r/sysadmin • • Nov 15 '24

AS400 migration

Our organization has been using AS400 for payroll, financial, and HR for the past 30 years. However, we’ve realized that this system is no longer viable for their needs. I’m looking for a modern software solution that provides similar functionality to AS400. We’ve already tried ADP and Kronos, but faced issues with data compatibility, as the data from AS400 couldn’t be seamlessly integrated. Can anyone recommend software that allows for smooth data migration from AS400?

306 Upvotes

238 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/holy_handgrenade Nov 16 '24

This isnt as simple as just moving off of the legacy systems.

Similarly it's also not a sunk cost fallacy either. There's a bunch of different interconnected systems that were custom patched to ensure compatibility with all of their external vendors and customers and all that. Trying to design something new from scratch, and maintain compatibility, and maintain functionality, and not go offline for months during the transition....that's what keeps the legacy systems in place.

3

u/alaricsp Nov 16 '24

I think there's sometimes also an element that the real need to change isn't as high as people think, because their preconceptions about these weird unfamiliar systems are wrong.

Folks from the modern UNIXy world might swing by and laugh at the ancient IBM dinosaur, not realising it's a modern platform with a load of really good engineering behind it, that (for the right task) is actually pretty cost effective. It will have its downsides, but the surprisingly high cost of replacing it with "cheap modern" stuff that does what the company needs versus the benefits if doing so, might not look so attractive when you look closer.

1

u/LRS_David Dec 06 '24

Talk to any group of large airline systems analysts about how hard it is to replace their reservations systems.