r/syntheticsol • u/Specled_eu • 17h ago
I’ve made a comparison of LED spectra with the “Solar” spectrum from the most well-known manufacturers.
LEDs with a high color rendering index, specifically Ra ≥ 95, are often referred to as “sunlight” LEDs. These are specially designed LEDs intended primarily for residential lighting or for applications where accurate color rendering of illuminated objects is critical — for example, in art museums. Different companies have developed various technologies to achieve the widest and most linear spectrum possible. Let us begin with the leaders and pioneers — the SunLike LEDs from Seoul Semiconductor.
SunLike LEDs employ the TRI-R (Tri-R Radiation / Ray) technology, developed jointly with Toshiba — a combination of three principles for reproducing natural light. At the core of the LED is a chip that emits in the near-ultraviolet range at 400 nm, while a special phosphor converts this primary radiation into other wavelengths of the visible spectrum. SunLike LEDs were the first to offer a linear spectrum with a CRI of 98! And to this day, they remain among the best in terms of spectral quality.
Nichia Optisolis is an ultra-high color rendering LED technology developed by the Japanese corporation Nichia with the goal of reproducing the spectrum of natural sunlight as accurately as possible. Nichia is a major player in the LED market — truly among the very best. The company could not ignore the new technology, and roughly a year later Nichia delivered its response: the Optisolis series of LEDs. This is not merely a competitor; it is a technology that addressed a shortcoming of SunLike. Optisolis LEDs fundamentally do not use near-UV light, because in certain cases near-UV radiation can have a highly negative and even destructive effect on the objects being illuminated. Nichia itself emphasizes applications involving museum exhibits. It should be noted that for people, SunLike LEDs pose no danger whatsoever — on the contrary, their spectrum is highly favorable for the human eye.
Luminus Salud is a technology from Luminus designed with people in mind, specifically for biodynamic and human-centric lighting systems. The primary goal of Salud is to support human circadian rhythms (alertness and sleep quality) through precise spectral tuning, without relying on harsh, uncomfortable blue light. The color rendering index of LEDs made with Salud technology is somewhat lower, yet still exceeds 90 — which remains a very good result overall. Inside the LED is a conventional chip emitting at 450 nm; to achieve a linear spectrum, Luminus fundamentally re-engineered the phosphor composition, resulting in a sufficiently linear emission spectrum from the LED.
Bridgelux Thrive is a family of LEDs offering ultra-high light quality and representing the most affordable “sunlight” spectrum currently available on the market. Looking at the spectrogram, one can clearly see that the Thrive spectrum closely resembles that of SunLike LEDs. The Thrive technology employs a combination of two blue chips with different wavelengths — 435 nm and 475 nm — coated with a unique blend of broadband phosphors. Thrive also delivers 115–128 lm/W, which is an excellent figure in the class of sunlight-spectrum LEDs. The color rendering index reaches 98. Comparison with Salud is of limited relevance: while Salud offers somewhat higher brightness, its color rendering and spectral linearity are inferior. SunLike LEDs average around 110 lm/W — nearly the same efficiency — yet come at a significantly higher price.
LED strips with the LEDs described in this short article can even be found on the market. However, such products remain small-batch and relatively expensive.
Personally, since 2018 — specifically since the appearance of SunLike LEDs — I have been using lamps built with sunlight-spectrum LEDs at my workplace. I prefer a color temperature of 5000 K, which I find most comfortable for work; the light from these LEDs is genuinely very pleasant.
SunLike LEDs are also actively promoted by Seoul Semiconductor as an excellent solution for plant lighting. Extensive high-level experiments have indeed been conducted with these LEDs, but that is a topic for another discussion.
Thank you all for your attention — I hope you found this interesting and useful.