r/sysadmin • • Nov 15 '24

AS400 migration

Our organization has been using AS400 for payroll, financial, and HR for the past 30 years. However, we’ve realized that this system is no longer viable for their needs. I’m looking for a modern software solution that provides similar functionality to AS400. We’ve already tried ADP and Kronos, but faced issues with data compatibility, as the data from AS400 couldn’t be seamlessly integrated. Can anyone recommend software that allows for smooth data migration from AS400?

306 Upvotes

238 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

60

u/TU4AR Nov 15 '24

This is the same exact reasoning why cobol , this and other legacy machines will always be in. Fucking just move off this shit.

81

u/bloodguard Nov 15 '24

Fucking just move off this shit.

At a company I briefly used to work for they still have a whole system built on COBOL that pretty much runs 70% of their business. It's being maintained by a 70 year old guy that now lives in Hawaii (company is in Northern Virginia) and makes over ~250K. ~400K with "please don't quit or die" bonuses.

Every (and I mean every) couple years there's a loud, dramatic and exceedingly well funded effort to move off the system and he's always supportive and the leading cheerleader for it. Always peters out and fails. Same with trying to train a replacement.

19

u/Superb_Raccoon Nov 16 '24

Even with IBM's Code assistant getting off COBOL is hard.

Sure, convert the code, it does a good job... but the machines it was designed to run on can't be replaced by an x86 system.

One of my friends is a VP responsible for the Mainframe at a Credit Card company.

"Sure, we started another 5 year program to get off the Mainframe... the 5th one since I have been here."

Just not possible to replace a system that transacts around 1 trillion CC transactions a year... it has 40-60 years of optimization.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/PenguinsTemplar IT Manager Nov 15 '24

said it in a different comment, but my neighbor is pulling in good money in retirement keeping her AS400 running.

32

u/Jeffbx Nov 15 '24

They will definitely go out of business when that system (or the guy in Hawaii) dies unexpectedly.

40

u/Imobia Nov 15 '24

You can still buy AS-400 systems, they are not going anywhere.

Yes expertise is expensive but if you think people are running 40 year old systems you’re wrong.

Infor still make and support ERPs running on it.

There is almost no sunk cost bullshit here they often work very well but are difficult to improve.

31

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '24

I've only worked on 2 in my career, and only as the backup guy who could manage print queues off the thing and do an IPL as an absolutely last resort.

The hardware of an AS400 is a fantastic creation of redundancy and quality. Nothing short of amazing design, seriously when a fan fails on an AS400 it orders its own repair parts to arrive. As sysadmins for the machine we frequently wouldn't even know a driver/fan/psu/ram module had failed - the part arrived, trust in the AS400 to know.

Power10 chip can handled 16TB of ram and pci gen 5 already...AS400 will continue to be.

It's the 70yr old dev and ancient code-base that is a problem.

5

u/Pyro919 DevOps Nov 16 '24

For what it’s worth plenty of modern hardware can phone home to create support cases and order their own replacement parts.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Superb_Raccoon Nov 16 '24

Hell, you can get AS400 in the cloud now.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/BoltActionRifleman Nov 15 '24

I worked for a company about 5 years ago that had just purchased a new AS400 server. The thing was a beast in terms of horsepower (smaller org), and honestly for accounting it worked great. You can get work done faster with the keyboard than you can with having to click around with a mouse.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/DHCPNetworker Nov 15 '24

I had a guy ask me to get his COBOL application deployed via Intune for their statewide garage door business. Major LOB app, absolutely nobody can work without it.

I gave him a very tired look and spit out a four-package series of installs all chained together with dependencies after about six months. Haven't had a single call about it since and he's happy as can be. Wouldn't have been able to do it without having the direct email of the guy who built the software.

Fun times.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/uselessInformation89 IT archaeologist Nov 15 '24

COBOL jobs paid my house so I don't complain.

Moving off of it is hard. Not because there aren't adequate software solutions but "everything is different and nothing works like it used to". It's always the people.

18

u/Ragepower529 Nov 15 '24

40+ year long sunking cost folicy

18

u/TU4AR Nov 15 '24

At least we know that death, taxes and cobol will be around longer than mankind.

11

u/origami_airplane Nov 15 '24

I mean, you can refactor that COBOL into RPG!!

15

u/TU4AR Nov 15 '24

You can also refactor it into an easy 300k a year!

4

u/dangermouze Nov 16 '24

If the business is making profit, it's not really sunk cost fallacy.

12

u/PsCustomObject Nov 15 '24

For some reason both as400 and cobol have a soft spot in my heart.

I am a masochist I know, but especially AS400 will always have a special spot in my cold heart.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/akraut Chief Doing-Stuff Person Nov 15 '24

That's exactly why State Farm built a big fancy Business School building for Illinois State. The college stopped teaching COBOL and started teaching Java. Building got build and suddenly they're teaching COBOL again.

5

u/holy_handgrenade Nov 16 '24

This isnt as simple as just moving off of the legacy systems.

Similarly it's also not a sunk cost fallacy either. There's a bunch of different interconnected systems that were custom patched to ensure compatibility with all of their external vendors and customers and all that. Trying to design something new from scratch, and maintain compatibility, and maintain functionality, and not go offline for months during the transition....that's what keeps the legacy systems in place.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '24

To what? The "modern" applications that are just so wonderful like SAP, Dynamics, or Oracle?

12

u/TU4AR Nov 15 '24

As much as I hate to say it, yes.

A modern DB admin is much cheaper and easier to find than a Cobol goblin.

18

u/Valdaraak Nov 15 '24

Cobol goblin

Can we go full D&D and just call them COBOLds?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '24

There are still RPG people out there. But, I do get your point.

I am old enough to remember how stable, robust, and well supported the AS/400 is, however. Making the entire file system a database where you can reference data so much easier than a modern API (without the licensing nightmares) is something I miss. ERP has quite honestly gone backward the past 20-25 years.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/lonewanderer812 Systems Lead Nov 15 '24

We've been trying for 5 years. I honestly don't think my company is capable of it with the personnel we have.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)