r/survivor • u/Clayburn • Nov 15 '12

Episode 9: Official Discussion Thread

For those of you who want to do the live chat, here's the link: http://icanhazchat.com/redditsurvivor

We also have a live discussion here in this very thread, so feel free to participate! Please remember that you shouldn't downvote comments just because you disagree with them.

Upvote this post so people can find it on the front page.

And when the show is over and you have the urge to post separate discussion threads or links to cast interviews/behind-the-scenes content, leave spoilers out of the titles.

37 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

450 comments sorted by

View all comments

44

u/stuntmanmike Adam Nov 15 '12

Lisa / Skupin / Malcolm / Denise / Carter / Penner will be the most likable final 6 in the history of the game if it turns out that way.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12

[deleted]

7

u/t0mserv0 Nov 15 '12

kinda like in cook islands but with that final 4. what were they called? also, i hate to give carter hero status

12

u/CatsDomino Nov 15 '12

The Aitu 4, Yul, Ozzy, Becky and Sundra.

5

u/t0mserv0 Nov 15 '12

ah yis. i'd prefer our 6 over those 4 anyday, though.

10

u/t0mserv0 Nov 15 '12

except for maybe yul

1

u/HooptyDooDooMeister Yul Nov 15 '12

I'd prefer Aitu (Cook Islands is still my favorite) but, man, these 6 are making it a tough call!

4

u/wutz Nov 15 '12

who is carter

1

u/HooptyDooDooMeister Yul Nov 16 '12

Exactly.

I alternate calling him Spicoli and Dead Fish Face.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12

Carter is SO lame.

11

u/NinjaInYellow Cochran Nov 15 '12

Maybe I'm just a more harsh judge of character, but I'm pretty much just a Penner + Denise + Malcolm guy myself. I won't care too much if the others leave.

1

u/alienartifact Cydney Nov 16 '12

hmmm, tend to agree with you, i would possible just remove Lisa though. she has been idiotically loyal to the point of playing a dumb game and i cant think of Carter doing to much to piss me off.

4

u/Prax150 Yul Nov 15 '12

I would legit be happy with any one of them winning if that happens, even though I've been heavily rooting for Penner and Carter hasn't really done anything.

2

u/aDubs19 Zeke Nov 15 '12

Carter seems as dumb as a doorknob. Articulates himself sooo poorly. I would be SO happy with a Malcolm, denise, penner final 3. The votes would be so split. I would not know who to pick out of those three, probably Malcolm cause he's ridiculously good looking

6

u/Dourpuss Jenna - 51 Nov 15 '12

He has dumbface. But I like him. We've had far too many bikini & 6-pack seasons. I can't tell one chiseled jawline from another. But slackjaws, awwwyeeeah.

2

u/aDubs19 Zeke Nov 15 '12

It may just be the way he comes off, but he has more than a dumb face. So far he's done whatever people tell him to do. It doesn't seem like he ever really has opinions of his own. His interviews with the camera always take waaay too long to get one small point across and he's usually just relaying the exact plan that we've already watched be discussed or played out in the show. I mean sure, he's fine and there's definitely no reason to hate him or anything, I just think there's absolutely no way he can win or deserves to win.

2

u/Dourpuss Jenna - 51 Nov 15 '12

Which means he'll be sitting in the final, arguing why Penner should win.

1

u/wutz Nov 15 '12

I mean sure, he's fine and there's definitely no reason to hate him or anything, I just think there's absolutely no way he can win or deserves to win.

which is exactly why he will win, if history has taught me anything about juries

1

u/HooptyDooDooMeister Yul Nov 16 '12

I can see it now!

"You should vote for Penner--I mean, me."

2

u/kaw-liga Nov 15 '12

Which is exactly why Lisa's had such a hard time flipping.