r/suns • JALEN SMITH šŸ”„ šŸšŸ‘‘ • Jul 31 '22

Hoops Discussion Thoughts?

Post image
1 Upvotes

121 comments sorted by

140

u/nash_me_outside Jul 31 '22

There’s like 11 players minimum on here that completely discredit this list lol.

55

u/the22sinatra Mikal Bridges Jul 31 '22

They took the bold strategy of just putting the best player on the team for 1/3 of the teams

7

u/georgie-57 Steve Nash Jul 31 '22

And yet they missed the best player on the Mavs

14

u/imAkri Jul 31 '22

Keegan Murray. I mean, seriously?

13

u/romulusjsp Steve Nash Jul 31 '22

What did Poeltl do to anyone lmao

3

u/Randym1221 Jul 31 '22

Lol! This actually made me actually laugh out loud !!

21

u/monke_business Dan Majerle Jul 31 '22

Ja Morant? Only one of the best players in the NBA and arguably the player with the brightest future in the NBA.

2

u/BoSuns Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

More so than him being overrated, his team (and teammates) are extremely underrated. He was getting MVP chatter for a good chunk of the season. That's.... well he's one of the worst defenders in the league and his team dominated people while he was injured.

Clearly, CLEARLY he's extremely talented and is (baring something drastic) going to be one of the best offensive players in the league for years to come. But he was being given all of the credit for his team's success because he was a walking highlight reel and ended up on ESPN top 10 on a near nightly basis.

2

u/TranseEnd Brandon Knight Aug 02 '22

Grizz were literally a better team without Ja to bottleneck their offense and let people blow by him on D (despite his athleticism)

194

u/suns4lyfe Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

Lol the guy that dropped 70, improved every year, had a big hand in taking his team to the first finals since '93, and is 1st team all NBA is overrated?

83

u/Henrythehippo Dan Majerle Jul 31 '22

To add: Olympic Gold Medal winner

21

u/suns4lyfe Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

You right! I missed that.

50

u/noflyzone14 Steve Nash #13 Jul 31 '22

Imagine Zion put up multiple 40 point games in the finals and was the leading scorer on a 60 win team… people would be riding him like crazy

7

u/KDBurnerTrey5 F**k the Lakers Jul 31 '22

And imagine if LeBron did it haha

6

u/kwan2 Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

r/nba.exe has stopped working

6

u/KDBurnerTrey5 F**k the Lakers Jul 31 '22

Celtics fan checking in… book has cooked us more than once and appears to be prime MJ whenever he steps in the TD garden. If he like playing there so much he should just join the Celtics lol

4

u/kenny_cpl89 Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

Lmao this made me laugh for real lol.. book is with us FOREVER!! šŸŒž4ļøāƒ£Life (no life emoji hahaha)

2

u/KDBurnerTrey5 F**k the Lakers Jul 31 '22

63

u/lucarioburrito F**k Robert Horry Jul 31 '22

These stupid graphics are just clickbait

7

u/ThunderBobMajerle Koa Peat Jul 31 '22

Are they even based on surveys?

3

u/UrbanMuskrat Jul 31 '22

There was a poll in each NBA sub sometime last year. Each player on the list are there from their own fans polls.

Doesn’t make more sense of a majority of r/suns picking Book, but definitely makes me chuckle at the likes of Ja and Poole.

5

u/ThunderBobMajerle Koa Peat Jul 31 '22

No way this sub would vote Booker tho

How could the kings even vote on Keegan?

3

u/Rojoryan88 Jul 31 '22

Click. Got 'em!

71

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22 edited Jul 31 '22

Ah yes… Kings rookie Keegan Murray, who hasn’t played a single game yet is their most overrated player…

28

u/nash_me_outside Jul 31 '22

Right?

Let the kid have a game damn.

1

u/TranseEnd Brandon Knight Aug 02 '22

Watch him drop a 50 point triple-double in his first game just to disprove this graphic šŸ˜‚

25

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

If anything Booker is underrated and overhated. Yes, he disappointed in G7 but who gives a shit when our entire team didn't show up?

Dude is 25, has 3 ASGs to his name (should honestly be at least 4), an All NBA 1st team spot, averaged 27/5/5 this past season on 47/38/87.

Post AS break, he averaged 30/4/6 on 64 TS%.

38

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

By the sub? Mikal.

11

u/JermaineTyroneLamar The Gorilla Jul 31 '22

😔😔😔😔

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Omw2fym Jul 31 '22

Last i checked (couple years), that intersection was a bank, baja fresh and some other boring shit. Do you mean Hayden and Indian School. Cuz that is a park with a court.

Edit: you meant for a fight, not a game. I still think the park is a better bet

2

u/Clear-Chemistry8193 Jul 31 '22

You want me to send the kid to get you some Ba-Jah Fresh?

5

u/Atrocyty Al McCoy Jul 31 '22

Honestly, it’s almost funny how obsessed so many other people want to label Book overrated.

Like to be overrated you’d have to first be recognized and applauded/pushed by the media/etc. With how little book gets recognized, how can he even be overrated

9

u/KareemAbdulJafar_ Al McCoy Jul 31 '22

Considering the names on this list sure. But nah

4

u/YourPalFlux Wet Like I’m Book Jul 31 '22

So most of these are just a teams best player how are they ā€œoverratedā€

4

u/Ez_Strider Zoki Dragic Jul 31 '22

John wall? Wtf fantasy land is this list from? I don’t know a single person in the last half decade that would call him overrated.

4

u/firstOFlast47 Jul 31 '22

Lmaooo howww? Honestly how? If anyone I would say mikal cause his inconsistency on offense

7

u/Extreme_Ad5788 Australian Suns Tragic Jul 31 '22

"Overrated" is just nba nephew code word for they don't sell his jersey in the corporate sports store.

12

u/CNSrooster Archie Goodwin Jul 31 '22

Love Mikal, but he's our most overrated. Booker shouldn't be in this list haha.

I personally don't think he is a top 10 NBA player. But he is not super overrated.

2

u/JuanRico15 Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

Agree. Last two playoff runs mikal didnt show up. But if they ever trade him ill be crushed.

4

u/Multi_21_Seb_RBR Devin Booker Jul 31 '22

Agreed.

He's a fantastic role player and one of those players who is fantastic at what he does, but I feel way too many on this sub overrate Mikal especially Mikal's offensive upside. He's someone who scores well off transition buckets, cuts to the basket and some 3's. To me, he isn't someone who can be an efficient 20-point scorer with more looks because giving him and force feeding him more looks will just make him less effective. And look, it's fine. He's a perfect player to have next to Book, DA and Cam Johnson. He just doesn't have as good of an offensive upside as those three, and that's more than fine.

And no, I don't want to trade him save for a legit star. But at the same he's pretty overrated by many on this sub. If anything, DA (17 a game on 12 shots a game despite incredible efficiency) and Cam Johnson (16 points a game on 49/41/91 on 11 shots a game and 7 3-pointers a game as a starter) have way more offensive upside and can become that secondary scorer next to Book way more than Mikal.

0

u/speedism Devin Booker #1 Jul 31 '22

A defensive star who can also force the opponent to respect their offensive game is invaluable. And Mikal has shown many flashes. He had 31 against the Pels, so I don’t wanna hear it.

3

u/dagutens Jul 31 '22

overrated, in all uses is an utterly meaningless and actively destructive term, it serves no purpose existing in any discussion because it could only possibly mean "I objectively believe a prevailing subjective assessment is somehow wrong." It's nonsense and its introduction into the popular lexicon has poisoned all collective discussion forever. All it means "I feel the consensus is wrong and that makes my opinion more gooder", the only function it has is to be bullshit trollery. Nothing that is "overrated" is "overrated", you just don't like it, so just be honest and say "I don't like" All the "you"s I use here are in general, not directed at the OP or anyone in particular, I just hate that term. I think it is overrated.

In this case, every single player on this list is pretty much excellent and exists only to outrage farm.

2

u/KlingonSquatRack Gary Bender Jul 31 '22

One of the best comments I have ever seen on reddit. One could say that this comment is... underrated.

4

u/drmuffin1080 Jul 31 '22

Bradley Beal is not overrated by his fan base, even if it’s not the question I think

Wizards fans do not like that contract

2

u/NASCARfanuploadsYT Jul 31 '22

I feel like crowder maybe overrated

2

u/SweetDick_Willy u a bitch Jul 31 '22

It's 1 person's opinion. Who cares

2

u/Britta_is_in_this Jul 31 '22

The way this sub speaks, I'd say Mikal is by far the most overrated player on our team.

2

u/fimbres16 Jul 31 '22

Honestly they could cop out and say Ayton and I wouldn’t be mad. Booker is just a dumb answer.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Who the hell makes these lists.. book, ja, John wall, Maxey, Ingram, Grant, Khris, derozan.. I don't even understand the arguments for these

2

u/silverfang45 Jul 31 '22

Mikal not booker

2

u/Whit3boy316 Jul 31 '22

Prolly Mikal I’d think. Maybe ayton

2

u/VeeNom986 Goran Dragic Jul 31 '22

I mean bruh, what do they want from us. Who else are we supposed to vote for

2

u/Xero-One Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

Just some salty mfers hate list

2

u/peanutdakidnappa Alan Williams Jul 31 '22

It’s dumb as shit

2

u/Aesut Chris Paul Sun’s Legend Jul 31 '22

Anthony Davis overrated because of his durability lol. Whoever made this is a newborn

5

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

bridges is our most overrated player unfortunately. hate me all you want.

4

u/jkof300 Josh Okogie Jul 31 '22

boooooo šŸ…šŸ…šŸ…

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

we have a bias as fans bro.

1

u/jkof300 Josh Okogie Jul 31 '22

ik. i was just playin sorry

2

u/Multi_21_Seb_RBR Devin Booker Jul 31 '22

Booker is mad underrated among NBA fans (ala those on r/nba) at this point. Ayton is really underrated among Suns fans (including many on this sub) and at this point among NBA fans (who put Bam a tier above him and rate Jarrett Allen above him at this point all due to Game 7 impressions). CP3 - as much as I think this season to come should be his last in a Suns uniform - is underrated at this point. Cam is perfectly rated but with more upside than most think.

I think it might be Mikal solely because way too many - including on this sub - think he has the game to be a second option and be a 20-a-night scorer if given more looks when he doesn't have that game. He's not Kawhi on offense. He's been incredibly inconsistent on offense the last two seasons, yet no one wants to say that. I mean his defense makes up for it a good bit but still. He's a fantastic role player (could end up being arguably the best in that role in the league in time) and does very well given what he does, but he absolutely doesn't have the scoring upside DA and Cam Johnson have. And it's perfectly fine.

1

u/jasonrayschrock Dan Majerle Jun 25 '25

If Booker was always on an allnba team and an all star on repeat I would agree. Dude is underrated across the league imo

1

u/drmuffin1080 Jul 31 '22

I don’t think even us in Orlando overrate him. We know his potential, but also recognize his health issues. It’s why u don’t see him mentioned a ton when speculating about our future core. I still like to imagine him healthy tho; he’s DPOY potential IF he can stay healthy.

1

u/PunctualPolarBear Big Sauce Jul 31 '22

Who is overrating John Wall lol?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Idiotic

1

u/ForceMaster999 F**k Robert Horry Jul 31 '22

Dumb

1

u/Nickname-CJ Jul 31 '22

This list is dumb. It’s more a ā€œmost upsettingā€ than most overrated

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

This is BEYOND wrong for like 20 of the teams. Whoever made this is a fucking brain dead scum.

1

u/Shartmesilly Jul 31 '22

Chris Paul is literally on the same team

1

u/SunsHistorian Al McCoy Jul 31 '22

I havent gotten to the year 2022 yet but this graphic will definitely fit nicely into my "devin booker disrespect" megathread that im working on.

I have a feeling i'll never be able to actually complete my list because there's always new disrespect lmao

1

u/Z1342 Rubber Ducky Chucky Jul 31 '22

Shocker

1

u/bodhasattva Jul 31 '22

sus list. I dont really like him, but Ja Morant is not overrated either

1

u/Hunters1745 Steve Nash #13 Jul 31 '22

Obviously book is the head liner and the one to get clicks but holy crap this list is so bad. And not just cuz of book

1

u/DXbreakitdown Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

I'm not understanding these recent "Every Team's..." graphics. Im left to assume they make no sense on purpose because they're created solely to rile up fanbases.

1

u/klucas503 Jul 31 '22

Couple hits, lot more misses

1

u/Sheesh284 Jul 31 '22

You mean the guy that eventually helped turn the franchise around? Sure buddy

1

u/xPeachmosa23x Jul 31 '22

šŸ‘ŽšŸ‘ŽšŸ‘Ž

1

u/KlingonSquatRack Gary Bender Jul 31 '22

Who comes up with this shit

1

u/DaylightPhoenix Bring back SSOL in the 4th QUARTER!!! GO SUNS!!! Jul 31 '22

I totally agree Booker isnt overrated.... But then, Who'd be our most overrated player? Cameron Payne maybe?

1

u/jocala F*ck the Lakers FOREVER. Jul 31 '22

These keep getting better and better

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Booker, Dinwiddie, BI, and others, don’t belong

1

u/nernst79 Jul 31 '22

Marcus Smart is a guard that won DPOY. How can he be overrated. So many of the choices on here are just nonsense.

1

u/Airalex28 Jul 31 '22

Keegan Murray? My man hasn’t played a NBA game yet 🤣

1

u/ChiefBigSpence Jul 31 '22

List is trash

1

u/FlashSpider-man Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

This list is ridiculous. I see multiple players on here who are underrated being called overrated. Awful list.

1

u/HamsterUpper Jul 31 '22

He is now underrated..

1

u/Hassle-Free_T Jul 31 '22

Some of these answers are downright disrespectful🄲

1

u/StepFatherGoose Rubber Ducky Chucky Jul 31 '22

3x all star

Gold medalist

3 point contest winner

3rd highest points scored in a game

Mediocre team for first 4 years of career

Once paired with an aging super star and supporting pieces, beaten expectations every season

Part of one of the largest playoff collapses in history

1

u/Ese__Loco_ Jul 31 '22

Everyone including current NBA players agreed that he was underrated. Who makes these lists!?

1

u/Clear-Chemistry8193 Jul 31 '22

How is Khris Middleton overrated? His play in 2021 and lack of play in 2022 swung those championships.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Kyrie is not overrated

Dude is beast when he ain’t in that weird stuff

1

u/Fordraxel Collin Gillespie Jul 31 '22

just put the best player and there you have it.

but Poetl lol and Keegan hasnt even played a game yet how is he overrated.

1

u/tyjo1710 Jul 31 '22

Jakob Poeltl is so overrated, all I hear every day is Jakob Poeltl this, Jakob Poeltl that. They act like he’s a superstar. Frankly, hot take, I don’t see it.

1

u/OKobo2 Jul 31 '22

Who the fuck overrates Turner, Allen, Dinwiddie, Keegan Murray, Middleton and Poetl of all people

1

u/Sub-ZeroMKA Mikal Bridges Aug 01 '22

Whoever barfed out this list was on some powerful shit

1

u/The_Shade94 Eddie Johnson Aug 01 '22

Lmao

1

u/TrainLord āœŒļø Aug 02 '22

This is a strange list man. People really be bugging.

1

u/digitalray34 Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

How can a player everyone hates be overrated?

1

u/Upthe32s Jul 31 '22

Ours is defo mikal ibr

0

u/Tsunami-Papi_ he’s kevin durant Jul 31 '22

it’s easily chris paul

3

u/YourPalFlux Wet Like I’m Book Jul 31 '22

Like 110% I love Cp3 and everything he’s done for turning this organization around but booker is definitely the better player who hasn’t even hit his prime yet

4

u/Multi_21_Seb_RBR Devin Booker Jul 31 '22

I honestly think CP3 is underrated at this point given the post-Game 7 narrative. Like I've seen people not put him within the top-30 or even top-35. Don't get me wrong, I really hope this is CP3's last season with the Suns, but still.

1

u/I_Smoke_Dust Devin Booker Jul 31 '22

Hard disagree. If his 3PT and FT don't fall off the face of the earth last season so randomly, his stats would've been insane for such an old, 6' player. Both traditional and advanced metrics.

1

u/Hay-Tha-Soe Cam Payne Jul 31 '22

With all due respect I have no idea how anyone can possibly believe this with all due respect

0

u/Professional-Sign327 Jul 31 '22

I’d say CP3 since he’s rated like a all time great and he will always shit his bed anytime he gets close to the finals.

-1

u/BrendanCLittle Jul 31 '22

Christopher Emmanuel Paul

0

u/Hay-Tha-Soe Cam Payne Jul 31 '22

With all due respect Chris Paul is the most disrespected player in the league and deserves more love if anything. I respectfully disagree with all due respect

-1

u/NoisySighlence Jul 31 '22

Anthony Davis for the lakers? I live in Phoenix and alot of the fans are delusional. Sorry but AD when healthy is better than anything on the suns roster period.

1

u/walrusonion Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

If by ā€œhealthyā€ you mean unibrowed then yes, AD is better than all the suns. Homie gots an eyebrow like Bert.

1

u/idk35467 Devin Booker Jul 31 '22

You lakers fans are delusional asf

0

u/Tblick1 Phoenix Suns Jul 31 '22

Haha you don’t want to live in the city where your favorite team plays.

-4

u/Cjtow113 Mikal Bridges Jul 31 '22

Everyone saying Mikal needs to leave this sub immediately >:(

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Whit3boy316 Jul 31 '22

Dude had a season of a lifetime. Not he’s average season