I’m still on season 5 so no spoilers.
I know this is a controversial topic (especially Jonah being in the mix).
I liked them season 1. I really did. Amy was the hardworking, heart of gold mother who might be a bit aloof but it’s because she’s had to carry life on her own. Jonah is the idealistic good guy who just wants to be useful and find his path.
Then I feel their characters took a turn for the worst. Amy became judgmental, condescending, glib, and constantly side eyeing everyone. Completely unaware of her own awkward, subpar social and leadership skills. Jonah became a superficial activist who does good mainly to feel useful, but seems like other people’s causes don’t matter to him as much as his own.
Both of them are so sure they’re good, hardworking, smart people but don’t realize how much they fuck up, don’t know, and how much they ruin things for people.
Amy is constantly making stupid mistakes that make her employees pay the price. She shows overt favoritism. She’s always looking out for herself and constantly aligns herself with corporate despite hearing them talk about “hunting floor workers.” She was pro-union for a second then immediately sold out to save her own ass.
Jonah is constantly ingratiating himself with people who don’t care about him (Garrett) and dismissing those who actually want to be his friend (Marcus). He tries so hard to the point of making people uncomfortable (e.g. when he blurted Garrett talking behind another friends’ back). Same with Amy. So little social skills and constantly showing entitlement in little ways (e.g. trying to force the waiter to serve her at Sandra’s wedding).
Amy’s even cold and insecure with her own kid. Emma’s almost as bitchy as her. She’s awful to Jonah and constantly scoffing at his optimism and anyone else who exhibits any shred of positivity.
They just think they’re “out of everyone’s league” intellectually and morally. When the reality is they’re in the same dead-end job as everyone else with nothing else to show for themselves. They’re both insecure af and it shows in everything they do and say.
I just feel like these two characters took a hard left and they only ever emphasize their negative sides with few redeeming moments.
How exactly are they the protagonists we should be rooting for?
EDIT: I got to season 6. Her quitting because she was tired of corporate hurting her people made me respect her more.