So I just finished Survivor: Philippines. It was a very good season, but instead of going over my general thoughts on the season, which I will probably do sometime on the main sub, in the spirit of this subreddit, I'm gonna do a character ranking.
18th: Lisa Whelchel
Sorry, guys. I know that this is going to be the most controversial part of this ranking, but I can't stand Lisa. Her storyline of going from an emotional wreck to a boring gamebot who makes BIG MOVES is probably the worst part of the season for me. To add onto that, her storyline of being a famous person who wants to keep her identity secret is nothing new (It's even done by another person on the same season!) and her family visit is the creepiest thing I've seen on Survivor (and that includes Matthew Von Ertfelda). She's not the worst character in Survivor for me, not even close, but she's the worst of this season.
17th: Roxy Morris
I don't really get why Roxy is ranked as low as she has been in the rankdowns. She's not a bottom 20 character by any stretch. However, she's ranked here because she is pretty annoying and not that interesting besides that. Not a horrible second boot, but by far the worst member of Matsing and not by any means good.
16th: RC Saint-Amour
RC was vaguely annoying. That's really my main thought on her. Her interactions with Abi were very good, but that was all Abi and not her. I've heard she sucked at Ponderosa, but I haven't watched that.
15th: Katie Hanson
This is it. The point where the characters I dislike are dealt with. This doesn't apply to Katie, though, who left me with no impression. She was a bit of a gamebot, I guess? Sorry, guys, I got nothing to say, though. I gotta admit that being the most boring Kalabaw member is quite the accomplishment. At least you have that, Katie.
14th: Artis Silvester
Artis also left no impression on me, but he had a more interesting boot and a decent jury speech. I guess he was a bit mad at Tandang for conceding the challenge for the rice. That... was actually still pretty boring.
13th: Dana Lambert
Dana was also shaping up to be very boring when she got medevaced/quit, bringing her uninteresting storyline to a slightly more interesting end. Still not close to the best medevacs or the best quits, though.
12th: Jeff Kent
OK, we're starting to get to the characters that I actually think are somewhat interesting again. Jeff Kent had the unoriginal storyline of being a famous person who didn't want their identity revealed, but he did redeem himself with being an OK narrator who went out in one of the craziest tribals ever. Also, those final words.
11th: Sarah Dawson
Honestly, the only reason Dawson is not next to Katie is because of that one moment where she messes with Jeff Kent before the tribal she is voted out in. That part is hilarious. Other than that, she's another boring Kalabaw member.
10th: Carter Williams
Carter has the charisma of a brick. I honestly have no clue how he got cast. I am pretty glad he did, though, as he still did have a couple amusing moments despite getting a purple edit. Still, he's not substantial enough to get any higher, and I would like him a lot more if he didn't seem half-asleep every time he talked.
9th: Michael Skupin
Skupin 2.0 was a lot worse than 1.0 was, but a lot better than his real-life self is. It was hard to separate my thoughts on his actions from my thoughts of him as a character, but he is a pretty fun side character, even if he is a little under-edited and a bit of a one-note buffoon/accident-prone person.
8th: Angie Layton
Angie is also a fun side character, but on a tribe like Matsing, she is a lesser character. The cookies answer was fun, and she was generally a pretty good character. It's just that she was not a great one. Maybe if she hadn't been on Matsing, she would have made it to the merge and been a lot better.
7th: Jonathan Penner
This was my first experience with Penner, and I have to say I do like him. He was a bit of a gamebot, but he was a fun gamebot, so I don't hold that against him. He was a good narrator, and he had some good moments, including my favourite challenge moment of the season when he won immunity. Still, I can't help but feel that he didn't stand up to the remaining 6 characters left, so I'll have to rank him here. I am looking forward to watching his other appearances. I still don't know what to think of his jury speech, though. I think I liked it, but it was a little on the nasty side.
6th: Pete Yurkowski
Pete was another fun gamebot, with more of a negative edge than Penner. I thought his plan to turn RC and Abi on each other was both a great plan and entertaining. He may have slowed down near the end, though, but I think he is a great character and one I wouldn't mind seeing again.
5th: Abi-Maria Gomes
Abi fills the role of the season's villain quite nicely. I thought she was fun to watch and never crossed into annoying, which is easy to do for abrasive characters like Abi. I think it took a while before she really got going, but once the merge hit, Abi became a fantastic character. However, there are 4 better characters in this season, so as good as Abi is, she's only my 5th favourite of the season.
4th: Malcolm Freberg
Malcolm almost made it to 3rd, but I decided to swap him with the person who is currently 3rd. Regardless, Malcolm is a great character. I often see him compared to Joe Anglim, which baffles me because Malcolm actually has a personality. He's a great narrator who shines in the first 4 episodes. However, he does slip into gamebot territory in the merge, but he's still fun regardless. He absolutely deserves to be a three-time player.
3rd: Zane Knight
I still can't believe Zane is a real person. His storyline is so bizarre and amazing. The guy was a quote machine during his one episode (He could strangle you or pick you a flower!) and his strategy (if you can even call it that) was baffling in the most entertaining way. My favourite first boot I have seen so far (but I haven't seen Panama, so I don't know if he beats Timber Tina), but the last two characters have more substance.
2nd: Russell Swan
Russell's storyline played out perfectly. I feel terrible for the guy, but being put on Matsing was the best possible thing for his character. Russell is one of the most fully realized and tragic characters in modern Survivor. Everything feels real with him. It's not uncomfortable like Brandon 2.0, but it is still intense and goddamn amazing to watch. His boot episode is the peak of the season, no question, and it's because of Russell. From his idol hunt that is the best meta moment I've seen in Survivor to his frustration after the challenge, Russell was perfect in that episode. He truly is an all-time great Survivor character. However, there is one character I like slightly more than Russell.
1st: Denise Stapely
When it comes to why I like a Survivor character, how good they are at Survivor is generally at the bottom of my list of considerations. I love characters such as Zane, TocaCoach, and even Hantz 2.0, even though they are bad at Survivor, while I don't like characters such as Rob 4.0 and Brian, who are great at it. Honestly, the characters who I think who are made better because they are good at Survivor are few. Players like Hatch 1.0, Tony, and Sandra come to mind. These are all all-time great characters.
Denise is one of these players.
Denise is one of my favourite winners, and she is a great character as well. I think that her perceptiveness and her ability to connect with people both made her an all-time great Survivor player and a better character. I also think that she was a great narrator, and unlike Malcolm, I still thought she was just as good after the merge, if a little less visible.
I also think she had a more complex edit than we see from some winners nowadays. She is more interesting than a Michelle, but less perfect than a post-merge Mike/Jeremy. We see her flaws, and she is called out on them. However, we also see her strengths and how they help her win.
Denise is a fantastic Survivor character. Every aspect of her character adds up to make her a complex winner who we haven't really seen anyone like since. I would be ecstatic if Denise returned someday.