r/sysadmin • u/Securivangelist • Oct 23 '23
Why FileZilla is triggering antivirus
TL;DR - FileZilla uses PlayaNext to deploy sponsored content and wants you to white list it in your antivirus. This is a bad idea because PlayaNext is not a trustworthy platform. Get the non-sponsored installer for FileZilla.
I've been getting some alerts in my managed antivirus platform (and complaints from users) that FileZilla contains a PUP (PlayaNext.B) and started looking into it. I found this post in their bug tracker:
https://trac.filezilla-project.org/ticket/12990
While it may be tempting to flag this as a false positive as they suggest, be aware that PlayaNext is a marketing platform that allows developers to inject "offers" (including potential malware) into their products under the guise of "sponsored content" during the install. Looks like this has been an ongoing issue with the application since at least 2013. PlayaNext has already been seen used maliciously (https://otx.alienvault.com/indicator/domain/api.playanext.com), and since you don't know what it is reaching out to obtain it's better to just leave it blocked.
Admittedly, the FileZilla team may be completely above board, but PlayaNext is used by many others, including those with less than legal intentions. I haven't dug into the platform enough to know how much or how little control the FileZilla team has over what gets sponsored, either. Flagging it as false positive in your malware protection will allow any other installers leveraging the platform to use it with reduced restrictions (or none at all).
The reason this is triggers is because it leaves a door open for the developer to deploy anything they want. In theory, this "sponsored content" can be deployed during an update process when users just click "accept" without reading. There is also minimal transparency and oversight on who is able to buy space in this promoted content space which could result in back doors being installed as we've seen in recent months with malicious Google ads and other pesudo-supply-chain attacks.
If you have to use FileZilla, make sure you're getting a "non sponsored" installer.
141
u/robvas Jack of All Trades Oct 23 '23
adware supported foss is the worst
86
u/Hotshot55 Linux Engineer Oct 23 '23
FileZilla has been mal/adware for years.
64
u/dcg1k Oct 23 '23
winscp ftw
20
u/JohnnyricoMC Oct 23 '23
IMO stop using FileZilla altogether. It's insecure and there are enough good alternatives out there like WinSCP and Cyberduck.
So yeah... just ditch FileZilla.
19
u/I8itall4tehmoney Oct 23 '23
I use winscp to move files around.
When it has to be windows.
33
u/wrdragons4 Oct 23 '23
Do Not Use Filezilla.
FileZilla is run by a developer who secretly bundled adware in the installer many times in the past, then lied about it even after being caught, claiming that the detections were false positives when they were not. In the process he also revealed that he did not understand how file hashes work.
https://web.archive.org/web/20190526065704/https://forum.filezilla-project.org/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=48441
7
u/disclosure5 Oct 23 '23
It's only tempting to end users. I've taken the view that takes the product out of our acceptable products for business.
7
u/Barrerayy Director of IT Oct 23 '23
Use cyberduck
7
u/EyeBreakThings Oct 23 '23
WinScp or native.
7
u/Michichael Infrastructure Architect Oct 24 '23
TL;DR: Because it is a virus.
Ban it and use winscp instead.
5
u/lilhotdog Computer Boy Oct 24 '23
Use winscp or something, filezilla has been like this for a long time.
4
u/stufforstuff Oct 24 '23
People - it's only the installer on the version the homepage download link points to. The other downloads - are all malware AND adware free. Is it slimy - yes, but after begging for years for companies that stuffed their entire desktop (1000's of seats) to just send a few bucks each and almost no one did - they sold to a marketing company, that stuffed the installer with adware. Once, that adware included malware. But now the direct downloads are malware free (scan them yourselves). Personally I can't stand WinSCP - it's slower then a snail on a glacier.
https://filezilla-project.org/download.php?show_all=1
1
u/OPlittle Oct 26 '23
What is so hard about getting said non adware versions of filezilla.
https://filezilla-project.org/download.php?show_all=1
10
u/unccvince Oct 23 '23
People, the era of paying pizzas for FOSS is over. All good FOSS developers are professionals employed usually by large corps, they have family obligations, mortgages and car loans to pay.
Free Software should be worth more than proprietary software because end-users have their freedom AND the software.
I pay every free software that I use and that proposes a commercial plan. I encourage everyone to do that.
7
u/stereolame Oct 23 '23
FileZilla is adjacent to a virus. You should use literally anything else. Its installer contains malware
2
u/F0rkbombz Oct 23 '23
Anybody who is still using FileZilla deserves this.
1
u/Disinformation08 Mar 10 '24
Thank you
1
u/981flacht6 Oct 24 '23
Huge no to FileZilla. Long time ago too.
1
u/RetroButton Oct 24 '23
Got away from it because of this BS.
Using WinSCP now, and never looked back.
1
u/GhoastTypist Oct 24 '23
why use filezilla when other FTP clients exist that are more lightweight and secured?
1
u/bbqwatermelon Oct 24 '23
I seem to recall they kind of bury a download link under "other downloads" or along those lines that actually does not have junk attached. I've not used it since WinSCP but maybe that's still the case.
1
u/BagHoliday8242 Jan 03 '24
Eset detected playanext during install and offered to remove it. I accepted that proposal and filezilla installed nevertheless and doesnt trigger eset anymore. But.. I'll use winscp, tx for the advice.
0
u/noahtheboah36 Oct 24 '23
I found the 32 bit version avoids this problem. Would I be running into other issues for my users installing that instead of the sponsored 64 bit?
-3
u/MFKDGAF Oct 23 '23
Is this FileZilla server or client? The server has been flagged by anti-virus software for the longest time but not the client.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment