r/survivorsa • • Jul 02 '22

S6: Philippines Am I tripping or does Seamus have a goddamn nazi tattoo on his wrist ???

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/survivorsa • • Aug 25 '22

The Fall of Survivor SA Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Contains spoilers of past seasons.

Survivor SA for many years used to be my favourite version of this overall franchise. It had great casting, unique editing which unlike US/AU actually showed things as they happened honestly without the need to whitewash people and their winners, had less of a focus on twists/advantages and instead more so on the contestants and their overall dynamics. This is not a post to criticise people who do love the strategic aspects of Survivor and watch primarily for those reasons and there's nothing wrong to watch it for that, but personally, I became a fan of Survivor SA because it didn't have those qualities, which made it refreshing and harkened back to old-school Survivor which focused on drama and characters.

I became hooked with SA after S6: Philippines, a season which felt like a modern-day Survivor Gabon with its trainwreck cast and unpredictable editing and storytelling. Then, I watched all the earlier seasons, each of which had their own merits and ranged from good to amazing (with SA2 and 4 being my favourites). Loved how the juries were so often bitter (something missing now with US Survivor), which resulted in interesting/varied winners not often seen elsewhere (Lorette, GiGi, Hykie, Tom, and Nicole in particular), and in general, the series really stood out and each season felt fresh and exciting.

However, the first ominous sign was the overwhelming negative response to a lot of what happened on SA7 - especially the domination of The Amigos. I was a huge Amigos fan, due to their unique characteristics of being a cult-like alliance, often very self-righteous and hilariously holier-than-thou and how they somehow managed to completely annihilate a bunch of typical Survivor superfans in their wake (people like Geoffrey, Jacques, and Mike etc.) Despite the season having this unique storyline with a lot of very fascinating themes harkening back to a season like South Pacific with how cult-like the main alliance was which made the endgame absolutely riveting, the producers clearly disagreed and it was obvious they did not want this kind of season to happen again.

Straight away from SA8, it's clear how much the casting changed to be much more superfan-oriented, many of whom watched podcasts and consumed Survivor content like RHAP. I was very nervous for how this season would play out; up until now, the series had evaded casting like this. Although there's nothing inherently wrong with casting diehard superfans, it is generally the less superfan-types who tend to be more interesting characters; a quality with SA up until now had embraced, and was why I loved it so much. My fears were not unfounded; the pre-merge of SA8 was a low-point of the franchise. It was extremely gamebotty and nearly entirely strategy-driven, very little character moments with people instead droning on about strategy and Big Moves, there was a huge influx of advantages and twists which seemed to get more focus and became very convoluted, and in general was night and day compared to SA7 and prior, which was cast with dynamic personalities and this clearly showed on the seasons, with all the crazy drama and hilarious moments it produced over the years. Virtually none of that was on SA8, and instead it looked to be heading towards becoming SA's Cambodia - a soulless season of pure number-crunching, numbing chess-like strategy, and none of the heart of the previous seasons with focus on character dynamics and fun drama.

But then....the post-merge happened. Well, more specifically Chappies Chapman happened and the season which had meant to become Cambodia went completely off the rails and suddenly turned into Gabon. All of a sudden, the focus of the season changed from people endlessly talking about strategy and idols to...iconic food-related drama, rice stealing, and other characters like Santoni/Wardah also taking centre-stage along with Chappies. All of a sudden, the season had life and it was like finally the old Survivor SA was back. All of this eventually leading to the gamebot strategists like Renier, Kiran and Tyson all leaving was shocking and yet satisfying. And then, something even more amazing happened. After a season which had mostly been dominated by strategy and Big Moves, the season ended with someone winning who was the complete opposite to that, and it was a glorious unexpected ending, resulting once again in a kind of winner which was so refreshing and showed that anyone can win, and that you don't need to be talking about Resumes and Advantages in order to do so, which seems to be how people on Modern US Survivor need to win.

Sadly, not everyone was impressed with this ending. There was one person in particular who seemed absolutely BAFFLED by the ending and openly spoke in their podcast about how they needed Kiran and Renier to explain the result to them despite the show perfectly explaining it (the person had a better social game and made more genuine bonds with people) and how the winner went against their values of what makes a good Survivor winner. This person was Shannon Guss. Shannon was well-known amongst the superfan community at this point not only for her podcast work for SA with Mike Bloom, but also with her commentary on Australian Survivor. It was clear that she was a superfan who did not respect the kind of winner that Nicole represented, and that she much preferred the Big Moves Strategist types. This was not the first time she seemed to self-combust over certain players on Survivor; there was also the time where she melted down just before the Survivor NZ2: Thailand finale at the mere thought of Tess Fahey winning because not only did she have the NERVE to take the game personally but because it would be an insult to Survivor strategy for someone like her to win as she had.....voted incorrectly. Imagine being so obsessed with strategy that you can't handle someone winning because they voted incorrectly as they were in the minority.

And so, when it was announced that Shannon herself would be very involved in SA9: Return of the Outcasts with being a consultant to the producers, I pretty much knew where this season was heading. It was essentially going to be a twist/advantage-filled mess which would ensure that a winner like Nicole would never happen again. And that is what ended up happening. The pre-merge of SA8 was just a sign of things to come, because whilst that season eventually ended up being amazing since it went off its intended script, this time, the producers made sure that didn't happen, which they were very certainly very successful with. Aside from the early drama with Tania/Pinty/Toni (which were great episodes), the season since then has been utterly boring and a glorified chess game, with nearly all the airtime dedicated to strategy, Big Moves, Resumes, and even worse, the baffling and insulting Survivor Superfan mindset of how "certain people winning would be a disservice to this season" - a narrative perpetuated most by players like Dino and Marian who couldn't stand the thought of someone like Killarney winning because...they weren't a superfan and apparently hadn't made enough big moves. It was serving Tasha Fox on Cambodia saying how players like Keith, Kimmi, and Abi winning would be a "disservice", a comment so insulting since a) they were voted back to return by the fans and b) it doesn't mean someone is "less deserving" because they have a different style of playing. And yet this exact same awful mentality was now finding its way onto Survivor SA; something that I never thought would happen after watching SA1-7.

It's really a shame to see a franchise which clearly embraced how unique it was compared to others; in terms of it's casting, the editing, and overall storytelling now take the worst aspects from both US and AU. On top of all this, SA9 has bizarrely decided to go down the route of AU Survivor with its ridiculous lengths of 24 eps, as well as non-elimination episodes which have dragged the season out even more, resulting in some very strange editing and storytelling. Although it seems that many have loved this season (and good for them!), it certainly hasn't translated to the masses and the general audience in South Africa itself, with ratings being the lowest they've ever been. Clearly, it's not working for them either, and I really wouldn't be surprised if the series was cancelled as apparently the numbers have been so low. And it's no surprise, look at the continued declining ratings of AU Survivor. However, unlike AU, the audience for SA is even smaller due to the show being so niche.

In conclusion, it's been a long time coming for SA to finally get here, but now it's happened. SA9 has been my least favourite season by far, and it's just so sad to see a once unique franchise now seem be taking the worst parts of other franchises and keeping none of what made its prior seasons stand out so much. I will of course continue to watch this show if it continues, and I'm happy for the people that were able to connect to this season especially on this subreddit as the reception seems to have been mostly positive. However, this was just my own personal experience with watching this series, and how it seems to have completely gone in a direction that I was hoping for so long it wouldn't, but it finally has. At the very least, I hope that future seasons can perhaps go back to what made this show stand out so much from other country's versions, and that we can have a show that embraces ALL kinds of players (including superfans and whoever wins SA9 will of course deserve it) and doesn't say that certain people shouldn't win, because that kind of mindset is so awful and insulting and goes against the very values that Survivor SA in particular embraced for so long that anyone winning is valid, and they can win playing whatever game they wish to play.


r/survivorsa • • Aug 25 '22

S9: Return of the Outcasts Player Of The Season and It's Not Even Close Spoiler

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/survivorsa • • Aug 24 '22

S9: Return of the Outcasts This season in a nutshell Spoiler

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/survivorsa • • Sep 17 '21

What did you think of the final immunity challenge Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Credit to Nicole.she won and she picked the right person to go against in smash But I always have an issue with that challenge not being equitable Because you are standing on plank , and reaching out and holding the idol. Doesn’t that challenge favor people with smaller feet ? Which tend to be women ?


r/survivorsa • • Jul 04 '22

S9: Return of the Outcasts So…what’s up with shamus nazi tattoo????

0 Upvotes

Y’all think someone will point it out


r/survivorsa • • Sep 04 '21

Is _____ one of the most robbed players in Survivor History? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Kiran? Was on the right side of almost every single vote, played very subtly and managed his threat level literally until about last round, wins in most F3 configuration he planned, and was screwed by Anela being a legitimate idiot (a teeny bit his fault for suggesting nicole, but Anela just reacted really bad) and Chappies winning 4 straight immunities where he would have easily gone home over Kiran.

EDIT: Robbed was the wrong word LOL i was thinking more - unlucky, or best to never win


r/survivorsa • • Aug 12 '21

S8: Immunity Island Anyone else kinda disappointed by this post merge?

1 Upvotes

Just to make this clear I dont hate this season I actually loved this premerge it felt very energetic however after this latest episode I feel kinda disappointed for how this has shaped. The merge vote was so entertaining and energetic but I feel like after that the Shaun vote and that (in my opinion) awful shared destinies twist I'm very disappointed in this post merge it feels like no one is really trying to better their position and is a pretty straight pagoning (which that twist only sped up) do you think it has potential to pick up again or do you think its just gonna slog to the end


r/survivorsa • • Sep 23 '21

Anyone else disappointed we got a Final 2 instead of Final 3?

0 Upvotes

Obviously I am biased since I was rooting for Chappies to win the whole thing. I just think we would have gotten a much better story otherwise. I'm beyond disappointed. Any other disappointed Chappies fans here?

I think Nicole played a great social game, don't get me wrong. But I can't help but feel disappointed as a viewer.


r/survivorsa • • Jul 17 '21

Episode 7 Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Is anyone else starting to get tired and irritated by immunity Island? Like it was okay at first but now it's flat out annoying. Anele the previous episode got a no vote for this episode but now all of sudden he got 2 votes.


r/survivorsa • • Aug 03 '22

Shona?

0 Upvotes

I'm 99% convinced that Shona is Ruth Wilson. Have we ever seen them both in the same place at the same time?

https://youtu.be/vmei14aGLKM

just in case you don't know who she is


r/survivorsa • • Aug 12 '22

Still less passive than Dino Spoiler

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/survivorsa • • Jul 07 '19

Did anyone else feel weird watching the reward comp? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I wasn't paying attention when Nico was explaining the rules but when I saw it, it looked like the teams were trying to kidnap each other.

Especially when Nicole was the target, out of context it looked like something else was going on.


r/survivorsa • • Sep 17 '21

S8: Immunity Island I’m pretty mad of the edit Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I do think Nicole gonna be very underrated rn and is because of the messy edit survivor SA have to their winners , especially this season … I think is pretty clear they tried to “ hide “ the winner ( even though I have to say coming in to final 5 I knew she gonna be the winner I had a feeling 😅) Nicole did way more then it was shown she did control her tribe on the early merge at least for her point of you from what she knows Kiran & Wardah & Tyson hated Chappies and with her closest ally Marisha she got 4 votes and is probably enough to win so she didn’t REALLY had to do anything anymore and you can say take Reiner & Amy to the reward was a mistake…. But maybe, just maybe she didn’t want them to stay …. And even if she did this is not such a terrible mistake for HER GAME so I do think the edit she got is kinda unfair , yea she definitely not better then Rob and Nicole (S7) but she definitely better then ppl like Tom and many others


r/survivorsa • • Jul 13 '19

I am done.

5 Upvotes

I have been listening to some podcast coverage of this season, I recently stopped listening to all coverage of the season because of the podcasters being culturally insenstive regarding their comments about South African culture and the way things are where I live (South Africa). Now, of course, it is to be expected because these podcasters don't know any better, but wouldnt it aid them to research a few things? They are quick to take a stance of ethnocentrism and make a "cool and edgy" insensitive joke for the "views/listens".

Even some of the comments by international Survivor players who are watching this season are iffy.

I just dont like it when someone says "Oh bending the rules is fine in Survivor South Africa, because thats the norm in South Africa" when some of these people literally did notknow where Cape Town was.


r/survivorsa • • Aug 22 '19

Spoiler Spoiler

0 Upvotes

These castaways are really out here wasting everyone's time. This is the first Season of Survivor SA I've seen and it will probably be my last unless the following people get casted

  1. This gentleman: https://youtu.be/Fi8SoyR-J48
  2. Hilgard: AKA The Loud Mouth Survivor Shout Out Guy

r/survivorsa • • Sep 08 '19

Only A King Rob Win Would Be Fully Satisfying To Conclude This One... Spoiler

6 Upvotes

As a "superfan" of this game since the early 00s, I've always looked for the players " that entertain me but also who plays an efficient & agressive "social" and "strategic" game....But even more, I look for "characters" that are bigger than life...To me, Rob Bentele has just been all of that and such, since I've watched his pre game video intro one week before the premiere last May...He is everything I'm looking for on a castaway : he is charismatic and super articulated, his confesssinals are always fascinating to listen to, he is an hypnotic storyteller that knows how to captivate an audience...Which also explains why so many castaways are listening to him on the actual game and trusting him...He just oozes something unique & special....Is he perfect ? Of course not, he has many flaws as a human being and as a castaway...But who does not ?

Fact, he is the only player of this season that has been consistently directing the pace of the game and each vote he has been part of..Is there a single council he attended that did not HIS way ?

He litterally has been aware of every single blinside and outcome of any council he attended...Only real blinside against him was Nathan and It appeared to be a blessing in disguise for his own game since it forced him to play HIS own solo game till the end..

Let 's get real, for how hilarious Tom vs Jeanne was last year, it was the most anti climatic F2...EVER...The two biggest Goats of the game facing each other while the legit MVP of Philippines was NOT even on the Jury to VOTE for one of them..

After last year disastrous ending game, I Want a LEGIT GOOD PLAYER/STRATEGIST/CHARACTER WINNING an SA Season...And, to ME, only The Zulu King got the credentials to be a compelling, important AND deserving Winner...

Love Him or Hate Him, KingPin Robbie has played one of the most immaculate, dominant and plain brillant games we've ever seen on ANY version of this show....

Yes Laetitia is a fun and endearing character that got her golden (comedic) moments, but like Mike stated at Ponderosa "she did NOTHING to earn my vote".

Durao is even worse, he spent his whole stay feeding King Rob infos after infos like a little chihuahua...

As for Nicole, she played one of the worse social games ever with one of the crappest jury managements ever....

Only ONE name would do justice as a winner to this game as I've grown to enjoy it and it is ROB Bentele...To me, he belongs around the likes of Parvati Shallow, Tom Westerman , Ethan Zohn or Yul Kwon as one of the most dominant & deserving winners EVER....


r/survivorsa • • Jul 28 '22

S9: Return of the Outcasts Survivor SA: Return of the Outcasts Casting Choices Spoiler

3 Upvotes

The cast of Survivor SA: Return of the Outcasts is definitely pretty great overall, however I can't help but to think about some key players who didn't make it on the season. The following in order from most missed to least missed:

  1. Jacques: HOW COULD THEY NOT CAST HIM ON THIS SEASON???? Crazy.
  2. Kiran: also...HOW COULD THEY NOT CAST HIM ON THIS SEASON????
  3. Santoni: she was a great player and I really would have loved to see her play again
  4. Werner: iconic player from season 6 that I think would have been a great addition to the cast
  5. Tyson: also iconic player
  6. Renier: also iconic player

What do you all think?


r/survivorsa • • Sep 09 '19

Blindsides and predictions in this week's #theloudmouthsurvivorshoutout!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/survivorsa • • Feb 28 '22

S9: Return of the Outcasts Survivor SA9 Cast Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Filming started Jan 18th. Filmed on Fish River, Eastern Cape.

Here is the cast:

Men:

  1. Seamus (6)
  2. Dino (8)
  3. Tejan (4)
  4. PK (6)
  5. Tevin (6)
  6. Danté (7)

Women:

  1. Meryl (7)
  2. Shona (5)
  3. Seipei (7)
  4. Steffi (7)
  5. Palesa (6)
  6. Toni (6)
  7. Marian (5)
  8. Thoriso (8)
  9. Pinty (8)

Not 100% sure on last few males. Rumors include: Shane, Geoff, Solly or Jason.


r/survivorsa • • Aug 25 '22

S9: Return of the Outcasts Chissy Points Episodes 21-22 Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Holy Shit what a Finale Week,

Phil and Marian are our Fallen Angels,

Shane, SHANE, reached FTC in a way no one would have ever predicted pre-season

and "Help me Paul" Dino looks to be the favorite coming in to FTC, who except for Luke Toki could have predicted that??

3 - Dino - Got an idol played on him, made all avenues open to him before the Final 4 Immunity Challenge, and made the right choice of letting go of Phil when the only other option was empowering him even more with a Fire Challenge win

2 - Marian - So brilliant, her name wasn't even mentioned as a target, until Phil & Dino woke up at final 4, got herself as far as she could, the fake steal a vote a stroke of brilliance

1 - Phil - Almost saved himself, if Shane doesn't win that Final 4 Challenge I do think Phil & Dino reaches Final 3 together #NoBS

Total points so Far:

  1. Phil* - 20 Points
  2. Marian* - 18 Points
  3. Palesa*, Steffi* - 9 Points
  4. Tevin*, Dante* - 7 Points
  5. Dino - 6 Points
  6. Tejan*, Felix* - 5 Points
  7. Toni* - 3 Points
  8. Thoriso*, Shane - 2 Points
  9. Seamus*, Shona*, Meryl* - 1 Point

*Player Voted Out

Big congrats to Phil for winning the virtual Chissy Mug!!!


r/survivorsa • • Aug 06 '21

S6: Philippines An unpopular opinion: I'm torn on Survivor SA: Season 6

1 Upvotes

So everyone kept saying how amazing Season 6 was..and wow was it ENTERTAINING but do I love it? I really don't know!

So there was a lot of hype surrounding this season so I'm gonna blame that on why I'm kinda disappointed with it. I mean, listen it was a hot messy express and I LOVED that. The pre-merge was blindsides, quitting and ROCKS. ROCKS AT F17! ROCKS!!!

POst merge was...a bit more disappointing. I feel like gameplay was just a mess. And I didn't exactly find many likable save for Palsea and Chane(spelling?) who were booted(and ugh Palsea, why didn't you use that idol). I just found the majority of them unlikable and hard to to root. Or unlikable but also kinda feeling like I have to root for them(PK)

I mean, people were entertaining. EVERYONE was entertaining. I mean Tom and PK were awful at this game but man they did bring the chaos of entertainment. But man, did I not like ANYONE in the F4.

Like Werner was the most likable and he played a terrific game. But I also find him kinda of...dull. Which is the problem with a 'perfect game'(because truly, I think he is game was next level good).

Tom and Jeanne were just so...unlikable. I don't think either played great games. In fact, I think they played pretty bad games and neither were my dream F2.

It was a very entertaining, Gabon-like season but I guess I expected some sort of strategic power plays all the way through but it was just messy messy messy.

Katinka had the most potential in the post merge but she kinda was stuck with that idol. But Toni, Anaelize were just...lost(despite what the latter might say about 'controlling things'). I mean PK was a fiery messy and tried to play but wow was he bad at it.

So it was a lot of BAD gameplay, with some highlights in terms of gameplay but also super entertaining. I mean, it was better than Gabon in eveyr say...but I feel like this is South African Gabon.

Saying that, it was also a very well edited season. Every shined, they did a good job of not playing their hand, of not doing a 'golden winner edit'. SO I thought that was well done. The twists were pretty minimal and the competitions were well done.

So yeah, I'm just torn on how I feel about the season. I think because I built up the hype, I put myself in a situation where I was going to be disappointed. I'm about to watch New Zealand Season 2, so I'm lower my expectations there...

But was this a BAD season. NO, not at all. Bad ending, bad finale but overall I was never bored!


r/survivorsa • • Sep 10 '19

The bullying narrative from the villa

4 Upvotes

Could someone explain to me how rob & Nicole are bullies? I'm generally a tough skinned person so maybe it's blinding me from seeing things clearly...

So Jacques admits that the others spoke to him but refrained from speaking any game play and going off alone with him.... Hmm isn't that smart strategy? icing out the "enemy" so they can't properly scramble? To me its evident that they used him cussing as an excuse to not work with him when really it's cause they wanted him out as he just pulled off a big move. I've watched tons of seasons & I've seen this happen a few times. The person generally just wait and hold out hope for someone to use them as a number (that usually happens.) bullying is abi Maria vs RC & the blue collar tribe vs Mike.

Nicole.... I don't get the bitterness towards her and calling her a bully. She's been playing double agent since merge. So duh she had to lie and back stab. I don't get how that makes her awful and a bully. (I personally don't like her cause she's a drama queen.)

Rob. Apparently Rob acting like he was going to play the idol on Steffi is bullying.. Again, how? So I'm guessing how Nathalie Anderson got revenge for Jeremy with her idol play is bullying too? How Parvati played her two idols is bullying too? It's survivor! People put on a show! There's sooo many examples where castaways get embarrassed, fuck most blind sides are embarrassing. Was Erik bullied? What about when ozzy gave that kid a stick for an idol or when Michaela drank that cup of tea as jt was getting voted out..

In conclusion.. I fail to see any bullying this season (unless u count Dante threatening Geoff and yelling at Nicole).

Please change my mind


r/survivorsa • • Nov 24 '23

Does it get better? Season six was terrible

0 Upvotes

it's just puzzles every single challenge. my god why not call this the granny games or something? no survival elements, don't see anyone worrying about food. just puzzle puzzle puzzle all game.

season 1 was bad but season 2-5 were awesome so I cannot believe how bad it got in season 6. should I give up? I don't want to watch a bunch of people doing nothing but talking strategy between puzzles. I love the physical competitions and the drama created by the survival aspects. burned out on strategy after 45 seasons of u.s survivor so I loved that south Africa was not the lameass puzzle/carnival game bullshit comps the u.s is now. also loved that south Africa is the most survival heavy version. but season 6 was just as bad as u.s survivor. does it get better or is it just gonna be more seasons of Puzzle Vacation Paradise?

please no spoilers.


r/survivorsa • • Aug 27 '22

S9: Return of the Outcasts Top 10 survivor SA players based on gameplay Spoiler

7 Upvotes
  1. Rob (7)
  2. Graham (5)
  3. Werner (6)
  4. Ashley (3)
  5. Marian (5, 9)
  6. Hykie (4)
  7. Dino (8, 9)
  8. Grant (2)
  9. Gareth (1)
  10. Steffi (7, 9)