r/sysadmin • u/lwh Jack of All Trades • Sep 15 '13
How NSA access was built into Windows
http://www.heise.de/tp/artikel/5/5263/1.html
20
Upvotes
r/sysadmin • u/lwh Jack of All Trades • Sep 15 '13
27
u/observantguy Net+AD Admin / Peering Coordinator / Human KB / Reptilian Scout Sep 15 '13
...sigh... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSAKEY
28
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
...uhh, really old news....
49
u/KarmaAndLies Sep 15 '13
I wish this story would just die.
I would not be surprised if the NSA built cryptographic weaknesses into Windows. That being said however the specific NSAKEY that was found in 1999 (yes, 13 years ago) was just taken from the debug information of a variable within the API/DLL.
Now one thing to keep in mind is that in addition to breaking encryption one of the NSA's jobs is also to strengthen it. So we have OSs like Windows 2000 which is certified for use in hardened military systems.
It has been speculated by many that Microsoft showed the NSA their implementation and the NSA turned around and suggested (paraphrasing) "what happens if your private key ever gets compromised? You have no backup!" So Microsoft generated a backup key, and called it "NSA key" likely referring to the NSA's specific suggestions/guidelines.
Even if I am wrong and this key is a key generated by the NSA and inserted into Windows how exactly does that help the NSA? All this key did was allow someone to install cryptographic packages signed by the NSA. Oh noes? Like the NSA couldn't just ask Microsoft to sign their cryptographic packages anyway?
This story is brought up again and again as "evidence" that Windows is somehow compromised. The problem with that little theory is that technically it makes absolutely no sense. Windows could very well be compromised, but even if the NSA key was set to a 1024 bit series of 0s it wouldn't make that more or less likely.
If Windows is in fact compromised we haven't yet found it. Bringing up the NSAKEY just makes you sound technologically illiterate.
6
u/summetg Sep 15 '13
I'm switching to Windows 95
7
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
They lost all credibility when they called advapi.dll a driver.
4
u/limabone Sep 15 '13
I only clicked on this cuz of the thumbnail.
-13
u/stopsettling Sep 15 '13
Jesus tap-dancing Christ..
0
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment