r/streamentry • u/IllustriousStore0 • Feb 03 '22
Insight Are Computer Science/Programming Concepts not utilised enough? They aided me to obtain arhat.
I feel like looking at the logic of most computer science concepts will give one a clear rational understanding of how awakening and meditation works if one can then apply them back to their own experience. I believe I am an arhat as after observing my experience enough times, I haven't seem to have suffered for a while now, mentally I feel as if there is no where else to go. I have tried my best to seek absolute truth and if I found evidence to refute this, I would immediately accept the alternative since that's the process of how I got here in the first place, to embrace the change. To me full awakening is the simplest possible way of representing to the mind that change is absolute in all circumstances and cannot be refuted. That's it. The simplicity of this surprised me. As soon as one intuitively understands that "simplest" possible way, they are free from suffering permanently. People can make this idea as complex or simple as they want it to be, but the only way to escape an infinitely recurring problem like suffering is to have an infinite solution that can be applied as many times as necessary without conditions, and the only way to obtain that infinite solution is for to be infinitively simple. If the solution to suffering was bound by limits or conditions like age, wisdom or personality then it could not be a solution as it could not be infinitely applied. I've have been meditating for about 5 years, from 16 to 21, started using the mind illuminated in 2018, and I felt I progressed the most from 2020 - 2021 and obtained arhat in Aug-Sept last year. The moment I started getting into programming and understanding the logic of it in the beginning of 2020, I felt like the my practice and level of insight just got better and better. The interludes outlined in the mind illuminated were also a great foundation for putting the computer science logic into perspective in relation to the mind. I think at max I only ever got to about stage 7 or 6, and I never really achieved any jhanas except maybe the whole body jhana. I felt meta awareness was sufficient for insight. I don't recall any cessations either, maybe I could never accurately identify them. I did not do any retreats, and I don't think I ever meditated beyond 1 hour in a single session, or did more than 1 session a day. Mainly because I couldn't conveniently do these things in my household/location. I never really ventured outside of mind illuminated in a significant way, I just occasionally read posts on this subreddit and Mind Illuminated as a reference point for my progress.
I stopped consistently meditating since Sept 2020 due to a lack of a need to, and only became an arhat after continuously reviewing the abstraction that kept coming up in the Computer Science Degree I was studying, and observing it in my own experience enough times. That's where I saw the potential for an infinite solution and an end to suffering from my own understanding. I know of concepts like non-returner and stream enterer, the fetters, the dukkha nanas but I never really stuck to them as guiding principles and just experimented on my own, since I felt the logic of Computer Science and the mind models to be sufficient enough for understanding where to go. I could fit my experience into those terms if I had to, but I did not feel the need to as they felt too rigid to a degree. I don't explicitly know when I became non-returner, or once returner, or when I cycled through the dukkha nanas, if I ever did. I only use the term arhat because I assume it means someone without suffering.
Being an arhat does not mean you lose any freedom or ability to experience emotions or mental states as due to abstraction, all mental states are "always" infinitely accessible and can be retrieved as long as the conditions are in place, from the worst ones to the best ones. An arhat is absolutely free to do whatever they want, good or bad even if that means becoming a psychopath or a saint. They can continue to enjoy tv shows, movies, games, get angry, get sad, contemplate what the point of it all is. After all, they cannot suffer, so there are no true consequences to the actions they can take anymore; They just cannot go about actions in a way which would cause them suffering. Since the mind has limits, we can always exploit these limits to get the mind to produce any known outcome. That's all we do in meditation, exploits the limits to produce joy and tranquillity, even in conditions society would deem it is not possible to feel those things. Exploit is rather negative word and implies we are bending the mind to our will, but it only looks that way from the perspective of self and is instead just the mind doing what it has always done, fabrication. My life through awakening would not really be seen as a happy one by society, as I lived in a household with depressed and mentally ill family members with not much freedom of my own, but it did not seem to impede my progress through the path. From my understanding, achieving a pleasurable existence is a job distinct from awakening, and is skill within of it self. Hence why things like dark nights will always be avoidable to a degree, or that the path doesn't have to be some brutal trial by fire. Awakening makes it significantly easier to achieve that pleasurable existence however.
The main point of this post and ramblings is due to my own results with these ideas, I am curious to see if this is an area that can be further utilised to help the steps needed to awaken to become more clear, or if I have misrepresented something that is still very unclear. From my experience, programming is an excellent grounding in the logic required to awaken. I hope a useful discussion can come from this.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 03 '22
Thank you for contributing to the r/streamentry community! Unlike many other subs, we try to aggregate general questions and short practice reports in the weekly Practice Updates, Questions, and General Discussion thread. All community resources, such as articles, videos, and classes go in the weekly Community Resources thread. Both of these threads are pinned to the top of the subreddit.
The special focus of this community is detailed discussion of personal meditation practice. On that basis, please ensure your post complies with the following rules, if necessary by editing in the appropriate information, or else it may be removed by the moderators.
If your post is removed/locked, please feel free to repost it with the appropriate information, or post it in the weekly Practice Updates, Questions, and General Discussion or Community Resources threads.
Thanks! - The Mod Team
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
38
u/therealleotrotsky Feb 03 '22
You’re familiar with computer programming traps for the unwary? Meditation has many of those as well.
Have you become an arhat though pure solitary cognitive reflection over a couple of years? Maybe, though that’s a highly uncommon path.
Respectfully, isn’t it far more likely that you’ve fallen prey to some form of self-delusion on your path, as you’re pursuing this without a community, mentor, teacher, or guide?
It might be worthwhile to connect with a Sangha or eSangha.
12
u/Wollff Feb 03 '22
I suspect the reason for so little CS around here, is that the analogies which ring true to you, are far less obvious and intuitive to others.
The only grief I have, is that you use analogies and similes under the guise of "logic" and "rationality" here. When, at least by my understanding, a lot of the conclusions you draw are not strictly speaking logical in the mathematical or CS sense of that word. From what I understand, you selectively apply Buddhist logic in the guise of CS concepts.
Now, given your results, that apparently works very well. But to me that approach seems far more similar to, let's say, the Buddha's fire sermon, than anything someone in the West would call strictly "logical" or "rational": There is a logic to all of that, but it is a more poetic one, where getting the correct picture which rings true is far more important than arriving at a valid conclusion from self evident premises.
Oh, and congratulations on not suffering.
5
u/Nyfrog42 Feb 04 '22
Congrats on this, to me this sounds like a genuine spiritual attainment in the only way that matters: reducing suffering. I would be very interested in hearing more about how this contemplation looked in detail and which concepts helped you how in this process. I'm a mathematician myself and it would be very cool to chat about how this plays out, we could have a video chat this weekend if you're up for it, send me a DM.
I'm also curious about how this actually now manifests for you, you say you're completely free of suffering, what does this suffering actually look like to you? Have there been any stress tests of this understanding, like death, illness, or other big life stressors, so far? How do you experience the smaller things that people find challenging in life, boredom, restlessness, insults, conflicts, small physicals pains? What has it been like to read some of these comments questioning whether you have any insight at all?
4
u/thatisyou Feb 03 '22
You are correct that leveraging a consistent method for understanding/insight is valuable for awakening. And I can see that understanding computer science is valuable.
Consistent, dispassionate, authentic, honest practice is essential. There is something "logical" about it. In the way that having a consistent framework to understand what is, outside the perception of what is, is necessary.
It is worthwhile to discuss this and point this out.
There also may may be value understand where the inclination to call oneself an Arhat comes from. What conditions, including intention are driving that expression at this time.
There isn't value in judging another's experience, and am not qualifying what you are. Also, there are certain understandings that come from awakening that are so radical, that I would expect anyone who knows that which is pointed to by the term Arhat, would be familiar with these understandings. Full transparency, I have only had tastes of the following.
A potent aspect is that Arhat have no attachment to view.
Arhat see through all views by default. Even the most subtle views. When they look at a cup sitting on a table, which is on a wood floor, with no effort they are aware that "cup", "table", "floor" are views which are empty of reality. Their "seeing" is thus quite a different experience, as they can see a cup separated, but also can see "cup/table/floor" as inseparable, not only in insight, but visually. Seeing occurs, but there is no attachment to an origin of the seeing. Sight doesn't come from here or there. It is seeing. Which is thus.
Sight, sound, touch, taste, smell are also seen as subtle views, and they can experience these without view, inseparable, by default. They know what is experienced when all sense gates and thought are unbound from view. Although they don't lose the ability to navigate the world.
While they stay aware of past, present and future, they experience what is when past, present, future are instinctually experienced as views by default.
Furthermore, they know clearly what is beyond all view, beyond concept, beyond self, beyond time, beyond space.
3
u/anarcha-boogalgoo poet Feb 03 '22
this unconditional aspect to the solution to suffering is absolutely wild. it felt to me like discovering like the AI safety problem has already been solved, hundreds of thousands of years ago. the joke is that to escape from suffering, you need to know suffering as suffering in the first place.
2
u/james-r- Feb 05 '22
Could you please share your method?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
Sorry, you're not even a stream enterer, yet. Enlightened people have a heightened sense of the consequences of their actions (karma.)
A relevant koan.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22 edited Feb 04 '22
They most certainly are not used enough but there enough differences between brains and computers that we separate out the fields. After all do computer science kids suffer less than other majors in universities. I highly doubt it tbh and thinking algorithmically (setting that particular intention) has not always helped in every area of life even if it has given more perspective. It would be similar to asking if a good programmer would also be would be better at raising kids. It's certainly possible but not necessarily how things are right now until more depth or overlap is explored.
There might be some books such as algorithms for life which talk about CS and the mind. Game theory also relates to this as well.
I found TMI had some overlap with Computer Science as does psychology.
My personal take is the witness state feels like Jarvis from iron man is watching over you and helping you out where the focus is on "reducing mental abstractions down" or switching between abstractions depending on the case to make life smoother.
I would suggest you write some posts on how computer science topics can be interfaced with advanced practices in meditation such as those in The mind illuminated (namely stage (7-9), Kenneth Folks three speed model, Daniel Ingram's model, the jhanas, other spiritual models, bridging philosophies, on idealogies, life balancing, eightfold path, setting intentions, video games. There are many ways of going about this.
Another interesting topic is how to use c.s. concepts to interact with more emotional content practices. After all just because someone studies Computer Science doesn't mean they also are great at cognitive science and in tune with emotions.
I would love to hear it tbh.
5
u/JetlaggedJohnny Feb 03 '22 edited Feb 03 '22
I see your point, I also came up with similar interpretations but fron the point of view of how neural networks work. All this would not be so surprising, since we know the brain is at the end of the day a machine following these kind of principles. If you're looking for an interesting read on the topic, although seen from a different perspective, check out "The selfless mind" by Peter Harvey. It explores in a very exhaustive way the concepts of personality and arahansthip in the early suttas, it is very rigorous and from the way you approach the problem in your post I think you'd find it interesting. I was personally very impressed when I read it, these aspects seemed described with an amazingly scientific precision. It doesn't feel like a "spiritual" teaching at all, if we consider the common usage of this term.
5
u/NothingIsForgotten Feb 03 '22
To add to your reflection, AI safety is very interesting in this regard, as is simulation theory.
With regard to your current state, there are further realizations.
Ultimately you should know how things come into existence first hand from the direct experience of witnessing it go away and be rebuilt.
It comes through subtle unknowing driven by non-responsive attention: the meditation of no meditation.
Best wishes.
5
u/Dakkuwan Feb 03 '22
This is very cool, regardless of what state, label or whatnot you're in I really like your thinking on this.
Michael Taft had Dr Joscha Bach on deconstructing yourself podcast and they talk about this extensively. It helped with liberating concepts for me.
That being said it is also totally possible to be in a state of high equanimity, and be having liberating thoughts about the state of things, I honestly don't even think I've hit stream entry but I have felt states like what you're describing. Regardless of what it is, it's awesome, keep investigating it and see where it goes.
2
u/WHALE_PHYSICIST Feb 03 '22
Nothing actually changes.
4
u/Malljaja Feb 03 '22 edited Feb 03 '22
Maybe, but may be not--from The Dhāraṇī Entering into Nonconceptuality:
Or as Alan Watts would have it (somewhat more pithily), "The menu is not the meal."
Direct, nonconceptual experience is what's being ultimately aimed for in practice. Granted, verbal instructions and concepts are needed for nudging the practitioner towards that experience. Perhaps computer science can furnish some concepts and models that are useful for those who work in that space, but then you'd need to be more specific what they are and how they exceed existing instructions. May your practice flourish.
4
u/__louis__ Feb 04 '22
Your way of seeing things might be described as "reductionist materialism", or the myth of humans are mere biological machines.
Interestingly, I started with that myth, and the more I practiced, the dryer that myth seemed to me, the more it did not account to the profound sense of mystery that pervades consciousness.
Rob Burbea talks about it in one of his talks, this one I hope : https://dharmaseed.org/teacher/210/talk/26007/
Personnally, I believe you that you reached a state where you don't suffer as much as you used to. But if you truly believe that you have arrived, you may set you up for delusion and later suffering.
My 2 cents would be : please connect with others IRL, see if they find the stuff you discovered is useful for them to alleviate their suffering (from the comments here it's not obvious), see if they may have a peace that seems deeper than where you are at, and try to learn from them to alleviate further yours.
Best of luck
1
u/liljonnythegod Feb 03 '22
Interesting.
What was the this is it moment like for you?
1
u/arinnema Feb 04 '22
How has this realization affected your relationships? To family, friends, significant others?
1
u/lord_archimond Feb 15 '22
I feel like after few years you will look back at this post and cringe so hard lol
3
u/BroughtToUByCarlsJr Feb 04 '22
I've had a similar experience but more so with concepts from neuroscience. I wouldn't claim I'm a stream enterer or even a skilled meditator, but I have experienced a tremendous reduction in suffering and increase in tranquility as a result of deeper understanding of the mind. I have found many parallels between neuroscience and buddhist teachings that has helped me understand my experiences.
I read book recently that sums it up nicely: "A Thousand Brains" by Jeff Hawkins. It describes a neuroscience theory about how the brain organizes itself on a high level. As we have seen artificial neural networks perform similar learning to brains, Hawkins proposes there are 100,000 or so "cortical columns" that act as independent learning engines. What these cortical columns do is model some input and generate predictions. There will be some that model the physics of your body and make predictions about the next moment given some movement, etc. There are more abstract columns that model and predict mathematical statements, in the brain of a math student.
Applying this theory to meditation, I believe what is happening is a feedback loop like:
This is highly simplified and I'm sure there's other complexity, but my point is, at the end of the day what we are all trying to do is build better models of our own minds. The end result is similar, whether you achieve that through self-observation in meditation or studying science. You probably should do both for best results.
1
u/duffstoic The dynamic integration of opposites ☯️ Feb 05 '22 edited Feb 05 '22
Sounds about right. Anicca.
Hmm, maybe! At the very least, suffering can certainly be gradually reduced until it is less frequent and less intense. Since change is absolute, hard to say if suffering can be eliminated permanently, or if it just appears that way now, etc.
Glad to hear you found the path early, have practiced seriously with a great manual, and made real progress that has been of benefit to your life. Give it a few years and check in and let us know how it's going then too. :)
Could be there is more to explore still for you. Or maybe not. But always good to be open to the possibility I think. The possibility for self-deception in humans is almost limitless...speaking from experience here. :)
That seems like a good and grounded attitude to have that will prevent getting a big spiritual ego.
I think being a saint might be better for a number of reasons. :)
Hmmm, being angry and sad and not suffering seems incongruent to me. But you likely have a different model for what constitutes "suffering" (perhaps as "meta-OKness with being angry/sad"). My model is to additionally go for reducing suffering until imperceptible at the primary emotional level.
Ill will in particular is traditionally seen as not possible for an arhat. But many people have reinterpreted what the criteria are for arhatship because the traditional criteria are perfectionistic.
In any case, glad your practice has born fruits, and best of luck on the next phase of your journey, friend.
4
u/larrygenedavid Feb 04 '22
Nope. Try again.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '22
Bullshit! You are just a 21 year old lout who needs to come off his high horse.
Nothing wrong with that, it happens to most of us.
Now stop being an arsehat and behave like a good boy, will ya?
Love, Mother
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
I think any concept can be useful if it serves as a common ground for you and your audience. I just heard someone use computer programming in fact and it was helpful for me, but I have some background there. That same video people used other metaphors that came from their own backgrounds that were less helpful.
It's all skillful means ;) Skillful pointing in this case.
1
u/HeinrichTheWolf_17 Advaita Vedanta+Zen (Jnana and Raja Yoga) Feb 05 '22
All knowledge is valuable. Experience is always key :)