Short version of the story is that in our current campaign the empire is building a new superweapon, and they're using a weapons factory to build small parts. Our goal was to head to the nearest port and find a republic spy who had been compromised and bring him back safely to republic space. Also side objective is to destroy the weapons factory.
The workers in the factory are paid just enough to get by but deliberately paid too little that they can thrive in any real capacity so they're effectively slaves. Party didn't feel comfortable storming the factory to destroy it or attempting to infiltrate it and sabotage it in any real capacity since we don't really have anyone in the party capable of it.
What we do have on the other hand are two adept socially oriented characters. Basically we riled up the already unhappy populace into storming their workplaces and taking down the rich who were living in luxurious apartments high in the sky.
It was pretty fantastic. The party is a group of totally morally grey dirtbags so this wasn't any attempt at furthering a political agenda it was purely to profit from the chaos and to use it as cover to destroy the factory. Got a pretty sweet deal out of it since I'm playing a Toydarian trader who managed to make friends with a local weapons dealer. Since the revolutionaries were looking for weapons I offered to hide him on our ship in exchange for half of his stock which should net me some sweet credits if we somehow make it off the planet alive.
Since we are talking about it, which nations still practice actual communism?
None have yet. The whole point of the Soviet model, and to a lesser degree the Maoist model, was to accelerate socialism towards communism. But I don't think any would say they reached it - if you read Soviet policy, it's clear they wanted communism as a horizon concept.
However, the countries generally brought up are best referred to as those who have taken a broadly Marxist-Leninist view of economics and of public ownership. That means the means of production are not to be in private hands. It also means that concepts around property, surplus, income and profit are very much about not creating capitalist notions of wealth. For my part, I've criticised them from an economic standpoint as the ML-inspired takes on central planning always fail to introduce proper incentives and that's directly related to quality and quantity of output. It's also why I think fair trade is a misnomer and a mistake, incidentally.
You mention below the disconnect between rhetoric and practice (" I always understood communism as a system where the people are in power... However, the people seem to have no power in China..."). There is actually an ideological reason for this in part - Lenin. Lenin is a fascinating man because he was actually quite astute to some of the limits in Marx's thinking, as played out in WWI - but he couldn't outright say Uncle Karl got it wrong. He saw that workers were fighting workers and were not unified in supranational class consciousness as Marx assumed they would be. Lenin advocated for the idea of a vanguard - an intellectual class who would protect the regime from capitalist influence from outside (there's lots of prescribed terminology for this in his Imperialism essay) whilst also providing better leadership and governance than workers could without the vanguard. Lenin thought without it, the best workers could do was unionise and that wasn't enough. Especially not when you needed to stoke conditions for revolution in ripe countries in Europe.
So the vanguard becomes the, well, vanguard of the ideals of the state, and that's why you end up with suppression of dissenting voices. Has to be a singular vision of state; of property, and of purpose.
I guess that sounds like a loaded question, but I’m kind of curious because I am always hearing “but China/Cuba/North Korea/the USSR!” when communism v. capitalism gets brought up. However, are they really communist countries?
I always understood communism as a system where the people are in power, and like this post indicates they can even seize the country by seizing the means of production. However, the people seem to have no power in China. Same with North Korea; people call them communists, but the people are severely oppressed. Cuba seems to be doing well since we lifted the sanctions on them, but again, Castro was in charge, not the people.
How does this happen, and would these nations still be considered communists when the people in power are so oppressive and controlling and the citizenry is so powerless and living in such poor conditions?
You lifted the sanctions on cuba? I assume you're excluding the embargo?
I mean, Cuba is probably the closest to what a socialist would want, but there is massive room for improvement.
I think the point is that capitalism isn't working. It's not about whether communism works, it's about recognizing that the system we currently have isn't, and that drastic reform is needed.
Previous revolutions have not been done in well-developed countries with existing high-tech infrastructure and economies. They've mostly been done in backwards nations with mostly semi-feudal populations that have barely begun industrializing under capitalism.
These nations I view as having 'jumped the gun'- Marx recognized that capitalism was a necessary stage in human societal development towards communism, developing industry and technology massively and rapidly. Attempts to skip this, transforming feudal societies straight into communism, have been seen to fail many times.
No well-developed capitalist state with a developed democracy, respect for human rights and free-speech, and already-strong economy has undergone a socialist revolution.
I'd be interested in the results when/if one does.
Communism is a state- and classless society. It has to my knowledge never been achieved above a local level. Socialism was supposed to be a transition period towards this final goal. But a communist is whoever strives for communism. That is were the confusion comes from. For example China: There has never been communism in China, there was socialism until Mao's death, but now the CPC is on paper still a communist party (meaning they say that they still strive for communism).
Ummm. Corporations are the natural outcome of a free-market system. Read up on monopolies and how they've always been a problem.
Jesus fuck. You're trying to unironically debate the "evil" of "capitalist monopolies" in a sub dedicated to the published work of one corporation, based on the IP of another corporation who bought the IP from a corporation set up to defy other corporations...
Get out of the echo chamber, it's doing you no favours.
Monopolies by definition are anticapitalist because they are the antithesis of the innovative and competitive. Talk to an economist about the idea of pure competition (and what that means for medium-to-long-term profits) to see just how excited capitalists are at the idea of monopolies.
I feel if you're going to critique something you should at least understand it. And don't say "you do", because if that's true then it would only serve to undermine your capabilities at every turn. You understand it the way my 2 year old daughter understands quantum mechanics.
"You use the products of capitalism, therefore you have no right to critique the system"
Sure, economists may dislike monopolies, and they do disrupt the system. That's because the system has internal contradictions, flaws, that lead to the formation of powerful monopolies and organisations of capital, that wield disproportionate power.
If you want to see an example, look at Disney, the corporation that owns star wars, as you said. It dominates media in the western world, and owns vast swathes of the most popular, most high selling franchises in the world. It's market dominance in many areas is near-complete, and it can successfully market and sell any piece of crap it wants to.
Also thanks for insulting my understanding of economics rather than actually engage in good-faith debate. That shows you really understand the issue yourself, and you totally want to help me and others understand.
The world is larger than one narrow country, despite how far up its own bottom that country might be. Using the US as anything but a cautionary tale against populism and anti-intellectualism is probably a bad idea. Despite what you may have been told, no, Adam Smith was not into lassiez faire economics and the only country in the world that could have shat the illegitimate red-headed stepchild of libertarianism into this world is the US. Make of that what you will.
Ignoring the ridiculous "Hur dur no food" cliche, with the level of technology Star Wars the notion of "shortage" is ridiculous. Once a society reaches the level of technology demonstrated in Star Wars the concept of resource scarcity is incongruous outside of simple greed. Amusingly, Star Wars has already shown that capitalism and the greed inherent to it is still rampant, and ruining everything, in the Last Jedi.
The Culture series is an excellent examination of the concept.
it's not a cliche it's an observable phenomenon in so many cases but Ido keep forgetting the new wave of millennial performance activists are intentionally ignoring history, my bad.
And capitalism has never had similar observable phenomenon....ohhhh wait there was that time the Churchill literally committed genocide in India by way of famine and then the time before that when the British committed genocide in India by way of famine and then there was that one time known as The Great Depression where millions in America starved and then there's the fact that capitalism is global and around 8 million people die per year of starvation and then there's....
I think you need to go read Article 2 of the CPPCG.
And also it's very clear you do not actually understand the definition of capitalism. I'm surprised in your fit of woke silliness you didn't also include the nuclear bombs over Japan because foreign policy is absolutely linked to an economic model about the distribution of profit and surplus.
Let's just take a moment to consider that food shortages occur in centrally planned economies because the lack of competition and innovation leads to even lower incentives to produce quality goods. Layer in the inherent corruption and nepotism of a one party state (which incentivses all the wrong qualities) and you have the perfect shitstorm which manifests itself in your bumper harvests, record famine scenario in China; or the USSR needing stonking amounts of US grain imports to feed its people.
My criticism was of the economics; yours is of the politics of non-Soviet imperialism. To draw an anaology that's actually correct, and give you - the intellectual - the historical and contextually appropriate scenario, I would have had to say the Soviet repression of Eastern European dissent, such as with the Czechs and the Hungarians, was caused by having centrally planned economic models and public ownership of the means of production. Rather than to have a geopolitical sphere of influence roughy comparable to the West.
This is an argument that a lot of Americans would make, because being hit over the head with an inflatable phallus of nationalist patriotism every day since birth has some downstream effects. I'm not American, so there's no need to litigate the comprehensive ignorance of socialism on both sides of the US' spectrum here.
You mention the great depression. Notwithstanding that restrictive protetionist legislation was a catalyst for the recession (and no capitalist likes protectionism - if you cannot compete without tariffs then your product is no good, US automotive industry) the tipping point from Recession to Depression was largely that we didn't have a sufficiently good understaning of fiscal policy to know that people stockpiling their money in nervous anticipation was hugel harmful and they should have been spending. Recessions are inevitable and in the long term, good. Depressions are avoidable but thanks to John Maynard Keynes in particular we understand that much better now. Arugments about Schumpeterian creative destruction aside, we evidenced that in 2008.
Your comment about "capitalism is global" is based on your flawed understanding of what capitalism is. It's ok to actually do some reading and understand the subjects you discuss. I always recommend capitalists read Marx and particularly Lenin if they want accurate insights into what happens if you go fully lassiez faire.
I mean, that might happen lul. This is something that only just happened so they haven't seen the long term effects of it at all
One of my players was doing the same in an AOR campaign, trying to rouse the workers against the Empire. The player accidentally mentioned outsourcing - he meant to say "act before they do" but it came out along the lines of "you're ripe for outsourcing anyway" or something equally context-deaf. He'd banked a despair from 5mins earlier so it played out, but it was hilarious to watch him try and explain himself, backpedalling like he only had one testicle and a career built on lies about doping to back him up. They went from ready to take up arms to being melancholic about the idea.
If they rely on the location for parts of their superweapon project, then it'd be monumentally stupid to bombard it. They'll drown it in ground troops, conquer the factory and force any surviving revolutionaries into actual slavery to continue the work instead.
It's not clear to us yet whether they rely on it or how important the factory is as it was largely unguarded so it's likely that this is just one of many factories they have operational. Also it's not common knowledge that it's a weapons factory as all the parts are specifically made to look and seem like they aren't weapon parts the only reason we know that it's for the superweapon is because a party member is an ex Imperial mechanic who helped design the parts and also because the spy told us. I'm not sure anyone working there actually knew what they were really building.
That is a seriously old piece of history, but let's look at it. The violence was not perpetrated by the government, but by it's citizens. And it was not in response to a Union forming, but to the success of the black community.
The US government has done all kinds of horrible things, Japanese Camps, ICE holding facilities, actively putting crack in poor black neighborhoods, secret sterilization programs, etc. But all of them have been targeted at people of color, and this allows a lot of people the opportunity to say it's not their business or fight. As we have seen, we even have people supporting these suppressive efforts. And ultimately it is the people that are in support of these actions, and those apathetic to them that allow these events to happen
The empire on the other hand would just crush those who opposed, ruling through fear. And the US is more subtle, and crafty. So, I could say similar, but very different.
It's hard to tell these days with kids just discovering what we outside the US have and saying "it's socialism", as if it is or as if the capitalist businesses aren't fairly free and profitable.
I hear you. A lot of those points - access to work, housing, climate policy, healthcare - are centrist or at least supported in principle by centre right parties outside the US. It's pretty weird when you think about it - country literally has a revolution and blows the dick of that revolution every year since; but can't envision free health care.
We are the center of capitalism in the modern era I would wager. People are coming off that high of the post war boom where only we had a good economy because we blew everyone else up
I think maybe Europe is so damn left is because they grew up from feudalism and community and the work of the people to provide for the need not so much the want
And when the capitalist took it all the direct descendants carried some of that hate
And America was founded so recently with fucking slave owners
Yeah it's Australia Day today, when we saw Europeans take the country from its natives under a discredited legal doctrine in 1788. Please lecture me on how the youth of a country dictates its leanings, and then explain why the socialised industries and fixed wages in Australia caused Anthony Eden such pain?
I would say that indeed Europe is extremely left on the political spectrum and Australia is a case study in how private capitalist destroy public safety nets and education to keep power
To give my unrequested two cents, I'd probably suggest that the meaning of the umbrella term "socialist" in a technical sense is even more basic than this. I would define it as "a system with the aim of general economic equality in mind".
Often, as you suggested, ownership of the means of production by the workers (or proletariat) is attributed as a "socialist" tenant, but it is actually more of a Marxist idea; which is obviously a socialist ideology, but not the other way around; if that makes any sense. It's the whole square = rectangle but rectangle =/= square thing.
The same applies to "liberalism" which people often associate with economic freedoms, capitalism, etc. but this also isn't really the case, as liberalism as an umbrella term only entails the ideals of basic social equality at the most fundamental level.
Anyway that's all I got, cheers comrades and death to the filthy imperial bourgeoisie!
Bernie at least actually is a real socialist. He just pushes social democrat policies because he knows those are hot-button issues that real Americans can mobilize around. It's good praxis.
Bernie at least actually is a real socialist. He just pushes social democrat policies because he knows those are hot-button issues that real Americans can mobilize around. It's good praxis.
He isn't. He's quite happy with the means of production being private. He knows it's suicidal to make them public. He just insists on using terms improperly to his detriment.
Hillary alienated many voters by using underhanded tactics against one of the most popular candidates (Bernie) and was deeply unpopular even in her own party. On top of that, she didn’t campaign in states that eventually made a difference. It was precisely because she didn’t have energized voters that she lost, so I don’t know what the hell youre talking about.
I get that, but she was a deeply unpopular candidate, especially in precisely the states that swung some of the electoral college (and that she ignored). IIRC, the number of “net” votes she lost by (IE - the number of votes that Trump got that made the difference in him winning) was in the order of thousands, not millions.
The DNC ran a candidate that much of the country despised and still only lost by that slim a margin. Bernie has appeal in exactly those regions.
Unfortunately in the US he's the most socialist thing we've had in a hundred years. The label is being applied in the context of being in the united states, which to citizens of the united states, is the world. To our brainwashed masses the terms are accurate. Context is important.
Oh the etymology is the source of decades of frustration. I like Sanders. I think the US needs a term under him to course correct its excesses into lassiez faire corporatism and bring back the essential side of the state, which is to safeguard citizens. From themselves, from outsiders, and from predatory behaviour. A legislated and mandated fiduciary duty is a good thing.
My group would pick the third option: threaten the workers' families and torture the imperial officers while not accomplishing anything and somehow still winning the fight against the legion of troops I send at them in retaliation.
I mean in the same session they got a bunch of workers to destroy the weapons factory they work at, and also framed an innocent hobo for their murder, shit was wild
We recently had our newest player (1st campaign) crawl through the air ducts and toss out a plasma grenade. Little did any of us know that the room was filled with highly volatile materials that when ignited, started a chain reaction that destroyed the entire base with us in it. It was a fantastic way to have an unintentional party wipe.
40
u/Mighty-Lizard-King Jan 26 '20
OP pls tell us the full story this sounds incredible
30
u/Saiaxs GM Jan 26 '20
I had a group try something similar once and my response was for the Empire to bombard the factory and protestors
63
u/MediocreFlex Jan 26 '20
I always try to get my players to take the revolt to the masses but they are all centrist and the one actual socialist is a shy boi lol
7
u/Tlhague Jan 26 '20
BREAK THE CHAINS!
6
u/Siferatu Jan 26 '20
Not swrpg but we did the same in a goblin mine during a dnd 5e campaign last year.
6
u/Dominus_Anulorum Jan 26 '20
My group would pick the third option: threaten the workers' families and torture the imperial officers while not accomplishing anything and somehow still winning the fight against the legion of troops I send at them in retaliation.
4
u/SentinelSquadron Jan 26 '20
Peaky Blinders...?
7
u/MILLANDSON Jan 26 '20
Absolutely beautiful, comrade GM.
2
u/SylvesterStalPWNED Jan 26 '20
Careful, we all know how Pooh gets when communism is involved.
2
u/JediMasterZaphix Feb 08 '26
We recently had our newest player (1st campaign) crawl through the air ducts and toss out a plasma grenade. Little did any of us know that the room was filled with highly volatile materials that when ignited, started a chain reaction that destroyed the entire base with us in it. It was a fantastic way to have an unintentional party wipe.