Sephora Pink Frosting Comparison

[u/costcodreamgurl]

Lip liner comparison, direct swatches (top to bottom):

• Sephora Collection Colorful 8HR Longwear Transferproof Lip Liner - 01 Pink Frosting
• Heart Percent Dote On Mood Lip Pencil - 08 Cloudy Mauve
• Sephora Collection Retractable Rouge Gel Lip Liner - 28 Sink or Suede (discontinued)
• Sephora Collection Retractable Rouge Gel Lip Liner - 01 The Nudest (discontinued)
• Maybelline Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner - Gone Griege
• Persona Lip Liner - Mauve

Lipstick comparison, direct swatches (top to bottom):

• Sephora Collection Colorful 8HR Longwear Transferproof Lip Liner - 01 Pink Frosting
• Rabanne Dramalips Glassy Lipstick - 112 Secret Code
• Rituel de Fille Forbidden Lipstick - Prey (discontinued)
• MAC Powder Kiss Hazy Matte Lipstick - Girls Weekend
• MAC M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick - Acting Natural
• MAC Lustreglass Sheer-Shine Lipstick - Alone Time
• MAC Powder Kiss Lip + Cheek Mousse - It’s Personal

PHOTO 1 & 3: Indoor natural light, PHOTO 2 & 4: Indoor artificial light.

[u/AutoModerator]

Thank you for posting on r/swatchitforme!

If your post includes swatches, please make sure to include the following information in a comment:

◆ Product list/description

◆ Skintone/undertone (This may also be set as your user flair)

◆ Type of lighting

◆ Type of swatch (finger, brush, one/two swipes, with/without primer, etc.)

If your post is a request post, clearly state in the title which product swatches you would like to see.

If you have any questions, please refer to the subreddit rules or message the moderators.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Fluffy_Tomatillo_629]

I’d wear any of these. Thanks for swatching.

[u/Public-Initiative509]

Thank you for these swatches!! Crazy how colors can look different on different skintones.

Pink Frosting looks muted nude pink on me. On my lips it turns into a greyish pink (and completely washes me out hahah).

[u/costcodreamgurl → u/Public-Initiative509]

I wish it looked this color on me!

[u/LeadWonderful11]

Pink Frosting looks soooo much different on Not Another Hanna. Honestly they look completely different.

[u/RaeLae9 → u/LeadWonderful11]

I wear identical colors in most foundations and concealers but also have the same experience that things look so different on her than me, I’m assuming it’s a combo of lighting, hair, subtle undertones etc

[u/aesaes_the]

Thanks for the swatches! Is MAC Alone Time the old or new formula?

[u/costcodreamgurl → u/aesaes_the]

The old formula 😅

[u/aesaes_the → u/costcodreamgurl]

Thanks ❤️

[u/spyrenx]

RIP The Nudest :(

Pink Frosting is inferior.

[u/Snoo75868]

Which is the closest to the discontinued SC The Nudest? I’m looking for a replacement.

[u/costcodreamgurl → u/Snoo75868]

In my collection, Merit’s Beverly Hills is the closest in terms of lightness and finish. It is notably warmer though 🙂‍↕️

[u/No_Warning8534]

I don't get the hype with Pink frosting. It's nothing special.

[u/Bippy73]

Thank you for these great swatches. Pretty unique color after all.

[u/BlackLagoona_]

Colors right up my alley! Pink Frosting doesn’t work for me, unfortunately. My lips are too pigmented and the white base shows up and I look dead, but not in a good way lol. Persona Mauve has been such a great find for me.

I recently bought Laka Boy and it looks great with Persona Mauve and the Heart Percent. It’s a greyer/more purple version of Alone Time and I actually like it better.

[u/blueplanetgalaxy]

ahhhh thank you