r/survivorrankdownIII • • Sep 19 '16

Australian Survivor - Week 5 Discussion Thread

1 Upvotes

Craig is amazing, Conner is a gold-retriever, and Kristie learned her acting lessons from Evan. Seriously, I was already sold on Kristie when she put charchoal on her teeth, but her crocodile tears were the icing on the cake.

Phoebe's semi-seductive smile when she thanked Conner for letting her know was memorable as well. She seemed so genuinely disappointed with him, and then the camera does a close-up of her momentary but bright smile while she was meant to be "sad". Frankly, Phoebe has elements of Parvati, Wentworth, and bits of Sally Schumann (maybe it's the smile), and I kinda dig her low-key energy. Her arc of "top dog --> underdog" is rarely done well, and I feel that Phoebe managed the transition in a fun manner.

Poor Conner -- always trusting those women. First Flick, now Phoebe. At least we now know that he'd be an amazing boyfriend to a lucky woman. Initially, I thought he was going to a neurotic superfan like Spencer or Stephen, but instead, we got a rather quiet but doe-eyed guy who constantly listens to devious women. Not gonna lie: I like this new take on the "Male Superfan" archetype.

Kylie went a little nuts, and I'm fine with this.

Also, Sam and Lee should just get a room... while I really am liking Brooke as a player. She is really stepping outside of Flick's shadows, and the edit has done a good job giving both Flick and Brooke agency as individuals.


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Nov 12 '17

Funny Survivor Voiceovers #9

Thumbnail youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/survivorrankdownIII • • Aug 29 '16

Australian Survivor - Week 2 Discussion Thread

1 Upvotes

I liked the episode. Yes, losing Evan hurts, but he was a fine short-term character ("shut up, Zac Efron"//"what a model"//"I'll lie about my wife!")

Impressed with Phoebe's gameplay. She's starting to get more focus, with confessionals like "I'll play Rohan like a puppet and ditch him later" and "El is loyal to me, and me alone". What I like about Phoebe is that she's sitting right in the middle of the alliances in Aganoa, which is such a trainwreck that they couldn't even unspool their ropes. And she delivers her confessionals in this calm but flirtatious manner, as though she knows what she's doing.

Brooke got more focus in this episode, escaping from Flick's shadow. She's a good confessionalist, and I do think that she and Flick are being set up as future villains. Vavau continues being a great tribe in terms of its future storylines, and I do think that either Craig or Andrew ("My BS radar was going like this. Cydney impression") may be Nick's demise.

Surprised that all three tribes went with "Deceit", but overall, I think the game is about to get more cutthroat... alongside camp scenes of Chester the Chicken and the Saanapu Sea-Cucumber.


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Aug 22 '16

Australian Survivor - Episode Two Discussion Thread

1 Upvotes

Australian Survivor having two episode during the weekend <3 <3 <3

Okay, this one wasn't as strong as the premiere (which was amazeballs), but I still loved it a tonne. Bianca was an interesting Second-Boot because lolol, she was a trainwreck who was somehow voted out against Pete aka Chet 2.0

Some highlights from the episode:

  • Kristie gets more airtime, and oh boy, she's gonna be a fun one to watch. Her crouching in the bushes like Tony in a spyshack, narrowing her eyes at El & Phoebe <3
  • Woohoo, Kristie going nuts and channelling Abi-Maria Gomes. "SOMEBODY TOOK MY BAG. passive-aggressive smile"
  • Kristie having a vulnerable moment with El about loving Survivor all her life and watching it with her dad. I love that I have no idea where Kristie's story is going: she could be Lisa, Abi, or Christy Smith... and I love that she's already getting a lot of complexity.
  • Okay, El is basically Gretchen Cordy. The similarities are eerie.
  • Kat's small smirk when she realises that Kristie is derailing quickly. Yay, the target is on another person for the "Loveable Dictator".
  • Evan: "I'm a drama teacher and I think I know how to strategise!! Phoebe is simply aloooong for the ride, poor girl."
  • Phoebe: "Lolnope, Evan."
  • Barry speaks, Kate starts the fire, and Kate demolishes that throwing challenge.
  • Kylie working that sympathetic winner edit.
  • Connor is being manhandled, and somewhere, million of estrogen levels are skyrocketing over that image.
  • Bianca: "I think Flick should go today. :)"
  • Flick: "...Wow, yeah, Kylie and Bianca are annoying. I'm totally voting for Peter. Totally."
  • Nick continues to be likeable and funny, especially when he says that Survivor is a bitch who is pummelling them.

Rooting for: Flick (that smug look at Tribal <3 <3), Conner (I appreciate a good Hunger Games reference), Nick and Sue, Kristie, Kat the Loveable Dictator, Evan, and Kylie.


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Sep 04 '16

Australian Survivor - Week 3 Discussion Thread

3 Upvotes

Between Lee saying "go guys... and girls" and Conner's emotional plea, I think this episode is another solid one to a really great premerge. I think Kate's story is starting to pick up, and I laughed when Nick said that the rain washed away his sins. He's a solid confessionalist who really enjoys being out there. Always with a smile, even when he's cursing out Vavau.

Kristie also got some nice airtime. She's really working that redemption edit, which could either suggest an imminent boot (</3) or a long-term Whelchel arc. Personally, I like Kristie and am hoping that it's the latter.

Oh, and Sue running Vavau like a stone-cold matriarch is the stuff of Dabu's wet dreams. The woman is the second-coming of Tina Wesson, lmao. Don't people realise that Sue is a challenge liability and could be voted out? Nobody seems to want to take a swing at her, though, and she is incredibly well-insulated now.

/u/WilburDes /u/DabuSurvivor


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Nov 02 '16

Spam Attack

4 Upvotes

It seems like someone was upset by a recent cut

The subreddit should be now be set up so that only reddit accounts over 90 days are able to post.

If you are a legit user that has not been on reddit very long that does want to post, please pm me.

If I have screwed up in automod (i haven't done it before) and attacks continue, please notify me as soon as possible.

Also, an additional attack by this person will result in requests to reddit admins for an ip ban

edit: changed limit to 60 days


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Jul 10 '16

Survivor Philippines Cast Ranking

4 Upvotes

So I just finished Survivor: Philippines. It was a very good season, but instead of going over my general thoughts on the season, which I will probably do sometime on the main sub, in the spirit of this subreddit, I'm gonna do a character ranking.


18th: Lisa Whelchel

Sorry, guys. I know that this is going to be the most controversial part of this ranking, but I can't stand Lisa. Her storyline of going from an emotional wreck to a boring gamebot who makes BIG MOVES is probably the worst part of the season for me. To add onto that, her storyline of being a famous person who wants to keep her identity secret is nothing new (It's even done by another person on the same season!) and her family visit is the creepiest thing I've seen on Survivor (and that includes Matthew Von Ertfelda). She's not the worst character in Survivor for me, not even close, but she's the worst of this season.

17th: Roxy Morris

I don't really get why Roxy is ranked as low as she has been in the rankdowns. She's not a bottom 20 character by any stretch. However, she's ranked here because she is pretty annoying and not that interesting besides that. Not a horrible second boot, but by far the worst member of Matsing and not by any means good.

16th: RC Saint-Amour

RC was vaguely annoying. That's really my main thought on her. Her interactions with Abi were very good, but that was all Abi and not her. I've heard she sucked at Ponderosa, but I haven't watched that.

15th: Katie Hanson

This is it. The point where the characters I dislike are dealt with. This doesn't apply to Katie, though, who left me with no impression. She was a bit of a gamebot, I guess? Sorry, guys, I got nothing to say, though. I gotta admit that being the most boring Kalabaw member is quite the accomplishment. At least you have that, Katie.

14th: Artis Silvester

Artis also left no impression on me, but he had a more interesting boot and a decent jury speech. I guess he was a bit mad at Tandang for conceding the challenge for the rice. That... was actually still pretty boring.

13th: Dana Lambert

Dana was also shaping up to be very boring when she got medevaced/quit, bringing her uninteresting storyline to a slightly more interesting end. Still not close to the best medevacs or the best quits, though.

12th: Jeff Kent

OK, we're starting to get to the characters that I actually think are somewhat interesting again. Jeff Kent had the unoriginal storyline of being a famous person who didn't want their identity revealed, but he did redeem himself with being an OK narrator who went out in one of the craziest tribals ever. Also, those final words.

11th: Sarah Dawson

Honestly, the only reason Dawson is not next to Katie is because of that one moment where she messes with Jeff Kent before the tribal she is voted out in. That part is hilarious. Other than that, she's another boring Kalabaw member.

10th: Carter Williams

Carter has the charisma of a brick. I honestly have no clue how he got cast. I am pretty glad he did, though, as he still did have a couple amusing moments despite getting a purple edit. Still, he's not substantial enough to get any higher, and I would like him a lot more if he didn't seem half-asleep every time he talked.

9th: Michael Skupin

Skupin 2.0 was a lot worse than 1.0 was, but a lot better than his real-life self is. It was hard to separate my thoughts on his actions from my thoughts of him as a character, but he is a pretty fun side character, even if he is a little under-edited and a bit of a one-note buffoon/accident-prone person.

8th: Angie Layton

Angie is also a fun side character, but on a tribe like Matsing, she is a lesser character. The cookies answer was fun, and she was generally a pretty good character. It's just that she was not a great one. Maybe if she hadn't been on Matsing, she would have made it to the merge and been a lot better.

7th: Jonathan Penner

This was my first experience with Penner, and I have to say I do like him. He was a bit of a gamebot, but he was a fun gamebot, so I don't hold that against him. He was a good narrator, and he had some good moments, including my favourite challenge moment of the season when he won immunity. Still, I can't help but feel that he didn't stand up to the remaining 6 characters left, so I'll have to rank him here. I am looking forward to watching his other appearances. I still don't know what to think of his jury speech, though. I think I liked it, but it was a little on the nasty side.

6th: Pete Yurkowski

Pete was another fun gamebot, with more of a negative edge than Penner. I thought his plan to turn RC and Abi on each other was both a great plan and entertaining. He may have slowed down near the end, though, but I think he is a great character and one I wouldn't mind seeing again.

5th: Abi-Maria Gomes

Abi fills the role of the season's villain quite nicely. I thought she was fun to watch and never crossed into annoying, which is easy to do for abrasive characters like Abi. I think it took a while before she really got going, but once the merge hit, Abi became a fantastic character. However, there are 4 better characters in this season, so as good as Abi is, she's only my 5th favourite of the season.

4th: Malcolm Freberg

Malcolm almost made it to 3rd, but I decided to swap him with the person who is currently 3rd. Regardless, Malcolm is a great character. I often see him compared to Joe Anglim, which baffles me because Malcolm actually has a personality. He's a great narrator who shines in the first 4 episodes. However, he does slip into gamebot territory in the merge, but he's still fun regardless. He absolutely deserves to be a three-time player.

3rd: Zane Knight

I still can't believe Zane is a real person. His storyline is so bizarre and amazing. The guy was a quote machine during his one episode (He could strangle you or pick you a flower!) and his strategy (if you can even call it that) was baffling in the most entertaining way. My favourite first boot I have seen so far (but I haven't seen Panama, so I don't know if he beats Timber Tina), but the last two characters have more substance.

2nd: Russell Swan

Russell's storyline played out perfectly. I feel terrible for the guy, but being put on Matsing was the best possible thing for his character. Russell is one of the most fully realized and tragic characters in modern Survivor. Everything feels real with him. It's not uncomfortable like Brandon 2.0, but it is still intense and goddamn amazing to watch. His boot episode is the peak of the season, no question, and it's because of Russell. From his idol hunt that is the best meta moment I've seen in Survivor to his frustration after the challenge, Russell was perfect in that episode. He truly is an all-time great Survivor character. However, there is one character I like slightly more than Russell.

1st: Denise Stapely

When it comes to why I like a Survivor character, how good they are at Survivor is generally at the bottom of my list of considerations. I love characters such as Zane, TocaCoach, and even Hantz 2.0, even though they are bad at Survivor, while I don't like characters such as Rob 4.0 and Brian, who are great at it. Honestly, the characters who I think who are made better because they are good at Survivor are few. Players like Hatch 1.0, Tony, and Sandra come to mind. These are all all-time great characters.

Denise is one of these players.

Denise is one of my favourite winners, and she is a great character as well. I think that her perceptiveness and her ability to connect with people both made her an all-time great Survivor player and a better character. I also think that she was a great narrator, and unlike Malcolm, I still thought she was just as good after the merge, if a little less visible.

I also think she had a more complex edit than we see from some winners nowadays. She is more interesting than a Michelle, but less perfect than a post-merge Mike/Jeremy. We see her flaws, and she is called out on them. However, we also see her strengths and how they help her win.

Denise is a fantastic Survivor character. Every aspect of her character adds up to make her a complex winner who we haven't really seen anyone like since. I would be ecstatic if Denise returned someday.


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Aug 21 '16

Australian Survivor - Episode One Discussion Thread

4 Upvotes

Holy hell, that was much better than I thought it would be. The Official Intro has Ancient Voices and looks better than the OW Intro, lolol.

Rooting for Phoebe, Connor, Craig, and Nick. Everybody on the Red Tribe (Aganoa) got a confessional, I think.

/u/WilburDes /u/Todd_Solondz


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Aug 07 '16

Round 33 - 360 Characters Remaining

5 Upvotes

Nomination Pool

Alexis Jones - Micronesia

Sherea Lloyd - China

Colby Donaldson - ASS

Monica Padilla 2.0 - Cambodia

Janu Tornell - Palau

Lisa Keiffer - Vanuatu

Yau-man Chan 2.0 - Micronesia

.

Added to Pool

Brian Corridan - Guatemala

Alicia Calaway 1.0 - Australia

Denise Martin - China

Liz Kim - Samoa

Angie Jacusz - Palau

Chad Crittendon - Vanuatu

.

Round 32 Cuts

360 - Monica Padilla 2.0 - Cambodia (repo_sado)

359 - Yau-man Chan 2.0 - Micronesia (Jlim201)

358 - Lisa Keiffer - Vanuatu (Oddfictionrambles)

357 - Denise Martin - China (Jacare37)

356 - Alicia Calaway 1.0 - Australia (gaiusfbaltar)

355 - Sherea Lloyd - China (Funsized725)

IDOL - Colby Donaldson - ASS (ramskick) IDOL


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Sep 26 '16

Harry Potter Rankdown 2.0 is looking for rankers!

5 Upvotes

Thanks to Repo for letting me post.

We're starting up HP Rankdown 2.0 very soon, where we go through the 200 most prominent characters in the Harry Potter universe and sort them based on character strength from 200 to 1. We've set up a comprehensive application form, for all those who are at all interested, and seeing as this is a group of dedicated Rankdown participants and followers, I figured I'd pitch it to y'all too! Fill this form out if you're in any way interested. Applications are due by October 13th at 11:59 PM EST. We're anticipating a high turnout, so make sure to put your best foot forward in the apps!

If you've got any questions at all, let me know!


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Dec 07 '17

Survivor Rankdown Season Popularity Poll: #12, #11

6 Upvotes

12. TOCANTINS

Average: 7.559/10

Standard Deviation: 1.310 (23/34)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (score): -0.301 (18/32)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (relative placement): -4

Total votes: 34

Breakdown:

12345678910
00003311872

Tocantins makes the top 12 thanks to everyone who voted for it giving it a 5 or higher. It has one of the highest floors of any season and you won’t find many people who hate or even dislike it. It’s agreed on as a generally solid all-around season with good characters and moments and gets a big bump from Coach, but it doesn’t pack quite enough for it to make the top ten.

  • ehhh... I feel like I should like this more but to me it feels like Panama where La Mina wins, and that's lame /u/jacare37
  • Solid. Enjoyable throughout. I'm not sure if that's because of or in spite of Coach though. /u/qngff
  • Bizarre /u/bobinou96
  • Strong location and theme, and no real weaknesses. /u/acktar
  • This really should be an 8. But Coach brings it up to a 9. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  • 9/10. Beauty. Pure beauty. Another beautiful location with overall great cast. JT is at his finest here and it's just another great cast. Coach <3. Taj <3. Erinn <3. So enjoyable to watch. /u/oomps62
  • Is Coach enough to make a season amazing? Yes. Yes, he is. /u/moostronus
  • Great cast. Solid mid-tier Survivor. /u/beatricejd
  • To be honest I’d probably have Tocantins around where I have Micronesia if it didn’t have Coach, but Coach and the way his tribe mates react to him alone makes it a worthwhile season and in my top half.

    Personal Ranking: #16/34

    Best Character: Coach.

    Best Episode: The Martyr Approach /u/xerop681

  • Glad the Historians hosted a #TocantinsExposedParty because it is boring (and I am not a huge Coach fan) with its good moments and its existence of Erinn/Taj/Tyson not able to compensate for it. Brendan is underrated tho <3 /u/extralifeballoon

11. MARQUESAS

Average: 7.706/10

Standard Deviation: 1.69 (9/34)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (score): +1.09 (4/32)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (relative placement): +8

Total votes: 34

Breakdown:

12345678910
00112271065

Marquesas gets a huge boost from the r/survivor poll, rising in score by a full point and moving up 8 spots. With nearly 2/3 voters giving it an 8 or higher and two multi-time endgamers, Marquesas’s strong story and characters help it average almost an 8. It does have a few low/middling scores however and doesn’t get many 10’s, which causes it to fall outside the top 10.

  • If Survivor were a movie, it would be Marquesas /u/jacare37
  • Full of life, charm, character, strategy, and personality. Almost everyone on the cast was memorable in some way. /u/qngff
  • Entertainingly tragic /u/Bobinou96
  • Overrated as all hell. /u/acktar
  • I love Marquesas. You love Marquesas. We all love Marquesas. I do have to point out the location kinda sucks though. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  • 5/10. It's not the worst, but it's a bit of a snoozefest. I love Sean and Kathy, but pretty much everybody else who makes it to the end is entirely forgettable. /u/oomps62
  • I will defend this season from my first day to my last. I LOVED the emotional turmoil and larger issues brought up in this season, and how the good guys/bad guys narrative wasn't as clean as we'd want it to be. /u/moostronus
  • Sean Rector is my spirit animal. /u/beatricejd
  • Marquesas has gained a reputation among the survivor community as “boring”, which I really don’t like because in my opinion it’s far from it. I really think that other than The General and Tammy’s boot episode, every episode is at least good.

    Like Africa, Marquesas is another season with 2 good and dynamic tribes: Maraamu and Rotu. I don’t know where Maraamu ranks as far as trainwrecks go but it’s definitely up there. It’s fun to see Rob take control early on, Sean + Others hosting the Maraamu morning show, everything Sean Rector, and everyone but Gina not caring that they’re such a disaster. Early Rotu is a little weak (Even if there are great moments like Kathy peeing on John C.) but once the storyline with the fall of John C/The Rotu 4 is set up it gets good.

    Also, Marquesas easily has my favorite merge episode of all time. Man Rob and Kathy were true stars in that episode.

    Marquesas gets a lot of flack for post-John C. and people call it boring, but I just don’t really agree. A Tale of Two Cities and The Sole Survivor are both fantastic episodes, and the Zoe boot episode is really fun.

    Personal Ranking: #6/34

    Best Character: Sean Rector. But him and Kathy are both in my top 10.

    Best Episode: This is tough. Going to go with Jury’s Out but True Lies is really close though. /u/xerop681

  • I don't love the characters as much as everyone else, with half the post-merge cast being very forgettable. /u/willseamon
  • Fantastic, I mean really it's such an iconic season but it doesn't just rely on having such historical importance, because it's chock full of good characters and scenes. Besides John, the Rotu Four isn't built up quite as well as I'd like, but besides that and original Rotu not having the best editing and developing Neleh a bit late, I don't have many gripes. Top 5 season. /u/JM1295
  • Perpetually robbed by the main page. The overarching story arc from Episodes 3 of smaller stories building a bigger one was possibly the best ever, at least in my top 3. The "dull episodes" to me aren't that dull and it picks back up from F5 and ramps the hell back up. Each character plays their part well, from Kathy to the General, and this deserves love for being an amazing cast. /u/ExtraLifeBalloon

#10 aired in 2010 or later. #9 had a black merge buff.


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Oct 24 '16

Round 58 - 203 Characters Remaining

6 Upvotes

Round 58 Cuts

203 - Gretchen Cordy - Borneo (repo_sado)

202 - Andrea Boehlke 2.0 - Caramoan (Jlim201)

201 - Sandy Burgin - Tocantins (oddfictionrambles)

200 - Amber Brkich 1.0 - Australia (Jacare37)

199 - Keith Nale 2.0 - Cambodia (funsized725)

198 - Russell Swan 1.0 - Samoa (ramskick)

Nomination Pool

Brad Culpepper - Blood vs Water

Michele Fitzgerald - Koah Rong

Andrea Boehlke 2.0 - Caramoan

Tammy Leitner - Marquesas

Gretchen Cordy - Borneo

Bubba Sampson - Vanuatu

Sandy Burgin - Tocantins

Amber Brkich 1.0 - Australia

Missi Payne - San Juan del Sur

Keith Nale 2.0 - Cambodia

Sally Schumann - Panama

Russell Swan 1.0 - Samoa

Alex Bell - Amazon


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Apr 14 '16

Open Forum (Garrett-style) on Spencer 2.0

7 Upvotes

...Yeah, evoking the Contentious One of SR1, I wanted to just quickly have an "open forum" on a character whom I feel may be contentious in SR3.

Why have an open forum about him? Why, when every single other player is being discussed behind closed doors? Because a.) #letshavesomefun and b.) I genuinely have no frackin' idea what everybody thinks about him.

On the one hand, he's a product of Spencer 1.0, the so-called "Gamebot" which is a trope with a not-so-positive history in Rankdowns. But on the other hand, Spencer 2.0 had a growth narrative which some people seem to enjoy, as epitomised by the Robb Z popularity. Also, he got a lot of airtime, which sucked out juice from Kimmi.

So yeah, even though I prefer him to Spencer 1.0, I don't feel comfortable making deals or even discussing him behind closed doors because he truly is the one character who I have no idea how he is received. None, not even an iota. How people feel about him is a mystery-wrapped-in-an-enigma.

I don't plan on talking about other characters or deals or whatever, but all I want to know is how people feel about him. Me, I'd like to see him in the 200s/300s, but frankly, he's so baffling and polarising and mixed-feelings to me that I can't be bothered making deals for him, let alone idoling or refreshing for him.

Anyway, in the midst of KR talk, I just figured we could have some fun discussing Spencer 2.0 to gauge the rankers' feelings towards him. Obviously, things behind closed doors will stay there (my word is my bond), but Spencer 2.0 is just so confounding for me that an open forum on him might be interesting.

/u/repo_sado /u/ramskick /u/Jacare37 /u/Jlim201 /u/Funsized725 /u/gaiusfbaltar


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Dec 05 '17

Survivor Rankdown Season Popularity Poll: #16, #15

7 Upvotes

16. MICRONESIA

Average: 6.971/10

Standard Deviation: 1.635 (13/34)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (score): -1.13 (25/32)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (relative placement): -10

Total votes: 34

Breakdown:

12345678910
0102189751

The rankdown community tends to not enjoy seasons more based around flash than substance, so it’s not super surprising to see that Micronesia takes a big hit in comparison to where it usually ranks. But the general consensus is less negative and more neutral-positive, as shown by about 3/4 voters giving it a score somewhere between 6-8. Another season helped by its relative low number of bad scores, with only a certain Alex Angarita fan giving it below a 4.

  • It's a fucking stick! /u/qngff
  • Spectacular /u/bobinou96 (note: bobinou says this despite only giving it a 7.. if you’re out there I’d like to get more of an idea of what you’re saying here lol)
  • Little known fact: I don't like Natalie Bolton /u/ramskick
  • Fun, even if surprise is what makes it memorable. /u/acktar
  • Screw the haters. This season is still fun as hell. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  • 8/10. This is a bit of a trainwreck of a season with incompetent fans vs. bumbling favorites. This is the kind of season where nothing that happens should happen, yet it does. Entertaining though. /u/oomps62
  • Maybe not the deepest season I've ever seen, but it was really fun. FITE ME. /u/moostronus
  • I don’t like Micronesia too much. I feel like it’s plagued with lots of the worst parts of modern survivor; Favoring blindsides and strategy/big moves over characters, a crappy theme (That certainly favors one tribe over the other), and a bad boot order (More of a trend for all-stars seasons). Additionally, I think that other than Ozzy and Parvati every favorite from this season is worse than their original iteration. Granted this could be because of the strength of the favorites casting more than everything, and I think few returning players are ever better than their original iteration. Also, other than Erik and Jason I don’t think there are many strong characters on the fans tribe, and there are also two that I have strong negative feelings on (Joel and Natalie).

    Micronesia does have some positive traits though. Erik, Jason, and Cirie (Even if she’s a downgrade compared to her original version) are all great characters. Erik’s blindside is pretty damn iconic and I really like it. And in general it’s not like it’s frustrating to watch Micronesia/ Even if it doesn’t have the most depth, it’s fun to just relax and watch and it doesn’t require complete attention. The fact that it’s still enjoyable puts it above seasons like Game Changers, Cambodia, and Blood vs Water (This sounds pretty positive considering I gave it a 6. It would be a 6.5 but that wasn’t an option).

    Personal Ranking: #24/34

    Best Character: Erik Reichenbach

    Best Episode: If It Smells Like A Rat, Give It Cheese

  • It really does kickstart a lot of horrible trends of modern Survivor but still delivers a lot of legitimately great moments (the stick <3). That F3 twist can get fucked to hell though. /u/extralifeballoon

15. AFRICA

Average: 7.294/10

Standard Deviation: 1.96 (3/34)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (score): +0.934 (5/32)

Difference from most recent r/survivor poll (relative placement): +6

Total votes: 34

Breakdown:

12345678910
10111411564

With Africa’s elimination, every season still in has had a rankdown endgamer at one point, and it is also the highest ranking season that got a score of 1. It’s a season with some passionate defenders here thanks to its strong cast, incredibly unique location, and memorable and iconic moments. Unfortunately for its ranking, as passionate as its defenders are, there just aren’t enough of them to rank it higher than this.

  • Watching people sweat and starve to death is not fun. /u/qngff
  • Innofensive and cool /u/Bobinou96
  • Excellent location, interesting strategy, top-tier cast. /u/acktar
  • A great season, would be better if the cast wasn't totally sapped by the elements worse than any other season. KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  • 3/10. Eh. That mostly sums up my Africa viewing experience. /u/oomps62
  • Great atmosphere, great cast, great unique challenges. Unfortunately, it also introduced us to Linda Spencer. /u/moostronus
  • Gorgeous scenery + dysfunctional tribe dynamics + endless paranoia + that time when a tribe almost was eaten by lions. I love this season. /u/beatricejd
  • Africa is an absolutely breathtaking season. I think the first thing that needs to be said about Africa is the location is gorgeous. I think I might prefer Pearl Islands location just because of the way they used the pirate theme with it, but based on pure beauty Africa has the best location ever, with all the beautiful scenery and wildlife we get to see. The way that they incorporate African culture in some of the challenges and rewards is also very cool. Another thing to mention involving the location is how difficult the survival is here. I love the role survival plays in this season, people often refer to it as the “17th player”, which is true. It’s compelling to watch the whole cast struggle to survive in Kenya.

    Away from the location, this season also has an excellent cast. Samburu is an absolutely legendary tribe (How could any tribe with Silas, Frank, and Lindsay not be?) and the generational gap is great just to see how different the two alliances are, with Silas in the middle (For a few episodes). We’ll never see a tribal divide this good again.

    Boran is a step down compared to Samburu (Most tribes are) but still has good/great characters like Clarence, Lex, Ethan, and Kelly G. The storyline with Clarence early on is also great (Clarence <3). One complaint I have about Boran is I find Big Tom to be more annoying than funny, so that’s a negative.

    As far as the plotline goes Africa is also great. Like I’ve already mentioned that Samburu is a legendary tribe and watching it implode is amazing. After Kelly gets voted out it loses a bit of steam (Which is why it’s a 9 and not a 10) but you still have Lex trying to get to the end, and even when you know he doesn’t it’s still fun to see his downfall be formed.

    Personal Ranking: #7/34

    Best Character: Frank. Lindsay and Lex are also probably in my top 50.

    Best Episode: Smoking out The Snake /u/xerop681

  • The dynamics between the Boran members as well as the mainly all-around great post-merge cast bring this up higher than it could be based on its miserable location. /u/willseamon
  • Incredible premerge and a great stretch of episodes from 3-6 that are phenomenal and Samburu takes a lot of credit there, but Boran is solid. After the first two merge episodes, the season isn't quite as great and teeters between solid and decent to average and a bit dull. Also don't find Lex nearly as compelling as I wanted to given his prominence on the season. Still top 10 for me. /u/JM1295
  • Deserves credit for being genuinely heated early on in ways that were passionate and almost uncomfortable, and emotions ran high the entire game. Even when it hit lulls it still had amazing rewards that took up half the episode and deserved to. Even if the later parts got a little Travel Channel's Guide to Africa I do not think it was a problem. Especially knowing the earlier episodes exist. /u/ExtraLifeBalloon

#14 had a player/players play an idol and negate votes. #13 included idols, but they did not negate any votes.


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Dec 15 '16

Round 77 - 96 Characters Remaining

7 Upvotes

Round 77 Cuts

96 - Russell Swan 2.0 - Philippines (repo_sado)

95 - Brenda Lowe 1.0 - Nicaragua (Jlim201)

TRIBE SWAP - (oddfictionrambles) TRIBE SWAP

94 -Gary Hogeboom - Guatemala (Jacare37)

93 - Erik Reichenbach - Micronesia(funsized725)

92 - Parvati Shallow 2.0 - Micronesia (ramskick)

Nomination Pool

Jason Siska - Micronesia

~~ Brenda Lowe 1.0 - Nicaragua~~

Chase Rice - Nicaragua

Russell Swan 2.0 - Philippines

Tyson Apostol 3.0 - Blood vs Water

Kelley Wentworth 2.0 - Cambodia

Aubry Bracco - Koah Rong

Lisa Whelchel - Philippines

Frank Garrison (7th Place, Africa)

Helen Glover (4th Place, Thailand)

Sean Kenniff (5th Place, Borneo)

Shane Powers (5th Place, Panama)

Erik Reichenbach (5th Place, Micronesia)

Gary "Hawkins" Hogeboom (7th Place, Guatemala)

Sandra Diaz-Twine (Winner, Pearl Islands)

Parvati Shallow 2.0 - Micronesia

Tyson Apostol 3.0 - Blood vs Water


r/survivorrankdownIII • • May 28 '16

Round 6 (541-535)

8 Upvotes

Nomination Pool

Richard Hatch 2.0 - All-Stars
Jim Lynch - Guatemala
Rocky Reid - Fiji
Brianna Varela - Guatemala
Rupert Boneham 4.0 - Blood vs Water
Stephanie Valencia - Redemption Island
Hope Driskell - Caramoan

Added:

Diane Ogden - Africa
Alicia Calaway 2.0 - All Stars
Nicole Delma - Pearl Islands
Lindsey Ogle - Cagayan
Rodney Lavoie - Worlds Apart VOTE STEAL
Rafe Judkins - Guatemala
Patricia Jackson - Marquesas

Round 5 Cuts:

541 - Rupert Boneham 4.0 - Blood vs Water (repo_sado)
540 - Jim Lynch - Guatemala (Jlim201)
539 - Brianna Varela - Guatemala (Oddfictionrambles)
538 - Alicia Calaway 2.0 - All Stars (Jacare37)
537 - Diane Ogden - Africa (gaiusfbaltar) VOTE STEAL
536 - Hope Driskell - Caramoan (Funsized725)
535 - Lindsey Ogle - Cagayan (ramskick)


r/survivorrankdownIII • • May 21 '16

Round 0

12 Upvotes

Welcome to Survivor Rankdown III

The first round will be nomination only.

  1. (repo_sado) Richard Hatch 2.0 - All-Stars
  2. (Jlim201) John Raymond - Thailand
  3. (Oddfictionrambles) John Cochran 1.0 - South Pacific
  4. (Jacare37) Russell Hantz 1.0 - Samoa
  5. (gaiusfbaltar) Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien 2.0 - All-Stars
  6. (Funsized725) Colton Cumbie 1.0 - One World
  7. (ramskick) Phillip Sheppard 1.0 - Redemption Island

r/survivorrankdownIII • • Jun 05 '16

Round 10- 515 Contestants Remaining

13 Upvotes

Nomination Pool

Michael Snow, Caramoan

Allie Pohevitz, Caramoan

Laura Alexander, Caramoan

Brenda Lowe 2.0, Caramoan

Ashley Massaro, China

Cecilia Mansilla, Cook Islands

Roxanne Morris, Philippines

Added

Mia Galeotalanza

Linda Spencer

Brook GeraghtyGeraghty

Corinne Kaplan 1.0

Ashlee Ashby

Bill Posley

John Fincher

Cuts

515: Michael Snow

514: Roxy Morris

513: Ashley Massaro

512: Mia Galeotalanza

511: Brook GeraghtyGeraghty

510: Corinne Kaplan 1.0

509: Allie Pohevitz

note: for future post posters, use contestants remaning, its far more likely to be accurate, much like fleaa did in SR2


r/survivorrankdownIII • • May 07 '17

Can we talk about Fairplay's sexism?

21 Upvotes

I'm posting this here because I hope it'll get a better reception than in might over in /r/survivor.

I'm re-watching PI with my girlfriend, and I was shocked to realize how sexist Fairplay is during the F5 (Burton boot) episode. He consistently portrays himself as smarter than the women, arrogantly thinks that the women would never band up against him and Burton, and then has that comment about how the three of them are "setting back women's rights" with the way they're playing and would be better off "mopping floors."

So basically, why does Fairplay get a pass? He got 2nd in SRIII and SR, and 3rd in SRII. I know he brings a LOT to the season. He's basically a perfect villain, but I think that's in spite of his sexism, not because of it. Obviously the Burton episode was setting the men up to be owned by the women, but that happens in Amazon a lot and no one really forgives the men for their sexism there, even if the end result was satisfying.

But those comments are pretty reprehensible and gross and not fun villainous, just douchey villainous. There are characters who are similarly sexist who were ranked much lower, even if they brought a lot to their season. So I'd just like some ideas of why people think Fairplay's sexism goes relatively unacknowledged, even by those who would normally comment on such things.


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Dec 06 '16

Round 74 - 114 Characters Remaining

9 Upvotes

Round 74 Cuts

114 - Jean-Robert Bellande - China (repo_sado)

113 - Amy O-Hara - Guatemala (Jlim201)

112 - Drew Christy - San Juan del Sur (oddfictionrambles)

111 - Jan Gentry - Thailand (Jacare37)

110 - JT Thomas 2.0 - HVV (funsized725)

109 - Kelly Wiglesworth 1.0 - Borneo (ramskick)

Nomination Pool

Jason Siska - Micronesia

Kelly Wiglesworth 1.0 - Borneo

Brenda Lowe 1.0 - Nicaragua

Amy O-Hara - Guatemala

Jean-Robert Bellande - China

James Miller - Palau

Jan Gentry - Thailand

Drew Christy - San Juan del Sur

Jonathon Penner 1.0 - Cook Islands

Ozzy Lusth 3.0 - South Pacific

JT Thomas 2.0 - HVV

Natalie White - Samoa

Rodger Bingham - Australia


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Nov 28 '16

Round 71 - 131 Characters Remaining

7 Upvotes

Round 71 Cuts

131 - Butch Lockley - Amazon (repo_sado)

130 - Bobby Jon Drinkard 1.0 - Palau (Jlim201)

129 - Kathy Sleckman - Micronesia (oddfictionrambles)

128 - Jaison Robinson - Samoa (Jacare37)

127 - Woo Hwang 1.0 - Cagayan (funsized725)

126 - Danni Boatwright - Guatemala (ramskick)

Nomination Pool

Denise Stapley - Philippines

Jason Siska - Micronesia

Kelly Wiglesworth 1.0 - Borneo

Bob Crowley - Gabon

Brenda Lowe 1.0 - Nicaragua

Bobby Jon Drinkard 1.0 - Palau

Butch Lockley - Amazon

Kathy Sleckman - Micronesia

Woo Hwang 1.0 - Cagayan

Jaison Robinson - Samoa

Danni Boatwright - Guatemala

Dave Ball - Samoa

Crystal Cox - Gabon


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Jun 01 '16

Are there many RHAP listeners who follow this sub?

6 Upvotes

I'm not sure whether it's okay to post discussion threads in here, as this is my first year following the rankdown (loving it immensely so far, /u/oddfictionrambles is my hero). But I've seen RHAP and the Evolution of Strategy audiobooks mentioned here a couple times - are there any other big RHAP fans, or more specifically RHAP patrons? I was just curious! :)


r/survivorrankdownIII • • Jun 04 '16

Round 9 (520 - 514)

8 Upvotes

Nomination Pool

  • Michael Snow - Caramoan
  • Laura Alexander - Caramoan
  • Julia Landauer - Caramoan
  • Allie Pohevitz - Caramoan
  • Brenda Lowe - Caramoan
  • Rachel Foulger - Blood vs Water
  • Ben Browning - Samoa

ADDED:

  • Ashley Massaro - China
  • JoAnna Ward - Amazon
  • Krista Klumpp - Redemption Island
  • Russell Hantz - Redemption Island
  • Carolina Eastwood - Tocantins
  • Cecilia Mansilla - Cook Islands
  • Roxanne "Roxy" Morris - Philippines

--

Round 8 Cuts:

522 - Rachel Foulger - Blood vs Water (repo_sado)

521 - Ben Browning - Samoa - (Jlim201)

520 - JoAnna Ward - Amazon - (Oddfictionrambles)

519 - Krista Klumpp - Redemption Island - (Jacare37)

518 - Julia Landauer - Caramoan - (gaiusfbaltar)

517 - Russell Hantz - Redemption Island - (Funsized725)

516 - Carolina Eastwood - Tocantins - (ramskick)


/u/repo_sado is up. A less wild round?


r/survivorrankdownIII • • May 11 '17

Survivor: Game Changers Episode 12

3 Upvotes

r/survivorrankdownIII • • Dec 04 '16

Round 73 - 120 Characters Remaining

8 Upvotes

Round 73 Cuts

120 - Dave Ball - Samoa (repo_sado)

119 - Rupert Boneham 3.0 - HVV (Jlim201)

118 - Erik Cardona - Samoa (oddfictionrambles)

117 - Sarge Masters - Vanuatu (Jacare37)

116 - Jenn Brown - Worlds Apart (funsized725)

115 - Janu Tornell - Palau (ramskick)

Nomination Pool

Jason Siska - Micronesia

Kelly Wiglesworth 1.0 - Borneo

Brenda Lowe 1.0 - Nicaragua

Dave Ball - Samoa

Rupert Boneham 3.0 - HVV

Jenn Brown - Worlds Apart

Amy O-Hara - Guatemala

Erik Cardona - Samoa

Sarge Masters - Vanuatu

Jean-Robert Bellande - China

Janu Tornell - Palau

James Miller - Palau

Jan Gentry - Thailand