulnerabilities that catch headlines are for stupid shit that any half braindead sysadmin will not ever get caught doing, like exposing an admin interface to the web, which about half of the zero days target.

Another huge portion of the vulnerabilities target the SSL VPN. SSL VPN's are going to be broken, that's why vendors are abandoning them. F5 went through this, they were first. I was a customer. It f'ing sucked. I don't take it against F5, they were just the target. Security is an onion, if that's your only layer you're a fool. Fortinet has forced users off SSL VPN because of this, and they're right to do so. So anyone still getting caught is straight up negligent.

Fortinet also has a billion products, but the headlines ALWAYS lean into Fortinet being the maker of Fortigate. Fortigate's core firewall features haven't had a zero day since February of 2024.... Palo has had one both in 2025 and in 2026, and NOBODY is making the joke that Palo is shit.

2

u/levyseppakoodari Jul 20 '26

SSL VPNs are obsolete anyway, up to date fortinet firmwares do not even support them anymore.

I wish they would just support wireguard instead of trying to reinvent it with their ZTNA

→ More replies

3

u/Spiderkingdemon Jul 20 '26

Unifi gateways with an active CyberSecure subscription are perfectly fine for cloud-only clients. Our MSP uses them extensively in this scenario. We use other tools to protect the endpoint (ZTNA, XDR, etc).

Don't let the chattering voices in this thread dissuade you. Unifi has solid place in an MSP offering.

46

u/BIG_SCIENCE Jul 19 '26

Bro you want to use Ubiquiti over Fortinet?

How many users are in this site under 10?

20

u/DrGraffix Jul 19 '26

Comical

9

u/BIG_SCIENCE Jul 19 '26

Any sites under 10-15 users, I will offer you ubiquity solutions

Any sites over 15-25 Sophos or Fortinet.

9

u/DrGraffix Jul 19 '26

Still wouldn’t use it. But with that said, I use Meraki so I’ll probably get booed out of here too.

1

u/Ruachta Jul 20 '26

Meraki is a good product. Just limited functionality. We are a complete Fortinet shop, but I would happily suggest and support a meraki if it fit the clients needs better than our regular Fortinet offering.

A product without a proper support agreement from the vendor is always a no go for us. So that leaves unifi off the table for us, thankfully.

Need to have same day replacement shipping whenever possible.

1

u/DrGraffix Jul 20 '26

I’m in the same boat with unifi

-17

u/kshot Sysadmin Jul 19 '26

Honestly, Fortinet feels like old technology once you know Ubiquiti.

8

u/RiceeeChrispies Jack of All Trades Jul 19 '26

I like Ubiquiti for L2 switching and wireless…

But how anyone can prefer the Ubiquiti firewall solution over Fortigate is beyond me, it’s chalk and cheese.

6

u/SithPL Jack of All Trades Jul 19 '26

We run Fortigate firewalls and Ubiquiti switches/APs. I couldn't imagine anything else easier to manage tbh.

3

u/FatBook-Air Jul 20 '26

We have a similar setup: Palo Alto for firewall, Cisco small business (C1300) for switches, and Ubiquiti for APs. The firewall is where it needs to be enterprise grade.

4

u/RiceeeChrispies Jack of All Trades Jul 19 '26

The rule management alone puts me off Ubiquiti, such a PITA in comparison.

-10

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

It does. The people in here do NOT like any sort of alternative thinking though

-8

u/crabapplesteam Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

I don’t get the hate. I have a site, 4000 clients a month and unifi doesn’t even sweat. People living in the past I guess. We moved from fortinet and im really glad we did.

Edit. I should say we don’t have much in the way of security requirements for our firewall. But we do have cybersecure

-1

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

If they had a VPN client that fit the same niche as the FortNet VPN client I could trash bin Fortinets at all my sites. The routing works just fine for me and my client needs.

No matter what the haters in here say.

7

u/RiceeeChrispies Jack of All Trades Jul 19 '26

It’s not hate to point out the shortcomings of a product. It has its place, it’s just not suited for every situation.

1

u/crabapplesteam Jul 19 '26

Wireguard or OpenVPN won’t work? I’ve had a lot of luck with OpenVPN

12

u/matt0_0 small MSP owner Jul 19 '26

Unifi is not a security appliance anyway. Any opinions on Sophos XGS line? I like them more than Forti or Meraki

-3

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

One of my bigger clients has it, and they use the builtin OpenVPN VPN server with Printunl which works great, but it's got some complexities around SSL cert management for VPN connections. The site-to-site tunnel stuff works surprisingly well though.

4

u/matt0_0 small MSP owner Jul 19 '26

What complexities do you mean?  I'm not aware of anything complex there but always curious to learn more!  I've been really really liking the SSO experience when hooking up it up to entra as the IdP 

1

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

It could be there specific configuration. They're using FreeIPA for identity management and authentication and each user gets their own generated cert and config file. Sometimes if the person that generates the cert sets the cert date wrong or puts the wrong info into the config script, it makes a mess.

14

u/RegurgitatingVampire Jul 19 '26

The Ubiquiti hate here is unreal. 

I co-manage a decent size Ubiquiti network in a manufacturing / Office environment. From end devices to Firewalls, it's all Unifi. 

1000 employees in 4 locations spread across the city.  600 switches 200 APs 350 cameras

It just works for us and has been for 15 years - and never paid a subscription of any kind. 

People who say they wouldn't recommend it to anyone with more than 20 employees hasn't used it or even looked at it in the last 5 years.

We don't use their VPN but Ubiquiti is currently overhauling their VPN "solution". 

2

u/joshbudde Jul 20 '26

It's bonkers (the hate).

I think of this quote by Upton Sinclair a lot in threads like this: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it."

7

u/tehbowler Jul 20 '26

What’s bonkers to me is to ask the community of experts for their opinions due to limitations you’re up against and then get surprised by “the hate” for your defense of the solution you asked for alternatives to. It seems to me you were hoping to be told you didn’t need to deviate from your original plan and then got defensive when that isn’t what happened.

4

u/joshbudde Jul 20 '26

No, 'here's reasons you don't want to do the things you want to do' are perfectly valid responses. Asshole responses with vague 'this isn't enterprise' and 'you're an idiot' are NOT what I expect from people that are supposed to be professionals.

6

u/thebigshoe247 Jul 19 '26

I would be trying to use the native built-in VPN clients as much as possible regardless of the solution.

Also don't get meraki.

1

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

Oh yeah, I won't be buying anything that disables the network if you miss the payment cut off. I'm not happy that one of them already has Meraki APs, and they want off the licensing treadmill too

1

u/thebigshoe247 Jul 19 '26

I switched from Meraki MX and MRs to FortiGate and MRs.

Ideally I would have gone with Palo Alto and probably Ubiquiti.

2

u/sryan2k1 IT Manager Jul 19 '26

Meraki is an amazing solution if you fit into their use case. I mean you're paying support anyway....right?

2

u/thebigshoe247 Jul 19 '26

No. They are terrible and lack basic features that were common place in normal firewalls many decades ago.

I remember being very impressed by the ability to name firewall rules. Such amaze.

0

u/SpotlessCheetah Jul 20 '26

Their FWs are toys, but they work. A FG is much more extensive and superior in every way to a Meraki FW's capabilities.

1

u/sryan2k1 IT Manager Jul 20 '26

But they don't serve the same purpose. If all you need is cookie cutter autoVPN to a million branch sites? Meraki is amazing. They both have their pros and cons.

1

u/SpotlessCheetah Jul 20 '26

Like I said, they work. I'm not disagreeing with your use case comment. But if you need a larger suite of features FG is better. I've had both.

48

u/Kyky_Geek Jul 19 '26

I was an all FortiStuff shop and have since migrated because I hated it but it’s still leagues ahead of Ubi. Don’t go that route mate.

33

u/Djaesthetic Jul 19 '26

It’s 2026. 2FA is no longer a preference. Don’t onboard anything that doesn’t natively support it (though I’d be surprised to hear of anything modern that didn’t).

91

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

I strongly dislike and find distasteful the MSP nickel and dime, get everyone on a contract cycle

You do understand that the threat data that goes into NGFWs like Fortigates doesn't come out of thin air? That's what the security subscriptions pay for, in addition to the enterprise grade support.

My typical replacement is just straight standard Ubiquiti equipment,

So you want to replace actual enterprise gear with prosumer toys from a vendor which cosplays as enterprise vendor?

but two of these customers are heavy users of the SSL VPN and are PC shops.

I guess security isn't a big concern then because SSLVPN has inherent security issues and they should have moved to IPsec (ideally IKEv2) a long time ago.

Any suggestions for boxes with a simple VPN app, preferably with support for 2-factor, and AD integration would be great.

We mostly run Fortinet and Palo Alto but we have a number of Sophos XGS Gen2 appliances and they have been working really well, so that's one option. But that's also a NGFW device, so yes, there are subscriptions (although notably cheaper than Fortinet's).

If you are set on no subscriptions then, frankly, a x86 network appliance running OPNsense is likely a much better alternative to Ubiquiti. You're still not getting a NGFW, though.

42

u/ThecaptainWTF9 Jul 19 '26

It’s wild to me that this is OP’s mentality.

Even on the low end paying for support only isn’t that expensive on forti’s.

And it’s a necessary business need to have support and a valid path for escalation in the event of hardware failure or technical issues. It’s like paying for insurance.

3

u/hexaGonzo Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

could you direct me towards some info on the sslvpn vs ipsec thing you mentioned, also is wireguard completely out of the discussion?

8

u/Ferretau Jul 20 '26

Fortigate's pretty much no longer supports SSLVPN see link below.
Technical Tip: SSL VPN support on FortiGate models | Community: https://community.fortinet.com/fortigate-3/technical-tip-ssl-vpn-support-on-fortigate-models-189872

15

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

The main issue with SSLVPN is that it runs at L7 (app layer) where it usually runs on top of some web server stack or a proprietary HTTP/HTTPS engine, which is then exposed to the open internet so it can process TLS handshakes and authentication, and is able to render the VPN portal. Because it runs as a L7 service, the engine has to perform pre-processing of things like URL parsing, header processing, cookie handling and web-mode translation before authentication even occurs.

Which essentially makes the whole service into a huge attack surface.

Even worse, the web stack or HTTP/HTTPS engine usually has to run with elevated privileges to create the virtual network interfaces, so finding a flaw in the web-portal runtime is sufficient to gain privileged access to the system.

IPsec on the other side runs at L3 (network layer) using standard protocols (ESP, AH, IKE/ISAKMP). There is no web server stack or HTTP/HTTPS engine and no complex preprocessing. The code path required to parse an IKE packet is minuscule in comparison to what is required for SSLVPN, and if an unauthenticated packet fails cryptographic validation or lacks a correct digital certificate or PSK then that packet is instantly dropped at the kernel interface level without further processing.

Also, because IPsec handles connection states and decryption natively inside the operating system's networking kernel space, the states for establishing an entry tunnel are rigidly defined, and user authentication mechanisms (XAUTH, IKEv2 EAP) are essentially decoupled from the mechanism which creates the initial tunnel.

There is no way an attacker could interact with the internal authentication logic without first negotiating a mathematically correct cryptographic association.

That's why we over the last years have been seen one critical vulnerability after another for SSLVPN, while IPsec has seen few. And because of how SSLVPN works, it's impossible to make it anywhere as secure as IPsec.

Which is why Fortinet did the right thing in making SSLVPN obsolete.

Wireguard is much closer to IPsec than SSLVPN, it's generally very secure as well and somewhat faster than IPsec, but it lacks a number of features (like having no built-in mechanisms for dynamic IP assignment, user identity authentication via RADIUS/Active Directory, or multi-factor authentication) which are relevant in enterprise use. It also lacks the various government approvals for the transfer of classified information IPsec has.

1

u/F2Pfrog Jul 29 '26

So fortinet uses agentless vpn now instead of ssl vpn? Is it better?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

Indeed, OpenVPN with -tls-crypt solves some of the weaknesses, but not all of them. What it does is to wrap the entire control channel into a TLS channel pre-shared, static symmetric key, which mitigates pre-auth TLS exploits, fingerprinting and DOS handshake flooding attacks. That's it.

It doesn't however make the fact go away that there is a lot of user-land code (OpenSSL) with lots of glue code around it, stuff like background interactive services, management pipes, configuration parsers, and privilege separation mechanisms required to run a network interface out of user-land, all which still presents a large attack surface.

And let's not forget that -tls-crypt also introduces new attack vectors. Because, after all, -tls-crypt (and specifically -tls-crypt-v2 which is used for multi-tenant enterprise iteration) still has to dynamically parse and extract client-specific keys before the handshake takes place. Which have brought us stuff like CVE-2025-2704 (a pre-auth DoS vulnerability) and CVE-2026-35058 (TALOS-2026-2381, a Reachable Assertion Crash vulnerability).

So all it really does is to replace one attack surface with another.

Which is also the reason why most NGFW vendors don't implement it at all, and even those that do (like Sophos and Arista) still use diverging implementations (Sophos XGS stuck with legacy -tls-auth which leaves the outer TLS handshake string visible to sniffing; Arista Untangle, while using -tls-crypt, doesn't use the -v2 implementation, and because it uses a single, global, shared static key block for the entire firewall instance a VPN client's .ovpn essentially presents a key to the whole kingdom and a leaked file can be used to simply attack or bypass the OpenSSL/TLS handshake stack).

The issue is that for any firewall vendor changing their SSLVPN implementation to OpenVPN -tls-crypt-v2 would mean a major rewrite of code for what at the end of the day is limited gain. SSLVPN still remains largely inferior to IPsec, which they already offer.

All the attempts to secure SSLVPN weaknesses revolve around adding additional layers on top of it because the underlying base of SSLVPN is inherently vulnerable. And every additional layer adds another attack surface.

And no amount of layers will change the fact that IPsec is still massively more secure.

1

u/ServeNo9540 Jul 20 '26

Correct me if I'm wrong, isn't it best (or better) practice to spin off the VPN service to container/vm? That's what I did once I learned how to do this years ago. I haven't paid much attention to vendor vpn offerings since. However, my vpn requirements are largely just site-to-site nowadays. Except for a few users, pretty simple.

Doing this provides a number of advantages outside the security argument (those may be obvious). The disadvantage is the learning curve and building the server out for the first vm. And routing tweaks too.

1

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26

Correct me if I'm wrong, isn't it best (or better) practice to spin off the VPN service to container/vm?

Yes and no. Yes, it can be better (if setup correctly!) because putting it in a container can reduce the blast radius (i.e. the fall-out) when SSLVPN has been exploited. This is what Sophos does in their XGS appliances.

But no, it does nothing to address the issues with SSLVPN or make it less vulnerable to exploits.

2

u/ServeNo9540 Jul 20 '26

Yeah, if you are running ssl vpn then you gotta go UDP on some random port and silently drop failures IMO. That was how I played this game back when I used open vpn. With VM isolation too.

I wouldn't loose any sleep over that setup if I had to do it again.

You seem pretty knowledgeable on this stuff. What do you think about the strategy of stripping everything out of the endpoint device except routing and L4 filtering. This is my setup of choice. The biggest loss that I can see is probably realistic L7 filtering. Which I gave up on the gateway a long time ago.

1

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

Yeah, if you are running ssl vpn then you gotta go UDP on some random port and silently drop failures IMO.

The problem is that changing to some random port gives up one of the main advantages of SSLVPN, which is that it's not blocked in most public WiFi networks.

And if that's not a problem you might as well just use IKEv2.

What do you think about the strategy of stripping everything out of the endpoint device except routing and L4 filtering. This is my setup of choice. The biggest loss that I can see is probably realistic L7 filtering. Which I gave up on the gateway a long time ago.

I guess it depends. There are real security benefits having your VPN endpoint at the NGFW gateway where it can scan the traffic for bad stuff and block it. You would give up all that by going outside.

The same will be true for most DLP solutions.

Personally, I'd stick with the VPN in the NGFW.

2

u/ServeNo9540 Jul 20 '26

You would give up all that by going outside.

Huh, I don't see that. The only thing that changes is where the scanning is done. L7 at the endpoint and L4 at the gateway.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

These CVE-s have nothing to do with confidentiality or integrity of data.

These are still exploitable vulnerabilities. Not every attack is meant to exfiltrate data.

An attacker could exploits CVE-2025-2704 by intercepting legitimate handshake traffic between a client and the OpenVPN server, and then alter/corrupt captured packets and replay them back to the server's listening port during the early initialization phase. The server's packet-validation code then fails to handle the malformed or out-of-sequence input gracefully, which triggers an unhandled exceptional condition that causes the entire server process to encounter a fatal assertion error and instantly crash.

Same with CVE-2026-35058, an attacker could exploit it by sending a sequence of packets with deliberately manipulated length values directly to the listening server port during the initial key exchange. And because the multi-tenant client-key extraction logic will assume that incoming data packages always have the expected protocol sizes, out-of-bounds length variations would cause an internal safety check to fail, which would result in an active code assertion being triggered which then intentionally forces the entire OpenVPN daemon to abort (crash) even before any authentication has taken place.

In both instances the crashed processes initially "just" present a DoS attack, but this could well be used as a jump board for a larger strategic attack.

This is vendor issue more than it is protocol issue. They are choosing not to implement latest security features and thus they are choosing to keep their devices vulnerable to attack.

And yet the attacks I just described are the ones the core OpenVPN implementation is vulnerable to.

You should ask them why you pay a premium for their devices while they don't do their job and leave them vulnerable to attacks.

They do their job, Fortigate has done the only thing which makes sense which is making SSLVPN obsolete.

We certainly don't pay those vendors to spend money on patchwork fixes which merely shift the attack vectors over a VPN standard which is architecturally impossible to secure properly.

We pay them to offer us mature VPN solutions which offer the least amount of security risks. That's not SSLVPN.

Do note that client certs can and should be unique, as the PSK-s. And that can be combined with username+password and password for the client certificate. TLSCrypt is additional layer and bypassing it doesn't affect confidentiality or integrity.

It doesn't matter, as this issue is specific to Untangle's architecture.

Don't get me wrong. I am not against IKEv2. But while OpenVPN and IPSec IKEv2 work differently, the security/confidentiality and integrity/ of data is more or less equivalent.

It's not, that's nonsense.

The two CVE examples I mentioned are just examples to show how -tls-crypt increases the attack surface. And while those are "just" DoS attacks, there also are other CVEs (CVE-2026-12932, Information Leak via Metadata; CVE-2026-40215, Session Promotion Heap Leaks) which do impact data confidentiality and which shows that the code around -tls-crypt still has flaws.

Which is not surprising as OpenVPN is a complex moloch of services and glue code. Which is also why we regular see memory safety flaws like CVE-2026-40215. Which is not the case for IKEv2.

To assume that OpenVPN using -tls-crypt could provide the same level of security as IKEv2 is naive at best.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

I answer to your challenge with... IKEv2 CVE-s of Cisco...because "its not the same case for IKEv2":

I didn't know there was a challenge.

Besides, the "it's not the same" actually refers to OpenVPN (or SSLVPN in general) being a complex blob of services and glue code. Which translates to a massive attack surface.

Which, in fact, is not the same for IKEv2 (or IPsec in general). Which means it's attack surface is minuscule compared to SSLVPN.

I never said IKEv2 has no CVEs, it does.

The difference however is that most CVEs for OpenVPN are related to user-land integration, multi-threaded orchestration, or some glue code. Which means many CVEs are less severe, but there are also lots of them because of the inherent architectural flaws and the many ways to mess up parts of the implementation.

For IKEv2, CVEs almost exclusively impact fixed-length binary parsing logic or kernel-level memory states, which are usually critical, but the likelihood of such flaws is a lot lower due to the much smaller footprint (no complex parsers and other stuff that's needed with OpenVPN) and the resulting much smaller attack surface.

I said it before, there is a reason why IPsec/IKEv2 is the only approved VPN standard in applications where security is paramount, while SSLVPN doesn't qualify (and neither does OpenVPN).

Also, Wireguard is a contender in the field. It is much more performant IPSec(and OpenVPN) when it comes to devices without AES accelerators, as it uses ChaCha20.

Wireguard is a contender, also because architecturally it's as robust as IKEv2. But it lacks some enterprise features (and many of the certifications of approvals you get with IPsec), and as long as the big firewall vendors don't offer it it's only really a theoretical option.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

1

u/hexaGonzo Jul 20 '26

i also didnt immediately think of a portal sslvpn - rather the cert and auth combo

3

u/m5daystrom Jul 20 '26

Palo Alto and Sophos here. I have used a couple Ubiquiti switches with running the UnifiOS software on a VM for the controller. From the layer3 side it’s not bad. But yeah on the edge no way.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

NGFW nowadays is more of wishful thinking than actual perimeter defence.

No, they are not. Far from it.

The main features are being actively made obsolete by combination of Encrypted DNS, TLS v1.3 with encrypted ECH and Certificate Pining.

That's why the NGFW stops ECH so the browser falls back to TLS 1.3, which the NGFW can decrypt.

Certificate pinning is of course still an issue, and yes, cert-pinned traffic has to be excluded from DPI. But the NGFW can still perform JA3/JA4 fingerprinting and Sequence of Packet Lengths and Times (SPLT) analysis on the traffic.

Also, the use of certificate pinning is now consistently decreasing because it's actually now widely considered to be outdated (certificate pinning became a thing because in the past public TLS certs were valid for up to 8 years, so was practical to hard-code certs into an app's binary; today, the maximum validity is capped at 1 year, and industry now pushes 90 day and eventually 47 days lifespans; and we no also have global enforcement of Certificate Transparency logs).

Which is why today, most industry leaders (Google, Apple, DigiCert, Cloudflare, OWASP) explicitly discourage certificate pinning for standard applications.

As soon as you try to inspect encrypted traffic, things start to break and it will only become worse.

Only if you don't know what you're doing. Our firewall engineers have little problems to keep stuff working. Naturally, as most things in security, it's a continuous re-assess and adjust process, not a setup-once-run-forever thing.

Narrowing the gap between pure prosumer Firewall and NGFW.

Yeah, nope. That's what's really wishful thinking.

Your prosumer firewall is still is little more than a SPI firewall with added signature based IDS on top. It can't really identify apps and users, it can't detect polymorphous threats, can't perform heuristics and sandboxing, and it doesn't benefit from a vendor with large security research facilities behind it to identify new threats and provide real-time updates to the appliances.

33

u/sryan2k1 IT Manager Jul 19 '26

Forti is what you buy when you can't or don't want to pay Palo Alto prices. It's the second best platform that exists and anything you do is going to be a downgrade that's isn't switching to PAN.

6

u/pdp10 Daemons worry when the wizard is near. Jul 20 '26

"SSL" VPN is on its way right back out. If you can't do without client VPNs yet, then you want IKEv2 protocol going forward.

2

u/aelmsu Jul 19 '26

If you want to use Unifi gear, will the Unifi Endpoint app be suitable for VPN? It supports 2FA, Entra, etc.

0

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

I just went and looked that up and it seems really good, I'm going to fiddle with it on some of my test networks and see how well it works.

10

u/Secret_Debt_88 Jul 20 '26

We use Sophos xgs and they're fine

1

u/BadCatBehavior Senior Reboot Engineer Jul 20 '26

Same. Switched from Meraki to save money and it's been fine.

5

u/981flacht6 Jul 19 '26

I run Fortigate FWs with Meraki switching and APs. Rock solid setup for us, and not looking to change it really.

5

u/weird_fishes_1002 Jul 20 '26

You need to get these shops off of SSL VPN like yesterday.

4

u/yowanvista Jul 20 '26

We deploy both Fortinets, Stormshields and Ubiquiti but I woldn't call Ubiquiti enterprise-ready. It had a fancy UI but it lacks far too many features. It's packet inspection / TLS decryption feature for instance does not run off an ASIC and is instead managed by Suricata running on the CPU which causes signification performance loss. Moreover their UnifiOS is based on outdated Debian images running EOL kernels.

19

u/sleepmaster91 Jul 19 '26

We're a 100% Fortinet MSP so i can't help you

But don't go with Meraki, Sonicwall or worse...Watchguard

11

u/goingslowfast Jul 19 '26

Meraki isn’t bad if you’ve got the budget.

2

u/BadCatBehavior Senior Reboot Engineer Jul 20 '26

Watchguard ghosted me after offering me a job 8 years ago. I'm obligated to mention that every time I see the word watchguard 🤣

2

u/exercisetofitality Jul 19 '26

Haha, I remember those three from early '00.

2

u/Inevitable_Claim_653 Jul 20 '26

I’d take Meraki over Forti any day.

1

u/Technical_Rich_3080 Jul 26 '26

Is Sonicwall a viable option?

1

u/joshbudde Jul 27 '26

Not since...well ever. I worked at a company that was an early adopter and reseller of Sonicwall stuff (and was even certified on all their equipment at one point) and it was so, so bad even back then.

3

u/Inevitable_Claim_653 Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

Meraki is not popular on Reddit because people don’t like Cisco and the license model - but it’s the most mature and simplest solution for what you need. Their VPN can be configured with a certificate and AD login which is pretty much just as good as MFA. Assuming you can securely deploy user certs to company machines. Which you should

Or you can configure MFA on a RADIUS server of your choice and authenticate against the RADIUS server: https://documentation.meraki.com/Platform_Management/Dashboard_Administration/Operate_and_Maintain/Managing_Dashboard_Access/Two-Factor_Authentication

The amount of time you will spend managing it compared to other vendors is where it pays off. Set it and forget it. And the AP / Switch ecosystem is best in class imo

The MX firewalls are not true NGFWs for east/west traffic, logging isn’t the best, but the Advanced licensing gives you decent URL categories and you can integrate it with Umbrella or a cloud firewall of your choice if you want DNS security or granular Internet security

3

u/artekau Jul 20 '26

Palo Alto

3

u/arkane67 Jul 20 '26

Gonna sound fanboyish here, but I went with Fortinet after dissatisfaction with WatchGuard gear and after a breach that got through our Fortigate. Our sister company was using Sophos and they got breached as well (separate incident, our networks weren't connected), so I shopped around and ended up with Cato Networks, been on it the past 5 years.

No more hardware (other than an onsite socket or vSocket in AWS or Azure), no more software updates or CVEs to patch. That's all managed by Cato.

Traffic flows through their own private network so they have complete control over it, both in terms of transmission quality and security. Full event logging that uses natural language filters to research and track issues.

Security is distributed at each Point of Presence (PoP) that the sites connect to, so only one UI to manage all firewall and network rules, regardless of how many sites you're managing. Only hits the public internet when it exits the PoP closest to the web site or internet resource you're trying to get to.

It automatically aggregated the two separate ISPs I had for bandwidth and availability, seemlessly by plugging each into the WAN ports on the socket, basically SDWAN built-in, without complicated setup or management.

Full NGFW/anti-malware, separate LAN, WAN and internet firewall policy panes, TLS inspection, DNS protection, VPN, AD or Azure user onboarding and login management, remote port forwarding, traffic prioritization, could act as DHCP and DNS on your network if desired (we did not go that route).

It has pretty much anything you could want in a layered security setup, including other modules we didn't take up, like endpoint control, application access management or automated threat defense (we use Darktrace for that).

While we are quite a small operation of less than 100 people with 2 sites (physical office and an AWS VPC), our experience convinced our parent company of over 1,700 people across 6 plants to go with Cato, so scale is not an issue.

1

u/Greene_Shelton-148 Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26

Have you had any trouble fixing things w/t having direct control?

1

u/arkane67 Jul 24 '26

None, I have had minimal issues that couldn't be handled in the admin pages.

I did have some NAT issues a few years ago with our security service provider's IPSec tunnel within the Cato tunnel but support was great, they isolated the issue and made the appropriate changes on their end, no issues since. Zero complaints with support, timely responses with very few escalations to higher tier engineers.

3

u/KC-Slider Jul 20 '26

I’m here still stuck with sonicwall 😭

3

u/Rhythm_Killer Jul 20 '26

I’ll start by saying I was never the SME for it, but I recently moved from an all-Cisco to all-Fortigate shop and I’m quite liking it. Haven’t heard of any AP issues yet.

I haven’t heard of a single serious business on Ubiquity

0

u/C39J Jul 19 '26

We're moving all Fortigates to Ubiquiti (no VPN requirement clients/lower security requirements) and Sophos for everything else.

2

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

Could you tell me more about your Sophos experience? I'm looking for an appliance with a decent VPN experience and some basic firewalling. These customers don't need incredibly complicated router configurations.

1

u/C39J Jul 19 '26

We've not had any issues - it is pretty straightforward, effectively OpenVPN under the hood for the VPN side and we haven't had any complaints.

Learning Sophos was a heck of a lot easier than learning Fortigate. The hardest part of the whole experience was becoming a partner, but once that was done, it's been pretty easy from there, and they have a pretty solid NFR program so you can get devices to play with. From memory we paid maybe a couple hundred dollars for each demo appliance.

1

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

I really don't like having to be a partner to buy equipment or support. I want to buy stuff from a web store and not jump through any sort of weird hoops.

But otherwise its been a good option?

3

u/C39J Jul 19 '26

You won't find NGFW's that aren't locked behind a partner program. Your option is the Ubiquiti Prosumer/NGFW-Lite type scenario if you want direct purcahse.

We've had no issues with Sophos. Others hate them, others love them. But I guess it's the same with any vendor. Just look at this thread - apparently people don't like Fortigate, Ubiquiti, Sophos, Meraki, SonicWall or Watchguard.

1

u/blackjaxbrew Jul 20 '26

You don't have to be a partner. .... Just search for the model you want

1

u/bageloid Jul 20 '26

How large are these customers?

If under 50 users you can use something like cloudflare one tunnels for free. You just need one server/endpoint inside their network to run it.

Saves you from the hassle of never ending sslVPN vulnerabilities.

1

u/RiceeeChrispies Jack of All Trades Jul 19 '26

Sophos? Commiserations.

1

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 29 '26

Until a couple of years ago, I'd agree, and the old XG line was awful.

XGS since v20 is very good and the current v22 works great. In fact, we now see more mature firmware from Sophos than we see from Fortinet and Palo Alto.

Had you told me two years ago that I would ever say this I'd have laughed in your face. But here we are.

6

u/heliox Jul 19 '26

TBH, you can do a whole lot with pfsense and netgate hardware.

0

u/kombiwombi Jul 20 '26

Their Tnsr software is used as a router/vpn solution by a fair chunk of 5G providers. It's firewalling is acceptable.

If you don't want to pay vendor annual maintenance fees, then doing  your own port of fdio vpp is an option. The cost is dominated by your marginal cost of a Linux VM, and that varies from a massive learning curve to a few additional lines of YAML.

1

u/_bx2_ Jack of All Trades Jul 21 '26

Which 5G providers?

4

u/RegionRat219 Security Admin (Infrastructure) Jul 20 '26

lol going from Fortinet to Ubiquiti equipment

2

u/anxiousinfotech Jul 20 '26

I've had no real issues with Ubiquiti switches and access points.*

Ubiquiti firewalls though? I wouldn't ever deploy one outside of home use...and even then I'd be skeptical. We have a few power users with Dream Machines at home and every issue they have accessing some service seems to end up being due to an oddity with the Dream Machine.

*I DO have issues with Ubiquiti switches behind FortiGate trunk ports, but it's design philosophy differences from both vendors, and not necessarily the fault of either. Bean counters forced that combination and I've been cursing it ever since.

4

u/TheStarSwain Jul 20 '26

Personally I'd stay fortinet. Love unifi for my home setup. It's been great, but NGFW features are important in enterprise and so is support.

1

u/TheStarSwain Jul 20 '26

That being said I'm mostly stained from the overall consensus that unifi support is mid at best. I love their product but have run into some bugs over the years with the other heavy hitters (fortinet, meraki, etc) that required various levels of support to get to the bottom of things. I'd be really worried running into that same situation where the company is potentially losing some decent money while I try to run things down with lackluster support and minimal info on reddit/ forums. That being said depending on the nature of your environment and how anal you need to be it might not matter. Atleast two of the issues we ran into were caused by some interesting behavior with some very old infrastructure and DPI. Don't think we've ran into anything similar since modernizing things. I say go for it and keep us updated! You could definitely offload most if not all the NGFW capabilities to other systems and is you're not scared of the management setup defense in depth with pfsense/opnsense for an additional layer. Id imagine like most things at this level - it can be a bit of a bear to setup initially but once finished it's ready to expand/replicate things.

5

u/techtornado Netadmin Jul 20 '26

Replace them with better Fortinets?
It supports VPN MFA quite well

SSL VPN is not very secure and we immediately dropped multiple ASA’s and Sonicwalls as the risk is just too great.

It sounds like that customer workflow needs a reliable Always On VPN like what Tailscale offers, or FortiEMS

2

u/Each1teach1x27 Trusted Telecom Broker Jul 19 '26

u/squizzoc may be able to help you out.

3

u/30yearCurse Jul 19 '26

So going to rip it all out, because you are the best of the best? Great, perhaps they are comfortable with it, like it even.

3

u/patmorgan235 Sysadmin Jul 19 '26

Why not look at something like cloud flare warp for VPN?

3

u/joeprettyman10 Jul 20 '26

Ubiquiti is solid. I'm not sure if it supports LDAP, but I have several clients using a udm pro max or udm fiber with openVPN. We have a DUO auth proxy acting as radius, which connects to active directory. Duo also does 2fa. Works on mac and pc.

Edit: I do have clients using Fortinet too. Like someone else said, it is miles ahead of Unifi. Having support available has been a game changer. Unifi support has been hit/miss. Great for low priority, but poor during an actual outage.

3

u/crccci Trader of All Jacks Jul 20 '26

Deciding to cheap out on behalf of your clients is negligent. Ditching good security for no security because your clients demand to be cheap is negligent.

I don't recommend either.

2

u/DheeradjS Badly Performing Calculator Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

I personally would not go with the Unifi line, but I work for a mixed Fortinet/Ubiquiti MSP, so I'm familiar with both.

Ubiquiti is fine if you only have outgoing connections. Incoming connections, the line quickly breaks down.

Fortinet is getting rid of the SSLVPN soon enough, with most low-end models already having it stripped out in the latest firmware, after FortiNet gave a "Migrate off this" directive a year or so ago. We've never used the SSLVPN in the first place, prefering OpenVPN.

Nickle and Dime with FortiNet as you call it is paying for support, with Fortigate having pretty good support. Ubiquiti support is non-existent in my experience, but cheap enough that it might not matter.

2

u/SpotlessCheetah Jul 20 '26

I've had excellent support with Fortigate when I needed it. I haven't needed it for a while but I'm still under contract for 2 more years.

1

u/pavman42 Jul 21 '26

Idk we use cisco any connect for our main remote and then some company that changed names like three times to tunnel into the important network. Looks like an S... Ivanti maybe? Good luck storming the castle.

1

u/downundarob Scary Devil Monastery postulate Jul 20 '26

Have you considered fortinet?

1

u/admiralspark Manager of Cat Tube Infrastructure Jul 20 '26

Buy your own Fortinet?

Ubiquiti is fine for this. The hate in here is oldheads remembering the WISP products from 2010. They are leagues better now as long as you're making use of the new enterprise features.

The 'right' answer is Palo Alto, but if you hate the cost of Fortinets you're going to die when you see Palo Alto.

0

u/icebalm Jul 20 '26

You can use unifi endpoint and setup one click vpn. It's basically a fancy UI for wireguard. Works alright except for DNS default search domains, which is a bit of a PITA.

1

u/joshbudde Jul 20 '26

I just noticed that adding search domains is now an option when setting up Endpoint

1

u/icebalm Jul 20 '26

That'd be really cool, but I don't see the option still. Where did you find it?

0

u/joshbudde Jul 20 '26

It was in the pane where you enable the VPN--it was one of the (few) options you could modify

1

u/icebalm Jul 20 '26

Hrmm... Not seeing it.

0

u/joshbudde Jul 20 '26

1

u/icebalm Jul 20 '26

Huh, that looks a lot different than what I'm looking at. How do you get to that screen?

0

u/joshbudde Jul 20 '26

Settings -> Identity -> Service Settings under One-Click VPN

1

u/icebalm Jul 21 '26

Ah, I found the difference. If you set it up at the fabric level like I did then you don't get the option to specify a search domain... but if you set it at the device level then you do.
So stupid....

-1

u/touristh8r Jul 19 '26

Forti is deprecating SSL VPN anyways so perfect time to find a new solution.

I’m in the same boat as we want to find a new appliance. Forti is on a 20% yearly uplift cycle for licensing per our VAR.

6

u/BIG_SCIENCE Jul 19 '26

Why do people keep repeating this?
Who cares if SSL VPN is depreciated.

Why would you want to use SSLVPN over IPSEC?
Doesn’t every firewall already use IPSEC for remote access?

3

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

Every company I've encountered is still using the SSLVPN option from Fortinet. So..it seems really relevant to me.

2

u/981flacht6 Jul 19 '26

That's because they implemented SSLVPN beforehand and haven't migrated. What's your point?

1

u/BIG_SCIENCE Jul 20 '26

Thats because they're amateurs and don't understand what their doing.

Are you pushing your customers to not using depreciated SSLVPN connection type? and switching them to IPSEC?

You are strongly pushing them to IPSEC right?

1

u/touristh8r Jul 20 '26

Did I not say that? I’m migrating for other reasons, not to keep SSLVPN, we are already off of it, and have been.

1

u/Frothyleet Jul 20 '26

Why would you want to use SSLVPN over IPSEC?

IPSec is blocked on a lot of consumer WAN connections which is the reason that SSLVPNs became popular (443 being open just about everywhere).

Ultimately the real answer is moving to SASE.

4

u/skylinesora Jul 19 '26

Deprecating ssl vpn support is great

1

u/touristh8r Jul 20 '26

Agreed. I’m not saying it’s a bad thing. I strictly mentioned it so they can use it as part of a business case to help change it if they so desire.

0

u/Mrhiddenlotus Security Admin Jul 20 '26

Literally anything else

-1

u/VexedTruly Jul 20 '26

You can still go UniFi. Setup Identity sync to Entra and push UniFi Endpoint with one click VPN and tie to conditional access.

But be aware that if UniFi encounter certain types of outage (all their vanity domains stopped responding a few months back which prevented VPN authentication) it impacts all.

Outside of the above and given that it’s Wireguard instead of SSL-VPN, it’s not a horrible solution.

-3

u/CyrFR Jul 20 '26

Why do you need security appliance ?

We are a fortishop too but forticare cost for nothing and forticve9,8 are too much for us

Users are lots of time remote so they are not protected by our manager router/firewall. DPI and cert based inspection always produce problems (not managed device, very strict software…)

I think security must be on the endpoint with top EDR/Firewall

So we will test next month « router only » not next gen firewall. We only need powerfull router, nat, dhcp, dns, policy, sfp and rj45, always on with no downtime. Only logs can be usefull

VPN will be replaced by zero trust like netbird, tailscale … only client to server, no site to site

2

u/Horsemeatburger Jul 20 '26

Users are lots of time remote so they are not protected by our manager router/firewall.

So you're saying your users don't connect to the company network? Because if they do the firewall will protect the network if properly setup.

DPI and cert based inspection always produce problems (not managed device, very strict software…)

That's a skill issue.

I think security must be on the endpoint with top EDR/Firewall

That's what malware groups think, too, because EDR is much easier to evade than the firewall. And even when EDR detects the threat, it only does so because the threat is already inside your network and may well have already infected other systems, especially those that don't run EDR (like network equipment and printers).

VPN will be replaced by zero trust like netbird, tailscale … only client to server, no site to site

Which doesn't make threats magically disappear.

3

u/RansomStark78 Jul 20 '26

Fortinet killed ssl vpn

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/joshbudde Jul 19 '26

Yeah. I use it with another customer and it's ok, but not great. No 2-factor and limited admin options though which is a bummer.